The courtroom was very quiet, and the sound in the video was infinitely amplified, and the moment Zhou Zhengu's body fell to the ground, there was a dull sound, like a hammer smashed on the hearts of the people present, the sound in the picture was noisy, but Zhou Zhengu's heavy panting sound could be faintly heard, inexplicably, making people a little heavy.

Father Zhou clenched the muscles of his cheeks, and the bloodshot in his eyes was clear.

Prosecutor Lin broke the silence: "The autopsy opinion of the victim Zhou Zhengu is that the gastric contents accidentally entered the respiratory tract and died of suffocation, that is, the vomit accidentally entered the respiratory tract and caused suffocation, and the beating and compression of external forces will cause the gastric contents to enter the respiratory tract ......"

"Against." Huo Ran interrupted what Prosecutor Lin had not finished speaking, "The effect of external force is only a possible cause, after strenuous running, it will also cause vomit to rise and enter the respiratory tract by mistake, not to mention, the victim Zhou Zhengu tried to escape twice, Jiang Hanting must take compulsory measures against him in accordance with the law, and the reason why the vomit accidentally entered the respiratory tract cannot be ruled out - regalia caused by violent running." ”

When Prosecutor Lin heard this, her eyes fell on Huo Ran's body, she pursed her lips and smiled meaninglessly: "But it is also not ruled out that the second coercive measures taken against Zhou Zhengu when he escaped for the second time caused the stomach contents to enter the respiratory tract by mistake. ”

"Against." Huo Ran's voice was low and calm, "This is just the prosecutor's guess. ”

When the presiding judge heard this, he said: "The objection is invalid, and the prosecution continues to ask questions." ”

Prosecutor Lin smiled, no longer looked at Huo Ran, but asked Jiang Hanting: "After Zhou Zhengu tried to escape for the second time and was recovered, you detained him in a police car?" ”

"Yes."

"Were you outside the car when he was being held in the car?"

"Yes."

"Why don't you look at him in the car?"

Jiang Hanting raised his eyes: "Because I want to report the situation to my superiors, I have to avoid it, and it is more convenient to observe the surrounding situation outside the car." ”

"Did Zhou Zhengu use handcuffs when he was in the car?"

"No, I locked the door."

"When you closed the car door, did Zhou Zhengu have any abnormalities?"

"No, he's calmed down."

"Outside the car, did you hear Zhou Zhengu's cry for help? Or some other weird sound? ”

"Nope."

Lin Jian lowered his eyebrows, looked at the file for a while, raised his eyes to look at the presiding judge, and smiled: "Presiding judge, I have no other questions." ”

Huo Ran's question to Jiang Hanting was to prove that Jiang Hanting handled the case in accordance with the law, and Zhou Zhengu's death was an accident beyond the reach of manpower.

"Did you know that the body camera was full before you went to the police?"

Huo Ran had already taught Jiang Hanting how to answer this question.

Jiang Hanting's voice was very light: "I don't know, the police force was insufficient that day, and the police were in a hurry, and to query the memory of the law enforcement recorder, you had to log in to the computer, and it was too late to log in to the computer to inquire that day." ”

"Would you have used such coercive measures against suspects before?"

"Yes, this is a coercive measure that is in line with legal norms."

"Before Zhou Zhengu was imprisoned in the police car, did you find anything unusual about him?"

"Nope."

"Zhou Zhengu is in the police car, has he ever asked for help?"

"Nope."

"How long did Zhou Zhengu stay in the police car alone?"

"10 minutes."

"Did you wait next to the police car for those 10 minutes?"

"Yes."

Huo Ran's eyes were steady, he raised his eyebrows, and looked at the presiding judge: "My question is over." ”

The presiding judge looked at the time, knocked on the gavel, and said, "Adjourn for ten minutes." ”

*

Huo Ran and Su Yu walked out of the courtroom, Huo Ran pinched his eyebrow bone, took Su Yu's hand, and sat on the bench outside the corridor together.

The expressions of the two were not relaxed, Su Yu pursed his lips, and his voice was very soft: "There will be witnesses waiting for the prosecution to appear in court, one is the young criminal policeman who handled the case with Jiang Hanting that day, and the other is an eyewitness other than the police." ”

Huo Ran did not invite any witnesses, and it was already difficult for the lawyer to collect evidence, and it was even more difficult to find a witness.

Su Yu's eyes turned slightly: "Jiang Hanting currently has three points that have been criticized, the first point is that the law enforcement recorder stopped recording during the critical period of time because the memory was full, but from this point of view, he was negligent, but it was not enough to convict; The second point is that the video clip of him subduing Zhou Zhengu looks a little rough and is easy to be criticized as rough law enforcement, but after all, it was Zhou Zhengu who tried to escape, Jiang Hanting must take relevant measures, and the judge has seen the prisoners in court irritable all year round, so he will not be entangled in this. ”

She paused, her eyelashes moving slightly, "So, can the eyewitnesses found by the prosecution prove ......?"

Huo Ran smiled faintly: "It can prove that Jiang Hanting didn't pay attention to Zhou Zhengu when he knew that he was unwell, which led to Zhou Zhengu's accidental death." His eyebrows raised slightly, "So, let's go ask Jiang Hanting again." ”

As he was talking, Jiang Hanting also came out of the courtroom, Huo Ran stood up, took the lead and walked with Su Yu to the corner at the end of the corridor, Jiang Hanting pursed his lips and followed.

He stood, just blocking the sunlight shining in from behind him, and his silhouette was tall and straight, and he showed toughness and fortitude just by standing.

Su Yu turned her face sideways, her tender cheeks were in the sun, a little transparent, and there were faint soft and fine hairs, her eyelashes moved, she looked at Huo Ran, met Huo Ran's eyes, and then turned her head and asked Jiang Hanting: "There will be witnesses in court later, let's confirm again, that night, when Zhou Zhengu was detained in the police car, are you sure you didn't notice anything unusual?" For example, she said, "Like, a cry for help? Wailing? Slapping sound? ”

Jiang Hanting replied very crisply, and his voice was low: "No." ”

*

The first to testify in court was a middle-aged woman, a resident who lived near the LAN bar, who went downstairs to buy something at the convenience store that night, and when she passed by the LAN bar, she saw a police car and saw the situation at the scene.

Prosecutor Lin smiled at the witness: "Ms. Zhang, did you see this policeman that night?" She pointed at Jiang Hanting.

Ms. Zhang followed her fingers, looked over, and her eyes widened: "Yes, yes, I saw him that day." ”

"What time did you see it?"

"It was about 11 o'clock in the evening, I went to the convenience store to buy something to eat, and when I was done, when I was about to go back, I saw several police cars parked in front of the LAN bar, and a lot of handcuffed people were running away, and someone was chasing after me." Ms. Zhang said with certainty, "I remember this policeman!" He was handsome, tall and tall, and recognizable. ”

Prosecutor Lin asked, "Do you see what he's doing?" ”

"See, it's so pitiful. The policeman was tall and big, and he pressed the thin other party to the ground at once, and his hand strength was great, and the other party didn't move much, and the police still pressed it hard, so cold weather, when he hit the ground, the pain doubled, and something must have happened. ”

"Did you hear anything?"

"Yes." Ms. Zhang recalled, "Later, the policeman escorted a person to the police car, and after a while, the police got out of the car to make a call, and I heard the person in the car shouting for help loudly, saying that he was not taking drugs, and the police must have heard it, and he sneered, but he just ignored it, and just cared about calling himself...... I just looked at it for a while, I was timid, I didn't dare to get too close, and I left quickly, and I didn't know anything else. ”

Huo Ran looked at her and suddenly asked, "So late, when you go downstairs to buy something, are you going to buy food?" ”

Ms. Zhang replied: "Yes, there is no food at home, I am already lying in bed and about to sleep, I am so hungry that I can't stand it, so I went down to buy something." ”

"Where did you stand that night and saw the defendant?"

Ms. Zhang thought for a moment and blinked: "Under a tree between the convenience store and the bar, the one closest to the convenience store." ”

"How far are you from the accused?"

"It's about 10 meters."

Huo Ran's dark pupils were calm, Su Yu stared at Ms. Zhang, Ms. Zhang would blink from time to time, the makeup on her face was exquisite, Su Yu always felt that something was strange.

The next witness was the criminal policeman who participated in the operation with Jiang Hanting that night, surnamed Zhao, very young, when he stood on the witness stand, he was still a little uncomfortable, and the corners of his lips were tightly pursed.

He glanced at Jiang Hanting, smiled at Jiang Hanting, and took a few deep breaths, as if adjusting his emotions.

Prosecutor Lin smiled at Zhao Shu, and his eyebrows curled: "After Jiang Hanting took compulsory measures against Zhou Zhengu for the first time, was there anything wrong with Zhou Zhengu?" ”

"Nope."

"Zhou Zhengu escaped while you were in charge of guarding?"

"Yes."

"How did he escape?"

Zhao Shu's throat moved, and he swallowed his throat: "We saw that he seemed to be quite honest, so we planned to escort him to the police car first, but as soon as he let go, he suddenly pushed me away and ran away, and then we immediately chased after him, and then, the Jiang team also ran over and subdued him." Because several other drug addicts also ran away, we continued to chase the others, and Zhou Zhengu was handed over to the Jiang team to take care of. ”

"Before you went to hunt down the others, did you find anything wrong with Zhou Zhengu?"

"Nope."

Prosecutor Lin continued to ask: "When did you find out that Zhou Zhengu's situation was wrong?" ”

"On the way back to the Public Security Bureau, I suddenly noticed that Zhou Zhengu had been quiet for a long time, he was leaning on the back seat with a pale face, his eyes closed, and his lips were pale."

After Lin Jian finished asking, the judge nodded and signaled that Huo Ran could start asking.

Huo Ran's fingers paused slightly, raised his eyes, and lifted his thin lips: "After Zhou Zhengu escaped for the second time, who did it to subdue him?" It's you? Your colleague Song Yiming? Or Jiang Hanting? ”

Zhao Shu paused: "It's Team Jiang." Zhou Zhengu fell on the way to escape, and we chased him after him with the Jiang team, and the Jiang team subdued him. ”

Huo Ran was thoughtful, his eyes were dark: "When Zhou Zhengu escaped for the second time, there were only you and Song Yiming on the scene?" ”