Volume 3 Wonderful Reward 2. White Horses Are Not Horses
Chen Caozhi will definitely come to this Wuyi Lane, but Xie Daoyun didn't expect Chen Caozhi to come so soon, and he came to participate in tonight's Deqing Talk Gathering.
Xie Daoyun's heart was pounding, and he thought: "Zizhong won't know that Xie Fu Deqing talked about Yaji for me to choose a son-in-law, so what is he doing here." He wants to argue with me and convince me? ”
As soon as she thought of this, Xie Daoyun's face turned red and hot, but she didn't seem to be the kind of woman who was easily self-absorbed after all. Immediately thinking that Chen Caozhi was very likely to be invited by Zhuge Zeng or Yuan Tong to help talk, thinking about it like this, he was inevitably a little embarrassed in his heart, and said secretly: "I thank Daoyun and refuse to marry." It's useless for you to come here, Zizhong, do you really think that you will be able to beat me if you have to talk clearly? Not necessarily. ”
The little maid who came to report saw that Daoyun Niangzi's face was flushed and white, and her expression was also happy and annoyed, she didn't dare to say more, and dared to go to Liu Wu, who was Dao Yun's maid.
When the catkins arrived, Xie Daoyun was ready to stop, so they went to the main hall through the rain listening corridor, which is a zigzag corridor, connecting several courtyards, and the corridor has a bamboo roof. The sound of rain is clear, the light rain is like jumping beads and splashing jade, crisp and gratifying, when it rains, it is like a mountain waterfall flying and noisy, and the sound of rain is full of ears, and there is a kind of noise in the quiet.
But tonight, Xie Daoyun didn't have the interest to wander under the corridor and listen to the rain, and he was in a hurry, and he was still holding a volume of Mingsheng Lake Xuanji in his hand. . .
Xie Daoyun took the maid Liu Fu from the back door into the side room of the main hall, the curtain hung low and separated from the main hall, heard the fourth uncle Xie Wanshi and the four uncles were defeated Shouchun was demoted to a concubine, although last year by the constant temperature recommended to return to the free cavalry permanent attendant, the scattered cavalry permanent attendant as the emperor's adviser, is Qinggui idle, but the dead uncle has no psychological politics, basically launched the center of the imperial court power, the heart is arrogant and arrogant The fourth uncle has been depressed since then, intoxicated with Xuanyan Qing talk, and also wanted to serve the five stones to relieve worries, was persuaded by her....
Xie Daoyun listened for a while, but didn't hear Chen Caozhi's voice, so he said softly: "Liu Wu, you go to inform my fourth uncle, and say that I have come." ”
The catkins rolled out the curtain, and at the moment when the curtain opened and fell, Xie Daoyun saw a lacquered crown and a tall shirt, sitting upright, with a smile on his lips as before....
As soon as the catkins went out, they stinged back quickly. His eyes widened, and he said to Xie Daoyun anxiously: "Lady, which Chen Langjun is here, it is Chen Langjun of Qiantang Chen Cao." ”
Xie Daoyun looked immobile and said, "I know, what kind of body are you panicking and go and report to the fourth uncle."
Liu Fu glanced at Xie Daoyun in surprise, went out again, and came to Xie Wanshi to salute and said, "Lord Shilang, Daoyun Lady has already come." ”
Dressed in a crane and holding an iron in his hand, Xie Wanshi looked at the side curtain, then looked around at the people in the hall, and said, "Then let's listen to Zhuge Xian's nephew and Yuan Xian's nephew first, who are the two of you who have to help talk?" ”
Yuan Daodao: "Xie Changshi, the younger generation is invited to be the branch of the public and the high disciple of the law cold"
Zhuge once said: "The younger generation is light Nanyang Fan Wuzi"
Zhi Fahan and Fan Ning both saluted Xie Wanshi just now, and they both bowed their respects at this time.
Xie Wan asked Gu Kaizhi: "What about Gu Jialangjun?" ”
Gu Kaizhi was busy: "The juniors and Chen Zizhong are here to listen to your handsome and high-ranking arguments, and they don't participate in the debate.
Xie Daoyun heard this sentence, and his heart was slightly empty, and he felt faintly melancholy."
The screen in the main hall has been arranged, and Xie Wan's son Xie Shao has been called Sister Yuan. Xie Daoyun walked out of the side room. A folding blue screen separates the hall from an independent space, one flower and one futon, Xie Daoyun kneels and sits on the futon, and a maid pours tea.
Chen Caozhi's eyes looked at the screen, the painting on the screen seemed to be painted by Xie Daoyun, there was a painting style of Dian'an, the painting was a picture of Huiji Dongshan, there was a light behind the screen, and the thin shadow reflected on the screen was Brother Yingtai, and it was vaguely recognizable that it was a woman's sideburns, and it was no longer a scarf and a rushan outfit.
At this time, Yuan Tong and the branch of the Han side, Zhuge Zeng and Fan Ning's side had to argue the difficulty, the two sides came out of one, Yuan Tong came out of the question first, and the study of the branch of the Han was very deep and the white horse is not a horse.
The white horse non-horse theory is an interesting topic of Gongsun Longde in the plains of the Warring States Zhao State, Gongsun Long is a representative figure of the famous family, the so-called criminal master, is to defend the righteousness with the right name, good at language analysis to get the debate, and is often a sophist, the white horse non-horse theory is a famous sophistry logic.
At that time, the Zhao State had a horse plague, and a large number of war horses died, in order to strictly prevent this plague from being introduced into the Qin State. Qin posted a notice at the Hangu Pass: "Where the Zhao Kingdom has horses can not enter the customs", on this day, Gongsun Long rode a white horse to the Hangu Pass, and the official said: "You can enter the customs, but horses cannot enter the customs." Gongsun Long argued: "White horses are not horses, why can't they enter the customs?" ”
The official said, "A white horse is a horse"
Gongsun Long said: "Is my Gongsun Long a dragon? The official was stunned, but still insisted: "No matter whether it is a white horse or a black horse, as long as it is a horse of Zhao State, it cannot enter the customs." "Gongsun Long is a sophist. At this time, it is natural to show eloquence, saying: "Horse refers to the name" white refers to the color, the name and the color are not the same concept, for example, if you want a horse, you can give a yellow horse and a black horse, but if you want a white horse, you can't give a black horse to a yellow horse, which proves that a white horse and a horse are not the same thing, so a white horse is not a horse
The more the officials listened, the more confused they became. was dizzy by Gongsun Long's high-minded talk, and he didn't know how to deal with it, so he had no choice but to let Gongsun Long and Bai Ma pass.
Zhi Fa Han is good at reading the Warring States Policy and working Zhang Yi and Su Qinde's doctrine, this time it has been a white horse and non-Ma to argue that it is difficult to be prepared, and last night in the Yuan Mansion and Yuan Tong had a long talk, Yuan Tong is also familiar with the white horse and non-horse theory, and the relevant questions and difficulties are also well understood. On the other hand, Zhuge Zeng, how can there be a little Zhuge Liang's tongue, the battle group is dashing, dumbfounded, just waiting for his help to talk about Fan Ning, Fan Wuzi for him to solve the siege, this debate is difficult to abandon the world, it is a difficult debate between Fahan and Fan Wuzi, the two main arguments are kuilei, Fan Wuzi is 24 years old this year, with a beard, medium height, handsome appearance, but a serious expression, even though he frowned slightly, listened to Yuan Tong, talked endlessly, and said that his mouth was dry, and he stopped drinking tea and asked
"Brother Zicai still has unfinished words about white horses and non-horses?"
Yuan Tong glanced at Zhi Fahan and replied, "It's not for the time being, and let's see how Brother Yongmin and Brother Wuzi refute it."
Fan Wuzi asked again: "Brother Fa Han has something to say?"
Zhifa said coldly: "Not yet." When Fan Tan has more to say, the little monk's free eyes correspond"
Fan Wuzi sat down and said: "The white horse is not a horse sophistry, the white horse is a kind of horse, but the horse is not a white horse, Gongsun Long is confused with 2, and it is clear at a glance that the wise man who seeks the same is different, if according to Gongsun Long's theory, then the Taoist is not a person."
Zhuge Zeng stared at Zhifa's cold bald head and stroked his palms and laughed: "Wonderful, the white horse is not a horse, a Taoist is not a person, and a non-person dares to ask what it is."
This Zhuge once argued that he was stammering, but at this time, he was sarcastic, but he had sharp teeth, and he was embarrassed and speechless.
Chen Caozhi shook his head secretly, Zhi Fahan should not use this kind of sophistry as an argument, thinking that white horses are not horses, this kind of sophistry is logical and hard, once he is caught, there is no room to fight back, only to admit defeat, and this Fan Wuzi is clear and concise, and does not use ornaments, typical of the spear of the son, attacking the shield of the son, and smashing the key point, he is indeed an extremely powerful master of debate.
Zhi Fahan said helplessly: "This first little monk lost and asked Zhuge Tanyue to solve the problem"
Zhuge Zeng had already prepared the topic that Fan Wuzi was best at getting the topic in the Spring and Autumn Three Legends, Chen Caozhi couldn't help but be stunned when he heard this topic, at this time, it was a coincidence that he had debated with Kong Wang the night before whether the Zuo family could take advantage of the risk in the Spring and Autumn Period
It's a pity that Zhi Fa Han didn't have the opportunity to listen to Chen Caozhi and Kong Wang's wonderful exposition on the sub-theory, otherwise he wouldn't have lost so thoroughly, and Fan Wuzi's thesis is that it is easy to take advantage of the risk, so the other side of the branch law Han must insist that it is easy to take the risk, but the ancient history books are time to persuade and punish, and there are few such examples, so the defeat of the branch Fa Han in this battle is also reasonable.
Finally defeated with hatred, Yuan Tong was defeated in 2 theories, and he couldn't argue with Xie Daoyun and lost under his rival first, Yuan Tong was inevitably depressed, but Yuan Tong was not the first time he had been defeated, he had been defeated four or five times in Xie Mansion, and he was happy to win and drove away the frustration in his heart, and he was so interested that he watched Fan Wuzi and Xie argue. Yuan Tong naturally didn't want Xie Daoyun to lose, Xie Daoyun was defeated, so Zhuge Zeng could be as proud as Xie proposed, although Xie may not marry Zhuge . But Xie Fu Qing talked about Yaji from now on, and he was willing to listen to his heart: "Xie Daoyun will not be defeated, she has beaten many Qing Tan masters in the past 2 years, but this Fan Wuzi is indeed very powerful." ”
The eyebrows that made Xie Wan flutter when he heard the argument, Tie Ruyi couldn't help but knock on the tiger's mouth, he enjoyed it very much, and then said to the screen: "Dao Yun, it's time for you to solve the question"
Chen Caozhi was present, Xie Daoyun was uneasy, she was a master of debate, and naturally she heard that this Fan Wuzi was a fierce opponent, and she didn't belong tonight. I can't concentrate on it, and I'm afraid that it's not Fan Wuzi's opponent
Xie Daoyun's white teeth bit his red lips lightly, and muttered: "Zizhong, you still hurt me~"