The plaintiff came forward in person, and with such an image, Lawyer Hu's brows immediately condensed together.

The final verdict of the lawsuit cannot be based on the judge's personal feelings, and he cannot be acquitted because of who he likes, but it must be based on the evidence, but it is undeniable that the judge's attitude still occupies a certain important proportion, especially when both parties have evidence and it is difficult to infer it, the judge's attitude is particularly important.

This lawyer Zhao obviously understands this very well, and deliberately let the plaintiff himself attend, and the sympathy points have already been obtained.

This is a public trial, and there are a few more media reporters in the auditorium, and they are very interested in the last trial, not in the plaintiff and the defendant, but in the wonderful trial defense.

Reporters know a little bit about all walks of life, and last time the lawyers on both sides were very good, and they attracted a lot of people.

A large part of this is also due to Zhao Minying's identity, before the last trial, others did not know that he was the lawyer who advocated for the people, and after knowing it, several lawyers were attracted.

One of these reporters is an editor in charge of the legal section.

The second trial began soon, and Lawyer Hu was fully prepared this time, she already knew the identity of the other party, this is a senior who is much stronger than her in terms of status and strength, and it is an honor to be able to fight with such a senior, even if it is a failure.

It's like a martial arts master, everyone wants to compete with him, so that after going out, at least I can proudly say to the outside world, I have fought with whomever I have fought against, although I am still honored.

It's like a photo with a favorite star and a solo photo, a group photo doesn't represent anything, but it is your pride.

"Mr. Judge, we understand the plaintiff's feelings, and we also know that the plaintiff originally had good intentions, he just wanted to romantically propose to his girlfriend, and he didn't want to have an accident, but it is undeniable that his violation was the root cause of the accident, he was not intentional, but he did make a mistake, and this mistake also affected my client and made him suffer harm!"

Lawyer Hu was the first to attack, sounding that he was thinking about the plaintiff, but in fact he was defending Zheng Kai's innocence and attributing the responsibility to Gao Shan.

"I have a lot of opinions about the defendant's defender's statement!"

Zhao Minying stood up, smiled slightly, and continued: "The main reason for this accident is that the defendant Zheng Kai does not know how to pretend to understand, and offers to do something that he can't do at all, which caused the accident, my client was injured in order to save him, and my client's injuries are much more severe than his, which is equivalent to saying that my client was indeed saving his friend with his own life at that time, how can it be called Lian Lian, if it is Lian Lian, it should be that the defendant Zheng Kai is Lian Lian my client!" ”

"I'm against it!"

Lawyer Hu stood up again, and they argued again about this issue.

"Zheng Kai, let me ask you, what did Gao Shan say to you when you were on fire?"

After two rounds of defense, Zhao Minying suddenly asked Zheng Kai in the dock, Zheng Kai was slightly stunned, thought for a while, and shook his head again: "I don't know, I was very panicked at the time, and I have completely forgotten about it!" ”

"No, you know, I don't deny the panic at the time, but we restored the whole thing afterwards, right here, we played the video of your accident at that time, you watched it very carefully!"

Zhao Minying took out the video again, and deliberately took out a short part of the video when Zheng Kai was just ignited, when Gao Shan was very panicked and shouted.

What he shouted was: Why don't you listen to me!

A very simple sentence, only a few words, under the deliberate editing, Gao Shan's panicked movements, eager and concerned eyes, and the content of the words shouted were all frozen there, frozen on the big screen.

This video has been identified as valid and can be used as evidence, which is also Zhao Minying's killer feature, and this video is much more effective in his hands than other lawyers.

"What my client said to you was, why don't you listen to me? What didn't you listen to him? Obviously, he has told you that you can't move with alcohol, but you don't listen and insist on doing things you don't understand, which ends up causing disaster! ”

Zhao Minying shook his head and said slowly, the image was frozen, coupled with Gao Shan's concerned eyes, and compared with his current image, it gave everyone a great impact, and many people in the audience even thought that Zheng Kai was responsible, not that he would definitely not cause this accident.

"No, I didn't, I didn't hear it, he didn't say that to me, Brother Gao, you say, what did you say to me at that time?" Zheng Kai looked very excited and shouted loudly, Gao Shan looked at him calmly and did not speak.

"No, it's not my son's responsibility, you turn black and white upside down, you don't have to die well!"

Zheng Kai's mother and grandmother shouted together, and the courtroom instantly became chaotic until the judge maintained order.

"We admit that Gao Shan shouted this sentence at that time, but the plaintiff's attorney's practice of taking words out of context seems to be detrimental to the identity of a barrister!"

Liu Xiaotian stood up, with a little smile on the corner of his mouth, and said softly: "This sentence is from the mouth of Gao Shan, but it does not prove that Gao Shan stopped Zheng Kai before, this qiē is just said by the plaintiff's agent himself, we do not agree, and the fact is that Gao Shan did not stop Zheng Kai from doing this, but only told him what to do, and it is very simple, and it does not play any guiding role at all!" ”

Liu Xiaotian said as he walked out and submitted another piece of evidence.

This evidence is also video data, and it is what Zhao Minying let go before, the difference is that it is a little earlier, last time Zhao Minying took out the video as evidence, the video is not confidential, Liu Xiaotian also has a copy in his hand, you can see this complete video.

The video is also edited, and there is only a short paragraph, which is what Zheng Kai said before he was burned, he questioned Gao Shan, and Gao Shan said a word to him, but the sound was not loud, and the position of the camera was a little high, and the sentence was not clearly recorded.

The video shows Gao Shan speaking in slow motion, and only his mouth can be seen opening and closing, the same simple, very short sentence.

"Mr. Judge, according to the translation of the speaking expert we were looking for, we finally translated what Takayama said at that time, what he said was 'be careful when you take the bucket and don't spill it on the ground', which is a certificate issued by the speaking expert after translation, which can confirm the content of what he said!"

When Liu Xiaotian handed over the video, he deliberately put it down in slow motion, before everyone couldn't understand what Gao Shan said, but after Liu Xiaotian said it, this comparison immediately found out that it was such a paragraph.

Things came to a big reversal, Gao Shan said, 'Why don't you listen to me' not to let him help, but to blame him for how to get the alcohol on the ground, when Zheng Kai was scared to throw the alcohol barrel on the ground after burning, and then was kicked by Gao Shan caused a heavier accident.

The same video brought a completely different result, the people in the auditorium were in an uproar, many people became more interested, and the reporters in the legal sector also looked at Liu Xiaotian in surprise.

They are also half professionals, knowing the results of the round just now, Liu Xiaotian came to a perfect big counterattack, not only the image created by Zhao Minying with Gao Shan before was completely lost, but the sympathy they gained was gradually disappearing.

The reason is very simple, Gao Shan didn't stop Zheng Kai, they said so before, but now that the truth is revealed, everyone will have a feeling of being deceived, and this trust has decreased a lot.

Zhao Minying's eyes widened, he didn't expect that the evidence he had prepared in a panic was that the other party still had such a way to crack it, he didn't know what to say at this time, but it was undeniable that Liu Xiaotian did a beautiful job this time, and such evidence could only have such a perfect effect after he took out the previous video! ”

The situation has changed, and gradually people's sympathy has begun to be with Zheng Kai.

In fact, Zheng Kai did make a mistake this time, he took the initiative to ask for the alcohol barrel, it was he who went to add alcohol to the drinking tank, and it was he who caused the accident, but because of the two simple and different words, it made everyone completely change their attitude, as if Gao Shan ordered Zheng Kai to do this, so all the responsibility for the accident is on Gao Shan.

Lawyer Hu quietly extended a thumbs up to Liu Xiaotian, and his eyes became brighter.

Lawyer Hu knew about this evidence before, but she didn't like it, they had already mentioned such evidence before, but in different forms, such a sentence can only prove that Zheng Kai's behavior was allowed.

Just such a simple and inconspicuous evidence, when used on different occasions, actually played such a big role, completely reversed the situation at once, they were very passive before, but now they immediately raised their heads, on the contrary, the other party is very passive.

Zheng Kai's mother screamed excitedly again, but fortunately she stopped after only one scream, and did not let the judge expel her.

Zhao Minying was stunned for half a minute, and a smile suddenly appeared on the corner of his mouth, and he actually applauded Liu Xiaotian's defense this time.

He didn't expect the other party to be so careful, and even noticed such a small detail, but this proves that the other party is powerful and rare, even if he notices such a small detail, he won't be too serious, even if he is serious, he doesn't show the previous evidence This video is not of much use, only two videos put together, can highlight the role.

According to what the other party did, it is obvious that they have made careful preparations, in order to wait for his evidence, how would the other party know that he will have such evidence to provide?

Zhao Minying will not suspect the assistant around him, nor will he suspect the other party of stealing secrets or something, there is only one possibility for this, that is, the other party's carefulness, the other party has carefully watched the video, and found out all the things that may become loopholes, and then supplemented, such carefulness can have such a result, this time he lost unjustly.

It's just that he lost this round, but he didn't lose the whole lawsuit, Zhao Minying quickly adjusted his thinking and conducted dialectics again, he changed his strategy, and instead of taking out a piece of evidence prepared in advance, he began to present responsible evidence.

There is responsibility to adduce evidence, first admit their own responsibility, but the other party is not without responsibility, this is an accident for which both parties are responsible, and the next key is how to determine responsibility, whose responsibility is heavy and whose responsibility is light.

Zhao Minying is worthy of being a famous barrister, this change immediately reversed the situation, and also made Liu Xiaotian lose the effect of many of their pre-prepared responses, but the other party has already admitted responsibility is equivalent to losing half, and they also changed their strategy and began to reduce the responsibility of the defender.

From the very beginning, both sides knew that this could not be a lawsuit with a no-fault judgment, and that the responsibility could not be on one person.

Both are responsible, whose responsibility has become the key, the two sides are fighting with each other, all kinds of wonderful things continue to show, the trial did not end until noon, after the end of lawyer Hu and Zhao Minying felt very tired, Liu Xiaotian is still very energetic, almost unchanged.

Those who don't know thought he was just following along, and those who knew understood that he was the protagonist in the morning trial, and he had a wonderful debate with Zhao Minying.

After the second trial, the verdict came out quickly, both parties were responsible, Gao Shan was the main cause of the accident, and Zheng Kai was secondarily responsible, and the responsibility ratio was eight to two, that is, Gao Shan was responsible for up to eighty percent, and Zheng Kai was responsible for two percent.

Eight to two is already a victory for lawyer Hu, she used to think that it was seven to three, and to have such a ratio is a victory, and now it is almost a complete victory.

The previous bottom line in Zhao Minying's heart was five to five, but now it is obviously not reached, which is equivalent to saying that he lost the lawsuit, but he was convinced.

According to the proportion, Zheng Kai has to bear 20% of Gao Shan's medical expenses, and similarly, Gao Shan also has to bear 80% of Zheng Kai's medical expenses.

The lawsuit is over, and the result is also satisfactory to the client, Liu Xiaotian and they really won this time, although it was difficult to win.

Liu Xiaotian has also experienced many court trials, this one is the most energy-consuming, and at the same time the most exciting, that bit of energy is nothing, even if it is like this for a month, he has no problem without eating or sleeping, he is a god general, and his physique is not known how many times better than that of mortals.

It was such a rare stimulation that made him feel a little excited.

In addition, the reporters in the trial were also satisfied, and they had already begun to think about how to report the trial, especially the two reporters in the legal section, who recorded all the proceedings of the trial and prepared to go back and publish it as a typical case.

This trial is definitely qualified as a case, and it is very exciting.

"Your name is Liu Xiaotian, right, a very good young man, I haven't lost for several years, but I lost to you, no loss!"

After the two sides negotiated, Zhao Minying smiled and stretched out his hand to Liu Xiaotian, before they were opponents and enemies in court, but this kind of hostility in court will no longer exist, they can also be friends.

"Thank you seniors for the compliment!" Liu Xiaotian is neither humble nor arrogant, but lawyer Hu is a little vigilant.

"I heard that you are a trainee lawyer, and after the internship period is over, how about me, you are definitely a formal lawyer!"

Zhao Minying said suddenly, he actually publicly poached in front of Lawyer Hu, but people have this capital, Zhao's Law Firm is not a small firm, it is a top-ranked law firm in Binhai, and there are forty or fifty formal lawyers, which is more than all their employees.

Such a big law firm, let alone being a partner, is also a very honorable thing to be a formal lawyer.

"Thank you Mr. Zhao for your appreciation, I'm very good here, and I'm used to it, I have no plans to change places for the time being!"

Liu Xiaotian refused with a smile, Zhao Minying was stunned for a moment, haha smiled and took out his business card, and stuffed it directly to Liu Xiaotian: "You think about it first, and it's not too late to reply to me after thinking about it, the Zhao family will always be open to you!" ”

Zhao Minying and they left, Lawyer Hu breathed a sigh of relief, Liu Xiaotian didn't agree, she was really worried that Liu Xiaotian would leave them like this.

Although she understood that with Liu Xiaotian's family background, not to mention the Zhao family, even the top three largest firms in Binhai would not be moved to invite him, but when Zhao Minying proposed the invitation, she couldn't help but be a little nervous, worried that Liu Xiaotian would leave.

"Damn, the person who poached me in front of me, this is also an old-timer?"

Lawyer Hu also deliberately said something angrily, but Liu Xiaotian smiled at him, grabbed him, and left the court directly.

Because the trial was too late, it was a simple boxed lunch at noon, and now that the trial is over, the two parties have also reconciled, and their task has been completed, lawyer Hu directly invited Liu Xiaotian to eat, and both of them ate a lot.

"Xiaotian, do you think you will leave us one day?"

In the car back to the company, Lawyer Hu suddenly asked faintly, Liu Xiaotian was a little stunned, why did she suddenly say this without his name.

"Actually, I know that even if you don't have that illustrious family background, you won't be with me for too long, our temple here is too small to fit you, the true god!"

Lawyer Hu sighed, Liu Xiaotian's ability is stronger than any of them, today in the face of an old-timer like Zhao Minying, Liu Xiaotian did not have any timidity, and even outperformed Zhao Minying, and finally won, after this lawsuit, I believe that his reputation will be more wanted, and there will be better development in the future, their small firm can't accommodate him at all.

Although the development of this firm is very good, and it has reached saturation in a short period of time, which has greatly inflated Lawyer Hu's self-confidence, she is a little discouraged when she thinks of Liu Xiaotian's dedication and Liu Xiaotian's role.

Now the firm is very good, but many of it is the credit of Liu Xiaotian, in the company Liu Xiaotian has done more than the two bosses, both are better, it seems that Liu Xiaotian is more like a boss.

"Xiaotian, if you don't want to be a partner, why don't you buy our firm, and we'll work for you?"

Lawyer Hu said suddenly, and looked at Liu Xiaotian expectantly after speaking, which made him even more stunned.

I don't know what Mr. Hu thinks, but he actually asked a trainee lawyer of the company to buy them, and they became migrant workers, which has to be said to be very strange.

"Mr. Hu, stop joking!" Liu Xiaotian smiled bitterly and touched his nose.

"I'm kidding, I'm reluctant to let you go, as long as you can stay, I believe that the firm will be better in the future, even if it becomes a big deal like the Zhao family, there is a great possibility, or even greater!"

Lawyer Hu pursed his lips and continued: "I know my ability, I have self-knowledge, if you acquire, we can work in one of the largest law firms in the future, and we are still the founding fathers, it is better than being a small boss now!" ”

At the beginning, when Liu Xiaotian came to apply, she only kept Liu Xiaotian because he looked good and was young, and the treatment of trainee lawyers was not good, and many companies also used trainee lawyers as handymen.

But gradually, she found that Liu Xiaotian was very insightful, and she began to hand over some real cases to her, what she didn't expect was that Liu Xiaotian did a very good job in these cases, and at that time she was thinking that maybe she could keep him in the future and become a formal lawyer.

But the development of things was far beyond his imagination, and it didn't take long for her to feel that the formal lawyer was no problem at all, and then she had to keep him, even if she became a partner, and then later, she had to pull Liu Xiaotian as a partner.

And now, she no longer has the luxury of asking Liu Xiaotian to be her partner, she is willing to work under Liu Xiaotian, such a change is a little hard for her to believe when she thinks about it.

"Mr. Hu, don't be kidding, we're at the company!"

Liu Xiaotian shook his head again, the car had arrived at the company, entered the parking lot, the two quickly got out of the car, looking at Liu Xiaotian's back, lawyer Hu sighed faintly.

The people in the company are here, they have already got the news before, the lawsuit has been won, and the win is very good, so Liu Xiaotian and they were congratulated and celebrated as soon as they came back, and the company was very lively.

This time it was not an ordinary person who won, but Zhao Minying, a real old-timer, and it was a bright and upright victory, everyone in the company had a sense of pride, looking at everyone proud of Liu Xiaotian, lawyer Hu suddenly thought again, his previous ideas may be good, I believe that Liu Xiaotian will be happier as the boss.

The end of the lawsuit does not mean that the work is over, Liu Xiaotian still has a lot of cases in his hands, and he has become busy again.

Time passed slowly, and a few months passed in a blink of an eye, Liu Xiaotian's fame became more and more famous, and even some old-timers heard that there was such a young and excellent trainee lawyer, who fought a lot of lawsuits before the internship period ended, and never lost a single one.

There are some real masters in this, such as Zhao Minying, and for example, several famous lawyers have fallen in his hands, making his reputation even louder, a trainee lawyer who has not passed the internship period can make so many peers know and praise, but it is a very remarkable thing.

At least Binhai has been in the past few years, and it is the first trainee lawyer to be as famous as Liu Xiaotian. Tian was a little stunned, why did she suddenly say that.

"Actually, I know that even if you don't have that illustrious family background, you won't be with me for too long, our temple here is too small to fit you, the true god!"

Lawyer Hu sighed, Liu Xiaotian's ability is stronger than any of them, today in the face of an old-timer like Zhao Minying, Liu Xiaotian did not have any timidity, and even outperformed Zhao Minying, and finally won, after this lawsuit, I believe that his reputation will be more wanted, and there will be better development in the future, their small firm can't accommodate him at all.

Although the development of this firm is very good, and it has reached saturation in a short period of time, which has greatly inflated Lawyer Hu's self-confidence, she is a little discouraged when she thinks of Liu Xiaotian's dedication and Liu Xiaotian's role.

Now the firm is very good, but many of it is the credit of Liu Xiaotian, in the company Liu Xiaotian has done more than the two bosses, both are better, it seems that Liu Xiaotian is more like a boss.

"Xiaotian, if you don't want to be a partner, why don't you buy our firm, and we'll work for you?"

Lawyer Hu said suddenly, and looked at Liu Xiaotian expectantly after speaking, which made him even more stunned.

I don't know what Mr. Hu thinks, but he actually asked a trainee lawyer of the company to buy them, and they became migrant workers, which has to be said to be very strange.

"Mr. Hu, stop joking!" Liu Xiaotian smiled bitterly and touched his nose.

"I'm kidding, I'm reluctant to let you go, as long as you can stay, I believe that the firm will be better in the future, even if it becomes a big deal like the Zhao family, there is a great possibility, or even greater!"

Lawyer Hu pursed his lips and continued: "I know my ability, I have self-knowledge, if you acquire, we can work in one of the largest law firms in the future, and we are still the founding fathers, it is better than being a small boss now!" ”

At the beginning, when Liu Xiaotian came to apply, she only kept Liu Xiaotian because he looked good and was young, and the treatment of trainee lawyers was not good, and many companies also used trainee lawyers as handymen.

But gradually, she found that Liu Xiaotian was very insightful, and she began to hand over some real cases to her, what she didn't expect was that Liu Xiaotian did a very good job in these cases, and at that time she was thinking that maybe she could keep him in the future and become a formal lawyer.

But the development of things was far beyond his imagination, and it didn't take long for her to feel that the formal lawyer was no problem at all, and then she had to keep him, even if she became a partner, and then later, she had to pull Liu Xiaotian as a partner.

And now, she no longer has the luxury of asking Liu Xiaotian to be her partner, she is willing to work under Liu Xiaotian, such a change is a little hard for her to believe when she thinks about it.

"Mr. Hu, don't be kidding, we're at the company!"

Liu Xiaotian shook his head again, the car had arrived at the company, entered the parking lot, the two quickly got out of the car, looking at Liu Xiaotian's back, lawyer Hu sighed faintly.

The people in the company are here, they have already got the news before, the lawsuit has been won, and the win is very good, so Liu Xiaotian and they were congratulated and celebrated as soon as they came back, and the company was very lively.

This time it was not an ordinary person who won, but Zhao Minying, a real old-timer, and it was a bright and upright victory, everyone in the company had a sense of pride, looking at everyone proud of Liu Xiaotian, lawyer Hu suddenly thought again, his previous ideas may be good, I believe that Liu Xiaotian will be happier as the boss.

The end of the lawsuit does not mean that the work is over, Liu Xiaotian still has a lot of cases in his hands, and he has become busy again.

Time passed slowly, and a few months passed in a blink of an eye, Liu Xiaotian's fame became more and more famous, and even some old-timers heard that there was such a young and excellent trainee lawyer, who fought a lot of lawsuits before the internship period ended, and never lost a single one.

There are some real masters in this, such as Zhao Minying, and for example, several famous lawyers have fallen in his hands, making his reputation even louder, a trainee lawyer who has not passed the internship period can make so many peers know and praise, but it is a very remarkable thing.

At least Binhai has been in the past few years, and it is the first trainee lawyer to be as famous as Liu Xiaotian.