"Master Mu, Master Xiao, what do you think?"

Seeing that everyone was amazed by the two exquisite enamel porcelain, Mr. He was naturally very happy, and then he began to ask Mu Lao and others who were sitting on the appraisal seat, those people were the masters he specially invited to do the appraisal, all of them were quite famous in the antique industry, they were authoritative figures, whether the porcelain could be affirmed, it depended on Mu Lao's opinions.

Mu Lao did not immediately answer Mr. He's question, at this moment, I saw that his expression was solemn, and there was a thoughtful light in his eyes, but no one knew what he was thinking in his heart.

"Mr. He, I took a closer look at the pair of enamel color vases just now, and in my opinion, there is no problem, it is something that opens the door wide!" A master sitting next to Mu Lao replied loudly, it was an old man with white hair but a ruddy complexion, who was about the same age as Mu Lao, and it was estimated that he was also a master in this industry, if he was not completely sure, he would not be so sure.

"Master Xiao, so to speak, the two enamel colors I bought are genuine, there is no doubt about it?" Mr. He asked with a smile, with the affirmation of the master on the stage, he was even more happy, as if the dust had settled, and the pair of enamel color bottles in his hands were undoubtedly genuine.

"Well, at least that's what I think, and my opinion won't change." Master Xiao nodded vigorously.

"That's good." Mr. He said happily, and then he glanced at the appraisers on both sides, and continued to ask, "Then the other masters, do you have different opinions?" If you have any thoughts in your heart, just say it directly, don't bury it in your heart, I want to be foolproof, and I must not go on any errands! Otherwise, if I get the wrong thing, after giving it to my father, he may recognize it, and then the work will be lost. ”

His words were solemn and earnest.

Except for Mu Lao, who was silent for a while, the rest of the masters did not have any objections, and they were full of praise.

At the same time, most of the audience applauded, but Yi Yang, who was sitting quietly in the crowd, was not excited at all, because he probably saw more than anyone present, and knew that the two pieces of fine enamel porcelain were only fakes, not real enamel porcelain.

Mr. He is really eye-catching this time!

Seeing that Master Xiao and the old master didn't see the slightest problem, Yi Yang couldn't help but be a little disappointed in his heart, it seemed that there were many experts who were not worthy of their names and were not so authoritative.

However, he quickly thought about it, and only said that it was enough to imitate the real one, and it was done vividly and flawlessly, and it was understandable that some experts could not see it.

And he only found it by relying on his ability, and without this special ability, he would not be able to tell whether something is real or fake.

"Did Mu Lao see that something famous?" Yi Yang thought to himself, at this moment his eyes were fixed on Mu Lao on the stage, and he saw that Mu Lao had a solemn expression, obviously having different ideas, but he hadn't said it yet.

Sure enough, I suddenly only heard Mu Lao say loudly: "Mr. He, I have a few words that I don't vomit and are unhappy!" ”

"Master Mu, please speak." Mr. He said politely, "What's the matter, but it's okay to say it!" ”

Mu Lao Ke is one of the chief appraisers he invited, so he naturally attaches great importance to the other party's opinion.

Mu Lao said solemnly: "I have also seen those two pieces of porcelain, from the shape to the color, to the decoration, they are very exquisite, impeccable!" However, I have a question, such a good pair of enamel porcelain, and a large bottle, I'm afraid it's not so easy to find, right? ”

Before Mr. He could speak, Master Xiao on the side said first, and only said, "Master Mu, didn't Mr. He say it clearly and clearly just now?" The pair of enamel vases was acquired by him with a lot of connections, so it was naturally not easy to find what you said. ”

Many people, including Mr. He, nodded in agreement, however, Mu Lao hurriedly shook his head and said: "I didn't mean that, I mean, there are very few heavy weapons like this, and they are rare, and now there is a complete pair, which is very debatable, isn't it, everyone?" Antiques, we have to have them first, we can find them, otherwise it's a fabricated 'monster'.

"As we all know, the enamel color boutique is the Qing Dynasty court porcelain, the folk is not, when the Republic of China is about to know this unique porcelain, the production, imitation of enamel porcelain kilns and workshops have gradually risen, can be manufactured enamel porcelain in addition to a few skilled imitation, basically are shoddy, can not be compared with the official kiln in the court. Most of the fine enamel porcelain handed down from the court is preserved in the National Museum of Zài, and cannot be collected by private individuals. ”

"You're right, that's just the majority, and it's not surprising that some have left the court, fallen into the hands of private collectors, and now are in the hands of Mr. Ho." Master Xiao said disappreciatively, "Otherwise, how can the auction company sometimes come up with some fine products for auction?" Personally, I think that Mr. He's pair of enamel porcelain is very open-minded, and it is a one-glance item, not controversial. ”

"Yes, if there is something wrong with something, then you have to put out the evidence, otherwise it is just a guess!" Someone said in agreement.

Hearing someone questioning like that, Mu Lao shook his head helplessly and said: "I'm not just guessing, but also have real evidence, maybe it can be used to explain that the real situation of this pair of enamel porcelain is not as good as everyone sees." ”

"What evidence?!"

As soon as he said this, Mr. He couldn't help frowning, his expression was a little nervous, in fact, not only did he react greatly, but everyone else present also reacted greatly, and even Yi Yang's face changed faintly.

"Could it be that Mu Lao has already seen the clue?!" Yi Yang secretly exclaimed.

Finally someone came up with him, and finally someone did not disappoint him, and had a different opinion on the ostensibly undisputed counterfeit porcelain.

In fact, since he met Mu Lao, Yi Yang has respected the other party very much and admires the other party's identification ability very much.

Now Mu Laoli put forward his own different views, and he looked at it differently, but he didn't know if the other party could point to the key point and point out the problems of the two porcelains.

"Mr. He, masters, I won't tell you anything, I have seen this kind of enamel porcelain before, and it can be said to be exactly the same as this pair!" Mr. Zheng then said, "Not long ago, a friend of mine bought such a pair of beautiful enamel vases from an auction company at a high price, but the result was identified as a fake. ”

"Huh?! Is there such a thing?! Exactly the same as me?! Mr. He exclaimed.

Zheng Lao nodded heavily and said, "Yes, it's exactly the same, it's just as beautiful!" But that's fake porcelain! ”

Hearing what Mu Lao said, Master Xiao and other masters looked at each other, their eyes were full of doubts, they didn't believe that the pair of porcelain that Mr. He took out for identification was a fake, but they couldn't deny that Mu Lao's words were false, people as virtuous and respected as him should not tell lies, and it didn't do him any good.

For a while, there was a lot of discussion in the treasure hall, and many people questioned it, because they didn't dare to imagine how such a beautiful pair of enamel porcelain could be fakes, and thought that Mu Lao's words were unrealistic.

"How was that identified?" Mr. He asked anxiously.

Mu Lao said: "This matter is a long story, but what I said is true, and there is no falsehood. ”

"Of course I believe you!" Mr. He hurriedly nodded and said, "It's just that a piece of porcelain is a fake, so you have to give actual evidence, otherwise how to determine?" Master Mu, please tell me truthfully, we are discussing, you can say anything, don't have any scruples. Didn't you just say that I have nothing wrong with this thing in your opinion? If that's fine, why should you be skeptical? ”

Mu Lao hesitated for a moment, and then said, "Okay, then I'll tell you about that matter from beginning to end." Here's the thing, my friend received the two pieces of porcelain and asked me to come and see them, and I was very optimistic at the time, there was no problem, and he thought that it was very affordable to receive such a good pair of porcelain at that price, and he picked up a big leak at the auction, but who knew that a few days later the police came to him and received the two bottles, because those two items were most likely the pair of enamelled porcelain that had been stolen from a museum.

"The matter was very big, and the auction company naturally couldn't escape the blame, so they found the seller and asked about the origin of the porcelain, in order to prove that the thing did not come out of the museum, the seller gave evidence to prove that the thing was a fake, so that he cleared the suspicion, but lost tens of millions, of course, he was selling fakes, which was a fraud."

"What evidence?!" Master Xiao asked uncontrollably.

At this moment, everyone present was very curious about the appraisal results of the pair of porcelain that Mu Lao said, and they didn't know how the seller proved it, so they immediately cleared themselves of the suspicion of stealing national treasures.

Yi Yang was also curious, wondering what it would be like, if it was the same as what he saw with his ability.

Mu Lao paused and said, "Anyway, I can't identify it, because that thing is too right, and it is as beautiful as Mr. He's two pieces of porcelain!" In order to prove his innocence, the seller smashed two pieces of porcelain on the spot, and then found the secret mark of Gao Fang from it, which turned out to be 'Ming Imitation'! ”

"'Ming imitation'?!"

As soon as these words came out, everyone was stunned, and all the masters on the stage couldn't help but widen their eyes.

The famous "Ming Imitation" is like a tiger, which makes people tremble when they hear it.

In fact, this is Mr. He's hidden worry, he is afraid that his things are "Ming imitation", but he didn't say it, now Mu Lao suddenly mentioned, the atmosphere of the scene suddenly condensed, many people held their breath, some of the masters who tried to recognize Mr. He's two pieces of enamel porcelain at the beginning of the attitude is obviously shaken, if it is a pair of "Ming imitation", then the imitation is so similar, so beautiful, not strange at all.

"Master Mu, is that really 'Ming imitation'?!" Mr. Ho was shocked.

"Yes, it's a copy!" Mu Lao replied unequivocally.

"The pair of porcelain that your friend bought is a 'Ming imitation', but it doesn't mean that Mr. He received an imitation." Master Xiao suddenly said coldly.

Mu Lao nodded and said, "Yes, I just asked questions, and I didn't affirm anything, nothing is absolute." ”

Master Xiao said: "According to what you mean, if you don't smash those two pieces of porcelain, you won't be able to find evidence?" Because the secret mark of 'Zhu Fang' is generally on the inner wall of porcelain, not on the outside. ”

"I don't know." Mu Lao shook his head and said, and solemnly built Mr. He, "Mr. He, you still think about it before making a decision, these two pieces of porcelain are not trivial in my opinion, and it is very likely to be 'Ming imitation', because such a large pair of porcelain vases is difficult to see on the market, if you can see it, it will only be a fake, right?" ”

"If you can't find any evidence, it's useless to say it, since everything is possible, why don't you believe it's genuine?" Master Xiao replied disappreciatively.

Between the arguments between the two, there was a lot of discussion on and off the stage, and most of the opinions of everyone were inclined to Master Xiao's, because Mu Lao couldn't come up with any evidence, and it was absolutely impossible to break the porcelain to prove things.

"Mr. Ho—"

At this moment, a high-pitched greeting came out from the crowd in the audience, and it was none other than Yi Yang, who had hesitated for a long time, to greet Mr. He.

"Brother Yi, what's the matter?" Mr. He turned around to look at him and asked.

Yi Yang said solemnly: "I have a few words, I don't know if I should say them?" ”

"Of course I can say that!" Mr. He nodded hurriedly and agreed, "Say it." Do you have any comments? ”

Yi Yang nodded and said, "Yes, I also have an opinion." Just now I took a closer look, and I also felt that there was something wrong with those two pieces of porcelain, and as Master Mu said, those two enamel color vases are likely to be high imitations, and they are the 'Ming imitations' that we don't want to see the most! ”

When he said this, everyone couldn't help but laugh, only to say that he was a little boy who had not dried up, and he even spoke wildly, which was really unbelievable.

"Young man, this kind of thing is not just talking, without real evidence, no matter how much you say, it is useless." Master Xiao said to Yi Yang disdainfully, "If you think those two large bottles are fakes, then come up with real evidence, otherwise it's nonsense!" ”

He seemed to be a little angry, and his words were a little disregarding the feelings of others.

Hearing him question himself sternly, Yi Yang was not in a hurry, just smiled slightly, and then said word by word: "Master Xiao, I won't stand up and say this without evidence." Of course I have proof! ”

There is evidence that those two enamel color vases are "Ming imitation"!

Yi Yang Buming was already a blockbuster, and in an instant, the entire hall was shocked.