After Li Dujun finished speaking, he licked his lips, this is a real fire in the debate. Li Chao does have a few brushes, good eloquence, skillful legal provisions, and rich debating skills. However, it is precisely because of this that Li Dujun is more interested in beating Li Chao.

With a kind of freedom and confidence, Li Weijun expressed his argumentative opinions, "I believe that the third party's gift of 4.71 million yuan to the defendant is legal and valid, and should not be returned. ”

"First of all, the defendant was not at fault in his dealings with a third person. The third party concealed his true identity and marital status and took the initiative to contact the defendant. The third party's rhetoric captured the defendant's favor, and the defendant's interaction with the third party was a legitimate love relationship, but it was only because the third party's purpose was impure and deliberately deceived that the two did not come together. ”

"Secondly, the act of donation by a third party is an expression of its true intention and is legal and valid. The third person is an adult citizen with full capacity for civil conduct. ”

"Judging from the acquaintance and love between the two, the third party paid the defendant money as a single and divorced person, and the purpose of the payment was to buy a house and a car for the two parties to live together in the future, and the defendant also used the money to buy a house and a car. Therefore, the act of giving a gift by a third party is an expression of the third party's true intention and is legal and valid. ”

Thirdly, the money involved in the case of 4.71 million yuan does not belong to the joint property of the husband and wife. The defendant had sufficient grounds to believe that the money was the personal property of a third party. The third party repeatedly flaunted in front of the defendant that he was rich and capricious, that he personally had a large amount of wealth, and said that he would voluntarily donate his personal property of 4.71 million yuan to the defendant as a guarantee for the defendant's divorce. Judging from the third party's statement and the living habits of the third party and the plaintiff, the 4.71 million yuan is the personal property of the third party. ”

"Finally, I would like to emphasize. Even if it is joint property, it is a third party who infringes on half of the plaintiff's joint property. The defendant's acquisition of the money was obtained in good faith. In the dealings between the third party and the defendant, the fault lies with the third party, and we are not at fault. As a weak woman, the defendant is a vulnerable group, and her rights and interests should be protected. Otherwise. It is unreasonable for a man to play hooligan and not bear any responsibility at all, which is unreasonable and violates the spirit of the law. ”

"To sum up, we believe that the plaintiff's claim should be dismissed!"

Li Dujun has an iron mouth and copper teeth, and the dead are said to be alive. Especially the last point, protecting the rights and interests of weak women, this point is really demagogic, and even the people's assessors can't help but nod.

Yu Ke'er's face was also a little bloody, and the strong psychological pressure brought by Li Chao before was relieved.

"A third person makes a statement of opinion."

Tong Yi drooped his head. There is no opening. Old Man Tong said excitedly: "Your Excellency, my unfilial son is at fault in his relationship with that woman, but that girl is not a good person, and she has a husband and has to entangle with my son." ”

"Such a bad girl, why should the law protect her, isn't this a disguised way to encourage other women to learn badly? The maid and my son will be condemned. The money I got as a junior should be returned to my daughter-in-law. ”

Old Man Tong reprimanded Yu Keer with a gun and a stick, and his words were not rough, and Li Chao smiled slightly when he heard it. Although this old man speaks funny, he can get to the point every time, and he can be regarded as a talent.

After the views of both sides were expressed, the presiding judge continued to preside over the trial, "and the three parties will present their final opinions." ”

"Request the court to support the plaintiff in accordance with the law!"

"Request the court to dismiss the plaintiff's claim!"

The defendant and the plaintiff had opposing opinions, and the presiding judge asked: "Whether the two parties agree to mediation." ”

Li Chao asked Chen Huiying. Then he nodded and said, "Agreed!" ”

Li Dujun replied indifferently: "Agreed!" ”

The presiding judge struck the gavel and announced: "The court will do mediation work for the plaintiff and the defendant respectively. The court will now be adjourned for 30 minutes. ”

The presiding judge first took the defense to another room to do mediation work.

Chen Huiying nervously asked Li Chao, "Lawyer Li, can you win this case?" At the time of mediation. What are we going to say? ”

Li Chao replied: "You must win this case, it is a question of how much 4.71 million yuan will be returned, the key is that we only froze to Yu Keer's house, she transferred the bank deposit and car smoothly, if you want to execute the rest of the money, it will be a little difficult." ”

Old Man Tong interjected, "Master Li, can't you ask that girl to return all the money?" ”

Lin Shanruo helped explain: "It's more troublesome, she transferred her property, and the court doesn't have the energy and it is difficult to verify whether it is a malicious transfer of property. ”

Chen Huiying then asked: "Lawyer Lin, what do we say during the mediation, and what is our position?" ”

Lin Shanruo patiently explained: "Then it depends on whether you can accept some concessions personally, the frozen house, the defendant will definitely not be able to escape." If the judgment is made, even if the court supports the refund in full, the enforcement will definitely start with the auction of the house......"

Before Lin Shanruo finished speaking, the judge had already walked over and asked Chen Huiying, "What is your mediation opinion here?" ”

Chen Huiying blushed and replied in a low voice, "I haven't figured it out yet." ”

The judge said to Chen Huiying: "You have hired two lawyers, they are both legal professionals, and they also know that the difficulty of your case lies in enforcement." Women are no better than men, she can find someone to marry at random, marry far away, it is difficult for you to find her, let alone chase her to pay back. ”

"What does the defendant mean now is that the house will be transferred to you, so what do you mean?"

Chen Huiying said sadly when she heard this: "Judge, this woman took all the money from my family, and the down payment and mortgage payment of this house are only 3.55 million yuan, and there is still a difference of 1.16 million yuan from 4.71 million yuan, the difference is too big!" ”

Lin Shanruoqiao had righteous indignation on her face, and also said: "Yes, judge, Chen Huiying is not at fault in this incident, why should she bear the loss, the defendant was immoral in this matter, and her illegal interests cannot be protected." Only the house was transferred, and the plaintiff's loss was too great. ”

The judge explained loudly to everyone: "Litigation is risky, it must be difficult to recover the money if it is given, and the third party is also at fault in this matter." ”

"Now it's a matter of mediation, and I'm just going to talk about a judge's free will. My personal opinion does not represent the opinion of the collegial panel, so please refer to it. ”

"Even if the court sentenced the defendant to return the full amount of 4.71 million yuan, she refused to perform, and the person ran away and married to another place, where are you going to get the money? It's not about starting with that house yet. When it comes to the execution stage, it is not as good as the current mediation, and the house cannot be directly transferred to your name, and the auction price must be auctioned first, and the auction price will be discounted to your execution fee. ”

"You think about what the court auctions off, what price can be sold, and then after deducting the relevant fees. After paying the mortgage from the bank, you get less money in hand. It is better to let the defendant cooperate now, transfer the house to your name, you go to repay the mortgage, and the house belongs to you. This is less than the loss. You tell me? ”

Li Chao listened to Lang with a look of enlightenment in his eyes, this is Li Dujun's trick, transfer the property in advance, let the plaintiff have no way to take the junior, and finally force the plaintiff to give in.

Sure enough, it is not according to common sense, and it is used to the extreme. Li Chao has a more intuitive impression of Li Dujun, this person is both good and evil, and there is nothing else in his eyes. There is only a way to win the case, and the rest are the means to win the case, no matter how despicable the means. He'll use it.

Li Chao immediately broke through: "Judge, you can't have the same point of view as the defendant, and you can't look at the problem from the defendant's standpoint." The defendant's malicious transfer of his property in order to evade future enforcement is inherently subjective and should be sanctioned by the court.

"The defendant is not incapacitated. Judge, I think you should be working harder on the other side. You can't just take her because the other party transfers property. Where is the judicial authority? ”

Old Man Tong also said excitedly: "Yes, that girl didn't pay attention to it, she was going to pay this money." ”

The judge asked Chen Huiying again: "Since you don't agree with the house, then you can express your opinions." ”

Chen Huiying looked at Li Chao pleadingly. Li Chao explained: "This is mediation, and it is completely voluntary. The purpose of mediation is to close the case quickly and get the money early. If you are willing to concede some steps, you can give your opinion. The judge asks you how much money the other party still pays, and you think it's appropriate. ”

Chen Huiying thought for a while and said to the judge: "Originally, the other party should have returned all 4.71 million yuan to me. However, I think it's all for women's sake, so I'll give in. ”

"She just needs to transfer the house and pay me an extra 1 million yuan."

The judge shook his head and said, "I have to pay 1 million yuan, which is too big a difference, and the other party will definitely not agree." You can tell me another number. ”

"Your case is better mediated. If the judgment is made, first, it will be difficult to enforce, second, the house transfer procedures will be troublesome in the future, and third, it will not have a good reputation when it is said. So I'm personally building yì, you make a little bit more and say a suitable number. ”

After listening to the judge's words, Chen Huiying gritted her teeth and said: "Okay, my biggest concession, except for the house, as long as she pays another 800,000 yuan." I conceded 620,000 yuan, which is already the biggest concession. ”

Li Chao also said loudly: "Judge, you go to do the other party's work, we have conceded 620,000 yuan, if the other party still refuses, it is better for the court to make a judgment according to law, we are waiting to execute, although it is more difficult to execute, but this case is gone, the court will go to her every year, and the defendant should not think about living a good life!" ”

Li Chao is putting pressure on the judge, or the judge thinks that Chen Huiying is easier to talk here, and will keep pressuring Chen Huiying to make concessions.

The judge nodded and said that he would go back to the defendant's work. Chen Huiying's eyes were a little red, she looked at Li Chao, and said uneasily: "Superman lawyer, will I make too many concessions like this." ”

Li Chao smiled faintly and comforted: "It's good if you can accept it, the money is earned by people, as long as the family is fine." ”

As soon as Li Chao's words fell, Li Dujun and the others followed the judge. Seeing the defendant, Old Man Tong snorted heavily, Chen Huiying's eyes were also red, and Tong Yi lowered his head and didn't dare to say anything.

Li Dujun greeted everyone with a smile, looking familiar, and then said to Chen Huiying: "Everyone is harmonious, Yu Keer did lose money in partnership with others, and now she doesn't have a penny, and she still owes a lot of debt." Yu Keer dated Tong Yi, got married and divorced, and got nothing, which was quite pitiful. It's too difficult for a weak woman like her, who has nothing, to come up with 1 million yuan. Chen Huiying, can you make some more concessions? ”

Chen Huiying shook her head with red eyes, and the old man Tong also pointed with his fingers, and said: "You mage, your words are too unreasonable, the female servant took 4.71 million yuan from my son and daughter-in-law, where will there be no money?" ”

Li Chao immediately refuted unceremoniously: "Everyone understands people, don't open your eyes and talk nonsense." Tong Yi transferred 4.71 million yuan to the defendant. The defendant only used the money to buy a car and a house, and did not use it for anything, so how could the money be missing. On the day the case was filed, Yu Keer took out the bank deposit and transferred the car to others, saying that it was a debt payment. ”

"Everyone is not a three-year-old child, and your so-called debt payment does not have any corresponding evidence. If you dig deeper, you will also be held accountable for transferring your property and refusing to carry it out. Now that we have given in, and you still don't agree, your heart is too dark. “

Li Dujun smiled absently, and said to Li Chao: "Lawyer Li, you said that we deliberately transferred property, not to pay off debts, you can go and investigate." If it is found out, we are deliberately repaying the debt, how about our full refund of 4.71 million yuan? ”

Li Dujun said without fear, he expected that Li Chao would not be able to verify it at all. Because it is difficult to verify whether the property was deliberately transferred, they have already found a good trust and fully cooperated with Yu Keer, so that outsiders can't see the flaws.

Li Chao smiled slightly, and immediately said excitedly: "Okay, lawyer Dujun, since you said such cruel words." Then please ask the court to temporarily stop announcing the verdict, give us half a month, and I will definitely find out! ”

Deliberately colluding with others to transfer property to avoid fulfilling responsibilities, this is difficult for others to find out, but for Li Chao, who has mind reading skills, it is really a piece of cake!

Therefore, Li Chao deliberately pretended not to be provoked and let out loud words, but in fact, his heart blossomed. (To be continued)

ps: Thank you for the, God comes to reward as much as 100! R580