Su Yu also stared at the photo-

Xie Shen carried Sheng Wan on his back, his movements were gentle, and he bent down slightly, making Sheng Wan lie more comfortable, as if he was carrying his whole world, which made people completely unthinkable that just two days later, it would be this man who killed the woman he was carrying personally, and it also made people completely unbelievable that it was such a seemingly gentle and affectionate man, but when his wife was pregnant, he was still carrying a drunk mistress in the middle of the night.

The information in Sheng Wan's hometown is still the same as the original, all in all, Sheng Wan is not doing well in her hometown, and her family only treats her as an object that can be exploited and a tool that can be used to help her younger brother. As for Sheng Wan's school information, in addition to her teacher saying that Sheng Wan often has wounds suspected of domestic violence, Su Yu also noticed a seemingly ordinary information - a month before the case, someone anonymously broke the information that Sheng Wan was raised by a married man on the forum of Sheng Wan's school, and picked up the situation in Sheng Wan's rural home in detail, with pictures and texts, and it was on the popular post at once, and it was hung high for several days.

During that time, Sheng Wan's days were very sad, she suffered a lot of strange eyes at school, those girls who had been friends with her were far away from her, and the materials about her, whether true or false, sprung up like mushrooms after a rain, and appeared on the school forum, Sheng Wan's private life was infinitely magnified, exposed in front of everyone, she was as if she had been stripped naked, * naked was tied at the school gate, and everyone was whipped.

At that time, Xie Shen was controlled by his family, or he was already tired of Sheng Wan, so he didn't show up at all, leaving Sheng Wan alone to face the accusations of 10,000 people, without Xie Shen, no one helped remove the posts on the forum, only new posts appeared one after another.

The worst thing is that one day on the path of the school, Sheng Wan was suddenly crushed to the ground by three tall black and strong women, the women were like crazy, they came up and didn't say a word, they fanned her in the mouth, gave her one slap after another, the two women restrained her body, did not let her move, and the other big palm grabbed it, and tore all her clothes, and even tore her underwear and underwear, her whole body was almost uncovered, the woman slapped her desperately, pinched the flesh on her body, Beat her body and even stepped on her stomach without mercy.

They just deliberately humiliated her, beating and scolding: "Little slut, do you dare to be a junior in the future, and dare to do such a disgusting thing?" Tell you to be a junior, you should be beaten when you are a junior, do you know that there is a big-bellied woman at home who needs to be taken care of!! It's good for you to take advantage of other people's wives to be pregnant and seduce other men's men outside, do you have any shame? Okay, okay, there's no shame, right, let everyone come and see your body and see how you use your body to seduce men! ”

Just because no one has passed on that path doesn't mean that no one really has passed.

Soon a student heard the sound, stood at the intersection, and took a mobile phone to shoot the grand evening on the ground, whether it was the theme of the goddess's fall or the goddess's body, it was enough for the boys on campus to be excited.

When several women saw someone filming, not only did they not stop it, but even generously let others shoot it, they also became interested, and the more they fought, the more energetic they became.

Lu Baptist also got this video, and the office was filled with the miserable cries and begs for mercy in the evening: "Please stop filming, please." In the back, Sheng Wan no longer asked for help, she seemed to have given up, wanting to curl up in a ball to protect herself, but in exchange for only the women gritted their teeth and stretched out her body and exposed it to the video.

She is a remnant flower ravaged by wind and rain.

Su Yu's chest was a little stuffy, she watched the video for a while, stretched out her hand, grabbed the phone, and turned off the video. Her chest felt like a large stone had accumulated on it, and it was difficult to breathe.

This video was named as the original partner beating the mistress.

Su Yu found the original URL of the video and looked at the comments, none of which expressed humanitarian sympathy for the beaten people.

"Xiao San should be beaten, this kind of woman should be beaten! Who asked her to seduce someone else's husband! ”

"It's really relieving to watch, there are a few more videos of this kind of positive energy!"

"If you cheat, everyone can beat the junior like this, I don't think anyone dares to cheat, right? I hope that the law can give the original partner the right to play the junior, please like it if you support me! ”

Su Yu sneered, how could these women only target women? But he didn't dare to touch Xie Shen at all? Is the cheating just the fault of Xiao San?

Huo Ran spoke: "So, the mental state of the evening during that time should not be very good, right?" A girl, alone in the face of these rumors, she is a junior, her family is poor, the video of being beaten naked has been spread all over the Internet, the family does not care about her physical and mental health at all, and even only pressures her to prepare money for her brother's wedding. And Xie Shen, the only one who can comfort her, is not by her side, and may even be accompanied by the original partner. ”

When Su Yu heard this, he felt a burst of suppressed dullness and despair.

For the grand evening.

is also a woman who is a junior like Sheng Wan.

She took a deep breath, looked at Huo Ran, and said calmly: "Do you want to say that Sheng Wan may have committed suicide?" This speculation does exist, no one has ruled out the possibility of her suicide, even if the police have sufficient evidence, they dare not make a 100% conclusion that Sheng Wan is definitely not a suicide, but according to the current situation, once Sheng Wan's death is identified as a suicide, there will be many, many unexplained doubts, and even contrary to human common sense and cognition. Do you think the judge will allow you to make such a defense in court? ”

Huo Ran's eyebrows were calm, his thin lips were pursed, and his dark eyes seemed to be dyed with a rich ink color, which blurred little by little, and gradually became a black mist.

He seemed to smile: "Why don't you wait and see?" ”

*

Su Yu understood what Huo Ran meant, whether it was legitimate defense or other reasons for defense, they had to start from the file and find out the contradictions.

Because everyone in the criminal defense circle knows that those who get the file will win the world.

Huo Ran reviewed the prosecution's indictment again, what was conveyed in the indictment was the prosecution's arguments, Huo Ran read it while summarizing the prosecution's arguments on the whiteboard, Su Yu cooperated with his arguments, found out the evidence part attached to the case file materials, and pasted it on the whiteboard with a magnet.

After Huo Ran finished writing his arguments, he handed the whiteboard marker to Su Yu, he stared at the whiteboard and said, "Now you can see if there is any problem with the procedural part of the indictment." ”

Illegal evidence is excluded in the practice of handling cases, and it is rarely accepted by the judge, Su Yu roughly glanced at the evidence collection part, and planned to start with the interrogation time, she listed a timeline, from the first time Xie Shen was summoned, to the end of the summons, and then to the formation of the next transcript, there seems to be no major problem, the police summon Xie Shen every time The interval is very long, giving Xie Shen enough time to rest, and every interrogation is also videotaped, judging from the file alone, there is basically no possibility of torture to extract confessions.

There are no major problems with the evidence collection part of the police either.

Su Yu pressed her temples and continued to look, the first time she looked at it, she didn't find any problems, and when it came to the second time, she noticed that the testimony at the hotel front desk was a little strange.

The hotel front desk said that at about 7 o'clock in the morning, she received a call from room 4012, she answered, but at first no one spoke, only a noisy friction sound, she realized that this was a 4012 guest accidentally pressed, called, she just wanted to hang up, the phone suddenly came from the woman's scream, the woman was shouting - don't touch me, get away and something, the man has not spoken.

Su Yu raised her eyes, glanced at Huo Ran, pointed to the one on the file, and said: "This testimony is very incomplete, she neither mentioned the length of time she answered the phone, nor did she explain what kind of handling she did after answering the phone, did she knock on the door of 4012, she also explained very vaguely the content of the call she heard, you can interrogate this front desk when you go to court tomorrow." ”

Su Yu's eyelashes drooped, her expression was serious, the warm light fell, and under her eye sockets, a shallow shadow was cast, and after she found a leak, it was like opening a plug-in, and the rest of the points were found smoothly.

"Looking at the "Physical Evidence Examination Report", the police extracted multiple bloodstains from Sheng Wan and Xie Shen's bodies for testing, but if you look at the test results, they did not have each other's blood on each other's bodies. If two people stab each other in an argument, how can there be no bloodstains? ”

Su Yu's words were very simple, and they stopped at the point, because she knew that Huo Ran understood what she meant.

"There are still several contradictions in the case file, for example, Doctor 120 said that when she arrived at the scene, she saw Sheng Wan 'lying on the bed with her hands folded on her chest', but if you look at the photos of the scene, her hands are outstretched. There is also "Scene Investigation Record", it is said that the fruit knife was found on the bed, and it is also on the photo, but in the "Case Solving Report", it is said that the fruit knife was found under Sheng Wan's body. ”

In the office, except for Su Yu's voice, it was very quiet.

Huo Ran lowered his eyes and looked at Su Yu, his gaze was also very quiet, watching her point out one suspicion after another with concentration and interest, and watching how she seriously explained to him where these contradictions were.

Huo Ran's gaze skimmed over her white face, followed her fingers, and also looked at the case file.

He watched in silence for a while, staring at the suspicions pointed out by Su Yu for a long time.

Su Yu was a little nervous for a long time, wondering if she had said something wrong, or if she had pointed out all the wrong doubts.

Then, Huo Ran said: "The last point is hard to say, maybe there are novices on the police side who are involved in handling the case, so there are such contradictory low-level mistakes, but the point of blood stains can be used to argue the points of debate." ”

As he spoke, he raised his eyes and glanced at Su Yu's face, probably seeing her nervousness, he laughed, and didn't say anything, let alone anything.

Su Yu understood that Huo Ran was deliberately making her nervous.

Just like when they were in college, they attended a dinner together at the Legal Aid Center, obviously they were not together at that time, the brothers and sisters teased the two of them, Su Yu was a little anxious, from her ears to her neck, she desperately denied it over there, but he hesitated and said, "Actually, ......"

At that time, the eyes of everyone present were focused on him.

His black and white eyes looked at her quietly, and then, for a while, he wanted to speak and stopped, and finally, he actually lowered his head and laughed, as if with pampering, and said, "It's nothing." ”

The noise of the people around him became more and more intense.

"Oh, I'm afraid of my girlfriend."

"Isn't that still called it? So what is it? ”

At that time, Su Yu stopped her tone, she couldn't say anything, the tips of her ears were so red that she pursed her red lips, yes, she also wanted to ask Huo Ran, what do they have?