Liu Ming's family sued the Cuihu Club today, Luo Ying attended on behalf of Liu Ming's family, Liu Ming's family did not come for some reason, and the two of them were still fighting with Sha Yu in the defendant's seat. Sima Qiqi and Xiao Yan glanced at each other and shook their heads helplessly.

Sima Qiqi patted Xiao Yan's shoulder and whispered: "This case is civil compensation, I won't go, just tell the truth, I estimate that this first lesson is very likely to fail, because it is something that everyone can see, there is no need to fight, you see if you can reduce the amount of compensation to the minimum, if not, we will appeal later!" ”

Xiao Yan nodded, separated from Sima Qiqi, and saw Sima Qiqi sitting calmly in the auditorium, there was always a bad premonition in his heart, Sha Yu was different, seeing Xiao Yan coming over alone, he hurriedly put on a smile and said very politely: "That lawyer Yan, this time I will trouble you again." You don't have to be stressed! ”

Seeing Sha Yu like this, he leaned into Sha Yu's ear and whispered: "What kind of hospitality are you kid, if you weren't smart, where did we come from, you really took off your pants and farted like this." ”

Sha Yu heard that he was still complaining about himself, rolled up his sleeves and prepared to fight with Da, Xiao Yan saw that the two of them were obviously almost thirty years old, and they sighed like two children who had not grown up, and hurriedly stopped the two from fighting, Xiao Yan made a look, and Sha Yu noticed Xiao Yan's eyes, followed Xiao Yan's gaze, and found that Luo Ying was looking at the jokes of the two, and he didn't smile.

Seeing this, the two of them invariably put their hands on each other's shoulders and looked at Luo Ying, Luo Ying felt funny when he saw the two of them, and then the magistrate slowly walked into the courtroom, and the court staff asked everyone to stand up and bow to the judge, and after the magistrate returned the salute, everyone sat back in their places.

The court staff read out the summary of the case number and sat back in their seats, and the magistrate simply flipped through the documents in front of him, looked at Sha Yu and asked: "First and second defendants, do you admit that it was because your Cuihu Club did not understand the safety performance of the props used in the competition, which caused the accidental death of the contestant Liu Ming?" ”

Before Xiao Yan could answer, he hurriedly stood up and said: "Your Excellency, Judge, wronged, this Liu Ming's death has nothing to do with me half a dime, if you want to find someone responsible, just find this fat man!" ”

The magistrate coughed and said, "This is the tribunal, not the court, call me magistrate!" ”

Only then did he realize that his mouth was quick for a while, and he staggered his titles, and quickly nodded and admitted his mistake.

The magistrate looked at it and asked, "What's your name, and why do you say that Liu Ming's death has nothing to do with you?" ”

Hurriedly bowed and replied respectfully: "Your Excellency, my name is Hao Dexian, others call me Your Excellency, Your Excellency Judge, Liu Ming's death was due to the golden carp purchased by the Cuihu Club, which killed him, there is nothing to say, but the Cuihu Club has nothing to do with me, why do you treat me as a defendant, it is really wronged!" ”

The magistrate motioned to sit down, flipped through the documents in front of him, looked up at Luo Ying and asked, "Plaintiff's lawyer, Hao Dexian is the first defendant in the list of lawsuits you submitted, but why does the first defendant say that he was wronged!" ”

Luo Ying slowly stood up at this time and tidied up her clothes, looked at the magistrate and said slowly: "Your Excellency, due to the accidental death of Qian Keyu, the major shareholder of the Cuihu Club, we originally thought that there was nowhere to sue for the death of Mr. Liu Ming this time, but when I checked the equity agreement of the Cuihu Club, I found that the first and second defendants had each purchased the equity of the Cuihu Club with 30 million in cash. As a result, Mr. Liu Ming, a relative of my client, died unexpectedly, so I claimed 30 million yuan from Cuihu Club, and since the major shareholder Qian Keyu had died, the first and second defendants should compensate. ”

The magistrate nodded, looked at Luo Ying and asked, "Are there any relevant documents for the distribution of shares in the Green Lake Club?" ”

Luo Ying nodded slightly, motioned to the assistant to hand over the documents to the court staff, and Luo Ying sat down slowly. The magistrate looked through the relevant documents and found that there was indeed the name of Sha Yu on it.

The magistrate looked up and said: "The first defendant, it is clearly written in the document of this share transfer agreement that the boss Qian Keyu accepted a cash grant of 30 million each from Mr. Hao Dexian and Mr. Sha Yu to transfer the same shares to Mr. Hao Dexian and Mr. Sha Yu, which is obviously one of the shareholders of the Green Lake Club, the plaintiff's lawyer sued the Green Lake Club, the major shareholder died, and the remaining shareholders of the Green Lake Club are only the first and second defendants, the first defendant, why do you say that you are wronged?" ”

Wanting to stop talking, Sha Yu patted his shoulder, signaling not to make senseless resistance, Sha Yu wrote a few words on the sticky note paper and handed it to him, took it and looked at it, it said "Happiness and hardship are shared, this is a good brother." Seeing the content on this sticky note, he muttered and didn't speak, but he had already scolded Sha Yu eighteen times in his heart.

Xiao Yan stood up at this time and said: "Your Excellency, my two clients are indeed shareholders of the Cuihu Club, but the time when they became shareholders was after an accident, and my two clients are both young leaders in the business world, how could they not know that Qian Keyu's Cuihu Club will cause official disputes because of the death of Mr. Liu Ming, so I think that the deceased major shareholder did not tell the truth about the risks behind the equity transfer, and is suspected of deceiving my two parties. The Green Lake Clubhouse Fishing Tournament was conducted by the deceased Mr. Qian Keyu, which was headlined in several newspapers during that time. ”

Xiao Yan took out several copies of the newspaper and held them high, Xiao Yan looked at the magistrate and said: "Your Excellency, according to the newspaper report, the fishing competition was held by Qian Keyu in his personal name, but the venue happened to be in the Cuihu Club, and the organizer of all this was not the Cuihu Club but Qian Keyu, and the plaintiff's lawyer saw that Qian Keyu was dead, so he immediately transferred the target of the lawsuit, which is unfair to my two clients." ”

The magistrate nodded, Xiao Yan sat down slowly, and the magistrate looked at Luo Ying and asked, "Plaintiff's lawyer, what is your explanation for this, and why did the personal complaint eventually become an accusation against a commercial club?" In the end, whether this accident is the responsibility of an individual or a company, have you figured out the plaintiff's lawyer? ”

Faced with the two sharp questions from the magistrate, Luo Ying stood up unhurriedly, bowed slightly and said slowly: "Your Excellency, indeed, my client wanted to sue Qian Keyu before, but he did not do it well in terms of security, and my client planned to accuse Qian Keyu of manslaughter!" ”

When the magistrate heard that Luo Ying actually planned to sue Qian Keyu, who had died, for manslaughter, the magistrate suddenly came to his senses, looked at Luo Ying and asked suspiciously: "Plaintiff's lawyer, why are you planning to sue the deceased Qian Keyu for manslaughter instead of civil compensation?" ”

Luo Ying bowed again and said slowly: "Your Excellency, we found out that the deceased Qian Keyu had purchased golden carp and ordinary carp from the Shuzhong Fishery Research Institute when he was alive, and in an official video provided by the Fisheries Research Institute, the staff of the Fisheries Research Institute once showed Qian Keyu the muscle explosive power of the golden carp, and it was clearly mentioned in the video that if an adult was hit by the golden carp with all his strength, he would also die, that is to say, Qian Keyu before holding the fishing competition, He already knew that there was a particularly dangerous golden carp in the object of this fishing, but he did not explain it before the game, nor did he provide special protective equipment, and he was lucky about the accident, so he planned to sue Qian Keyu for manslaughter, but since Qian Keyu was dead, the manslaughter prosecution was not mentioned again. ”

The referee nodded, asked Luo Ying with his eyes if he still had a statement, Luo Ying nodded, and then said: "Your Excellency, although the fishing competition was initiated by Qian Keyu, but the Green Lake Club provided the venue, and the operator should provide the safety facilities of the venue to the organizer, and add the corresponding safety facilities in the communication with the organizer, but unfortunately the organizer and the venue operator are the same person, but the responsibilities of the two identities are different. In view of the fact that the venue operator is the provider of the venue but not the fish, it only bears a small part of the responsibility in the case that the corresponding safety measures are not in place, and more responsibility is still on the organizer Qian Keyu, but according to many eyewitnesses who were present at the time, there were no lifeguards at the scene, and there were no corresponding first-aid facilities, so when the deceased Liu Ming fell into the water, several witnesses jumped into the water, and it was not until a few minutes later that the staff of the Cuihu Club arrived at the scene and participated in the rescue, that is, If the Cuihu Club knew that Qian Keyu was going to hold a fishing competition and set up corresponding personnel on the spot, then Mr. Liu Ming might still be saved, so the Cuihu Club, as the venue provider, lacked safety awareness, and there was management negligence that indirectly led to the death of Mr. Liu Ming, so I filed a corresponding civil claim against the Cuihu Club! In view of the fact that the Green Lake Club is a shareholder system, all shareholders should be responsible together, and the major shareholder Qian Keyu is dead, so he claims 15 million from the first and second defendants each! ”

After the magistrate finished remembering what Luo Ying said, he nodded slightly to show that it made sense, the magistrate looked at Xiao Yan and asked Xiao Yan if he had any objections to Luo Ying's statement, Xiao Yan slowly stood up at this time and said: "Your Excellency, I object to the plaintiff's lawyer confusing the concept of the Green Lake Club, the plaintiff's lawyer is suing the Green Lake Club that provides a venue for fishing competitions, at this time the Green Lake Club has and only one shareholder is Qian Keyu, and my client was not a shareholder at that time, The plaintiff's lawyer's lawyer's lawsuit was filed before my two clients became shareholders of the Queen's Lake, Your Excellency, legally speaking, at this time, the Lakeside Club was not the Queen's Lake Club. ”