Chapter 359: It's Not Scientific
Lehi knew that this must be the sequelae of the leakage of the proxy word, otherwise who would be in trouble on this kind of issue? But he was also a little curious, what could he find fault with this?
I only listened to Ding Lidao: "After the report of that issue, an enthusiastic reader wrote to point out that there were two typos in the article, the so-called Boulevard, according to the latest official Chinese explanation, should be written Linyin Avenue." Because of the controversy surrounding this issue, my client spent a lot of time researching and debating, and consulted leading scholars on the subject, and only recently came to a conclusion. My client accepted the advice of an enthusiastic reader and decided to publish a correction and apology in the latest issue of the magazine. The latest issue of the magazine just left the printing house in the early hours of this morning and was distributed to various distribution points for sale, which means that it has been published to the public. โ
As she spoke, she pulled out a magazine, handed it to the bailiff, and submitted it to the judge, and at the same time, the two reporters around Ding Li who attended on behalf of the Nanguo Rising Sun Magazine both showed a smug smile at the plaintiff, especially the yellow reporter, whose eyes were staring at Li Hai, desperately expecting his face to show a stunned panic, so that he could let out a bad breath, and know that he was not good at being tossed by Li Hai in Zhijiang last time!
In fact, Li Hai really wanted to pretend, and let Reporter Huang refresh first, and it would be more comfortable to slap his face later. It's a pity that Zhao Shiqian doesn't have a city government, so she hurriedly asked Zhu Sha: "Teacher Zhu, what is this?" โ
Zhu Sha calmly whispered: "It's not a big deal, it's just a small trick, I want to beat the morale of our side, and the purpose is to pave the way for the next stage of court debate." You all learn a little bit, and that's the experience, see how I cope. As soon as Zhao Shiqian heard that it was just a little trick, she was immediately relieved, and rolled her eyes at the other side, looking like she didn't care, Li Hai couldn't help but sigh, you can't hide things like you, then you really don't have to play.
When the judge finished reading the new magazine and asked the plaintiff for his opinion, Zhu Sha said very calmly: "Dear judge, I have a different opinion from the defendant's lawyer, and the report with typos does not affect the reader's understanding of the meaning of the article, which can only prove that the report misleads the reader's opinion, damages the reputation of my two clients, and also spreads the non-standard use of Chinese characters." I am glad to see that the defendant has done a good job of correcting the typo, and I think it is even more appropriate for them to do the damage they have done to my clients. โ
High, really high! Li Hai secretly gave a thumbs up, Zhu Sha really deserved to be one of the top barristers in Zhijiang City, this time she was so beautiful that she easily pulled her momentum back. Zhao Shiqian was even more excited and blushed, this is her first trial experience, the first time, it is very significant, you must not lose, you have to win beautifully!
Ding Li's face stiffened, and she paid a little attention to this female lawyer of Zhijiang who was much more beautiful than herself, but as Zhu Sha said, this is just a small trick, just take the lead, even if the other party can't answer when she is dumbfounded, the big deal is to supplement the evidence, submit a new magazine to the court, and it's over. Since it's a trick, it's good to succeed, but it's okay to fail.
The next step was the main one, and she questioned the plaintiff's submission to calculate the amount of loss suffered by the plaintiff. Generally speaking, the court will choose a more conservative way to calculate the amount of damages, and it is not that there are no plaintiffs who have made huge claims, but it is difficult to get the court's approval.
The most difficult thing in a lawsuit over the right to reputation is the estimation of the damage, and the court cannot determine the part that is difficult to calculate. The difference this time is that Lehi came up with a very bizarre calculation model to quantify the economic losses caused by the damage to the right to reputation. To be honest, although lawyers know more because of their profession, very few people will delve into advanced mathematics, if it weren't for Lin Feili who leaked the proxy words here in advance, the defendant saw this model in court, only dumbfounded, you can't even read it, where to refute?
To tell the truth, the day before the trial, that is, yesterday, when Lehi went to sea to play and fly together, the defense side was busy looking for professors from the mathematics department and the economics department to analyze the model. The results of the analysis surprised them, because the experts and professors who were asked all praised the model, saying that the model uses the most cutting-edge mathematical theories, such as game theory, new achievements in probability theory, etc., and the way of calculation is unbelievable, which is very inspiring. When they learned that the model was made by a law student, none of them could believe it.
If you don't believe it, experts don't all eat white rice, and many times experts make some brain-dead remarks, not because of a problem with their heads, but just because their buttocks are crooked. The rebuttal given by experts for this model is that it has not yet been proven to be effective. To put it simply, from a mathematical point of view, this cannot be called a theorem, but only a hypothesis, a theory to be verified. In economics, this is very common, and the big bulls rely on the models they make to eat, especially those who do analysis, everyone is sure that their theories are more correct, and no one is convinced. Then again, if there really is a so-called truth in this regard, then Wall Street will not fall into the position of shooting itself in the foot and making people angry.
Therefore, don't look at the fact that experts can't come up with a model like Lehi, you can still do it. In fact, Ding Li is not interested in how to pick thorns, and it is best for her to be disapproved by the court of this calculation method, and it will be a hundred. It's a pity that through her previous private work, she also knew that the other party's strength was also very strong, and she actually asked the local snake Wang family in Yangcheng to do the work of a judge, so that she, a senior lawyer, had no way to start. If it weren't for the fact that the defendant Nanguo Xuri also had an official skin, and Ding Li herself had a hard waist, she would have been too scared to take on this case if she had changed to an ordinary lawyer. - For this point, Li Hai's own feelings are actually the most profound, when he took over the divorce case between Wang Yun and Wu Hao, he didn't end up like a rat crossing the street, and the reputation of the Wang family in Yangcheng is much more stinky than Wu Hao.
Having said that, it is precisely because Judge Zhilu Dao may be inclined to the plaintiff side that Ding Li simply said that this model is unacceptable and has no legal basis, it will not work. The court will not care in this regard, because it is a civil case, as long as the law is not express, then you can toss and turn at will. In other words, as long as the plaintiff can justify this model, the court will be able to recognize it, and even the case will be reported to the Supreme Court, in the form of judicial interpretation, to provide a legal basis for the trial of similar cases in the future.
So Ding Li can only pick on from a mathematical point of view, she listed the reasons put forward by the mathematicians one by one, and the whole courtroom was silent for a while, only to hear the female lawyer struggling to read all kinds of mathematical terms, and few people present, including those reporters who were observing, could understand! The judge's eyes are straight, he has tried so many cases, and he has never tried such a technical content!
Zhu Sha doesn't speak, she doesn't understand! Anyway, it was Lehi who made it, so she just stopped talking and waited for Lehi to go up.
Li Hai waited for Ding Li to finish speaking, coughed dryly, and said, "Honorable judge, this is the stage of cross-examination, it seems that there should be no debate, right?" Of course, I can explain to the court the theoretical basis of our calculation method. The judge suddenly realized that this is indeed not the time for court debate, of course, this explanation is still needed, and the plaintiff's attitude is also very correct!
How to explain it? Of course, it is impossible for Lehi to tell you that my calculation method was derived from supernatural powersโour party is atheistic, and if you preach feudal superstition in court, what kind of lawyer should you be? He used the simplest method, first asked Ding Li to write down her income last year and put it in an envelope. Then Li Hai asked Ding Li a few questions, such as how many years she has been in the industry, how many times she has been in court every year, and how long she has been buying the clothes on her body, and then pretended to calculate it with a pen for a while, then raised her head and wrote a number on the paper: "Lawyer Ding, I calculated that your income last year was this number, do you see it right?" โ
Ding Li saw it and was taken aback! Because this number is very similar to the number she wrote down herself, and it is the result of calculating a lot of her gray income! Now she has nothing to say, if she doesn't admit it, then she will have to open the envelope to confirm it, and she doesn't want her income to be made public like this.
After weighing it repeatedly, Ding Li had to smile and nod: "Lawyer Li, your calculation is very accurate. On the one hand, she elegantly put the envelope with her income in her bag, and refused to announce the mystery, which caused a small commotion among the reporters who were listening, and they were secretly scolding the female lawyer for being too cowardly, and not revealing the mystery after singing a play, what is this!
Ding Li doesn't care what the onlookers think, she has a headache now, and she was actually passed by the other party in such a way! Reporter Huang was even more indignant, the leader of this agency refused to go to court, and he volunteered to serve as the defendant's representative in this case, not to see the pride of Li Hai, the enemy of the enemy! whispered to Ding Li: "Lawyer Ding, this formula is now recognized by the court?" It's not good for us! โ
Ding Lixin said that you still need to talk about it? The most annoying thing when fighting a lawsuit is that the parties are disobedient! She also had to be reassured: "Don't worry, it's just a formula, for those variables in it, what values are used to calculate and which ones can be accepted, this is all up for debate, it's still early to win or lose!" Having said that, but when she thought of the evidence listed in the proxy and prepared by the other party, she couldn't help but have a headache, not only because of the difficulty of this lawsuit, but also because of the high-tech content of this lawsuit. It's so unscientific!