Due to the appraisal of the "Records of the Green Capsule", the court considered that this kind of cultural relics identification does not require too many technical links, and the key is senior and experienced cultural relics appraisers and scholars, so the court informed the original defendant that it had contacted provincial cultural relics experts to come to the court to identify and announce the appraisal results.

Qin Xiao and Luo Chuan received the notice, so they took the original copy of "The Testament of the Green Capsule" to the court.

Su Xiaoman also hurried over, so the two sides entered the venue in order, at this time, Su Xiaoman was surprised to find that his father Su Jingkun also arrived at the scene, Su Jingkun saw Xiaoman, and said a little unnaturally:

"Xiaoman, you are here, it has been so many days, and I won't go to see your mother when I come back, she misses you very much."

Xiao Man saw his father Su Jingkun, and he was also a little at a loss, but said: "I'll go back after I'm busy with the case, what are you doing here?" ”

Su Jingkun didn't answer, just lowered his head and entered the courtroom.

The two sides sat down, and the presiding judge read out the facts of the case in accordance with the procedure, so the two sides were ready to begin the appraisal of the "Green Capsule Record", but at this time, Zhang Zhengguo proposed that there was new evidence to be presented, and the presiding judge agreed, so his lawyer got up and said:

"My attorney and I were going to be prepared to receive the results of the experts' appraisal, but just a few days ago, this Mr. Su Jingkun was willing to take the initiative to testify against us, and I implore the presiding judge to allow Mr. Su Jingkun to appear in court to present his case.

The presiding judge agreed. Su Jingkun slowly walked to the front of the stage, but it could be seen that he was unwilling to look at his daughter Su Xiaoman, he came to the front of the stage and said:

"To be honest, I also went through a great ideological struggle when I said these words, but in the end I decided to say it, that is, the process of making zuò seven spirit flowers scattered by Luochuan Company that I know, especially the inner side, is not the internal process recorded in the "Green Capsule Testament". To tell the truth, in the process of making the company in Luochuan at the beginning. When the staff of our health system conducts regular or irregular inspections every year, colleagues from the food and drug health supervision department of the prefecture reported that the process of making zuò in Nakcheon is extracted using the current process and equipment, and is not prepared according to the recipe of traditional medicine. In other words, even though I don't know the specific preparation method of the Seven Spirits Flower Powder in the "Green Capsule Testament", I can be sure that the two have completely different ideas. In fact, the ancient recipe should be prepared according to the traditional Chinese medicine theory of traditional medicine, and the powder should be dark and mixed in color. Judging from the seven spirit flowers that have been circulated on the market, the Luo family's company has obviously adopted modern extraction technology. This evidence can be found in our inspection records. ”

After Su Jingkun said these words, there was a commotion in the audience, and everyone was talking, at this time, Su Xiaoman was also very surprised, she didn't expect that at this moment, her father Su Jingkun, who was sitting opposite, would become an opponent in a case that could be said to have nothing to do with her Su family, which couldn't help but make her a little cramped and annoyed. Recalling his father's look just now, Su Xiaoman also immediately realized. Su Jingkun was still dissatisfied with what his daughter had done, and this time he helped the Zhang family to testify, firstly, because of his friendship with Zhang Zhengguo for many years, and more importantly, his escape from marriage made him very angry.

But Xiao Man was only in a trance for a while, and instantly regained her calm, because she knew that this was in court, and her words and deeds should be worthy of being a lawyer, so she still suppressed her dissatisfaction with her father. Try to maintain a peaceful mind, Banghu Luochuan and Qin Xiao won this protracted lawsuit.

At this time, Zhang Zhengguo's counsel lawyer applied to speak, and after receiving permission, he said: "The statement of my witness just now is already very clear. Judging from this situation, Luochuan Pharmaceutical Company is using new production processes and technologies, and it can even be said that it has nothing to do with Qiling Huasan, and as for him taking out the "Green Capsule Testament" to prove that this is an ancient prescription, at most it can prove that they keep the "Green Capsule Testament" prescription. If this method is not used, then all the previous inferences are not valid. Before, the other party just said that this is an ancient recipe, because of the age, my client does not know much about it, so, if the expert appraisal results are true, then this ancient recipe for anyone, has the opportunity to produce, but our husband applied for this patent, which is our patent right, and the other party is not qualified to produce it; If the other party uses the ancient party to show that they have used the domestic party and concludes that they also know the foreign party, and says that our patent is invalid, this is obviously a double standard. Because Mr. Su has proved just now that the Qin family did not use this inner method, but used a new process, and the age of this process cannot be verified, maybe they have been using it for a long time, but it is not the inner side recorded in the "Green Capsule Testament". However, my attorney, Mr. Zhang, told me that at this point, he did not want to continue to expand, as long as the other party respected his patent and carried out commercial cooperation in accordance with the original contract, he was willing to withdraw the lawsuit immediately and did not make any claim for compensation, and I don't know if my statement is clear. ”

Qin Xiao didn't expect that the Zhang family would immediately withdraw the lawsuit at this time, and he also used Su Jingkun to create a huge obstacle for himself, and he did it according to his intentions. He knew that it was not a bad thing for the Zhang family to withdraw the lawsuit now, and it would be beneficial, but he didn't expect him to suddenly withdraw his sword, so that Qin Xiao and Luo Chuan lost their targets all of a sudden.

But Qin Xiao plans to fight to the end at this time, if the defendant withdraws the lawsuit, at most it will lose the profits during this time, but such a fight has made the two drugs have a huge market, Zhang Zhengguo wants to quickly understand the case, but he just wants to make a profit quickly, and if it is late, it will change, and there will be many manufacturers in the future to share the profits.

Seeing this situation, the presiding judge also wanted Qin Xiao to put forward whether he was willing to accept the other party's request to withdraw the lawsuit and continue to perform his duties in accordance with the contract. Qin Xiao immediately refused:

"Mr. Presiding Judge, it is the other party's business whether the other party withdraws the lawsuit or not, and we believe that this formula itself is an ancient party, and the double standard that the opposing party's lawyer just said, that is, we know that the internal and external parties are just applying for patents for no reason, is obviously untenable. Well, let's admit that both of us can produce both domestic and foreign parties, but the premise of the contract is that we know that the legal patent of this party is valid, and this is very clear in the contract. We didn't have enough evidence to prove that this was an ancient recipe before, so we borrowed it from the Qing Dynasty to the present, and many of my ancestors used it to prove it, and it was also out of the helpless choice that we didn't find the original "Green Capsule Testament" at that time. But now the situation is different, we don't need to use this kind of circumstantial evidence, we have more direct evidence. It is the "Testament of the Green Capsule", as long as he is authenticated in court now, it can prove whether the Seven Spirits Flower Powder is an ancient formula, and it can also prove the validity of the Zhang family's patent, and according to the contract. As long as the patent is invalid, we will not perform the contract, which is stipulated in the contract. As for the other party's withdrawal of the lawsuit on the condition of our performance of the contract, we will not accept it. ”

Qin Xiao's words instantly reversed the situation, making the jury admit all the previous brief evidence. The circumstantial evidence, including Liao Kai and Meng Fan's father, is not convincing, as long as the authenticity of the book is identified, it will be clear in a word.

The presiding judge thought for a moment and said, "Then let's ask the experts in the province to appraise the "Records of the Green Capsule". ”

At this time, the "Records of the Green Capsule", which was already a little scorched, was placed in the public eye, although the Qin family has been well preserved, but due to the long-term weathering after Meng Haichang took it, it has been a little silky. The Tribunal has consulted with the parties. A total of three experts were invited to examine the book carefully.

The three experts were all extremely prestigious scholars in the provincial capital, and some of them had gray hair and were about seventy or eighty years old, and the three of them used a continuous magnifying glass to check and carefully look at the color and handwriting of the paper, and for about 20 minutes, the three experts came up with the appraisal results after discussion. -- Although this "Records of the Green Capsule" has a sense of age on the paper and handwriting, it is not certain that it is a relic of the former Qing Dynasty; Moreover, on the line of the mounting. There are already many places, and it is something from the Republic of China era, so whether it is a volume in the "Siku Quanshu" is not certain. Even if someone goes to make the old, it's okay; The third point is that this book is said to have been scattered by Wenyuan Pavilion, but other library pavilions have not, which makes it even more difficult to identify.

When Luo Chuan heard this, he was angry. But Qin Xiao immediately signaled him not to be impulsive, Qin Xiao had long expected that the result would be like this, he knew that Zhang Zhengguo had the ability and means to cheat in the process of identification, but those experts still didn't dare to directly deny this authentic work, once they said so, they were likely to be ruined, so they said something ambiguous. However, if it is harmonious and ambiguous, it is enough to reverse Zhang Zhengguo's unfavorable situation.

Qin Xiao saw that Su Xiaoman had completely eased up from the love he had just seen his father singing against him just now, so he made a forward gesture to him and Luo Chuan, and now Su Xiaoman is often with Luo Chuan and Qin Xiao, and a lot of the sign language used by the two of them in the army has been understood, so Xiao Man stood up and applied to speak:

"Mr. Judge, we are not very satisfied with the appraisal results of this book, we are not doubting the level of several experts, but as a few old experts said just now, after all, this book is a volume of the "Siku Quanshu" officially compiled in the pre-Qing Dynasty, and for these, the limitation that the three experts cannot reach after all, that is, the handwriting of the transcription of this book. Before the trial, my agents, Mr. Luo Chuan and Mr. Qin Xiao, went to the Palace Museum in person and expressed their willingness to donate the original copy to the museum, and they also agreed to send the person who knew the book best to see it, and if it was genuine, they were ready to receive it. What my agent means is that it is best to ask the collection unit of the "Siku Quanshu" to identify it, after all, whose child knows best. ”

The presiding judge said: "As for your request, considering that it is also a reasonable request, I don't know when it will be evaluated?" ”

Su Xiaoman said: "As long as the court can give accurate time, they will send someone to come over at any time to identify, and the court can also directly negotiate with their unit for specific details." ”

The presiding judge finally agreed to Su Xiaoman's suggestion, and three days later, the court immediately held an appraisal in court.

Without further talk, Qin Xiao immediately fed back the situation to Tang Ni, who had been on standby in Beijing, and after getting the situation, she also immediately fed back the situation to her colleagues in the Ministry of Culture.

Because of the avoidance, Qin Xiao and Su Xiaoman did not go to meet these appraisal experts, but judging from their strong lineup, Tang Ni helped them a lot, and among the five people, one of them was the current administrator of Wenyuan Pavilion.

As soon as they saw the book, several people were very excited, and they couldn't stop telling each other their opinions, and they could see extremely happy looks in their eyes. As soon as Qin Xiao saw this situation, he already knew what the result was, and sure enough, in less than five minutes, several experts said in unison that the real "Legacy of the Green Capsule" was true.

Zhang Zhengguo expected a qiē, but he didn't expect this hand, in this case, he always felt that Qin Xiao could always be one step ahead of him, so that every time he always suffered a loss, defeated and retreated, and every time he relied on continuous delay, he only coped with it until now, he now feels that Qin Xiao is a little terrible, which reminds him of Xu Jianhua who does not want to think but always forgets it.

But Zhang Zhengguo was unwilling to admit defeat, this time he did not ask his lawyer to quibble, but stood up directly and said:

"I have objections, may I ask the experts, how can you conclude that this book is a rare copy of the "Siku Quanshu"?"

Several people explained the reasons from different angles, not only for Zhang Zhengguo, but also for the jury in the audience. To sum up, there are the following points:

First of all, from the handwriting, you can see at a glance which person copied the handwriting; Second, when you touch the cover and the paper inside, you can understand that it is exactly the same paper as the real book in Wenyuan Pavilion, which is like many tellers can find counterfeit banknotes at once; Third, although some lines and glue are from the Republic of China period, but also for repair, from the entire binding process and habits, the spacing between the lines and these details, you can conclude that it is no different from the original Wenyuan Pavilion.

After listening to this, some people even applauded the experts' fine business level. (To be continued.) )