In the car, Liu Xiaotian looked at the reporters around him and nodded heavily at Pu Haitai.

He had promised Pu Haitai before that he would do his best to fight this lawsuit, and he also sued Pu Haitai that there might be other variables in this lawsuit, but the specific reason was not said.

The lawyer is not a policeman, but some evidence also needs to be kept confidential, and he only sued one person, that is, Ji Zhengguang, the general manager of Sino-Ocean Department Store and the vice chairman of Sino-Ocean Department Store, in fact, Sino-Ocean Department Store is the family property of the Ji family.

"May I ask Mr. Zhuang, Sino-Ocean Department Store has always claimed that there are no fakes in the market, and there is such a word-of-mouth to grab the market, what does Zhuang always think of this anti-counterfeiting incident!"

"Mr. Zhuang, it is said that Sino-Ocean Department Store has admitted to selling fake goods and is willing to compensate, but he is dissatisfied with the amount proposed by the other party before finally going to court, is this so?"

"Mr. Zhuang ......"

The reporters outside have surrounded the vice president who came together, he only came on behalf of the general manager, and he didn't know much about the specific situation, and now he is also suffering these unwarranted disasters for the general manager, and he is surrounded by reporters.

The questions of these reporters are all straight to the point, and the meaning of all the reporters' words is that Sino-Ocean Department Store sells fakes.

"Please give way!"

Zhang Yang hurriedly ran over, protected him with Mr. Zhuang's secretary, and brought him into the courtroom, his face was very ugly, chasing a group of people to ask questions, and the questions were so tricky, and he could still smile and grin.

"Mr. Pu, believe me!"

Liu Xiaotian smiled at Pu Haitai slightly, and followed into the courtroom, and those reporters quickly surrounded him again, Liu Xiaotian was the defense lawyer this time, and although Liu Xiaotian was young, he also had a small reputation, at least he was a good junior elite in the legal circle, and he had won many lawsuits.

This time, his opponent is an individual, not a lawyer, but this time Sino-Ocean Department Store is obviously extremely unfavorable, and I don't know how much he can recover the loss, or how many times the compensation will be paid in the end.

Before the lawsuit was heard, all the reporters, including many of their own people in Sino-Ocean Department Store, decided that they had lost this time.

Gao Shi walked down from a taxi, with his head held high, full of confidence, he had no lawyer to follow, only a companion, and this companion only came with him, but he prepared a lot of information, a lot of things were in his briefcase, and he was absolutely confident that he would win the lawsuit.

Not only to win, but also to let the other party use the highest multiple to compensate, although he did not hire a lawyer, but he also consulted, and someone gave him the idea and provided so much evidence, it is difficult to win.

The two sides quickly entered the courtroom, because of the previous media hype, this time the trial was public, but only 20 media were allowed to enter, so as not to affect the order of the court.

Even though there were only 20 houses, there were quite a few people coming in this time, and more than half of the auditoriums were occupied.

The two sides quickly came to power, Zhang Yang also nodded to Liu Xiaotian, the smile on Liu Xiaotian's face became even brighter, and Zhang Yang was already full of admiration and complete reverence.

He didn't expect that the facts of this case would be like this, and Lawyer Liu made all the details clear and restored the truth of the facts.

The trial started directly, and Gao Shi was menacing, directly showing the fake identification certificate purchased this time, the video image of the fake, and the text related to the ocean department store, and even the image he bought, complete evidence, no one can deny it at all, and Mr. Zhuang, who was sitting in the defendant's seat, lowered his head unnaturally.

Gao Shi finally explained that because the other party was selling health care products, such fakes were more infuriating and the danger caused was more difficult, so he asked the court to sentence him according to the highest standard, and sentenced the defendant Ocean Department Store to compensate him ten times the price of the goods, that is, 28 million.

"Do the defendant and the defendant's advocate have anything to say?" The judge looked at Liu Xiaotian and asked routinely.

"Yes, Mr. Judge, I would like to ask the plaintiff, Mr. Gao, a question, and ask the court to agree!" Liu Xiaotian stood up, and the judge glanced at Gao Shi and nodded directly: "Agreed!" ”

The defendant's defender asked the plaintiff, this is a very normal thing, the court is a place that pays attention to evidence and allows people to defend, and will not say what others say, Liu Xiaotian, as a defense lawyer, wants to ask some questions to the plaintiff, and there is no problem at all.

After all, the plaintiff does not have a lawyer, and if he is a lawyer, he does not need to ask for instructions, he can ask directly.

Liu Xiaotian looked at Gao Shi opposite and said softly: "Mr. Gao, when we met for the first time, I asked you a question, I don't know if you remember?" ”

"You've asked a lot, but I don't remember which one you asked?" Gao Shi frowned and said dissatisfiedly.

"Okay, I'll ask again, what I asked that time was, Mr. Gao, do you know anyone in the Ocean Department Store, and I want to ask again today, Mr. Gao, do you know anyone in the Ocean Department Store?"

Gao Shi couldn't help but feel a little flustered in his heart, he didn't expect Liu Xiaotian to ask this question again, and he asked it at the beginning of the trial, his face also changed color, and he shook his head ugly: "I can't remember how to answer, but this has nothing to do with today's case, I refuse to answer!" ”

Gao Shi still understands some laws, Liu Xiaotian smiled slightly, turned to the judge and said: "Mr. Judge, this question is very important to me, so I implore the plaintiff to answer this question!" ”

The judge looked at Gao Shi again and said directly: "Plaintiff, please answer the questions of the defendant's defender!" ”

The judge spoke, and Gao Shi had to answer, this question seemed very simple, but it was indeed very sensitive, and the judge also understood this, so he agreed to Liu Xiaotian's request and let Gao Shi have to answer.

"Nope!"

Gao Shi said impatiently, Liu Xiaotian immediately took his words and asked again: "Mr. Gao, can you be sure of your answer, that is to say, Mr. Gao did not know any employees of Sino-Ocean Department Store before, let alone have any other relationships, right?" ”

"Yes, I can be sure that I don't know anyone from Ocean Department Store before, let alone have any other relationships!"

Gao Shi nodded again, the corners of Liu Xiaotian's mouth quietly rose, and he shook his head slightly: "This is strange to me, Mr. Gao is obviously very familiar with Mr. Xu Wenwu, deputy director of the supervision department of Sino-Ocean Department Store, and has eaten together many times, why do you want to deny this?" ”

After Liu Xiaotian finished speaking, he looked at the judge again, bent his head slightly, and said softly: "Mr. Judge, I have a surveillance video here, which can prove that Mr. Gao Shi met with Deputy Director Xu of the Supervision Department of Sino-Ocean Department Store on the third day, the sixth day before he purchased this batch of goods, and the second day after purchasing the goods, and ate and drank coffee together!" ”

Zhang Yang immediately took out a piece of evidence to submit to the court, this is a synthesis of part of the surveillance video, on the sixth day, he was waiting for Xu Wenwu in a corner of the headquarters of the Ocean Department Store, the two got into Xu Wenwu's car together, and then the video went to a medium-sized restaurant, the two ordered two set meals inside, and left separately about an hour later.

The second record of meeting is in a café, on the third day before Gao Shi buys goods, the two entered the chat after meeting in the café, and left separately in less than half an hour.

The last one, on the third day after Gao Shi bought that batch of guys, this time Gao Shi looked sneaky, waiting for Deputy Director Xu in a small restaurant not far from the Ocean Department Store, Deputy Director Xu was very unhappy to see him, reprimanded him, the two talked in the car, and soon Gao Shi left by himself, or took a taxi to leave.

The three-point video completely confirmed that Gao Shi knew Xu Wenwu, and the relationship was not shallow.

All the people, including the judges, jurors, and many reporters in the auditorium, all looked at Gao Shi, Gao Shi's previous denial and the current video formed a strong contrast, everyone understood that Gao Shi lied, since he was lying, he must be trying to hide something, plus this incident, everyone has a hunch that this case will not be so simple, and it may make another wave.

Gao Shi was a little flustered, his forehead was sweating, he didn't understand and didn't know where Liu Xiaotian got these evidence, and he didn't know how to deal with it all of a sudden.

"I thought you were talking about a department store sales person, I didn't know anyone there, Director Xu was an old friend of mine!"

Gao Shi hurriedly distinguished the sentence, but his discrimination this time seemed pale and weak, and he did not explain the relationship between the words in this way, but made everyone more suspicious of him.

"Mr. Gao, you don't have to be nervous, the current evidence is beneficial to you, even if you don't want to admit your relationship with Deputy Director Xu, I can't help you!"

Liu Xiaotian said with a smile, Gao Shi was slightly stunned, Liu Xiaotian was right, the court is a place that pays attention to evidence, the other party has no evidence to prove that this batch of goods was not sold by them, and he has ironclad evidence, no matter what, the final winner of this lawsuit will be him, what is he to be nervous about.

It's just that he was reminded by Liu Xiaotian, and he always felt weird, and the others also looked at Liu Xiaotian with some surprise, not knowing whether he was the defendant's defender or the plaintiff's agent, how could he help the plaintiff and deliberately remind him.

Some smart people have already seen Liu Xiaotian's power, a simple question, so that Gao Shi was immediately at a loss, and even asked his reminder to calm down, although Liu Xiaotian reminded his enemy, but in the other party's heart has already left a seal, so that the other party is afraid of himself, fearful.

In this way, he can better defend himself, not to mention the final outcome of this case, only this point, the possibility of a final award of full compensation is not very large, and it may even be that one trial is not enough.

This is the power of well-known lawyers, a small detail, a little thing that everyone doesn't care about, in their hands can become a powerful weapon, and even turn things around.

"Mr. Gao, I don't want to ask you what you talked about when you and Deputy Director Xu met before, why did you sneak to see him again, what I want to know is that on the third day before you bought this batch of goods, that is, after meeting with Deputy Director Xu, why did your account suddenly have three million more, and these three million are exactly the same as buying this batch of health care products, and you didn't have so much money in your account before!"

Liu Xiaotian asked again, and Zhang Yang showed evidence, when he was high, he swiped his card, and it was not difficult to get his account information.

"Awesome!"

Some knowledgeable people quietly admired, Liu Xiaotian kept saying that he would not ask about the relationship between Gao Shi and Deputy Director Xu, but he brought Deputy Director Xu with each sentence, which made people naturally associate this qiē together, making everyone suspect that this was a conspiracy.

They all know very well that it is only video evidence, which cannot prove anything, and when asked about the content of their chat, they can refuse to answer or directly shirk the past, this is a court, not a police station, and it is impossible to ask so clearly.

Liu Xiaotian simply let these go, and deliberately said it to lead everyone into other thinking, this young lawyer really deserves his reputation, and he is worthy of being an upstart who has beaten many barristers.

The entire court has been dominated by Liu Xiaotian, that is, Pu Haitai and the Zhuang president did not expect such a result, and now it is not how they should compensate, but it has become the responsibility of the plaintiff Gao Shi, no matter how he looks at it, it seems to be premeditated, and it is premeditated with the company's people.

"I, I ......"

Gao Shi was a little panicked, and he didn't know how to answer, his mobile phone suddenly lit up, he picked it up and looked at it, and immediately replied: "These are my privacy, I can refuse to answer, no matter how my money comes from, no matter what relationship I have with Deputy Director Xu, it is always a fact that the goods I bought are fake, and the law has never prohibited the act of fighting counterfeits, so I implore the court to determine the fact that the defendant sold the counterfeit and give the highest multiple compensation!" ”

Gao Shi suddenly recovered, obviously got other guidance, this point is the mobile phone just now, but what he said is indeed not wrong, even if Gao Shi's money was borrowed before, even if he and Deputy Director Xu know each other and have a relationship, it is Deputy Director Xu who sued him for this news, and it is always a fact that he bought a fake.

It is also true that as long as you buy a fake, you can make a claim.

The court led by Liu Xiaotian just now was finally moved over by Gao Shi, and everyone remembered that today's case is a fight against counterfeiting, as long as the evidence of counterfeit goods is full, the defendant will undoubtedly lose, and what should really be argued is the multiple of compensation.

From the current point of view, Liu Xiaotian has succeeded, and ten times the maximum compensation may not be obtained, but more than eight times is still no problem, after all, this time he bought a fake in the food ranks, and such cases have always been heavy sentences.

"Mr. Gao, since health care products can be faked, then why can't the evidence be faked, Mr. Gao, since I know the relationship between you and Deputy Director Xu, I must know more than this, if you are willing to withdraw the lawsuit now and apologize publicly, we can not hold you accountable, otherwise, the consequences will not be as simple as an apology!"

Liu Xiaotian released a bomb again, even Mr. Zhuang raised his head, looked at him in dismay, and finally Zhang Yang quietly told him, don't worry about him, lawyer Liu has been fully authorized by General Manager Ji.

The auditorium was in an uproar again, the case turned a 180-degree turn, no one expected that Liu Xiaotian was not responsible for defense, but not responsible for defense, obviously, he now means that the other party deliberately faked, falsified evidence, deceived the mall and the court, and wanted to obtain huge compensation.

If this is true, there is no problem in sending them to prison.

"You, what nonsense are you talking about, Mr. Judge, I object, oppose their statement, they are slandering, slander!"

Gao Shi looked very angry, but Liu Xiaotian had noticed that what was hidden under his anger was panic, a very strong panic, and he was already afraid of what Liu Xiaotian said.

"Defendant defender, please show the evidence you said, otherwise this court will convict you of threatening!"

Mr. Judge said directly to Liu Xiaotian, he would also be a little annoyed, Liu Xiaotian is not a judge, he actually publicly asked the plaintiff to withdraw the lawsuit in court, and said that he would not be held responsible, so the judge's words were so heavy, and even the conviction was said.

If convicted by the court, Liu Xiaotian will not be arrested, but he will be formally dealt with once, and if he is convicted, it is likely that his lawyer's license will be revoked, which is already a very strict warning.

"I'm sorry, Your Honor, I'll present the evidence right away, but before presenting the evidence, I would like to request a witness to appear in court!"

Liu Xiaotian apologized first, he understood that this would be a certain stimulus to the judge, but he had all the evidence, enough evidence, and the judge would not do anything to him if he presented evidence, let alone such a conviction.

"Witnesses are allowed to appear in court!"

The judge quickly agreed, he had given a warning, he had done what should have been done, and he would not deliberately embarrass Liu Xiaotian.

The court is a strict place, and it is precisely because of knowing these that Liu Xiaotian indulged it rarely, and the witness was quickly brought over, and when he saw the witness, he was stunned, and there was a trace of panic in his eyes.

This witness turned out to be Deputy Director Xu.

Deputy Director Xu on the video came to the court in person before, and many people have already understood that there will definitely be a turning point in this case, and it is a big turn, that is, those reporters are also watching with great interest, and they have a strong interest in the case itself.

Some smart reporters have begun to quietly write press releases, turning back and sending them out as quickly as possible.

Deputy Director Xu was not in good spirits, standing on the witness stand, first taking an oath, and then starting his own testimony, his testimony completely overturned what Gao Shi said before, and denied Gao Shi's evidence.

According to Deputy Director Xu, he was actually bought by another shopping mall, deliberately trying to discredit the shopping mall where he is now working, the other party gave him a sum of money, and also had some bad evidence of him, he was forced to do so, Gao Shi was also the person he was looking for in that shopping mall, and he had nothing to do with him before, it was he who taught Gao Shi what to do, how to buy things, he was dropping these things and turning them into fakes, and then asked Gao Shi to sue Ocean Department Store and sue the media.

The previous qiē was right, that is, after Gao Shi, he was clever and wanted to ask for more benefits, but he didn't notify the media, and then he was scolded by Deputy Director Xu once, and there was a warning from the shopping mall over there, so he suddenly exposed this qiē.

Immediately afterwards, Liu Xiaotian handed over a series of evidence.

There is the real source of the goods, the goods are in the hands of Deputy Director Xu, and he handed them all over, as well as the source of the fakes, how Deputy Director Xu secretly took the official seal of Technician Wang, how to imitate his notes, how to identify the results, and some images.

Deputy Director Xu is not stupid, he was blackmailed to do this, so he kept an eye on it and left some evidence, and now these evidences have been taken out and become ironclad evidence of Liu Xiaotian's reversal.

Pieces of evidence, like knives, cut off Gao Shi's flesh and blood one by one.

In addition to Deputy Director Xu, Liu Xiaotian also prepared witnesses, this time the witness was a courier company, this batch of goods was couriered from other places, because the express delivery of food now has strict regulations, they opened and inspected.

The courier is not complicated to verify the authenticity of these health products, they just confirm that this batch of goods is indeed couriered by them.

The evidence is ironclad, the real goods and the fakes all appear together, at a glance, the result of this lawsuit is completely clear, this is a framing in itself, deliberately targeting the framing of the Ocean Department Store, but the Ocean Department Store itself does not know, and thinks that someone really sold the fake, so it will be dealt with according to this.

It's no wonder that Ocean Department Store didn't find out the truth, the other party's evidence is too sufficient, how could they think that someone or the management is an internal response, plus Liu Xiang is really short of money, he has a motive to sell fakes, so he can't listen to Liu Xiang's identification at all, plus Liu Xiang was caught eating with Technician Wang a few times, and he can't tell clearly.

It wasn't until the facts came out that they found out that in fact, this qiē was guided by Deputy Director Xu, and it was also his idea to choose Liu Xiang's health care product sales office, and Liu Xiang was the most suitable person to frame.

Fortunately, Liu Xiaotian believed Liu Xiang's words, believed that he was wronged, and then began to investigate, and it took a lot of effort to finally find Deputy Director Xu's internal response, and found his evidence, and finally the general manager personally came forward, sternly warned and was willing to let him go, he finally agreed to be a tainted witness.

Deputy Director Xu's backlash also completely brought the truth to the surface.

The trial announced the verdict on the spot, Sino-Ocean Department Store did not sell fake goods, rejected all of Gao Shi's claims, and Gao Shi was falsely accused, his crime will be tried in a separate case, including Deputy Director Xu, and General Manager Ji has called the police, Gao Shi and Deputy Director Xu will be dealt with.

Greedy Gao will definitely be sentenced, in fact, Liu Xiaotian really gave him a chance before, and wanted to let him go, if he withdrew the lawsuit at that time, and when he turned around as a tainted witness, Sino-Ocean Department Store would not hold him accountable, and he would still have freedom, but unfortunately he didn't seize the opportunity, and finally ended up in this situation.

In addition, there is Deputy Director Xu, although he is also responsible, but Sino-Ocean Department Store has said that he will not be investigated, Sino-Ocean Department Store will not be investigated, his crime is much lighter, but it is inevitable to go in, he must stay in it for a period of time, his behavior has violated the criminal law. The person was quickly brought over, and when he saw the witness, he was stunned, and there was a trace of panic in his eyes.

This witness turned out to be Deputy Director Xu.

Deputy Director Xu on the video came to the court in person before, and many people have already understood that there will definitely be a turning point in this case, and it is a big turn, that is, those reporters are also watching with great interest, and they have a strong interest in the case itself.

Some smart reporters have begun to quietly write press releases, turning back and sending them out as quickly as possible.

Deputy Director Xu was not in good spirits, standing on the witness stand, first taking an oath, and then starting his own testimony, his testimony completely overturned what Gao Shi said before, and denied Gao Shi's evidence.

According to Deputy Director Xu, he was actually bought by another shopping mall, deliberately trying to discredit the shopping mall where he is now working, the other party gave him a sum of money, and also had some bad evidence of him, he was forced to do so, Gao Shi was also the person he was looking for in that shopping mall, and he had nothing to do with him before, it was he who taught Gao Shi what to do, how to buy things, he was dropping these things and turning them into fakes, and then asked Gao Shi to sue Ocean Department Store and sue the media.

The previous qiē was right, that is, after Gao Shi, he was clever and wanted to ask for more benefits, but he didn't notify the media, and then he was scolded by Deputy Director Xu once, and there was a warning from the shopping mall over there, so he suddenly exposed this qiē.

Immediately afterwards, Liu Xiaotian handed over a series of evidence.

There is the real source of the goods, the goods are in the hands of Deputy Director Xu, and he handed them all over, as well as the source of the fakes, how Deputy Director Xu secretly took the official seal of Technician Wang, how to imitate his notes, how to identify the results, and some images.

Deputy Director Xu is not stupid, he was blackmailed to do this, so he kept an eye on it and left some evidence, and now these evidences have been taken out and become ironclad evidence of Liu Xiaotian's reversal.

Pieces of evidence, like knives, cut off Gao Shi's flesh and blood one by one.

In addition to Deputy Director Xu, Liu Xiaotian also prepared witnesses, this time the witness was a courier company, this batch of goods was couriered from other places, because the express delivery of food now has strict regulations, they opened and inspected.

The courier is not complicated to verify the authenticity of these health products, they just confirm that this batch of goods is indeed couriered by them.

The evidence is ironclad, the real goods and the fakes all appear together, at a glance, the result of this lawsuit is completely clear, this is a framing in itself, deliberately targeting the framing of the Ocean Department Store, but the Ocean Department Store itself does not know, and thinks that someone really sold the fake, so it will be dealt with according to this.

It's no wonder that Ocean Department Store didn't find out the truth, the other party's evidence is too sufficient, how could they think that someone or the management is an internal response, plus Liu Xiang is really short of money, he has a motive to sell fakes, so he can't listen to Liu Xiang's identification at all, plus Liu Xiang was caught eating with Technician Wang a few times, and he can't tell clearly.

It wasn't until the facts came out that they found out that in fact, this qiē was guided by Deputy Director Xu, and it was also his idea to choose Liu Xiang's health care product sales office, and Liu Xiang was the most suitable person to frame.

Fortunately, Liu Xiaotian believed Liu Xiang's words, believed that he was wronged, and then began to investigate, and it took a lot of effort to finally find Deputy Director Xu's internal response, and found his evidence, and finally the general manager personally came forward, sternly warned and was willing to let him go, he finally agreed to be a tainted witness.

Deputy Director Xu's backlash also completely brought the truth to the surface.

The trial announced the verdict on the spot, Sino-Ocean Department Store did not sell fake goods, rejected all of Gao Shi's claims, and Gao Shi was falsely accused, his crime will be tried in a separate case, including Deputy Director Xu, and General Manager Ji has called the police, Gao Shi and Deputy Director Xu will be dealt with.

Greedy Gao will definitely be sentenced, in fact, Liu Xiaotian really gave him a chance before, and wanted to let him go, if he withdrew the lawsuit at that time, and when he turned around as a tainted witness, Sino-Ocean Department Store would not hold him accountable, and he would still have freedom, but unfortunately he didn't seize the opportunity, and finally ended up in this situation.

In addition, there is Deputy Director Xu, although he is also responsible, but Sino-Ocean Department Store has said that he will not be investigated, Sino-Ocean Department Store will not be investigated, his crime is much lighter, but it is inevitable to go in, he must stay in it for a period of time, his behavior has violated the criminal law.