Chapter 42: Fierce Debate (Asking for Recommendation)
Duan Jingzhu's words were amazing, not that what this kid said "save his wife first" was correct, but that people first gave their answers the title of standard when they opened their mouths.
Duan Jingzhu smumbly swept around, and said loudly: "It makes sense for me to say that I should save my wife first, first of all, mother and wife, from an emotional point of view, even if the two cannot be equated, they are similar, so this emotional factor must be eliminated first." Secondly, after excluding the emotional factor, then it has to be measured in terms of social value and family value. Obviously, compared with the mother, the wife is far superior in terms of physical power, mental power, intermediary or working years, and will inevitably create greater social value and family value. Therefore, choosing to save his wife must be the only choice. Of course, my analysis is purely rational. In fact, as far as I am concerned, I belong to the category of single-minded love for my lover, and I have always thought that it is not my mother who spends my life with me, but my wife, my beloved partner who will cherish in my life. ”
Duan Jingzhu said affectionately, and a pair of eyes stared at Su Meiren tightly, as if it was a declaration of courtship. There are many female students who have not been seen in the world, and at this time they are not like the next generation, the network is developed, the information is smooth, the emotional world of girls at this age is almost still a blank paper, seeing that Duan Jingzhu has excellent manners, full of affection, and was immediately moved by these words, for a while, there was a short sobbing sound in the room.
At this time, a group of female classmates who were not deeply involved in the world were moved to tears by Duan Jingzhu; Over there, Xue Xiang pressed his head on the table, and he wanted to vomit when he heard it, scolding secretly, what kind of TM thing, if you don't save the old lady, his mother still dares to say that she is single-minded. It's shameless.
Duan Jingzhu didn't care what others thought, his words were purely for the beautiful and moving Teacher Su in front of him, and he wanted to come. As long as this iceberg can melt instantly, it will shatter the whole world.
However, Su Meiren finally disappointed Duan Jingzhu. There was no expression on the frozen goose egg, and he said coldly: "Very bold answer!" The implication is that Duan Jingzhu's answer is against the world, and people who are not cold enough to a certain degree of nature dare not say it.
In an instant, Duan Jingzhu's smiling face froze, and Su Meiren waved his hand several times to signal him to sit down, but he didn't realize it. The Sumers ignored him. Then he twisted the beautiful head and asked the others if they had any answers.
Originally, when the Sumers first asked a question, they had long hands like a forest. all hope to be a blockbuster and win the favor of the Sumei people. But at present, Duan Jingzhu's experience has undoubtedly sounded the alarm for everyone - don't be in the limelight, but make a fool of yourself.
Therefore, no one stretched out his hand at this time. Just as Su Meiren sighed in her heart, her eyes began to glance at the northwest corner again. Coincidentally, Xue Xiang peeked through the shoulder of the person in front of him, and in an instant, the four eyes met, and Xue Xiang was cold to the bone! Because he had a premonition. The Sumers' unsolvable dead problem is coming at themselves!
If you want to say that Xue is really nervous and sensitive, Su Meiren's question is really tailor-made for him. It turned out that the previous several debates. Xue Xiang's words are sharp and logical, and he does not let Sumeiren, a top student at Stamford Bridge, do not let him be at all. After several encounters, Xue Xiang was not convinced, which naturally aroused the competitiveness of the Sumei people, so he searched out this unsolvable problem from the clip bag.
Su Meiren looked around, and when he saw that no one raised his hand, he was about to drink out Xue's name, and suddenly, another warrior stood up: "Teacher Su, classmates, I don't agree with Duan Jingzhu's point of view. I don't mention all kinds of reasons, just say that our Chinese nation has been advocating filial piety to rule the world for thousands of years, although we regard the feudal society as dross today, but even today, honoring parents is still the traditional virtue of our Chinese nation. In short, my point of view is that there is only one mother, and the wife, hehe..."
The meaning of this "hehe" is clear to everyone, and the atmosphere of the full hall is suddenly relaxed, and many people are happy. With the laughter, the dullness caused by the previous Duan Jingzhu's obstruction was immediately broken, and then someone stood up again: "If it were me, I would save my mother, and then indulge with my wife." ”
As soon as this unique and creative answer came out, it immediately caused the whole hall to exclaim, and even Duan Jingzhu, who had been hit before, secretly gritted his teeth at this moment: If I could have come up with this answer at that time, I'm afraid Mr. Su wouldn't be so cold.
How do you know that Su Meiren still has a cold face, and said crisply: "Very creative answer!" With that, he waved his hand to sit down.
In fact, at this moment, Su Mei's hearts are already extremely unhappy. This question was originally deliberately used by him to embarrass Xue Xiang, but he didn't want to make so many Cheng bite gold out of it. But no matter how unhappy Su Meiren was, she had to fulfill her obligation as a lecturer at this moment to explain the case to the students. After all, the three choices were answered, and she was not allowed to shirk.
Su Meiren coughed a few times and said: "The answer of the first classmate is undoubtedly moral utilitarianism, which is to emphasize utilitarianism in the field of morality. In his value system, man is no longer a person, but a part of the whole social machine, and the existence of man is only the size of the role, and there is no other value, such as emotional value, such as humanistic value...... Of course, I am not criticizing Duan Jingzhu, because everyone, including me, in most cases, follows this principle, and in our behavior, we often follow the principle of saving the crisis and saving the emergency, can we overturn the correctness of these principles? These acts and principles are in fact a copy of saving the wife or the mother, and there is no essential difference between the two..."
Next, Sumei people extended and expanded utilitarianism, liberalism, and humanistic care with this case, which can be described as a whip into the inside, hearty, this kind of deep layer by layer excavation, not advocating absolute truth of the academic and teaching attitude, so that the teachers and students in the audience opened their eyes, even Xue Xiang, who has listened to a lot of wonderful speeches on the Internet in later generations, also felt that Su Meiren's class was really a bit breathtaking.
Who knew that just when Xue Xiang was secretly applauding for Su Meiren, Su Meiren opened his mouth again: "The classmate in the northwest corner who put his head on the table seems to be unimpressed with my explanation, so you must have another experience, then don't hide your secrets, tell it, let's discuss it together." "Su Meiren is unwilling to let Xue Xiang go, after all, this kind of dead pimple problem is not something that exists.
Su Meiren's cold voice just pointed out a general direction, and he didn't even say a few rows and columns, as long as the full seat swept towards the northwest corner, he didn't know who she said. Because the interaction between the two of them has not lasted for one or two lessons, but has almost stopped listening.
I don't know how many male creatures have secretly slandered the relationship between these two, and there are even more people who envy and hate them, and even more, I wonder if this Teacher Su is the type who provokes more and more energy, and he also provokes him with his idea, but just when he was about to act, he saw the ice-like face, and the courage that had just risen in his heart immediately dispersed.
Xue Xiang had no time to visualize what was going on in his mind when the house was full of animals, and at this moment he was already about to scream in his heart: I put my head on the table, how did I have an opinion on the problem? If you want to find faults, come clearly!
Seeing that he couldn't hide, and was even more provoked by Su Meiren, Xue Xiang stood up and said loudly: "In my opinion, this proposition of saving his wife first or saving his mother first is a false proposition at all!" ”
Whoa, whoa, whoa!
Xue Xiang's words were amazing, and the eyes of the audience were attracted by him, and Su Meiren was even more upside down, staring at him with a pair of Danfeng eyes!
Xue Xiang was fearless and said in a deep voice: "As we all know, rational thinking and the best choice can only appear in a calm and relatively relaxed environment. This is because the situation of saving the wife first or the mother first can only appear in our discussion, not in the actual situation. Of course, we can live in peace at this moment and think about utilitarianism or value, but if we are really in a critical situation where two people fall into the water at the same time, as an individual, we can only instinctively choose whether to save or not, or how to save while ensuring our own safety, and we will never think deeply about who to save. ”
"As a single social person, we all have a sense of freedom and independence, and can make free choices, and this free choice is the cornerstone of a legal and moral rationalization. But in fact, this kind of thinking is mistaken for unity between first and then and love and more love. thinks that saving first is more love, and then saving is slightly inferior love, but in fact, rescue at critical moments has nothing to do with the level of love, and naturally it is not even better to save first is to love. Therefore, the question of who to save first raised by Mr. Su is fundamentally a paradox, and it is a choice that is mistaken for rationality grafted on a special situation under an ambiguous theoretical premise. So, discussing this paradoxical proposition, I don't think it has much practical significance, of course, its pedagogical significance is still undeniable! ”
Xue Xiang looked at Su Meiren, whose eyebrows were about to stand upright, and talked eloquently, with a loud voice and a clear voice, so that hundreds of people in the audience listened clearly. Especially when the last sentence is spoken, it is even more word-by-word, and the irony is self-evident.
At this moment, after Xue Xiang finished answering the question, his heart was about to bloom, and he secretly shouted: Who wouldn't stir up the situation! Who wouldn't mess around!
After Xue Xiang finished speaking, the audience was silent, and the teachers and students present were immersed in Xue Xiang's words, and the more they thought about it, the more they felt that Xue Xiang was reasonable. Su Meiren was even more forced by this applause, and had to stretch out a pair of jade onions, suppressing his anger and giving praise to the hateful guy. After all, Su Meiren is still a teacher, and the teacher's bearing is still needed, even if it is pretended.