In the court again, after Xu Ya was appeased by her mother, she seemed much calmer, but her eyes were still red, and she pursed her lips tightly.

Xu Ya actually knew Huo Ran, because Xu Ya had a good relationship with her grandfather Uncle Afu, so she knew about Huo Ran from Uncle Afu and had also met Huo Ran.

Huo Ran smiled at her.

Maybe it was because she was in the courtroom, Xu Ya looked a little afraid of Huo Ran.

Huo Ran's eyebrows were sparse, and he asked, "On the day of the crime, after you fell asleep, didn't you hear any sound?" ”

Xu Ya shook her head: "I didn't hear anything, I took the medicine and fell asleep." ”

"When did you fall asleep?"

"I don't remember, uncle, but I took my medicine not long after my mother left for work."

Huo Ran nodded: "Your mother's work time is half past eight, she is used to leaving the house at seven fifty, you will take the medicine not long after she leaves, assuming that the medicine is taken at half past eight, the effect of the medicine makes people sleepy between half an hour and an hour, that is, you fell asleep between nine and nine and a half o'clock, right?" ”

Xu Ya hesitated: "...... Should be. ”

"Do you know exactly when grandma goes out?"

"I don't know, she was still at home when I fell asleep."

Huo Ran's gaze stayed on Xu Ya's face, and asked lightly, "Do you know when grandma came back?" ”

"It was 10:45 a.m. when my grandmother called me to call the police."

"When Grandma Comes Back"

"Grandma came to wake me up, she cried and scolded me, saying that I slept like a dead pig, she told me to call, she said that my sister died, she was going to take my sister to the hospital, and then I was very scared, I went to see my sister......" Her voice choked up, and her nasal voice was heavy, "My sister is no longer breathing, I am scared ......"

Her whole body trembled uncontrollably, and she bit her lower lip tightly.

"You just said, did you hear grandma and nanny and aunt discussing pinching your sister?"

"Yes."

Huo Ran asked, "Did you tell the police that the nanny aunt killed my sister?" ”

Xu Ya nodded, because this was the first time she told the police when she called the police.

"Since you heard that your grandmother and the nanny aunt discussed killing your sister, and your sister really died, at that time, you and your grandmother were at home, are you afraid of grandma?"

Xu Ya's fingers clenched, and she swallowed her saliva: "I'm afraid of grandma." ”

Huo Ran nodded, turned to the presiding judge and said, "Apply to show evidence of defense A (12)." The white curtain flashed the picture from the law enforcement recorder that the police rushed to Xu's house after receiving the call to the police.

Xu Ya shrunk tightly in her grandmother's arms, she was still a child after all, and when she encountered such a thing, she couldn't cry anymore, in the video, Xu Ya said: "...... Grandma ......"

At that time, Xu Ya didn't seem to be afraid of Aunt Afu at all.

Huo Ran stared at Xu Ya: "At that time, you knew that it was your grandmother and aunt nanny who were discussing to kill your sister, why did your sister just die, but you looked for security from your grandmother?" Did you really hear your grandma tell your nanny aunt to kill her sister? ”

"I ......" Xu Ya's lips trembled, and tears in her eyes were rolling.

Prosecutor Zhang frowned: "Presiding judge, the state of the witness is not good. ”

But just now the court was adjourned, and the presiding judge also frowned, and said to Huo Ran: "Defender Huo, please pay attention to the tone, this is a witness, not a criminal suspect!" ”

Xu Ya turned her head to look at Mrs. Xu, she bit her lip tightly, and after a while, she turned her head again, she said: "Uncle Huo, I didn't hear grandma tell the nanny and aunt to pinch my sister, what I said was that I heard grandma and nanny aunt say that they wanted to strangle their sister." ”

Huo Ran asked directly: "Then why did you immediately determine that it was the nanny and aunt who strangled your sister when you called the police?" And not grandma? ”

Xu Ya's tears were about to fall, she was still a child, and her heart quality was not so strong, so she could only endure it, she said: "Because I knew at that time that my grandmother was not at home when my sister died, it was impossible for my grandmother to do it herself." ”

Her voice fell.

Huo Ran said coldly: "The case just happened at that time, how do you know that when your sister died, your grandmother was not at home?" You didn't know when your grandmother was going out and when she was coming back, you were sleeping all the time, the medical examiner didn't make a determination, and you didn't know when your sister died, so you couldn't know if your sister died when she was at home, or when she was away...... Unless, you saw ......" Huo Ran paused, "The nanny is pinching my sister, or, you pinched my sister......"

Huo Ran's voice was very calm, but when it landed in the courtroom, it was like *, and it suddenly blew everyone up.

His previous questions were so bland that no one could hear any questions.

Bai Shu originally thought that Huo Ran just wanted to refute that Xu Ya did not hear the conversation between Weng Jinmei and Liu Sanhua about killing her granddaughter, but he didn't expect that according to his thinking logic, he pushed it all the way, and finally came to the conclusion that the witness Xu Ya actually witnessed the scene of the nanny murdering her own sister, and even suspected that Xu Ya strangled her sister.

This is ridiculous.

Xu Ya is just a minor child! If she saw the nanny pinching her sister, how could she not stop it, and let the nanny strangle her sister, she still pretended to be nothing, and went back to the room to sleep; If she strangled her sister, it would be even more absurd!

Bai Shu sneered: "Objection, this is just Lawyer Huo's malicious speculation on the witnesses!" Lawyer Huo, attacking witnesses will not do your client any good. ”

Zhang Jian also felt ridiculous, and he pulled the corners of his lips: "Presiding Judge, Lawyer Huo's arbitrary conclusion without any evidence is an insult to a juvenile witness protected by law." ”

The presiding judge frowned tightly, this case has been open for so long, there is no problem with Weng Jinmei's trial, but Liu Sanhua's charges have always been ambiguous, he has always pursued stability in his trial, focusing on evidence, if he wants to convict Liu Sanhua, the existing evidence is not enough, if Liu Sanhua's crime is not convicted, looking at the current evidence, she is extremely suspicious, and if he is not convicted, he cannot explain to the society, to the procuratorate, and to the police.

But now...... Huo Ran didn't go as usual, and the curtain covering the case was lifted by him.

The presiding judge was thoughtful, he tightened his chin under the aggressive gaze of everyone, glared at Huo Ran seriously, and said: "Lawyer Huo, you'd better give me a satisfactory explanation, for the conclusion you made above, if you can't give evidence, I will let the lawyer investigate you." ”

Huo Ran glanced at Su Yu with a twist of his eyes.

Su Yu pursed her lips, the clues in her mind had long been clearly connected.

Huo Ran applied to the police to show the evidence submitted in the morning, the inexplicable shredded paper bonded, and with the permission of the presiding judge, Huo Ran walked in front of Xu Ya.

He put the piece of paper on Xu Ya's desktop and asked lightly, "This piece of paper, is it yours?" ”

The moment Xu Ya saw the paper appear, her face turned pale, her eyes widened, and horror appeared in her eyes.

"It's not ......," she subconsciously denied.

Huo Ran's eyes were bright: "But after handwriting identification, this is what you wrote, and you also have a book with the same material and shading as this paper, and your classmates can also testify that this is what you once wrote." ”

She opened her mouth, as if to explain something, and then she said, "I don't remember, even if I wrote it, what does it mean?" That's a list of names......"

"yes, it's just a string of names." Huo Ran's eyes looked dark, "However, if you search for all these names together, you will find that the news that comes out is all the pseudonyms of the protagonists such as killing grandma or killing younger brothers and sisters, and each name can correspond to one such news, and you also drew two bloody knives under the name." After your mom became pregnant, you had a good time with a few exceptional classmates in your class, who all had younger brothers or sisters at home, and they all hated their younger siblings, and even posted on the Internet that they threatened to kill their own younger siblings! ”

The more Huo Ran said, the more ugly Xu Ya's face became, her pupils dilated, and suddenly her emotions came up, her eyes were red, she grabbed the piece of paper and tore it up, she shook her head and retorted loudly: "No, it's not me!" I didn't! ”

Huo Ran stared at her and moved his lips: "So, it was you who strangled your sister, you joined forces with the nanny and strangled your sister, you are the real murderer." ”

Xu Ya's face was as white as wallpaper, her tears fell, her whole person's expression collapsed, she turned around to look at her parents, she saw doubt on Mrs. Xu's face, her pupils shrank, she couldn't speak, just kept shaking her head, tears blurred her vision.

Su Yu's hand was clenched very tightly, Xu Ya looked as if she was about to collapse, did they use the wrong method, they pressed it too tightly, she was just a child after all.

Zhang Jian's patience is almost at the limit.

He said to the presiding judge: "Presiding judge, apply for an adjournment, the defense lawyer misbehaves ......"

Over there, Huo Ran's face was indifferent, his eyes were deep, and the lines of his contour looked cold, he didn't put pressure on him, but he stood in front of Xu Ya, and Xu Ya remembered many possibilities in an instant.

She clenched her palms, fear creeping through her body.

She suddenly said loudly: "It's not me, my sister didn't pinch me, I didn't pinch my sister!" I'm not going to pinch my sister! It's the sister of the nanny aunt pinching, I saw her pinch the sister!! ”

Hearing the last sentence, Su Yu's heart, which had been in her throat, finally slowly stabilized, and the palm of her hand holding the pen was also soaked in cold sweat.

She raised her eyes and looked at Xu Ya.

Xu Ya's face was full of tears, and her voice was hoarse: "It's really the nanny aunt who pinched my sister, not me!" I see it...... But I was afraid, and I was still because I ......" she didn't say the reason, "so I always knew that it was the nanny aunt who strangled my sister, and when I called the police, I also told the police uncle, I saw my sister's body, I regretted it and hated myself, so I asked the police to catch the nanny aunt quickly!" ”

Huo Ran asked, "Why didn't you tell the police at the time that you heard a conversation between grandma and nanny about killing your sister?" ”

Xu Ya's body trembled: "Because I ...... Didn't hear grandma and nanny aunt say that......"

She closed her eyes, tears rolling down her cheeks, embarrassed and pitiful.

"Why are you committing perjury?"

Xu Ya opened her eyes suddenly, her eyes were bloodshot: "Because I hate grandma!" In the police video clip you saw, we were all scared, that's why grandma would hug me, and I would hug grandma! But what about the usual grandmother? She will only beat me, scold me, abuse me! In the year since my sister was gone, she blamed my mother and me for her death...... She would only scold her mother......"

"So, I want her to go to jail."

"The reason why the nanny pinched my sister was because my sister kept crying that day, crying very loudly, and I was also very annoyed, I woke up after a while, and walked out along the cry, and I saw that the nanny was very angry and impatiently pinched my sister's neck......"

Su Yu looked at the window of the courtroom, faintly sunlight penetrated, and there were undulating dust in the pillar of light, slowly, slowly, falling on the floor.

She withdrew her gaze and smiled at Huo Ran.