On the way back, Huo Ran drove the car, and while waiting for the red light, his slender fingers tapped lightly on the steering wheel, and his dark eyes were full of emotion.

Su Yu also wrinkled her eyebrows, she really didn't have a good impression of Xie Shen.

Xie Shen has no respect for women, and even discriminates against women, in his eyes, women should not have the right to work, when he has such contemptuous thoughts about women and does not attach importance to women's human rights, then it is reasonable for him to casually kill a female lover of his?

As soon as she returned to the law firm, Su Yu began to read the file, her hand holding the pen became tighter and tighter, and her lips were pursed into a straight line.

The deceased's name is Sheng Wan, her family is poor, a senior in the dance department, three years ago, she worked part-time in a coffee shop, and accidentally met Xie Shen, after that, Xie Shen took care of her, and Xie Shen had just gotten married at that time.

During these three years, Sheng Wan had two abortions, and Xie Shen emphasized that after each abortion, he compensated her with money and a famous bag. A month ago, Xie Shen was tired of her and wanted to break up with her, but Sheng Wan refused. The night before the crime, Sheng Wan went to the bar to drink, got drunk, and fell on the street of the bar street, Xie Shen received a call from her, and felt that after all, they had been together, so he took her to the hotel. But unexpectedly, the next morning, he felt a pain in his chest, opened his eyes, and saw Sheng Wan stabbing him with a knife, fortunately he reacted quickly, only a slight injury to his chest, but the two were arguing, his face was cut by a knife, he was angry, snatched the knife over, and stabbed the knife into Sheng Wan's chest. Then, when he saw Sheng Wan lying on the floor bleeding and no movement, he got up and changed his clothes, went out to take medicine, and suddenly had the idea of drinking coffee, so he went to drink it.

This transcript is followed by Xie Shen's signature.

There is also a version, he said that Sheng Wan was insatiable and wanted more breakup money, as soon as he opened his eyes, he saw Sheng Wan threatening him with a knife and cutting off his face, he disagreed, Sheng Wan stabbed him in the chest, and he grabbed the knife and stabbed people out of legitimate defense.

What a scumbag.

Huo Ran stood in front of Su Yu, the man's facial features were deep, as cold as the cold wind in winter.

He said, "Xie Shen is lying. ”

Su Yu swallowed his throat and said almost at the same time: "He's lying." ”

Xie Shen's two transcripts, he signed them, and the content of the two transcripts was not the same, but he put the fault on Sheng Wan in both transcripts.

In his transcript, Sheng Wan is an insatiable money worshipper, and he said that Sheng Wan did it first, and he was just defending himself.

He's a lawyer, and he knows how to control his emotions and how to steer the wind.

Su Yu used a highlighter and circled it.

Sheng Wan had two abortions, the two met in a coffee shop three years ago, and Xie Shen went to that coffee shop three years later after killing Sheng Wan.

Su Yu raised his head and looked at Huo Ran.

"What do you want to say?"

The man's voice was mellow and a little hoarse.

Su Yu said: "No, I just think it...... Mrs. Xie Shen was pregnant, and his grandfather was running around for him, and the only people he could see now were us, but he didn't ask about them at all. ”

Huo Ran didn't speak.

Someone pushed open the office door, wearing a peaked cap, only the contoured and smooth chin could be seen, very pointed, and the young man's coat was large, and when he came in, he took off the peaked cap.

It seemed to be snowing outside, and white snowflakes were falling on his shoulders.

Lu Yan's face was a little pale, there were dark circles under his eyes, and he was a little tired, he squinted his eyes slightly, and lay down on the sofa skillfully, with his cap upside down on his face.

"Brother Ran, what are you checking this time?"

His voice was a little muffled in his hat.

Huo Ran walked over, took off his hat, and said, "Help me check the lawyer Xie Shen, as well as his lover Sheng Wan." ”

"Okay."

Lu Bapt took over the task, he sat up, and his hand supported his forehead: "Is there anything to eat?" ”

"Nope." Huo Ran handed him the envelope, "Last time." ”

Lu Yan took the envelope casually, and then his eyes lit up, but his eyes were looking at the half-cooked cheesecake on Su Yu's table.

Su Yu smiled, there was a small pear vortex at the corner of his lips, and gave him the cake.

Lu Yan was probably hungry and devoured, his skin was white, the blue and black under his eyes were particularly obvious, and his eyelashes had fallen a thin shadow under his eyes.

Su Yu asked, "You haven't eaten for a few days?" ”

Lu Baptist said: "A few days ago, I followed the news, squatting at the train station for several days, and I didn't catch anything. When he finished eating, he put his hat back on, stood up, walked outside, and waved his hand, "Let's go, I'm going to feed my family." ”

The office was quiet again, and the two continued to work together.

Su Yu suddenly remembered something, and turned out the autopsy report again, her eyes swept over one by one, and then paused, she said: "The autopsy report mentioned that Sheng Wan was beaten before she died, and Xie Shen beat her?" ”

"Xie Shen didn't admit it, but it should be him, maybe it was when he had an argument with Sheng Wan that Sheng Wan angered him."

Su Yu twisted his eyebrows: "Xie Shen refuses to cooperate with us, we don't know anything about him, we really don't know where to start." ”

Huo Ran was also flipping through the file, and his voice was faint: "Start with the file, although the prosecution will not put evidence unfavorable to the prosecution into the file, but the police and the prosecution are not God, there will definitely be omissions or contradictions, look for them carefully." ”

*

Two days later.

Huo Ran met Xie Shen again, Xie Shen was still not in a good mood, he was a little annoyed when he saw Huo Ran, his brows furrowed, and there was obvious anger.

Huo Ran stared at Xie Shen's expression and said directly: "You and Sheng Wan have been together for 3 years, it seems that you still like her." ”

Xie Shen leaned back in the chair and hooked the corners of his lips: "I like it, don't you like to be able to buy her so many luxury goods?" Can you raise her for three years? ”

"You signed two transcripts, the content is still different, did you sign both of them?"

"I forgot." Xie Shen's expression was a little indifferent.

Huo Ran pursed the corners of his lips: "You are a lawyer, you should know what it means when you sign the transcript." ”

"Of course I knew, but I was innocent from beginning to end," Xie said. He raised his eyebrows, "Maybe in the eyes of the world, my character is corrupt, I cheated in marriage, raised Sheng Wan, and let Sheng Wan have two abortions, but I raised Sheng Wan for three years and gave her so much money, is there a problem with her paying for these?" It's her own cheapness, I said I annoyed her and wanted to break up, but she was insatiable as a woman, she stabbed me with a knife, and I stabbed her to death in self-defense. ”

"You hit her with bruises?"

"What do you think?"

Huo Ran's expression was faint: "Yes." ”

"Oh, that's not it, I didn't hit her." Xie Shenman didn't care.

Huo Ran continued to ask: "You directly snatched the fruit knife in her hand and stabbed her?" ”

Xie Shen seemed a little surprised: "I don't remember, it's possible, it seems to have stabbed her a few times, but I remember that when she was lying on her stomach and motionless, I gave her a touch on the right side of the neck." ”

The right neck was the final fatal wound.

Huo Ran tightened the lines of his cheeks.

How can this make people fight legitimate defense, when Sheng Wan was already motionless, that is, Xie Shen had already escaped the environment of illegal violations, but he also took the initiative to cut Sheng Wan's neck.

Huo Ran raised his eyelids: "Xie Shen, fortunately, you didn't explain this in the transcript, otherwise, your sentence would be less." ”

Xie Shen chuckled: "But whether I confessed this or not, I was justified defense, and my situation at that time fully met the five elements that constituted legitimate defense, first, she wanted to kill me, and the reality of illegal infringement existed; Second, although she is lying on her stomach and does not move, who knows if she will suddenly stab me again, and the illegal assault is ongoing; Third, I was defensive, and I didn't want to kill her; Fourth, the only person I stabbed was Sheng Wan, and I was defending against the aggressor; Fifth, she wanted to kill me, and I killed her in the course of legitimate defense, which still fell within the scope of legitimate defense, and did not clearly exceed the necessary limit. His gaze swept over Huo Ran's face, "Lawyer Huo, I don't need to remind you of these basic knowledge, right?" If you forget, I advise you to go back and review the criminal law. ”

Su Yu, who was sitting on the side, clenched his fists.

Xie Shen was too arrogant, and when he didn't move in the evening, he shouldn't have done it again, but he made the most fatal cut.

Xie Shen didn't even look at Su Yu, and said to Huo Ran: "When you go to court, you remember to me that I am justified defense, if you dare to say anything else in court that I am holding me back, I will terminate my defense relationship with you." ”

When he had finished speaking, he got up and walked in the direction of the door.

Su Yu opened his mouth and said: "Sheng Wan's family also filed an attached civil lawsuit, and they proposed 10 million compensation, do you have any thoughts on compensation?" ”

Xie Shen's footsteps stopped, and he turned sharply.

There was not a trace of a smile on his face, a gloomy light flashed between his eyebrows, he gritted his teeth, and was a little hideous: "Ten million?!" I'm not going to give a dime. ”

Su Yu's pupils widened slightly, the corners of his lips tightened, and he clenched the pen in his hand.

Xie Shen was angry, he clenched his fingers, and his bones turned white from the exertion.

Huo Ran's eyes flashed over his hand.

Xie Shen said: "What a brazen and insatiable family, the lion opens his mouth, 10 million?!" Have I given them less money in the past three years? Fortunately, Sheng Wan died, otherwise I would have been dragged down by her family until I don't know when! It's not worth 10 million to sell your daughter! I don't know how many women I can support with 10 million, not to mention, this time it's Sheng Wan who wants to kill me, I'm the victim, and I have to ask them for compensation! You tell them that they don't think so beautiful, go back to their countryside and farm, and want to sell their daughters in exchange for wealth? Dream on! ”

When Su Yu heard this, his chest rose and fell.

She tensed the lines of her jaw, and it took all her strength to suppress the anger in her heart, and her chest was burned with anger, and she trembled with anger.

Every word Xie Shen said revealed that he had no guilt, expressed his contempt for women, and showed his disrespect for the dead.

He even has class discrimination.

People like Xie Shen, if they go to prison, don't deserve sympathy at all.