Wang Qi, who had just drunk enough water, almost vomited out a stomach full of top-grade bamboo leaves, and couldn't help but curse in his heart.

Ma Dan, if you forget to present new evidence in the debate session, you will return to the court investigation stage again, and you were really happy in vain just now.

Moreover, seeing that the rookie's eyes were becoming more and more attentive, he became more and more uneasy.

If there is new evidence, why not submit it at the previous stage of the trial investigation, but wait until this time?

Ling Li was not in a hurry to say what the new evidence was, but turned her head to look at Judge Cheng: "Presiding judge, before we present the next new evidence, I would like to ask the other party's lawyer, lawyer Qin Beibei, a few words, is it okay?" ”

Judge Cheng replied: "Of course, asking questions to the other party is originally a procedure of the trial. ”

Ling Li nodded, turned her head to look at the other side, and said slowly: "Lawyer Qin Beibei, may I ask, what is the relationship between you and Zuo Qingshan?" ”

As soon as he heard this name, Qin Beibei's face turned pale all of a sudden, his hairs stood on end, and he said, "I refuse to answer this question." ”

Seeing that the other party was silent and pretended to be dumb, Ling Li simply offered a sentence at the bottom of the box: "I have a courier document in my hand, showing that on March 17 this year, Zuo Qingshan sent a courier through SF Express, and the recipient's phone number seems to be Qin Beibei's lawyer." ”

Qin Beibei was speechless, but Wang Qi immediately retorted: "Zuo Qingshan is a student of Nan Zhiyi, and we ask the collegial panel not to recognize his testimony." ”

Nan Zhiyi hugged his arms and raised his eyebrows slightly, and his voice seemed to be smiling: "What are you afraid of?" Afraid that Zuo Qingshan will suddenly turn against the water to testify against you? ”

Ling Li took over his words: "Don't be afraid, Zuo Qingshan has been detained by the police for questioning for stealing the secrets of the laboratory, and he is currently unable to testify to the court. However, the police did provide some things that were found in Zuo Qingshan's house. ”

Qin Beibei was shocked, and subconsciously asked, "When did it happen?" ”

Ling Li hooked the corners of her mouth: "Isn't it just last night?" Probably you only confirmed it by talking yesterday during the day, right? What we are going to show later is the video of Zuo Qingshan stealing some materials from the laboratory. ”

Qin Beibei objected again: "There are quite strict restrictions on the use of audio-visual materials as evidence, and the videos you secretly took without permission cannot be used as evidence in court. ”

Yang Qianfan couldn't help but lower his head and whispered: "He started to panic, the Hong Kong film language came out, I don't know if the meeting will take the wrong line and back Miranda's rules." ”

Ling Li lowered her head and smiled, bowed slightly to Yang Qianfan, and said loudly: "The laboratory is a public place, and this is not a video recording that was carried out in secret. Moreover, long before the installation of the cameras, the school had already made a public announcement about the installation of monitoring in the laboratory, one was posted on the blackboard at the entrance of the campus, and the other was hung in a conspicuous position on the school forum for three days. ”

After a pause, he continued: "We have the materials presented by the Notary Office of the Lunar Capital. ”

This finally made Qin Beibei dumbfounded.

When he saw a thick stack of notarized materials, just to prove that there had indeed been a public announcement of the installation of cameras in the laboratory on the school forum and on the blackboard, Qin Beibei was speechless for a while.

The school forum and the blackboard newspaper at the school gate have to take pictures to make a big fuss, and the other party's procedures have obviously made up for all the loopholes that may be exploited by him, and it is also premeditated.

Unsurprisingly, the footage was allowed to be played in court. A short video, but the picture is clear and scary, obviously it is not an ordinary camera usually used for surveillance, it is obviously a high-end product.

For several minutes of footage, the camera is pointed at a safe in the lab. A tall, thin figure in a white lab coat appeared, expertly twisting the safe and removing a stack of documents.

Qin Beibei was speechless.

There is nothing to say now, he didn't expect the other party to quietly pull out Zuo Qingshan, and besides, they thought it was an opportunity and a double insurance thing, but now it seems that it is a trap deliberately set by the other party.

Ling Li took advantage of the victory to pursue and said a reasonable inference: "Stealing Nanzhiyi's signed blank paper to forge evidence is a common method of Yamazaki Seeds, and he has repeatedly poured dirty water on our client. ”

Wang Qi's face was gloomy: "I can't see from the video what he is taking, what is it?" ”

The clerk immediately enlarged the picture with an informative interest.

Under the high-definition camera, Zuo Qingshan's body happened to block what he was holding in his hand. I could only see that it was a stack of paper, but I couldn't see what was on the paper.

Wang Qi's heart was relieved.

Fortunately, it is really a great luck in misfortune, Zuo Qingshan's angle just can't see what he is holding, so naturally he can't say that it is a signature.

It's a pity that Yang Qianfan's words of adding oil and vinegar to this little transparency made Wang Qixin grasp it more tightly.

He said: "The Rudu police are asking us to verify whether what Zuo Qingshan stole was the secret of the laboratory that we reported to the police to steal before, or the signature of Mr. Nan, who was used to forge the IOU in this case. Lawyer Qin Beibei, maybe the police will also ask you about the theft of the core technology of the Heshengyu improvement project. ”

Nan Zhiyi put his hands behind his head, and suddenly laughed ruffian and poor: "What did you steal, don't you dare to say?" ”

Wang Qi was speechless for a moment. Zuo Qingshan's chess piece was not exposed so early, and the blame is that Yang Zhongchun involved the IOU, and now he has given the other party a handle.

Suddenly realizing that something was wrong, Wang Qi looked at Nan Zhiyi in horror and exclaimed: "Stealing trade secrets? ”

Qin Beibei obviously realized the problem as well, her lips trembled, and she couldn't say a word.

But Qin Beibei suddenly came to life, and his head sobered up.

The person who contacted Zuo Qingshan from the beginning, but he. Whether he is prosecuted for the crime of obstructing testimony or the crime of stealing trade secrets, once his license is revoked, he will bear the brunt of the crime.

Professor Wang has a rich family background, even if he is idle for the rest of his life, he is not afraid of sitting and eating empty, but he is a small follower, and he doesn't even have a house in the imperial capital.

It's not impossible not to be a lawyer, but what Tian Zhengyan said just now will definitely kill them, if he can't be a lawyer, it is impossible for him to take the road of academics.

Could it be that he will spend the rest of his life in an unknown company and be a legal counsel for the rest of his life?

Thinking about it, he shuddered and immediately shouted, "We are willing, accept reconciliation." ”

The look of urgency was as if he wanted to climb out of the plaintiff's bench and rush to the judgment table.

Judge Cheng picked up the gavel and struck it, asking the plaintiff's lawyer to pay attention to his words and deeds.

After speaking, he glanced at him again and said, "You are a general authorized agent, and you have no right to accept mediation on behalf of the parties." ”

Then he looked at Wang Qi: "Plaintiff's lawyer Wang Qi, you are specially authorized, and another lawyer on your side proposes mediation, what is your opinion?" ”

Wang Qi moved his lips, his mind still a little confused.

Zuo Qingshan was exposed, how did he get Qin Beibei in? The crime of stealing trade secrets, I am afraid that it cannot be filed without a real hammer, it turns out that Nanzhiyi is waiting for them here?

The corners of Ling Li's lips curled with a slight smile: "Lawyer Wang, I don't know the connection between Qin Beibei and Zuo Qingshan, have you been involved?" ”

Wang Qi shuddered.

Qin Beibei's virtue is very clear to him, if he enters the police station, this soft egg will definitely confess him.

This case has to be fought, one is stealing trade secrets, and the other is falsifying evidence, it sounds like falsifying evidence will be much lighter, but he can't put himself in it, right?

As a stopgap measure, I had to reconcile first.

So, he said a little unwillingly: "Okay, on behalf of the parties, I accept the settlement." ”

It's a pity that this good show was mixed up.

However, when this matter is over, it is not difficult to find out what happened to Zuo Qingshan and find another reason to sue Nan Zhiyi again.

Before he could figure out how to play the next game, Ling Li suddenly spoke up again: "Presiding judge, I have just received a notice from Haidong Province that Changling, a shareholder of Yamazaki Seeds, has reported to the public security organs after learning of the current trial process of this case, and Sheng Qianhe, another shareholder of Yamazaki Seeds, is suspected of illegally operating the same kind of business, being deceived by dereliction of duty in signing and performing contracts, and violating trust and harming the interests of listed companies. ”

Judge Cheng was crazy: "Lawyer for the defense, are you broadcasting live to the other party while the court is being held?" This is against the rules of the court! ”

Ling Li was also a little embarrassed, and pointed at Yang Qianfan and shook the pot sneeringly: "It's not me, it's him." Moreover, there are no audio and video recordings, they are communicating entirely in text. ”

Wang Qi's voice was solemn: "Can anyone tell me what is going on?" Why is Changling involved?"

"Lawyer Wang, you have been misleading us that the black hand behind us is Changling, but since you know that Ke Hongsheng has a problem, you should know that his friendship with Changling is not bad, with him as a matchmaker, the misunderstanding between Professor Nan and Changling can be solved with a phone call, and Changling told us that it was Sheng Qianhe who secretly supported the promotion of Pinyou Qianhao back then!"

Wang Qi was stunned for a moment, gritted his teeth and said: "Even if the case is filed, it will not be able to reach the court, you are counting on the distant water to save the near fire, no way!" ”

Ling Li's face was full of ease: "It's unfortunate that we have also filed a lawsuit with a court in Haidong for defamation of Sheng Qianhe, Wang Qi, and Qin Beibei." ”

"Defamation?" Qin Beibei was a little crazy.

Just now, I was still fainting to testify and steal trade secrets, why did I slander again in the blink of an eye? Is there any end to it?

Wang Qi was also surprised. Why did you get to the crime of defamation again? It seems that this case is not very tenable.

Yang Qianfan, who has always played the role of a little transparent, also came out to show off his power at this time: "Lawyer Wang, don't you know that 'malicious collusion' needs to meet the criminal standard of proof?" As you are well aware, the standard of proof is still quite high to determine that the personality of a legal person is confused, or to pierce the veil of a legal person. The facts that are difficult to verify in civil litigation have to be ascertained through criminal proceedings. ”

Wang Qi was dumbfounded again. Just now, if he deliberately showed off in his defense, he was actually taken back by this hairy boy to block him?

And Nan Zhiyi saw that his face was getting darker and darker, raised his head and smiled mockingly: "I, a legally illiterate person, know that the crime of defamation is a private prosecution case, you say that I plagiarized academic achievements, forged my signature, and splashed a basin of dirty water, and I am not allowed to sue?" Since you're going to die, it's better to pull a few more pads. ”

Wang Qi finally couldn't hold back his anger and stood up on the ground.

When Tian Zhengyan appeared just now, he held his breath, knowing that Tian Zhengyan was threatening him, but he couldn't do anything about others.

The strong dragon does not suppress the head snake on the ground, Tian Zhengyan has a fearless appearance, as if he is determined to be on the boundary of Funan, Wang Qi can't move him for half a point.

Moreover, this is the case, so Tian Zhengyan can be rampant like that.

Tian Zhengyan got off the field, and this group of rookie additions and blind combinations ran out again and again to provoke three or four times, which was really unbearable.

Judge Cheng, who was watching the excitement just now, suddenly remembered his great responsibility of presiding over the trial, and knocked on the gavel in a solemn voice: "Plaintiff lawyer, who told you to stand up, sit down quickly." ”