Chapter 149: Uncooperative

Yao Lianhua's words were sincere, and Li Chao and Shanruo nodded again and again when they heard it. Shanruo's eyes were red, and she responded excitedly, "Yao Lianhua, don't worry!" We will definitely try our best to help you fight this lawsuit and try to convince the court to give you a lenient judgment! ”

Yao Lianhua rubbed her hands, kowtowed her head directly to the platform to kowtow, and begged bitterly: "Superman Lawyer, Lawyer Lin, I ask you, you must help me!" ”

Li Chao waved his hand again and again and refused to accept Yao Lianhua's kowtow gift.

Li Chao persuaded loudly: "Don't kowtow, don't kowtow, we know your current situation, you have been beaten before, so you will kill people in anger, we will also work hard to handle your case well and help you get back to fairness and justice." ”

When the prison guard saw Yao Lianhua suddenly hit the platform with her head, thinking that she was self-harming, her eyes suddenly widened, and she immediately rushed up nervously, quickly stepped forward and clasped Yao Lianhua with her backhand, and shouted loudly: "Be honest, don't move!" ”

Shanruo hurriedly stood up and explained to the prison guards inside: "Officer, don't get me wrong, she didn't harm herself. She was kowtowing to us and asking us to help settle the lawsuit. ”

Li Chao also stood up and explained, "Yes, don't misunderstand, the police officer is indeed kowtowing to express her request, and she has no intention of self-harm, this is all a misunderstanding." ”

Yao Lianhua herself also said again and again: "Officer, I'm just kowtowing to the two lawyers, I don't have any other ideas, I really don't have any other ideas." ”

If a prisoner injures himself, the prison guard may take further coercive measures to punish and restrain the prisoner. After a long explanation, the prison guards did not deal with it further, but they still kept a straight face and said majestically: "When the meeting time comes, Yao Lianhua, you will be imprisoned immediately!" ”

The prison guards escorted Yao Lianhua out, and Yao Lianhua turned back pitifully from time to time, her eyes full of pleading, begging Li Chao that they must help her win the lawsuit.

With a bang, the iron door slammed shut, and Yao Lianhua's figure completely disappeared behind the door. Shanruo's big eyes looked at the closed door stupidly, and the whole person was stunned for a while, this woman was really pitiful.

Seeing that the two of them hadn't moved, the prison guard next to him reminded: "The meeting is over, please go out with me!" ”

Li Chao and Shanruo followed the prison guards out of the detention center. Standing in the open space outside the gate of the detention center, Shanruo frowned and asked, "Li Chao, how are you going to collect evidence, and what evidence can prove that Yao Lianhua's murderous methods are not cruel?" ”

"Yao Lianhua's inner thoughts at that time are impossible to express externally, and it is difficult for us to find evidence to prove her inner thoughts!"

Shanruo was always worried that he would not be able to wash away the stain of Yao Lianhua's cruel methods and bad circumstances. The actual situation is indeed the case, and now it can be shown that Yao Lianhua did not intend to torture and kill, but Yao Lianhua herself had her inner thoughts at that time, but how can her inner thoughts be proved? There are no witnesses and no corresponding evidence, so it is impossible to confirm whether Yao Lianhua really thought that way when she cut it.

Li Chao's brows also frowned, his brain was running at high speed, to be honest, he really hadn't thought of a way to deal with it now. In order to appease her, Li Chao agreed to help her explain to the judge that there was no cruelty in her ways. But Yao Lianhua did cut her hou more than a dozen times, and how to prove that this kind of excessive harm was for self-protection, this is really a big question mark.

If you say yes, you have to do it, but how to do it is really a headache. The only thing that can show that the killing method is not cruel is Yao Lianhua's inner thoughts, but what can his inner thoughts be used to prove it?

Mind reading? Mind reading is not at all in this case, Yao Lianhua is a criminal suspect, and he is her defense lawyer, so it is completely useless to read her heart.

Li Chao has encountered a big test, Li Chao, as a defense lawyer, wants to defend the criminal suspect Yao Lianhua, and the victim Ye Tianlong has been killed, Li Chao's mind reading skills are useless, he has lost his biggest weapon and dependence!

Wouldn't it be possible that without mind reading, I wouldn't be able to handle cases? No, I also need professional legal ability, I must be able to think of a way, and I will definitely be able to help Yao Lianhua win a lighter punishment! Li Chao thought unwillingly in his heart.

Li Chaolang had a look of determination in his eyes, and said affirmatively: "Don't be discouraged, there are always more ways than difficulties, and the difficulty in this case is how to prove that Yao Lianhua's excessive harm is not a particularly cruel means!" This is a difficult point and a breakthrough point, there must be a way, let's think about it carefully. ”

Shanruo listened, but shook his head in frustration, with a yin on his face, and said with a wry smile: "How can it be revealed? Since there were no witnesses to see through her heart, and there was no evidence to record her inner thoughts, how could the judge be sure that she was not tortured and killed at that time, but for self-preservation, fearing that she would be counterattacked, so she carried out excessive harm? ”

Shanruo said, "There is no witness to see through her heart", a lightning bolt flashed in Li Chao's mind, and with a flash of inspiration, Li Chao instantly grasped the key point to solve the problem.

With the certainty of success in his heart, Li Chao immediately stretched his brows, with excitement in his eyes, and said happily: "I have a way!" ”

Shanruo saw Li Chao's brows stretched, and immediately asked curiously and excitedly: "Li Chao, what solution have you thought of?" Say it! Say it! ”

Li Chao smiled slightly, and said: "I can't be sure yet, but I just thought of a way, and after going back and asking, I can determine whether it is effective." ”

Shanruo became interested, stared at Li Chao with a pair of beautiful eyes, and couldn't wait to ask: "Li Chao, don't hang my appetite, okay." What is the solution, you can reveal it to me first, and I will see if it is feasible? ”

Seeing Shanruo's anxious appearance, Li Chao no longer procrastinated, and smiled and told all his guesses and what he was going to do.

After Shanruo listened, Liu Mei also stretched out, her big eyes were full of joy, and she sincerely appreciated: "Li Chao, you are too powerful, this method should be feasible, I think Yao Lianhua, as a victim of domestic violence, will definitely have a certain pattern in her inner activities, and what we have to do is to present this law to the court." ”

Li Chao nodded and said, "Well, the key to judging whether Yao Lianhua is a murderer with heinous circumstances and cruel means is here." However, this evidence is still a little verified, let's not rush, let's go back and verify the investigation. ”

"Now, let's go to the Public Security Bureau to apply for two pieces of evidence, one is the relevant information about Ye Tianlong's improper relationship with Lan Yuer in Ye Tianlong's mobile phone, and the other is Yao Lianhua's injury report."

These two sets of evidence are strong evidence to prove that Ye Tianlong committed serious mistakes, and their extraction will go a long way in reducing the punishment of Yao Lianhua.

Shanruo excitedly agreed, found a way to wash away the stain of Yao Lianhua's crime, and after removing the biggest knot, Shanruo's whole person felt refreshed and full of fighting spirit again.

The two drove to the Public Security Bureau again. When they came to the Criminal Investigation Brigade of the Public Security Bureau, Li Chao and Shanruo submitted a written application to the criminal police handling the case to collect evidence.

The criminal police officer handling the case roughly looked through the written application, and then directly refused: "This has nothing to do with our investigation of the homicide case, and there is no need for us to obtain these two pieces of evidence." ”

Li Chao explained with a smile: "Officer, it is fairer for the criminal suspect Yao Lianhua to comprehensively investigate the motive for Yao Lianhua's murder and why the entire murder case happened, and investigate the case clearly." And these two sets of evidence can effectively prove the situation before the crime and why Yao Lianhua killed in passion, so it is quite valuable, and I ask the police officer to help collect it. ”

When the police heard this, they still shook their heads and shirked: "The job of our public security organs is to solve the case, and your two pieces of evidence are not obviously related to the facts of the case, and your intention in collecting these two pieces of evidence is to reduce Yao Lianhua's culpability." This is your lawyer's job, you have become Yao Lianhua's defense lawyer and received money from others, so you must find a way to find evidence in her favor. ”

"But our Public Security Bureau, as an investigative agency, has a neutral position and cannot be biased in favor of criminal suspects, and we cannot help your side to obtain evidence that mitigates the criminal suspect's crime!"

Li Chao smiled and patiently persuaded: "Officer, these two pieces of evidence are directly related to this case, and now Ye Tianlong's mobile phone is seized in your bureau, and Yao Lianhua is also being held in the detention center, it is impossible for our lawyer to obtain these two pieces of evidence by his personal ability, so he can only apply to your unit for help in obtaining them." Our application is also in accordance with the law, and we ask the police officer to understand that it will be collected during the investigation. ”

The policeman said impatiently: "I have already sued you, the evidence you want to collect has nothing to do with our investigation, you have to find a way to collect the corresponding evidence by yourself, but you can't collect it, and you need the cooperation of our Public Security Bureau, and it is not your lawyer who comes directly to our Public Security Bureau, and our Public Security Bureau has no obligation to assist the lawyer in obtaining this evidence." ”

"In this case, your feasible way is to apply to the court to come to our public security bureau to collect evidence at the litigation stage of the case."

Obviously, the police who undertook the case didn't want to do much, and they didn't want to cooperate with Li Chao and be kind to them, but they just wanted to shirk it.

Li Chao tried to persuade again, and persuaded without humility or arrogance: "Police officer, according to the corresponding provisions of the Criminal Procedure Law, the defense lawyer has the right to apply to the investigation agency to obtain the corresponding evidence, and also ask the police officer to act in accordance with the law. ”

The undertaker officer had a blank face and immediately replied: "We are doing things according to the law!" Your defense lawyer has the right to apply under the law, and our investigative agency also has a law that cannot unilaterally collect evidence irrelevant to the case for the client. ”

This is a complete refusal, the police made it clear that they would not accept Li Chao and Shanruo's application to collect evidence, but they didn't expect the police to be so uncooperative.

Seeing that he was at an impasse, Shanruo asked euphemistically: "Then can we find your leader and communicate and reflect the situation?" ”

The policeman replied coldly and unhappily: "It's really unfortunate that our captain and the leader in charge have gone to the city for a meeting, and they won't be back until tomorrow." ”

As he spoke, the police directly pushed over the application for collecting evidence and returned it to Li Chao. After Li Chao took the application, he smiled slightly, and said without discouragement: "Okay, then we will go to the procuratorate to report the situation and apply for an investigation!" ”

The policeman ignored it and said "please"! Immediately, bury yourself in other things. R1152