Two days later, Shen Wuhuan posted a long Weibo on Weibo.

This long Weibo made the boiling network calm down instantly.

"The content of the so-called manifesto questioned my professional quality and my teaching achievements, which caused a great adverse impact on society."

"So I've summarized here the main points that several 'authority' figures and people have questioned me, so let's take a sober look at them."

"One: 'Authorities' have questioned my teaching materials as misleading and will train people into robots."

"Second, 'authoritative figures' question that the Little Sonata is not taught at all in many educational institutions."

"Third, 'pundits' question that allowing children across the country to use the same textbooks to educate students will make them carve out of a mold."

"Fourth: 'authoritative figures' questioned me for having no teaching experience at all, no teaching results, and the teaching materials were imaginary."

"Fifth, some people question that pianists don't necessarily make good students."

"Sixth: Some people question my identity as a composer."

"In response to the above six points, I will respond to you one by one, restore a real piano education to you, and ask you to analyze calmly, and do not be misled by people with intentions."

"As for me becoming a businessman, it is completely groundless, I want to ask you if you sell textbooks without publicity, I will become a businessman when I sell them? In the eyes of these people, all legitimate behaviors can be distorted, and if they say that I will destroy the next generation of the motherland, then even more reasonable people will not believe it, you are treating the Aegean people of the whole country as fools, right? ”

The people who calmed down agreed with the major problems summarized by Shen Wuhuan, and they suppressed their anger, just to see what Shen Wuhuan could say!

"The first point, misleading and robotic, probably means that my education direction is different from the mainstream of the public, and I did not choose music to teach, but used a large number of etudes, and the etudes lack musicality, which is easy for people to lose their sensitivity to music, and here I want to talk about it in relation to the "Little Sonata Collection" in the second article."

"There are indeed such situations where there are too many etudes, so I use the "Little Sonata Collection" in the textbook, and in the enlightenment textbook, there are also many pieces of music used to cultivate musical interest, and those have actually achieved the basic training effect."

"As for the "Little Sonata" that educational institutions do not teach, this is complete nonsense, first of all, the educational methods of the teaching institutions are not under my control, and secondly, the difficulty of the music in the "Little Sonata" is indeed not small, this set of textbooks has only been on sale for three months, and how many students can reach the level of learning "Little Sonata" during this time?"

"Teachers don't teach, it's because they think you're not good enough to learn the Little Sonata, it's not that they don't teach at all, and besides, the order and content of the teaching are confidential to the educational institution, and these people ask, why would others tell them?"

Oh, yes... Teaching content is something that even teachers and teachers don't necessarily communicate privately, so why tell you an outsider?

Even if someone really reveals something, and everyone's teaching materials are sold, do you really dare not teach? Isn't that a fraudulent sale? I'm afraid that their education center will have to weigh it themselves, right?

As for whether the teaching is based on etudes or music, it is too professional, and the people directly ignore it, anyway, this is their professional stuff, the mother-in-law says that the mother-in-law is reasonable, and the public says that the public is reasonable.

The people's anger dissipated slightly, but they didn't let Shen Wuhuan go, and began to wait for answers to other questions.

"The third is to say that letting piano children all over the country learn the same teaching materials will turn everyone into the same mold, which is even more ridiculous."

"The scope of application of textbooks in school education is greater than that of provinces and cities, I don't know how many schools are using the same textbooks, and have students become the same? It would be nice if there were! As long as one person becomes the champion, then everyone is the champion! ”

Oh, yes... Aren't all the textbooks in the school the same, so why don't you see the students all become the same?

Let's take a look at it calmly, this is too untenable, right?

"This is completely a lie made up by the compilers of these textbooks, you can look here, I have several textbooks published by several gentlemen here, including Mr. Zhang's "Piano Improvement and Teaching Guide", Mr. Li's "Piano Improvement Level 1 Textbook", Mr. Zhu's "Improvement and Progress: Piano Teaching Method"..."

Most of the books and authors listed above are the same as those of the joint manifesto.

What is this for?

The crowd was immediately attracted to the eyeballs.

"There are about 20 textbooks here, judging from the name, these are piano skill improvement textbooks, not enlightenment textbooks, nor advanced textbooks, but textbooks used by beginners after enlightenment, and the sales scope of these textbooks only covers a very small number of the whole country, and most of them are only sold in certain provinces and cities."

"We can turn to page 31 of Mr. Zhang's book, and then look at page 20 of Mr. Li's book and page 42 of Mr. Zhu's book..."

Shen Wuhuan listed 20 different pages of the textbook in succession, some at the front, some in the middle, and some at the end.

"You will see that although the name of these knowledge points has changed, the content is almost the same, this situation is very common in the same level of textbooks, although there are occasional amazing original knowledge points, but most of them are similar, that is, these textbooks can be regarded as the same textbooks, saying that they plagiarize each other without any problems!"

"I'm here to say this, if you don't have a book at hand, you can go to the bookstore to confirm it, as long as you take Mr. Zhang's books, screen layer by layer, and find the books of several other gentlemen, you will find that the content is really the same, of course, if you find a book with different content, then I congratulate you on finding the treasure! That is the conscience of domestic textbooks. ”

Damn, this is a shocking secret!

You people have copied a lot of similarities from each other, and you still have the face to talk about this?

I have long heard that in the eyes of domestic textbooks, but I didn't expect there to be such a thing?

You said that you people, you can publish dozens of textbooks with the same content, it is really a conscience for the dog to eat!

Shen Wuhuan's words dare to say this, so he is naturally not afraid of others to verify it.

Once people went to verify her words.

Then this face is too hard!

People questioned your teaching materials and wanted to forcibly pull Shen Wuhuan to the same IQ as them to defeat her.

It's a pity that people don't eat that set at all, and directly expose the unspoken rules of the industry? That's an exaggeration, isn't it? But...

But the people love these the most!

In this way, as long as the originally extremely powerful manifesto is disassembled, analyzed one by one, and questioned one by one, there will be no secrets to speak of.

Shen Wuhuan even broke the news of such a big thing, and it was also her confidence in her own textbook, because she was different from the previous mainstream textbooks, she chose the etude as the main way to improve, those people could use this to attack her, and she could also use this as a shield to defend!

The battle continues!

"Fourth, you say that I have no teaching results, sorry, I have always had a student who has never been in the public eye, this time I want to respond to the question, so that my student can come out and show up, she is also using the same teaching materials as everyone."

Shen Wuhuan's students? Oh my God, that's big news!

All of a sudden, the entire network shifted its attention to Shen Wuhuan, the mysterious student!