Chapter 377: Adverse Evidence
"Against!"
Sima Qiqi immediately stood up and said when she heard Tu Minghao's accusation against Meng Meimei.
Tu Minghao looked at Sima Qiqi, waiting for Sima Qiqi to say the reason for his objection, and the judge turned his head to look at Sima Qiqi and asked, "Defense lawyer, what are the reasons for your objection?"
Sima Qiqi and Tu Minghao looked at each other for a while, looked at the judge and said with a serious expression: "Your Excellency, everything the prosecutor just said is completely based on this video to speculate on my client's behavior, the prosecutor has no substantive evidence to prove that my client believes that the body of the deceased in the car accident was destroyed, and the prosecutor just said that my client did this to exonerate the car accident defendant Mr. Hao Deyi, and my client and Mr. Hao Deyi do not know each other at all, and there is no interest involved, why did my client do this?"
Sima Qiqi paused and then said: "Your Excellency, the prosecutor's statement just now is a false accusation against my client without evidence, and I hereby lodge a serious protest with the judge."
When the judge heard Sima Qiqi say this, he looked at Tu Minghao, Tu Minghao looked indifferent, the judge coughed and asked Tu Minghao, Tu Minghao spread his hands and said with a smile: "I was really right by the defense lawyer, I really have no substantive evidence to prove what I just said."
The judge heard Tu Minghao say this, if it weren't for his identity in the court, the judge would probably be scolded, the judge glared at Tu Minghao, but Tu Minghao didn't care at all, and when the judge was about to declare Sima Qiqi's objection valid, Tu Minghao suddenly interrupted the judge: "Your Excellency, although we have no substantive evidence to prove what I just said, but we have witnesses who can prove that the defendant's behavior is abnormal, and I have said before that this case is because there is no substantive evidence. The defendant can now entrust a professional lawyer to defend him in court, and if there is substantial evidence, the defendant should be in prison by this time, so Your Excellency Judge, I request that witnesses be called. ”
The judge had already been in a bad mood by Tu Minghao at this time, and the judge barely calmed the anger in his heart and said slowly: "Defense lawyer, whether your objection is valid, I will make a judgment after hearing the testimony of the prosecution witnesses."
When the prosecution witness came to court, everyone was surprised, it was actually the intern forensic doctor who appeared in the previous video, the intern forensic doctor sat timidly on the witness stand, Tu Minghao came to the intern forensic doctor, and said with a smile: "Young man, relax, you are a man who wants to become a forensic doctor, how can you show timidity?"
When the intern forensic doctor heard Tu Minghao say this, he nodded slightly, and Tu Minghao still said with a smile on his face: "May I ask if the person in this picture is you?"
The intern forensic doctor looked up at the big screen in the courtroom, nodded slightly, and replied in a low voice, Tu Minghao knocked on the table in front of the intern forensic doctor, and said in the tone of a teacher educating students: "Witness, please be louder!"
"It's me."
The intern forensic doctor seemed to have the courage to say loudly, Tu Minghao smiled and continued: "Witness, may I ask you, what are you mainly responsible for in the dissection room?"
exercitation
When the forensic doctor heard Tu Minghao say this, he said with a little pride: "I am mainly the assistant of the forensic doctor, responsible for the records, and after the forensic doctor completes the work, I suture the corpse and organize the autopsy room......"
Tu Minghao suddenly interrupted the statement of the intern forensic doctor: "Witness, you said that you are generally responsible for the aftermath, right?"
The intern forensic doctor nodded slightly and said, "Yes, the general forensic doctor is responsible for the dissection, and I am responsible for the aftermath."
Tu Minghao pointed to the big screen and asked, "So, at this time, I want to ask you, have you completed the dissection after you left the dissection room?"
The intern forensic doctor scratched his head and said cautiously: "That day, Forensic Doctor Meng received a call, I saw that she looked nervous, she said that she would not autopsy for the time being, I wanted to put the body away, but Forensic Doctor Meng said that she would clean it up by herself and let me go first."
Tu Minghao heard the intern forensic doctor say this, smiled and said, "Well, then may I ask, did Forensic Doctor Meng take the initiative to deal with the aftermath in his usual work?"
As soon as Tu Minghao finished speaking, before the intern forensic doctor could react, Sima Qiqi stood up and said loudly: "Objection, Your Excellency Judge, the prosecutor used guiding words to induce witnesses to answer."
The judge nodded slightly and looked at Tu Minghao and said slowly: "The objection is valid, and the witness does not have to answer the question just now."
Tu Minghao shrugged his shoulders and said with a smile: "Witness, I'm sorry to delay your time, I'll change the question, isn't it strange that the defendant asked you to leave first and leave her alone in the autopsy room?"
"Against!"
As soon as Sima Qiqi shouted out, Tu Minghao quickly retorted: "Your Excellency, there is no substantial evidence to prove that the defendant is derelict in his duties, which I have already explained at the beginning of the trial, but the forensic department still transferred the case to the prosecution department after passing the internal investigation, which means that in the eyes of the forensic department, the defendant's behavior is very abnormal and completely inconsistent with his usual work behavior, so it is believed that the defendant may have human error, and the testimony of witnesses is very likely to prove whether the defendant's behavior is reasonable."
When the judge heard Tu Minghao say this, he thought for a while and said slowly: "The objection is invalid, and the witness asks you to answer this question."
Tu Minghao looked at the intern forensic doctor at this time, and the intern forensic doctor said cautiously: "This, at that time, I heard that the teacher of Forensic Doctor Meng's child's class called, telling Forensic Doctor Meng that something happened to her son, and that Forensic Doctor Meng usually loves her son, so I was thinking that since the autopsy could not be carried out immediately, Forensic Doctor Meng should also go to her son immediately, I was about to clean up, and Forensic Meng said that she would clean up, let me leave first."
Tu Minghao took the words of the intern forensic doctor and said loudly: "That is, you also think that the defendant's behavior at that time was very strange and can be said to be inexplicable."
The intern forensic doctor was about to say something, but at this time, Tu Minghao ignored the intern forensic doctor, looked at the judge and said: "Your Excellency, the defense lawyer just listed a number of character witnesses to prove the defendant's personality, and the defense lawyer himself said that the defendant is a good mother who loves her son, so when you hear your son."
If something happened to the son at school, why didn't he go to see how his son was doing at the first time, but instead left his assistant, and the defendant himself stayed in the autopsy room for a full twenty minutes, and then the body disappeared out of thin air, which can't help but make people suspicious, and the testimony of the prosecution witnesses just now also proves that the defendant's behavior can be said to be abnormal, in this case, I think the prosecution's accusations against the defendant should also be reasonable, Your Excellency Judge. ”
The judge nodded and said: "Defense lawyer, I have heard the statements of the prosecution witnesses, and combined with the points you raised in this trial, it is indeed suspicious for the defendant to stay alone in the autopsy room and leave the autopsy room after 20 minutes, so I think the prosecutor's accusations against your client are reasonable during the previous statement."
Sima Qiqi slowly stood up and nodded, looked at the judge and said, "Your Excellency, I didn't ask too much about the testimony of the prosecution witnesses, but I would like to ask my client, the defendant in this case, to personally explain why she behaved so strangely."
The judge nodded, and then Meng Meimei came to the witness stand, Meng Meimei seemed a little nervous, Sima Qiqi came to Meng Meimei and nodded slightly, and Meng Meimei barely calmed down.
"Can we begin, defense lawyer?"
The judge saw that Sima Qiqi had no further action, so he asked Sima Qiqi, Tu Minghao was sitting in his prosecutor's position at this time, and it seemed that what Sima Qiqi was going to do next, what Meng Meimei wanted to say had nothing to do with him.
Sima Qiqi nodded slightly, and asked Meng Meimei why there was that strange behavior in the video, Meng Meimei sighed and said with a wry smile: "Everyone thinks that I am a mother who loves her children, I am very grateful, but everyone may forget that my child has no father, not that his father abandoned us, I alone want to be a mother and a father, when I heard my son fighting with others, my first reaction was indeed to go to him quickly, don't let him suffer a little grievance, but I thought about it later." I couldn't be in front of him right away, so that every time he made a mistake, he would have an expectation that his mother would come soon and help him deal with the aftermath, so I didn't go right away. ”
Sima Qiqi smiled and nodded, and asked slowly, "So, defendant, what are you doing in the dissection room for twenty minutes?"
Meng Meimei said with a smile: "I dissected the corpse, but due to time reasons, I did not perform a routine autopsy, but removed the left kidney of the corpse."
"Why?"
Sima Qiqi had just raised a question, but this time Tu Minghao stood up and objected: "Your Excellency, the facts stated by the defendant do not exist at all."
Sima Qiqi retorted in a very serious tone at this time: "Your Excellency, before, my client was accused by the family of the deceased that no autopsy was conducted, and my client had proposed to the relevant departments that she removed the deceased's left kidney and kept it, if my client didn't do anything, she could not say it, why should she publicly tell everyone that she had performed an autopsy, would my client be so stupid as not to know whether what the relevant department said in order to verify whether she said it or not."
Is it true and forensically evaluated? ”
"However, after a judicial examination, the kidney did not belong to the deceased, Your Excellency, and therefore cannot be considered as the truth of what the defendant said."
Tu Minghao looked at the judge with a cold expression, and said slowly word by word.
"Why did my client do so many senseless things, and what good did it do her?"
Sima Qiqi said very angrily, Tu Minghao sneered and looked at the judge and said: "Your Excellency, the defense lawyer asked the most critical point, and it is definitely beneficial for the defendant to do this, because she and Mr. Hao Deyi, the perpetrator of the car accident, have a date."
(End of chapter)