Lin Xianyu looked at the screen with her eyes, stretched out her hand to pick up the milk, and she smiled: "How can these people say as if they saw Xie Shen kill Sheng Wan at the scene, but obviously all they can see is second-hand news materials from media reporters." ”

Su Yu gently blew the milk, it was a little hot, she lowered her eyebrows and took a sip: "Yes, in fact, now the main network media is developed, and many self-media public accounts have written highly inflammatory and private articles in order to cater to the excitement of the masses. ”

"It's even more ridiculous to say that Huo Ran violated the Lawyer Law, most people on the online media only know a few laws and watch a few legal dramas, and they feel that they are legal experts."

As the two were talking, the door of the office was pushed open again, and it was Lu Yuzhou who came in, holding a cup of hot coffee in his hand, and raised his eyebrows: "Because everyone has preconceived the facts they have identified, what they are pursuing is not fairness at all, all they need is fairness that is biased towards them all the time and unconditionally." ”

Su Yu browsed the news of the square on Weibo for a while, and Weibo was full of ridicule and insults against fairness and justice and lawyers.

Lin Xianyu also saw it, her eyes crooked: "This person left a message saying that Huo Ran reduced Xie Shen's sentence without a bottom line, not only to make money by unscrupulous means, but also to become famous, but anyone with a little conscience will not take this kind of work, and this lawyer's appearance is too ugly." ”

"Then there must be some people who say that even if the lawyer who takes on this kind of case is famous, he will only get infamy." Lu Yuzhou hooked his lips lazily, he understood the routines of netizens very well, and took a sip of coffee, because he had just come in from outside, his fingers were a little red from the cold, "There is no absolute fairness in this world, life is inherently difficult and unfair." ”

"I also saw a WeChat push yesterday, saying that Huo Ran not only has no social morality, but also has no professional ethics, and his behavior seriously violates the Lawyers Law." Lin Xianyu's tone was very light, but it was full of faint sarcasm, "What's even more terrifying is that the comments actually support him, the blogger also said in the article that he also knows a little about the law, I can't be angry, so I left a message saying that he does know a little about the law, so I can write such a brainless and rhythmic article, what do you guess he replied to me?" He said - so the demands of these civilians should be dissed? ”

As soon as Lin Xianyu's words fell, Lu Yuzhou couldn't help laughing: "Hahahahahaha, this is too funny, how can he reply like a mob?" is quite good at buttoning his hat, begging him not to say that he is a civilian, he is blind. ”

"He said that the profession of a lawyer should be supervised, and he was only exercising his right of supervision as a citizen, so he said that Huo Ran violated the Law on Lawyers."

Su Yu put down the cup and smiled: "A lawyer can indeed accept the supervision of citizens, and when there is conclusive, reliable and sufficient evidence, it is called supervision; In the absence of any reliable evidence, relying only on the arbitrary distortion and self-righteous speculation of an article, that is called slander. ”

"There are still many people who feel that the truth is so clear, and it is because of the lawyer's interference that the truth is even more confusing, and they also warn all lawyers to be based on facts in the article."

Lin Xianyu raised his eyes and looked at Lu Yuzhou with a smile: "Where is the truth clear, it's just that the people think they have got a clear truth." Before the trial, most of what we can get is only one-sided information, and what most people can get is even just the information selectively transmitted by the media, which is the 'truth' that has been processed by the media and what the media wants them to see, and these 'truths' are not even supported by reliable evidence, but they can make the audience preconceived, stand on the moral high ground and begin to be complacent, and even swear that if he is Xie Shen's lawyer, he must not want money or fame, just to give the world a justice, the question is- They don't even know what the real truth and justice are, and they just foolishly believe their own unsupported speculations. ”

"And most people also have a misunderstanding of the 'facts' based on facts, this fact is not the so-called fact in the public's mind, but the fact that there is evidence that can be seen by the naked eye, they are too idealistic, for example, in all previous cases, they only listen to the victim's speculation, do not look at whether there is evidence, do not see whether there is concealment, and make a judgment that the defendant is a murderer and should be sentenced to death."

Su Yu pursed her lips, and just as she wanted to say something, she heard the sound of the office door lock being unscrewed again. She followed the sound and looked out the door, first Huo Ran's slender, straight, knobby hands, and then his handsome and well-defined face.

Su Yu's eyelashes moved, and she was still thinking about the conversations just now.

She tried to put herself in the position of the other party, in the position of ordinary netizens, she was a little absent-minded: "Actually, I can understand them, their values are very simple, there is no systematic legal thinking, they habitually think that people who study law should represent the justice in their hearts, but they have not thought that a thousand people, there are a thousand definitions of justice, so whose definition is the real justice?" Moreover, they determined that what the prosecutor found was the absolute truth, and the file provided by the court was the whole truth, and they did not think that the prosecutor would also deviate from the truth due to various reasons in his work, or mistakes, or deliberately. ”

Huo Ran didn't know when, he had already walked in front of Su Yu, he leaned down slightly, and there was a shallow smile in his dark eyes.

He could clearly and clearly feel the change in Su Yu.

He saw his reflection in her dark pupils, looked into her gaze, and added in a low voice, "Besides, didn't you notice that there were only a few comments on the Internet?" - Hell is empty, and demons are on earth; Justice will be late, but it will not be absent; Kindness limits your imagination; A lawyer does not represent justice, a lawyer is just a profession, and a lawyer is for money...... Do you think they will be willing to spend time thinking about what is the truth when they claim to represent fairness and justice, but who even want to express their inner feelings by copying other people's words, who refuse to even take the time to organize their own language, and who only want to seize the hot spot, vent their dark emotions that are unknown to others, and enjoy the praise and superiority of being held on the moral high ground? What is the evidence? ”

Huo Ran's poisonous tongue is not too merciful, sometimes his language is like a sharp knife, mercilessly cutting through the surface that has been hard to maintain, revealing a bloody and embarrassing scene.

He narrowed his eyes, straightened up, and said lightly: "Or to be precise, most of the people who only vent their brainless emotions on the Internet, have no thoughts of their own, copy and paste other people's words, and blindly follow the trend, most of them don't read much, and they belong to the ignorant crowd." ”

Huo Ran walked to the whiteboard in the office, he picked up a black pen casually, took off the cap, and wrote and drew on the whiteboard.

First a coordinate, then a curve.

The abscissa represents the knowledge reserve, and the vertical axis represents the level of confidence.

His eyes stared at the whiteboard faintly, and he said: "This is the Duck effect diagram, this diagram is enough to illustrate that people who know little about it are the most confident." ”

His pen circled the highest peak on the picture, "This is the mountain of ignorance, when people are in this state, the knowledge reserve belongs to the state of half-knowledge and half-understanding, but the self-confidence has reached the peak, and even produces an illusion that I know the most in the world." Unfortunately, most people are at this juncture. ”

He then circled the lowest trough, "This is the valley of despair, if people don't stop learning, as their knowledge increases, people's self-confidence in themselves will fall to the trough." His pen slowly rises along the arc of the two-dimensional diagram, "Continue to learn without stopping, and then self-confidence will be proportional to the knowledge reserve." ”

Su Yu leaned on the back of the sofa, hooked his lips and smiled, and the tails of his eyes fell slightly.

Lu Yuzhou raised his eyebrows: "Ah Ran, you despise a large group!" ”

Huo Ran's eyebrows moved.

Lin Xianyu's eyes lit up: "This picture is good, it can solve a lot of problems, when I know a little about the law and the truth, a large number of people are full of confidence in their guesses, logical thinking and identification, and they only believe in their own guesses, and they can even say it with confidence - although I don't understand the law, I have my correct logic and values, I think xxx should be sentenced to death, xxx must have killed someone." ”

Lu Yuzhou snorted and was amused.

Su Yu thought quietly for a while, and said in a low voice: "The traditional Chinese moral concept is to pay for life by killing, and people who do not have the logic of legal thinking, and even many people in law are in favor of the death penalty. ”

Lu Yuzhou suddenly remembered that when he was interning, Huo Ran and he went to do legal aid.

Lu Yuzhou: "We can still say a lot of big things to adults to kill those who are legally illiterate, but a few years ago, a child in the orphanage rushed up to ask me and Ah Ran questions, we were going to the countryside to do legal aid at that time, the child glared at me and Ah Ran, and asked angrily: Why does the lawyer defend the bad guy, his father was killed, but because of the existence of the lawyer, the murderer was not sentenced to death. Lu Yuzhou paused, "At that time, I was really asked, and I didn't know how to tell such a young child, and I didn't know where to explain." ”

Lu Yuzhou's eyes were teasing: "But Ah Ran is very serious, although he only said one word." ”

Su Yu raised his eyes, and his eyelashes trembled slightly.

She knew what that phrase was.

This is also the principle that Huo Ran has always adhered to, the lawyer stands in the courtroom in order to ensure as much as possible that the innocent will not be wronged, and the guilty will be punished.

There is no logical relationship between the judgment in the hearts of the people and the real truth.

If this is the case, this so-called public opinion is a social regression, and society has completely returned to the popular trial period of Socrates in ancient Greece, and whoever has less votes is a sinner who should be executed.

All of this can only be confirmed by evidence that everyone can see.

Thinking of this, Su Yu smiled lightly.

When she was a prosecutor, she often believed that the opposing lawyer had committed perjury, lied, and did whatever it took to defend herself, but in fact there was no reliable evidence, mostly because the opposing lawyer had a different point of view from herself, and the opposing lawyer's defense reasons were particularly ridiculous in her opinion, and the opposing lawyer stood on the opposite side of her and refuted her own arguments.

The complexity of human beings determines the obscurity of the truth.