054 The law is not the most perfect

Su Yu turned his head sideways and pursed his lips to look at Huo Ran.

She asked softly, "What about the truth?" ”

Huo Ran's dark eyes seemed to be smiling: "I don't have God's perspective, how can I know the truth?" There was no smile in his eyes, the ice floes were heavy, probably mentioning those past events, and his eyebrows and eyes were gloomy.

"In this case, I am one of the chess pieces, used as a stepping stone, and I don't know anything, when I was a child, I thought that even if I didn't know who was the murderer of my father, but at least, I knew that my mother was not the murderer of my father, I thought I was a person who only valued evidence, but in fact, I had already been influenced by public opinion, and I was also emotionally biased."

"Because I saw my dad push down my mom with my own eyes, and I heard my dad say that he was going to kill my mom, and even vaguely believed what others said that they both cheated on each other, not to mention, I just lost my dad at that time, I actually didn't want to lose my mom again in my heart, I didn't want to be an orphan, I didn't want my grandma to be old and go to work to support me, so I didn't judge it a long time ago and chose to stand on my mother's side - I think, how can a weak woman kill a strong man? What's more, my mother was cheating on someone else that day, and this dirty reason made me choose to believe it at once. ”

The curvature of Huo Ran's lips was sarcastic, with a sneer, and he stared at Su Yu lightly, with a slight outline: "So what I usually say that I don't believe in the superficial truth is nothing more than saying it to myself, because I know better than anyone else that I am the kind of person who has not been judged before trial and is prejudiced, and I am one of the murderers of my father's unjust death." ”

"But you were a kid at the time."

Su Yu looked at him, his eyes steady.

"These thoughts are all malicious speculations about Xiao Huo Ran when you grow up, in the endless guilt, that little boy may not know anything at the time, he didn't think about anything at all, he only knows that others showed him evidence, he believes that his mother didn't kill his father, he can't wronged his mother after losing his father, you can't use adult standards to criticize a child."

Huo Ran's eyebrows and eyes were dark and deep, and he saw his own reflection in Su Yu's eyes.

He pursed his lips tightly, his fingers still clenched tightly.

Su Yu slowed down her speech, her voice was gentle, and she called him softly: "Huo Ran." ”

Her eyes were like the moon hanging in the night sky.

"Even if you did something wrong when you were a child, you made up for that mistake later, didn't you? After you know that your mom and lawyer falsified the alibi evidence that you used cheating to cover up the murder that night, it was you who told the police the news, and it was you who allowed the police to solve the unsolved case that had not been solved for so many years by combining the relevant evidence that had been found before. ”

Her fingertips trembled slightly: "What's more, this mistake also pushes you to become an excellent criminal defense lawyer, you are different from your mother's defense lawyer, you have a strong professional ethics, you will not falsify evidence, create perjury, you will not treat your client with personal bias, you will do your best to protect the legitimate interests of every client, you have an excellent professional ethics, you pursue procedural justice, you value every real evidence, you will not judge before trial, You believe that everyone is innocent until trial, and you say that your lawyer's duty is to ensure that your client has a fair and just trial......"

Su Yu didn't know how she could have so many things to say, she actually had so many words to comfort Huo Ran.

Huo Ran listened quietly, his lips tightened, but his dark eyes were stained with unknown flames, which were originally just small clusters of flames, and then slowly turned into a fire, the flames were about to burn Su Yu and devour everything.

He stood up, looked at Su Yu condescendingly, and walked to Su Yu's side.

He suddenly reached out and grabbed her wrist, slowly exerting force.

Su Yu was a little stunned.

Huo Ran smiled faintly, his voice was low and hoarse, and he spoke very slowly: "You understand the truth, but in practice, you still won't do it." ”

Su Yu pursed the corners of her lips, she seemed to have just come back to her senses, and said: "Because, people will always think that they have God's perspective, they will always think that what they see is the truth, and they will choose to believe what they know. ”

She lifted her eyelids, her eyes straight at Huo Ran.

"Le Pen has said that individuals in groups feel a strong force of 'justice', for whom the group is justice and quantity is the truth. All of us, like this, will fall into such a strange circle, choose to side with the crowd, choose the justice in their hearts. ”

Huo Ran used a slight force and dragged Su Yu up.

Su Yu didn't stand firmly, and it hit his undulating chest in one fell swoop, Su Yu could hear his heartbeat, and his cheeks could still feel his noisy heart.

He seemed to be holding back some emotion.

Tightly tensed the jaw line and pursed her thin lips.

When Su Yu stood up, the sleeves of her clothes also brought down the empty beer cans on the table, staggering, when she heard Huo Ran talk about the past just now, she drank a lot alone, and now her cheeks are a little hot.

She lifted her eyelids and slid them straight into his eyes.

She spoke: "I understand procedural justice, but sometimes, I just think, obviously there is so much evidence in my hands, obviously that the person confessed to rape, obviously that innocent girl was killed and suffered a relapse of depression, everything points to the boy who raped the girl." So, even if in court, there are defense lawyers who raise errors in the judicial process and loopholes in the judicial process, I want to do everything I can to get the judge not to take the defense opinion of the opposing defense lawyer, because I want to let the loopholes in the law become a reason for the criminals to escape, and procedural justice is to prevent innocent people from going to jail, not to let people who have already committed crimes escape justice. ”

Huo Ran's Adam's apple moved slightly, and he smelled the wine on her body, soft and crispy, mixed with the original aroma of her body.

He whispered: "But back to square one, you can't judge whether the person standing in the court is an innocent person or a criminal person just by the unilateral evidence in your own hands. The reason why we set up a cross-examination link in court is to let both the prosecution and defense present their own evidence, and the two sides work together to eliminate illegal and unreasonable evidence, and finally, use the remaining and screened evidence to piece together a truth that is closest to the truth. ”

"And the last time you didn't let the judge, as a fair neutral, use your thinking to interfere with the judge's thinking. Human capacity is limited, rather than allowing people to be wronged, it is better to respect procedural justice, and if there is illegal evidence and a chain of evidence that cannot be closed, it will be classified as innocent. No one should think of themselves as having the truth, because the truth in your hands is most likely to be a fake, or the truth that others want you to see. ”

Su Yu lowered his eyelashes, and his eyelashes trembled gently.

Her eyes were a little hot, her fingers were clenched, her heart was like being pinched by an invisible hand, and it hurt a little, and even her breathing was painful.

She remembered the innocent and dazed look of the young man after he was wrongfully imprisoned.

It was as if his heart had been pierced by arrows, and his chest was dripping with blood.

She pursed her lips and suppressed the emotions that were about to come out of her chest: "I feel guilty, every time I think of that teenager, I feel guilty......"

Su Yu said, tears rolling down the corners of his eyes.

Her cheeks were hot because of the wine, but the temperature of her tears seemed to exceed the temperature of her cheeks.

"Huo Ran." She lifted her eyelids again, her dark eyes were shining, watery, the tip of her nose was a little red, her eyelashes trembled, and her flushed cheeks were like rouge.

She smiled, and there were tears on her eyelashes.

"I'm not qualified to be a prosecutor, in fact, at the beginning, I accused a suspect, because of insufficient evidence, he was acquitted in court, but within a month, he killed again, this time the evidence was conclusive, he was convicted. At that time, I was very confused, I didn't know what was right and what was wrong, so when I accused other suspects later, I took a stern accusation and prosecuted the most serious crimes, but I didn't expect that three years later, the teenager who had been accused of rape by me was innocent, and the real murderer was someone else. So I had the idea of backing down, I couldn't be a prosecutor anymore. ”

Huo Ran lowered his eyes, stretched out his hand, and gently hugged her into his arms.

Slowly tightened his hand.

"It's not your fault. Nothing in this world is absolutely perfect, and the same is true of the law, which is not the most perfect, but it is by far the fairest. Without God's perspective, we can't know the truth, we can't guarantee substantive justice, all we can see is procedural justice, procedural justice may let criminals go, but it will also prevent innocent people from being persecuted, not to mention, if there are really criminals who escape through procedural justice, this is also a warning to the public procuratorate and law organs, and do their best to ensure that all evidence is legal and valid. ”

Su Yu's fingers tightened tightly, and for a long time, he hugged him hard and bit his lower lip.

She felt like her whole body was aching.

The chest is constantly heaving.

The heart hurts the most.

But the calm and cool breath on Huo Ran's body seemed to be able to soothe the dense pain in her chest.

Both of them had made mistakes, and now they were both trapped in each other's arms, like trapped beasts, seeking comfort and licking each other's wounds.