Xu Bolin is going to be finished today.

Xu Bolin shouted in court: "He lied! It's not my car, it's not me! ”

The judge struck the gavel: "Silence! ”

Xu Bolin still wanted to make a noise, but Guo Xueyi grabbed him and stopped him with his eyes...

The judge asked the lawyer for the second defendant whether he had any objections to the witness testimony.

Guo Xueyi got up and raised an objection: "First of all, there is one thing I want to state first, the witness Wan Hedong's roommate Yao Yongjin was killed by a gambler named Cui He, Cui He has died because of cancer, and there is no evidence to prove that my client instructed Cui He to kill people, so what the witness Wan Hedong said about killing him is not valid at all." ”

After overturning this premise, Guo Xueyi asked the witness: "Witness, why didn't you tell your so-called truth when you were in the police, instead of waiting until the court to retract your confession? ”

Wan Hedong's tone was firm: "No one coerced me, it was because I was too scared and hesitated, and I didn't tell the truth until now." ”

It seems that the witnesses are well prepared.

Guo Xueyi did not continue to question the witnesses, he changed the direction of his defense: "Your Excellency, jurors, have you found a pattern?" Ding Si retracted his confession, and the No. 3 defendant Xu Tanling also retracted his confession, and now the witness Mr. Wan Hedong retracts his confession, as if he had made an appointment, as if someone was manipulating. Are the witnesses' confessions so casual? If you want to turn it over, if you want to change it? If so, what credibility is there for what the witnesses say. ”

After a remark, the testimony of the three witnesses was denied. Even Zhou Tangru, who is a prosecutor, has to admire Guo Xueyi's on-the-spot adaptability.

Guo Xueyi continued: "And it is very unfortunate that all the proofs accusing my client of murder are human witnesses, and there is no physical evidence to prove that my client is directly related to these two cases, and the interests of the doubts belong to the defendant, and I hope that the judge and the jurors can consider this during the trial." ”

Witness Wan Hedong spoke at this time: "Who said I have no evidence? ”

As soon as these words came out, the court was suddenly silent.

After the whole lawsuit, this is the first time Guo Xueyi has been completely stunned.

The situation reversed again, and it became Zhou Tangru who was at ease, and she asked the witness: "What evidence?" ”

Wan Hedong took out a USB flash drive: "This is a recording of my conversation with Xu Bolin, and he personally confessed the crimes he committed." ”

This is temporary evidence, and Guo Xueyi immediately questioned the evidence.

Wan Hedong said: "The recording is real, and there is an authenticity appraisal report. ”

After a brief deliberation between the judge and the jurors, the evidence was allowed to be presented.

Guo Xueyi looked at Xu Bolin at this time, and Xu Bolin looked stunned, obviously not knowing the content of the recording.

Zhou Tangru proposed: "Your Excellency, please allow me to play it in court." ”

After the judge and jurors have determined that the evidence can be used as a finding fact, they are allowed to play it in court.

Then the clerk played the recording.

The first to come out was Xu Bolin's voice: "Tomorrow I will ask Tan Ling to bring a sum of money over, and I will tell her that I will give you a deposit, and you will find a way to shoot a video, which can be used as evidence to identify her later." ”

Only then did Xu Bolin realize that he had been pitted by Wanhedong.

Then came Wan Hedong's voice: "What about the police? I'm going to turn myself in? ”

"No, I'll give your address to Tan Ling then, she thinks you're with her all the way, and she'll definitely tell the police."

"And then I'm going to put all the blame for your murder on her?"

"Well, that's it, when the case is closed, I'll transfer one percent of your shares first. Don't be careless when making a record, so that the police don't see the problem. ”

The recording ends here, less than two minutes before and after.

Xu Bolin was completely confused: "I didn't kill anyone, I didn't hit it, it was Wan Hedong!" It's Wanhedong who drives! ”

Zhou Tangru immediately asked: "Mr. Xu Bolin, haven't you been to the scene of the crime?" Why do you now swear that it was the car driven by the witness? ”

Xu Bolin was dumbfounded.

Guo Xueyi frowned, Wan Hedong's confession and the evidence that suddenly appeared were not within his preset range, and the current situation was very unfavorable to him.

Zhou Tangru took advantage of the victory to pursue: "Your Excellency, we still have one last witness on our side, please allow her to be summoned to court." ”

The judge allowed the witnesses to appear in court.

The last witness was Xu Tanxi.

Rong Li, who was originally lazy and sitting, straightened his back and sat up straight, his eyes followed Xu Tanxi closely.

The two old ladies of the Hong family and the Qi family were wet again when Xu Tanxi appeared.

"Witness, please introduce yourself first."

She stood on the witness stand, her voice calm, faint, and low: "I'm Xu Tanxi." ”

Zhou Tangru added: "The witness Xu Tanxi is the daughter of Hong Lingyi, the victim of the hit-and-run case 25 years ago, and a survivor of the Xu family car accident last year, and she is also an eyewitness to the case. After the introduction, Zhou Tangru asked, "Miss Xu, may I ask what you saw at the scene at that time?" ”

Xu Tanxi glanced at the auditorium.

Rong Li gave her a reassuring look.

She said: "I also heard the testimony of the previous witness, and what he said is true, it was Xu Bolin who hit the person with his car. ”

Xu Bolin immediately yelled: "You lie! "It's clearly Wanhedong!

The judge struck the gavel: "Silence! ”

Uncle Xu gritted his teeth and glared at Xu Tanxi angrily.

Xu Tanxi's eyes were filled with tears: "The car I was riding in with my grandmother and aunt was stuck on the guardrail, my aunt was driving in the main car, and she had fainted at that time, and my grandmother and I were still conscious, because of the leg injury, I couldn't move, and I didn't know where the mobile phone fell, Xu Bolin appeared at this time." ”

She paused for a long time, her eyes were sad, and her voice was slightly choked: "My grandmother and I thought that the savior was coming, so we asked him for help, but he didn't move, I don't know what to say to the driver, Mr. Wan Hedong, after saying that, they changed positions, and after the big truck staggered, they drove into it." My grandmother, Ms. Lu Yanqiu, hugged me for the first time, after the car caught fire, only I was still conscious, I climbed out, but because of serious injuries, I fell to the ground, and then someone came over and stretched out his hand to me, and I saw a watch. ”

Xu Tanxi stopped.

Zhou Tangru took advantage of this time to ask Wan Hedong: "What did the second defendant tell you at that time?" ”

Wan Hedong said: "He asked me to drive into it, said that he would give me the watch if it hit, and said that there would be no surveillance, and the people in the vehicle in front also fainted, but I still didn't dare, so he changed positions with me and drove himself." ”

Guo Xueyi got up: "I have a problem. ”

The judge agreed to his question.

"At the beginning of the case, the prosecutor told everyone that the survivor, Miss Xu Tanxi, only saw a watch, and now she said that she saw the murderer of the crash, isn't this inconsistent?"

Xu Tanxi replied: "After the car accident, I suffered from post-traumatic stress disorder, forgot the events at the scene, only vaguely remembered my watch, and recently did hypnotherapy before remembering the matter." ”

After Xu Tanxi finished speaking, Zhou Tangru immediately provided evidence: "This copy of the diagnosis issued by Miss Xu Tanxi's psychiatrist can prove that Miss Xu does suffer from post-traumatic stress disorder, and there is also a record of Miss Xu's recent treatment for psychological hypnosis." ”

Zhou Tangru presented the two pieces of evidence to the court.

The judge asked the lawyer for defendant No. 2 if he had any objections.

"I still have two questions." Guo Xueyi walked up to Xu Tanxi, "Miss Xu Tanxi, do you know that you are Ms. Hong Lingyi's biological daughter before going to court?" ”

She replied, "Yes." ”

Guo Xueyi asked again: "Do you know the hit-and-run case 25 years ago?" ”

"Yes."

"Then do you also suspect that the murderer is my client?" Guo Xueyi didn't give Xu Tanxi time to answer, he raised his tone and was aggressive, "You think it was my client who bumped into your biological mother, so you want to avenge your mother and collude with Wan Hedong to frame my client." ”

Zhou Tangru retorted: "Your Excellency, the defendant is confusing the public. She faced Guo Xueyi, "Wan Hedong has provided clear evidence that can prove that it was Xu Bolin who crashed and killed someone, where did the collusion come from, the defendant's lawyer, please don't speculate and slander my witnesses for no reason." ”

Guo Xueyi did not continue.

Zhou Tangru's defense is not over yet, and she still has one last trump card: "In addition, I have a piece of evidence here that can prove that the defendant Xu Bolin is the real murderer of the Xu family's car accident." ”

The evidence presented in the court is a video conversation between Huang Jianbo and Xu Tanxi.

After the playback is over.

Zhou Tangru spoke: "The reason why the witness Miss Xu Tanxi forgot the scene of the car accident was not only because of post-traumatic stress disorder, but also because the defendant Xu Bolin bought off Miss Xu's psychiatrist Huang Jianbo at the time. Huang Jianbo hypnotized her memories and made her forget the truth she had seen. The reason why the defendant bribed Huang Jianbo and instructed Ding Si to go to Xiangyun Town to murder Miss Xu was because Miss Xu saw him crash and kill someone with her own eyes, and he wanted to kill him and cover up the crimes he had committed, so he harmed Miss Xu twice and three times. ”

Xu Bolin stood up and retorted: "It's not my car, it's Wanhedong!" ”

He kept repeating this point, but no one believed him.

Two witnesses and two pieces of evidence came out in a row, the matter was a foregone conclusion, Guo Xueyi was silent, and he had no defense, this lawsuit has been lost so far.

Later, when Wen Zhaofang's lawyer made a closing statement, he directly pointed the finger at Xu Bolin, claiming that whether it was destroying the brakes or instructing Ding Si to murder Xu Tanxi, it was not Wen Zhaofang alone, and there were elements instigated by Xu Bolin.

Guo Xueyi's closing argument focused on the hit-and-run case 25 years ago, emphasizing that there was no direct evidence in that case, and the doubtful interests should go to his client.

Finally, the prosecution closed its case.

"Twenty-five years ago, because the defendant Xu Bolin drove illegally and two lives were killed, Ms. Lu Yanqiu, out of selfishness, cleaned up all the evidence, so that the victim could not get revenge. After many years, the defendant Xu Bolin not only did not repent, but also intensified, killing his mother and sister for shares and property, and blaming his own daughter, there are human and material evidence, and two lives, plus Yao Yongjin, who was mistakenly killed because of his watch, two cases, a total of five lives, the defendant Xu Bolin is simply heartbroken. ”

In the auditorium, Qi Zhiyang's eyes were red and his fists were clenched.

First is human feelings, and then legal principles, Zhou Tangru continued to state: "There is a clear chain of evidence in the Xu family car accident case that Xu Bolin committed it, and the hit-and-run case is causally related to this case, although there is no clear evidence to prove that the hit-and-run is the defendant Xu Bolin, but from Ms. Lu Yanqiu's various acts of making up for Miss Xu Tanxi, it can be indirectly pointed out that the murderer is Xu Bolin." ”

At the end of the closing arguments, the judges and people's assessors deliberated, and because the case was complicated, the results of the collegiate deliberations came out three hours later.

The judge pronounced the verdict in court: the defendant Xu Bolin was convicted of intentionally killing Lu Yanqiu and Xu Shulan, and the defendant Xu Bolin was not convicted of intentionally killing Hong Lingyi and Qin Duanyang (driver), and the two victims were related to the defendant, but the defendant Xu Bolin not only showed no repentance, but also tried to frame others, and the circumstances of the crime were extremely heinous and serious, and the defendant Xu Bolin was sentenced to death with a two-year reprieve.

Defendant Wen Zhaofang was convicted of intentionally killing Qiao Liangtian and indirectly killing Lu Yanqiu and Xu Shulan, but Nian Zai showed remorse and was instigated by others, and was sentenced to 16 years imprisonment.

During the criminal investigation, defendant Xu Tanling gave false testimony and was sentenced to three months' detention with a six-month probation.

In addition, Ding Si upheld the original verdict and sentenced him to eight years in prison, and the witness Wan Hedong had obstructed the investigation of the case and would file a separate case for prosecution.

------Off topic------

****

I don't know if there are any bugs, I checked a lot of information and asked for a monthly pass~