ff37; u85c0f; 8bf4; 66f4; 65b0; 6700; 5feb; 5c0f; 8bf4; 9605; 8bfb; 7f51;.

Yang Fan said: "I cite this example to illustrate that the law is established by people, so it cannot be perfect, there are always some problems that have not been thought of when the law was established, when the law is obviously contrary to morality and ethics or even reasonable, it is ridiculous to blindly adhere to the law, and this is even contrary to the original intention of establishing the law."

Cheng Ling sneered: "Let your tongue be a lotus, it's just that you want to be exempt from the crime of Chang Zhiyuan!" The two things of etiquette and law, the king teaches Daduan. Yang Langzhong, in this murder case, if the person is released according to the rites, the law is useless! If it is according to the law, the murderer deserves death! Etiquette and law are both kings, how do you choose? ”

When Zhao Jiulong heard this, he hurriedly promoted his theory of commutation, and said: "Therefore, if Chang Zhiyuan does not save his father, it is contrary to filial piety." If you kill someone to save your father, you will use too drastic means, and if you don't punish it, someone will violate the law of the country in the future. Our imperial envoy advocates a light sentence, which not only demonstrates filial piety, but also makes people dare not break the law easily! ”

Yang Fan said: "Zhao Yu is also false, and Cheng Sizhi is even more wrong. Weishenme says so? On top of the law and etiquette, there is a trade-off between great righteousness and small righteousness. For example, my Great Zhou Law stipulates that if someone commits a crime, if you know and don't sue it, you are guilty! But when the offender is your grandparents or parents, you are guilty if you sue it, and that's because filial piety is involved.

When you see a foreigner sinning, you don't accuse it. He who saw your grandparents or parents sinning, and you were guilty, and you were to be hanged; However, if your parents or grandparents commit a major crime of treason, the rules change and you are acquitted. If you don't sue, you're guilty, why is that? ”

Yang Fan glanced at them and said aggressively: "Weishenme is also a crime committed by grandparents and parents, and the former sued you for being guilty because you are not filial." The latter doesn't accuse you of guilt? Because it's a rebellion! The victims of rebellion are thousands of families. Therefore, the filial piety of your family and surname must obey the public welfare of the people of the world.

It can be seen that when there is a conflict between law and morality and ethics, it is generally necessary to accommodate morality and ethics. However, this scope is limited to the law and morality between one family and one surname, and if the offender's crime harms the whole world, it is a serious crime of rebellion. Then the law should be placed above filial piety, and even children should sue him.

To sum up, whether it is the Fa or the Dao, the application depends on how effective it is for the people of the world. Chang Zhiyuan was eager to save his father, and killed people by mistake. He didn't commit murder on purpose, he did it for filial piety, and the person who harmed him was only Pan Junyi. And what did the slain do?

This Pan Junyi got excited when he saw it, set up a gambling game, and forced Cheng to death. Chang's family, Chang Zhiyuan's grandmother, father, and mother were all victimized by Pan Junyi alone, and his actions hurt heaven and reason! Chang Zhiyuan caused his death because of filial piety, and he should be forgiven, so. It is not only the filial piety of Changzhiyuan, but also the righteousness of the people of the world! ”

Cheng Ling said calmly: "In this way, the old woman of the Chang family who killed her daughter-in-law should also be exonerated." Isn't this filial piety! ”

Yang Fan said: "This is not filial piety!" Cheng's lady is young and strong compared to this old woman, but this old woman beat her to death, has she ever resisted? She has done her filial piety. After Cheng's wife was beaten to death, did her husband and son ever sue? They don't. So they also did their filial piety.

Who is the accuser? The people in the market are also! The old woman of the Chang family was brutal and cold, obviously a traitor, and her son was of poor character, but she was angry with her gentle daughter-in-law for no reason and beat her to death. aroused the anger of the public, from the people in the market to Fangzheng and Wuhou, and then from Fangzheng Wuhou to Luoyang Mansion, this is righteousness, the righteousness of the world! ”

When Yang Fan said this, he mentioned the spirit of dantian and sent his closing statement far away, that is, the officials scattered in the veranda of copying hands heard it clearly: "If the law cannot encourage moral behavior, it is not a good law, and if the rule of law cannot encourage moral behavior, it is not good governance!" According to this, the official thinks that Chang Zhiyuan is not guilty! ”

Cheng Ling said in a deep voice: "My Dali Temple is against it!" ”

Zhao Jiulong also said angrily: "My imperial envoy is against it!" ”

"Then there is no way!"

Yang Fan spread his hands, put on a soldier's jiashi, and said: "Since the three law divisions have their own opinions, it seems that the triage of the three divisions is inconclusive. Then ...... Something to do, submit it to the book, and let the prime ministers decide! ”

"Karala ......"

An autumn thunder sounded in the sky at the right time, marking a thrilling annotation for Yang Fan's words.

※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※

"Alas!"

Prime Minister Su Wei held the pen in his hand, drew a circle in the air for a long time, and finally couldn't put down the pen, so he put down the pen, changed his other hand to support his cheek, and continued to sigh.

"Alas!"

The little chamberlain waiting beside him smiled and said, "Su Xianggong, why do you keep sighing, but do you have a toothache, do you want the slave maid to ask someone from the hospital to come and treat Xianggong?" ”

Su Dongpo's old ancestor has a very good temper, and the little eunuchs waiting around him are not afraid of him, and sometimes they will laugh with him.

Su Wei said with a bitter face: "It's not a toothache, it's a headache!" The lawsuit of the Three Law Divisions has been fought back and forth, and it has been pushed in front of my Lao Su, how is this good, how is it good! ”

In the prime minister, Su Wei was mainly in charge of the judicial affairs, so the trial of the three law divisions had no results, and the case was sent to him. Yang Fan, Cheng Ling, and Zhao Jiulong each insisted on their own words, one was not guilty, one was sentenced to death, and the other was sentenced to commutation, which made this great talent, one of the "Four Friends of the Article", sad.

The little chamberlain said curiously: "Xianggong is a person who asks questions from universities, can't he still break such a case?" ”

Su Wei shook his head again and again and said: "It's easy to say, here, there are laws, etiquette, justice, morality, and human feelings, and factional disputes, even if there is a living immortal, I can't understand it." ”

The little chamberlain leaned on the side of the case, supported his chin with both hands, and said curiously: "Then the prince thinks that in the judgment of the three law divisions, who has the best opinion?" ”

This question can be asked ambiguously, Prime Minister Su frowned, pondered for a long time, and said secretly: "

According to the meaning of Dali Temple, Chang Zhiyuan was sentenced to death. Then you will offend the Imperial Embassy and the Criminal Department. And behind Yang Fan, there was still Liang Wang Wu thinking twice, which was inappropriate. Moreover, this matter has been boiling with public resentment, Pan Junyi has his own way to die, how can Chang Zhiyuan pay for his life?

According to the will of the Criminal Department, Chang Zhiyuan was not guilty. That would offend Dali Temple and the Imperial Envoy Tower, and there was still King Wu Chenghei of Wei standing behind them, which was also inappropriate.

What about commutation of sentence according to the suggestion of the Imperial Embassy? The Criminal Department and Dali Temple were not satisfied, and besides, Li Xiang had already confessed. The Imperial Envoy must not be asked to make a comeback from this case and regain his authority, so as to prevent the cool officials from running amok again. Therefore, the judgment of the Imperial Legation cannot be used, so only innocence and capital crimes can be chosen, but no matter how you choose, you will offend people......"

The little waiter saw that the more he thought about it, the more his face was twisted, and he was about to turn it into a bun, so he couldn't help but smile and said, "Xianggong doesn't often say it." If you don't want to make a decision, you will be blamed if you make a mistake, but it's good to be ambiguous and hold both ends, then it's with the mud. ”

Su Wei said with a sad face: "I can't do it, I can't do it!" This matter is that the theory of the three law divisions is not clear, so it was pushed to my Lao Su, if I am ambiguous, where else to push, can I still push it in front of the emperor? ”

As soon as this sentence came out, Su Wei suddenly seemed to have fallen into the "fixation method". The whole person stayed there, and the little chamberlain saw that his eyes were straight and expressionless, as if he had fallen into an evil spirit, he couldn't help but be a little scared, and quickly stretched out his hand and shook it in front of him, and asked nervously: "Xianggong?" ”

Su's eyes staggered. Suddenly, with a smile on his face, he took out a box from under the table, and stuffed it into the little waiter with a smile: "Haha! You're good! Come on, have a snack! ”

The little waiter ate and said, "Su Xianggong, what's wrong with you?" ”

Sue touched his head kindly. said: "Xianggong is fine, you can eat snacks, Xianggong go out!" ”

After Su Wei finished speaking, he put the transcript of the three law divisions into his sleeve, and walked out happily.

※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※

On the Wucheng Palace, Wu Zetian finished reading the record of the three legal words, and said to Su Wei: "Prime Minister, is this going to make me decide?" ”

Su Wei said in a deep voice: "Of course not! ”

This benevolent brother can preach "ambiguous theory" in front of his colleagues and subordinates, but in front of the emperor, he will never show that he has no opinion.

Wu Zetian said suspiciously: "So, what does Su Xiang mean?" ”

Su Wei arched his hand and said: "Bixia, the minister thinks that in this case, the compromise strategy of the imperial envoy is not advisable. bixia has always been missionary, Ming national law, guilty is sin, innocent is innocent, each with fifty boards, ambiguous and muddy, how can this be? ”

Su Wei, who has always believed in the most ambiguous philosophy, actually ......

Shangguan Wan'er listened to Su Wei's righteous and stern words, and Rao was nervously looking forward to the result in order to know if it was beneficial to Lang Jun, but she still couldn't help but want to laugh. The corners of her mouth hooked, and she quickly pursed it again.

Wu Zetian nodded and said, "Hmm! A compromise is not advisable, so, Su Xiang thinks, is Chang Zhiyuan guilty or innocent? ”

"Sizzle......"

Su Wei took a breath of cold air, and frowned like a toothache: "Bixia, the difficulty is here!" ”

The corners of Wu Zetian's mouth couldn't help but twitch twice.

Su Wei frowned, made Xizi hold his heart, and said in embarrassment: "This case, if you are not guilty, I am afraid that people all over the world will follow suit, and there will be frequent homicide cases from now on, and the law cannot be indulged in vain." If it is sentenced to death, the will of the people cannot be bullied, the will of the people cannot be violated, and Pan Junyi has his own way to die. ”

Wu Zetian said helplessly: "Then what do you think should be acquitted or capital crime?" ”

Su Wei said loudly: "Minister, you should be convicted!" But ......"

Wu Zetian's eyebrows, which had just been raised appreciatively, quickly drooped down again, and asked, "But how?" ”

Su Wei got up, teased his robe, shook his head, and said sonorously: "Pan Junyi plotted against his wife and set up a situation to frame him, which is hateful!" Chang Zhiyuan saved his father and killed people, and he was in prison, sad! Minister, please bixia, descend Ganlin to amnesty, then Chang Zhiyuan and the world's filial sons are all Mu Shengshang Longen! ”

After a while, Wu Zetian looked at the back of Su Wei who was far away, and said with a wry smile: "This Su is ambiguous......"

Shangguan Wan'er playfully said: "The old traitor is slippery! ”

P: These two chapters are not easy to study the law and study the logic; The claws don't hurt too much, but it's a headache, upload it regularly tonight, and go to the nest in advance, friends, it's been double 48 hours at the end of the month, please vote for the monthly pass!

Thanks!

ff37; M is good, please help us promote and recommend this site, thank you for your support! Every time you share and publicize, it is the motivation for our high-speed debut!