"May I ask the opposing party, do you have a real-time basis for your views? All our opinions need to be backed up by facts and figures, shouldn't they? ”

The other party's second argument has an expression on his face that is waiting for you to ask this question. After the other party answered, they realized that they had completely fallen into someone else's trap.

Immediately after the other party's three arguments, he put forward a sharp point: "According to an authoritative international assessment program for student competence by the World Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), 15-year-old students in Shanghai who participated in the assessment for the first time ranked first in all three evaluations of reading literacy, mathematics literacy and science literacy. May I ask the opponent's defense friend, are middle school students with the above three qualities talents? ”

They can't refute this question, so they can only start from another angle.

"The opponent's defense friend, for the ultimate purpose of exams and grades, students have to spend a lot of time to complete homework, and intensive training of the sea of questions, so as to lose time for exercise and recreation. When you see teenage children fainting for more than ten minutes while standing at the flag, and when you see many students with mental illness due to exam pressure, do you still say that exam-oriented education is conducive to the selection of talents, and it seems ridiculous that you are not idle? ”

Of course, the other party knew that they were deliberately avoiding their questions, so the other side stood up and said: "Please don't change the topic of the opponent's defense, please answer my question head-on, is the student trained by the exam-oriented education talented?" ”

Because it was the offensive and defense stage, the other party repeatedly asked them to answer. If they evade it any longer, they will obviously fall even worse. Wang Yangyu thought about it and stood up: "The other party is a friend." I do admit that if I can rank first in several assessments of reading literacy, math literacy, and science literacy, it's talent. ”

"We have never denied it. Exam-oriented education has existed for so many years, and it has its justification. But the disadvantages far outweigh the advantages. ”

"As long as the opponent's debate friend admits that what has been cultivated under the test-oriented education is talent, it seems that there is no need for our debate today to continue, and even the other side has already agreed with our point of view!"

"Papapa~~!" The audience erupted in laughter and long-lasting applause.

The High School Attached to the University of Science and Technology was completely suppressed by the 12th Middle School.

Finally, at the end of the attack and debate, the free debate began. Free debate is a crucial round of the whole debate.

"My classmates, my classmates' classmates...... Almost every student in school says, "Read good books." There is a way out". "Only by studying well and getting into a good university can you get a good job. to earn money. "So the only way out is to read. There is a feeling of "everything is inferior, only reading is high". ”

"At the end of the day, the purpose of reading is for one word. Money! Everyone goes to school for money. ”

"I would like to ask the other side of the defense. Students who study with such a purpose and prepare for exams, no matter how high their reading literacy, math literacy and science literacy are, can we call them talents? And it just so happens that this is the purpose of most people's reading under today's exam-oriented education. Including the four debaters sitting across from you, aren't you studying to have a better way out? ”

Xiao Jinluo deeply understood the importance of seizing the opportunity at this stage, so she stood up in seconds at the moment when the supporter's voice fell. And used the other party's most proud point just now to refute them. Of course. Her rebuttal is from the perspective of a higher outlook on life and values.

Therefore, Xiao Jinluo's problem made the Polytechnic University team, which had always been at a disadvantage, suddenly change the situation.

The audience burst into applause.

"The other side argues friend. Is it wrong to have such a purpose? If you have a good job, you can earn more money, and your living standard will continue to improve, isn't it contributing to the country? Our country will only get better if the life of the individual is better, isn't it? ”

"Friend of the other side, I think you have deviated from our topic today. What we are discussing is whether exam-oriented education is about selecting talents or discouraging talents. It's not about studying and getting a good job, whether it's contributing to the country! ”

Xiao Jinluo's words made the audience laugh.

As soon as the other party spoke, his face was red and white, and he sat down.

"The opponent's defense friend is indeed sharp and knowledgeable. In my opinion, the opponent's defense friend is a complete talent. And may I ask, are you in the middle of exam-oriented education? ”

After the other party sat down, the fourth debate quickly stood up. used Xiao Jinluo himself to argue their point.

The question received a tidal wave of applause again, and if it weren't for the fact that they were on opposite sides, Xiao Jinluo would have immediately reached out and applauded her. This problem is airtight. How can I refute it?

"I reiterate my point of view. We believe that examination-oriented education inhibits the development of talents, but we do not say that examination-oriented education is useless. Maybe you think that we are already talented people when we can talk about it here. But I would like to ask the other side of the debate. Does the progress of society depend on our rhetoric or on the development and progress of science? ”

After Wang Yangyu finished speaking, Xiao Jinluo was the first to applaud desperately, and I have to say that Wang Yangyu's argument was very high-level. This mirrors their initial view that test-oriented education erases the creativity and innovation of individuals.

Because the progress of society is definitely more dependent on the development and progress of science, which is of course also proved by social practice. And isn't the development of science exactly what requires innovation, creativity and hands-on ability? What should be most lacking in education is the cultivation of students' hands-on ability.

So during the entire eight minutes of free debate, the disadvantages of the first two stages of the Polytechnic University were slightly changed.

In other words, the results of the two teams are already in a similar state in the eyes of the judges and the audience.

Then what can determine the outcome of the whole competition is the final four debate summary arguments and the Q&A stage with the audience.

The eyes of several people looked at Xiao Jinluo at the same time. The worry in Li Shuangshuang's eyes, the encouragement in Li Junmo's eyes, and the trust in Wang Yangyu's eyes. Xiao Jinluo understood everything at a glance.

As a twenty-six-year-old soul, to tell the truth, it was a bit difficult for her to sit here and debate with a child ten years younger than herself.

But now she can't care about that. She wants to win because it's a different life for her. This is a more exciting life in her life.

She slowly stood up and looked down the stands.

She saw Liu Haoran. The emotions in Liu Haoran's eyes are too complicated, there is support, encouragement, belief, and deep affection. I don't know why, at this important moment.

She only had him in her eyes.

She took two deep breaths, word by word, and said her summary statement in a straight voice.

(To be continued.) )

PS: First of all, thank you very much for subscribing and supporting the lost relatives, the road of writing accompanied by someone is happy; Secondly, I am very sorry to say that because I have been really busy recently, the update time will not be fixed, most of the time will be late; Thirdly, this debate competition is basically my own thoughts, maybe not exciting enough, maybe there are many shortcomings, please bear with me.