Updated: 2013-01-01

Yi Tianhao continued: "But the achievements of poetry cannot hide his other flaws, such as the ancient rooster and dog thief, their moral flaws cannot hide their outstanding ability, we cannot only look at the surface, but also look at two or more aspects. For example, you can't directly judge me as a good person because of my gentle and handsome appearance, in fact, I am a typical bad person, because men are not bad and women are not loved, so I can get the love of every girl. ”

Cheeky, the thickness of this cheek is really a bit amazing, this is a deeper and deeper sense of the whole class to Yi Tianhao, Yi Tianhao confessed to the school flower in front of him on the playground, proving Yi Tianhao's courage, and now Yi Tianhao has proved his cheekiness through facts, he really has courage and cheekiness, and it is a pity that this kind of character is not to be a politician.

"Actually, teacher, I have heard of your heroic views on Haizi more than once. In his essay "Religious Poets: Hai Zi and Luo Yihe", the Shanghai critic Zhu Dake gave Hai Zi's death a lofty ceremonial significance; As a result, Haizi became a hero, a symbol of the dedication of the Chinese poetry scene at the end of the 20th century, and some people even associated Haizi with Qu Yuan, Wang Guowei, Zhu Xiang, and even Sylvia Plath. , what is all this and what? Who doesn't know Qu Yuan? He was a patriotic poet who died for his homeland in the end, this is indeed a patriotic hero, but what about Haizi? Did he die for the sake of his country? Where is he sublime? ”

"He didn't die for the country, he didn't die to save people, if he died by diving to save people, then I admire him, he is a hero, but it's a pity he didn't! He is nothing, why should he be regarded as a hero, just because he is a poet? ”

Although Yi Tianhao's words were simple, they were easy to understand, and at this time, in addition to the stubbornness of some of the teachers in the class, many students had begun to nod secretly.

If he is really dedicated to the poetry, then he should not commit suicide, but should continue to write good poems and continue to make due contributions to the poetry, rather than directly cutting off his precious life. How old he was when he died, do you know? ”

Chen Jiandao: "25 years old. ”

"That's right, at the age of 25, just 25 years old, he committed suicide, if he lives, how much contribution can he make to China's poetry scene in the future? Have you thought about this? God gave him this talent, and he was obliterated by himself, is it a thing of appreciation? ”

Chen Jian defended: "This is only because his thoughts on the poetry stage have reached a certain height, and the sublimation of his spirit has brought about a conflict between ideals and reality, which has led him to the road of suicide." ”

Yi Tianhao sneered: "If anyone else committed suicide, would you still say that?" ”

Yi Tianhao pointed to a boy on the side and said, "If this male classmate commits suicide, will you also say that he is a hero, and will you also say that his spirit has been sublimated?" Surely not, you will criticize him after his death, criticize him for being naïve, frivolous, immature, a person's life is extremely precious, even the person himself has no right to end his life easily. According to the information I know, Haizi's parents are farmers, and a pair of farmers have provided him for so many years, can you understand this kind of hardship? You certainly can't, you will only immerse yourself in the world of those ethereal poems, your high has long forgotten the suffering in human reality, and the suffering you remember is also the beautiful sound of poetry and songs. ”

Chen Jian's face was a little ugly, and it became more and more difficult to refute at this moment, and some of the boys below who were envious, jealous and hated Chen Jian before began to cheer up.

Yi Tianhao continued to say impassionedly: "What a ridiculous thing to give a person's death as a noble sublimation of the spirit? Death is just an act of escape, no matter what kind of person's death, as long as it is meaningless death, it is an escape from life, don't you think Haizi is? His thoughts are noble, his spirit is noble, but his actions are cowardly, what he represents is a kind of escape, in the face of the reality of powerless struggle, he brings people not a spirit of active resistance, but a kind of absurd behavior of breaking free from prison and going to heaven to enjoy a carefree life since they cannot resist. ”

"He is an ordinary person, because his life is also brought by his parents, his parents who are physically exposed to his skin, he should not easily decide his life, his parents have provided him for so many years, and society has given him so many years, is he relying on a few poems written to repay his father and mother? Could it be that his father and mother's wish to let his own son live in his own life were easily deprived by him, and even then he was a noble spirit? What a bullshit fallacy. ”

"That's right, if this kid says this, it's not filial piety at all, it's not so easy for a couple of farmers to raise their children to college."

"That's it, if you say you're dead, you're dead, it's just a big unfilial piety, how painful it should be for a white-haired person to send a black-haired person!"

The students below finally began to discuss, obviously moved by Yi Tianhao's words, Chen Jian's words are the height of thought, but Yi Tianhao's words have returned to the actual reality, and the intensity is naturally much stronger, and Yi Tianhao is not nonsense, but clear and reasonable.

Yi Tianhao continued: "And his death, even in thought, is not as noble as imagined, in fact, it is no different from mortals, there are many factors in it. On the first side, Haizi himself has repeatedly proved that he is an immature man in behavior, and he has a suicide complex of his own. Haizi is a person with a suicidal complex, who attempted suicide in 1986. Spiritual clues to Haizi's suicide can also be found in a large number of Haizi's poems. For example, "The Sun Poetry Drama" published in the first and second issues of October in 1989 and his unpublished long poem "The Sun and the Decapitatorial" repeatedly and concretely talk about death—death and agriculture, death and earth, death and heaven, as well as blood, skulls, corpses, and so on. Even, Haizi talked to his friends about the way to commit suicide. Hai Zi is too deeply immersed in the image of death, the illusion of death, and the topic of death, all of which form a huge hint to Hai Zi, and causes him to finally fall uncontrollably into his own darkness. ”

At first, when Chen Jian listened to Yi Tianhao's eloquent talk, his face changed from disdain to anger, but now he also began to think quietly, with a thoughtful expression on his face, even the students around him, although they didn't know much about what Yi Tianhao talked about, and they didn't even know what Yi Tianhao said, but they also noticed this, and they couldn't help but be a little surprised in their hearts.

"The second point is his character traits, a person's character determines a person's fate. He is pure, simple, stubborn, sensitive, loves clean, sometimes a little sad, sometimes immersed in pain and can't extricate himself, and is persistent in ideal love. Maybe these are the spirits you said before, but he still has a kind of paranoia in these character traits, which undoubtedly determines his fate, a paranoid person who is prone to extremes, in fact, I personally think that this is not worth advocating. And how ridiculous it is that you, and many others, actually regard this as a sublimation of thought. ”

Third, Haizi's life is quite closed, and the simple and boring life harms Haizi, making him feel less warmth and joy in life. You can imagine that a person lives a monotonous life every day, lives over and over again, closes himself in a cage every day, and this shackles on himself cut off all the connections between a person and the outside world, and under this mode of life, it will naturally make a person feel bored in life. ”

Fourth, like all modern and contemporary Chinese poets, Haizi faces resistance on two fronts. On the one hand, there is the distrust of poets by some people in society, and the resistance of certain conservative literature to avant-garde literature. This is not a literary issue, but a political one. On the other hand, there is mutual distrust, mutual incomprehension, and mutual exclusion within the suppressed avant-garde literary circles. Haizi has been slandered and attacked a lot, he can't withstand this kind of psychological pressure, and his resistance to pressure is not as strong as he imagined. ”

"Fifth, Haizi, like many ordinary people, has an imperfect love, which is a fatal blow to a paranoid person like him, so in the end he went to the road of suicide."

After Yi Tianhao said this, he suddenly stopped and became silent, and Teacher Chen Jian couldn't help but ask, "What about the sixth?" ”

Yi Tianhao sneered: "Do you think that six points is not enough? ”

This time it was Chen Jian's turn to be silent, and the other students all watched quietly, waiting to see who the final victory of this debate belonged to, originally the students all thought that Yi Tianhao was just a naughty student who had nothing to do, and Teacher Chen Jian could make Yi Tianhao speechless in a few words, but he didn't expect Yi Tianhao to refute so sonorously and powerfully, and his calm and confident temperament when he spoke conquered many students, and many girls looked at Yi Tianhao. There was a sparkle in his eyes, and his heart was like a deer.

When Yi Tianhao was talking, he was like a general speaking on the command platform, calm and proud.

Chen Jian was silent for a long time, and finally said with a wry smile: "My thoughts for so many years have been completely refuted by your words, alas, what you just said is indeed very reasonable, even some big critics now, I'm afraid they don't have these unique opinions of yours, ashamed, ashamed." ”

As soon as Chen Jian's words came out, the whole class was in an uproar, just now they just vaguely felt that Yi Tianhao seemed to have the upper hand, but deep down they still couldn't believe it, after all, Chen Jian's identity was there, you know, Chen Jian is not only the most authoritative expert in Chinese language and literature at Bauhinia University, even if it is one of the authorities in the entire Sanjiang City, it can be called a little famous in the whole country, but now as soon as Chen Jian's words are spoken, fools can hear that Chen Jian is willing to bow down.

It is really an unthinkable thing to bow down to a student, and in literature, after a disagreement, he actually admits that his student is right, so in this way, isn't Yi Tianhao's level still above the authoritative expert? Oh my God, is he still a student?

ps: If you think this book is cool, please collect and read this book, every collection ticket and every red ticket is the greatest support for extraordinary.