Li Chao adjusted his feelings and calmly asked Yao Lianhua: "Yao Lianhua, after Ye Tianlong's failed election as a public opinion representative and beat you, Lawyer Lin and I have already reported to the public security organs on your behalf, demanding that Ye Tianlong be held criminally responsible for intentional injury.

When the public security organs approached you for an investigation, how did you answer? ”

Yao Lianhua lowered her head and replied ashamedly: "I told the police who came to investigate that I fell and injured myself, and it has nothing to do with Ye Tianlong." ”

Li Chao then asked: "Why did you say that at that time? The public security organs have filed a case for investigation, why don't you let the law severely punish Ye Tianlong's violent behavior? ”

Yao Lianhua tilted her head, took a deep breath, and sighed faintly: "I...... At the time, I thought that there was no need for a husband and wife...... I just want to divorce him and get my fair share of the property and all four children to raise. ”

Yao Lianhua's kindness was really heartbreaking, and everyone sighed when they heard it. It turned out that before the case, the public security organs had already filed a case against Ye Tianlong for investigation, and if Yao Lianhua insisted on using the law to punish Ye Tianlong, the tragedy that followed would not have happened.

Hearing everyone's sighs, Li Chao nodded with satisfaction, and then asked, "After the incident, did you repent of your crimes?" ”

Yao Lianhua's tears came out again, and she sobbed, "I...... I regret it very much, I feel so uncomfortable, whether I open my eyes or close my eyes, I think that Ye Tianlong is gone.

I shouldn't be like this, he still loves me, otherwise he would have beaten me to death in the past ten years, I really regret it! As long as he leaves Lan Yu'er, he and I can still come together and raise the children together. ”

Yao Lianhua repented very sincerely, but everyone was speechless when she heard this.

Li Chao just wants to show Yao Lianhua's kindness and weakness, so that everyone can fully understand Yao Lianhua's character. Such a docile person, such a hard-working woman who was tortured and still tolerated Ye Tianlong, finally killed her husband in anger. The extent of the pain and suffering can be imagined by everyone.

Li Chao said to the presiding judge: "Presiding judge, our inquiry is over. ”

"Now it has entered the stage of presenting evidence and cross-examination, and both sides will each present evidence to prove their claims, and the prosecutor will submit evidence first."

Xu Ling was prepared and said loudly: "The prosecution submitted a total of five sets of evidence.

1. The iron frame, which is stained with the blood of the deceased Ye Tianlong and the fingerprints of the defendant Yao Lianhua, proves that the defendant Yao Lianhua smashed Ye Tianlong to death with an iron frame.

2. The autopsy report proves that the deceased Ye Tianlong died of shock caused by cranial trauma, that is to say, the defendant directly stoned the deceased to death with an iron frame.

3. Half a wine bottle. It was stained with the blood of the deceased and the fingerprints of the defendant Yao Lianhua, proving that the defendant Yao Lianhua cruelly cut the hou with a wine bottle after Ye Tianlong's death, which was excessive harm, the circumstances were heinous, and the methods were cruel.

4. Photos of the scene of the deceased Ye Tianlong, from the photos, we can clearly see that most of Ye Tianlong's neck was cut through, and it was connected to the flesh and blood of his head that was only two or three centimeters long, proving that the defendant's criminal methods were extremely cruel. After killing the deceased, he also frantically cut his head, the circumstances were heinous, and the subjective malice was great.

5. The interrogation record of the defendant Yao Lianhua during the investigation stage, in which Yao Lianhua made a statement verbally. Because she was beaten by Ye Tianlong and Ye Tianlong abandoned her, she killed Ye Tianlong with resentment, proving that the defendant subjectively and intentionally conspired to kill Ye Tianlong, and that he was a serious danger to society. ”

With Xu Ling's evidence. The bailiff on duty presented the evidence in turn, and the iron frame and the wine bottle were all physical evidence, and the bailiff on duty held it in his hand to display.

For the autopsy report, Yao Lianhua's interrogation transcript and a photograph of the deceased Ye Tianlong. The clerk uses a projector and a large screen to show the crowd one by one.

The evidence presented by Xu Ling fully proved that the defendant Yao Lianhua deliberately killed Ye Tianlong, and also tried to instill in the court the view that Yao Lianhua maliciously cut off Ye Tianlong's head after Ye Tianlong's death, and the method was extremely cruel, the circumstances were heinous, and the subjective malice was great, and should be severely punished.

After seeing Sen Sen's murder weapon, everyone had a depressed feeling in their hearts, facing the murder weapon, no matter what, they felt a little uncomfortable in their hearts.

The presiding judge said: "The defendant cross-examined evidence. ”

Yao Lianhua lowered her head, not daring to look at these murder weapons, but replied in a low voice with tears in her eyes: "These are all true, I have no opinion." ”

Yao Lianhua is simple and honest, and has no legal knowledge, so she also recognizes the content of the proof that is unfavorable to herself.

Li Chao immediately loudly expressed his cross-examination opinions for Yao Lianhua.

"Respected presiding judge, as Yao Lianhua's defense lawyer, I would like to supplement the cross-examination as follows: I have no objection to the authenticity and legality of evidence 1, but I have objections to the content of the evidence, although the defendant smashed Ye Tianlong with an iron frame, she is not sure whether Ye Tianlong was stoned to death.

There is no objection to the authenticity and legitimacy of Evidence 2, but we want to explain that the defendant, as a rural woman, does not have sufficient medical knowledge to determine whether Ye Tianlong was stoned to death when he was smashed with an iron frame.

There is no objection to the authenticity of evidence 3, and we also put forward in our defense opinion that this is in line with the response model of domestic violence victims, and it cannot be determined that Yao Lianhua's methods are cruel and the circumstances are heinous, and we insist on the defense opinion.

There is no objection to the authenticity of evidence 4, but the content of the proof is not established, Yao Lianhua was worried that Ye Tianlong was not dead, and recovered, but instead intensified her destruction, in order to ensure that Ye Tianlong died, she took excessive harm.

In this regard, we have repeatedly emphasized that it is in line with the law of resistance of the victims, and the target of their crimes is only the perpetrator Ye Tianlong, and there is no danger to other members of society! ”

After listening to Li Chao's supplementary cross-examination opinions, Yao Lianhua nodded painfully and hurriedly said, "Yes, yes, I agree with Lawyer Li's opinion." ”

Yao Lianhua's family also nodded again and again, at the beginning, Xu Ling put all the evidence on the table, it was really ironclad, Yao Lianhua and her family felt that it was difficult to refute, and they didn't know how to express their opinions.

Fortunately, Li Chao was powerful, and with a sharp rebuttal, he tore off the cruel label that Xu Ling attached to Yao Lianhua.

Xu Ling's delicate apricot eyes looked at Li Chao curiously, and Li Chao always emphasized that Yao Lianhua's excessive victimization behavior was in line with the general rules of dealing with victims of domestic violence.

Xu Ling wanted to know whether what Li Chao said was correct or not, and whether Yao Lianhua's reaction did not conform to = the general law, although she was a legal professional, she did not have an in-depth study of domestic violence, and she was looking forward to how Li Chao would prove it.

Not only did Xu Ling want to know how Li Chao could prove that Yao Lianhua's methods were not cruel, but even the judges of the collegial panel were full of eagerness and expectation.

The presiding judge excitedly looked at the application for professional witnesses to testify in court, which Li Chao had submitted to the court before the trial.

Before Li Chao repeatedly said that Yao Lianhua's excessive harm was a general law, the judges also heard it in a fog, and the defendant was about to present evidence, and it was almost time to uncover the mystery.

Presiding Judge Meng Qingge suppressed the restlessness and excitement in his heart, and said calmly: "Now the defendant submits evidence to this court. ”

The highlight is coming, thousands of words are empty without evidence to support them, although Li Chao has successfully shown Yao Lianhua's tragic experience before, and also showed Yao Lianhua's docile and even cowardly character, winning the sympathy of the collegial panel and the audience.

However, this is far from enough, and if the collegial panel wants to reduce the punishment of Yao Lianhua, it is necessary to wash away the stain of Yao Lianhua's cruel murder methods and heinous circumstances, which is the top priority of this case.

Now the opportunity has come, and it is finally Li Chao's turn to present evidence, and the big trump card that Li Chao has carefully prepared can be revealed.

Li Chao and Shanruo glanced at each other, Shanruo nodded admiringly, and both of them smiled.

Shanruo laid out the thick stack of evidence, Li Chao said confidently: "As the defendant's defense lawyer, I submit the following evidence to the court. ”

"1. The defendant's marriage certificate and household registration book prove that the defendant and Ye Tianlong are husband and wife, and that the two parties gave birth to three daughters and one son after marriage.

2. Three witness statements, two proofs and a letter for help. The three testimonies were given by Yao Lianhua's three fellow villagers, Yao Lianhua's cousin and cousin-in-law, and Yao Lianhua's neighbors, respectively stating that on December 30, 2013, they saw Ye Tianlong beating Yao Lianhua in a chess and card room, that Ye Tianlong chased Yao Lianhua with a knife in a restaurant, and that Yao Lianhua was beaten and called for help every night next to the house.

The two certificates were issued by the village committees of Yao Lianhua and Ye Tianlong, respectively, and the content of the two certificates was that the village committees of both parties had reconciled their marriages because of Ye Tianlong's domestic violence.

The letter was written by Yao Lianhua, who sent me a request for help, in which Yao Lianhua described in detail the domestic violence she had suffered over the years.

This set of evidence can fully prove that Ye Tianlong has been suffering from domestic violence for a long time, which has destroyed Yao Lianhua's physical and mental health.

3. Three medical certificates and two disability reports.

On December 30, 2013, after Ye Tianlong poisoned Yao Lianhua in the chess and card room, Yao Lianhua was seriously injured and hospitalized, and the hospital diagnosed skin trauma and skull trauma.

On the night of Ye Tianlong's failure to run for public opinion, he beat Yao Lianhua again, and Yao Lianhua was taken to the hospital for emergency treatment by me and lawyer Lin Shanruo, who diagnosed a fracture of his right hand, a large area of skin contusion throughout his body, and a traumatic injury to the skull, which was determined to constitute a minor injury of Grade A.

On the day of the incident, Yao Lianhua was beaten to death by Ye Tianlong again, and the forensic examination determined that the skull was cracked, concussion, skin burns, muscle damage from the back bat, and facial nerve damage, constituting a second-degree serious injury.

These materials favorably prove that Ye Tianlong's domestic violence was brutal and the consequences were vile, resulting in Yao Lianhua's multiple disabilities all over her body. ”

Li Chaobian said that the clerk Bian Tong Guò projector displayed the evidence on the big screen.

These evidences fully prove Ye Tianlong's evil deeds of domestic violence, and everyone gritted their teeth and was furious when they saw it. Yao Lianhua's parents saw it, and they were even more heartbroken, so that a daughter was beaten inhumanly by Ye Tianlong.

And Ye Tianlong's parents looked at the evidence, pursed their lips, their faces were pale, and they closed their eyes in anger. (To be continued......)

ps: Thank you for An Ruo calmly for the 2 monthly passes, and proudly ask: "Dear friends, are there any rewards?" ”R1292