After Qi Nian asked, he looked at the judge and said slowly: "Your Excellency, as the witness said, the defendant did not admit that she and the injured person were boyfriend and girlfriend from the beginning, and after there were new witnesses to prove that she and the injured person were boyfriend and girlfriend, she was forced to admit that why should an ordinary relationship between men and women be concealed, so the prosecution has reason to suspect that the defendant is the murderer who seriously injured Xue Moxuan." ”

Sima Qiqi stood up and retorted: "Your Excellency, many units now do not want employees to fall in love with each other, so as to avoid bad impact, moreover, Xue Moxuan is a world-renowned cardiologist, if people know the relationship between the two men and women, it may bring trouble to the work and life of my client and the injured person, so my client chose to conceal her relationship with the injured person, and she did it completely out of a show of love, which is the most selfless." And I can't just hide the boyfriend and girlfriend relationship to conclude that my client is the murderer. ”

Qi Nian smiled, looked at the judge and said slowly: "Your Excellency, I ask to ask the next witness, Hao, De, Xian." ”

C.K heard Qi Nian ask him to go to court, although he already knew that he would be a witness, but he didn't expect Qi Nian to really ask himself to testify, C.K was full of doubts: "This Qi Nian asked me to testify, I have met Xue Moxuan twice, and the nurse has met twice, and I haven't said more than 10 words." What can I prove? ”

C.K sat down on the witness stand, C.K looked at Sima Qiqi, Sima Qiqi didn't pay attention to him at all, but talked to Xiao Yan about something, then Qi Nian suddenly asked: "Mr. Hao, I want to ask you, did you tell the police that the defendant was the girlfriend of the injured Xue Moxuan?" ”

C.K hurriedly explained: "Eh, I just told the police that Xue Moxuan has a girlfriend who is a nurse in their hospital. ”

Qi Nian nodded and continued to ask, "How do you know that the defendant is Xue Moxuan's girlfriend?" ”

C.K replied: "Because I met Xue Moxuan and the defendant in the billiards club, and Xue Moxuan directly called the defendant his girlfriend at that time, so I told the police that Xue Moxuan had a girlfriend, and my original intention was to let the police ask the girlfriend ......."

Qi Nian interrupted: "Your Excellency, I have no problem. ”

After saying that, he sat down.

Sima Qiqi stood up and asked, "Witness, is it the first time you have seen the defendant in the billiards club?" ”

C.K was stunned for a moment and replied slowly: "No, I went to Xue Moxuan to talk about things the day before the billiards club, and I met the defendant." ”

Sima Qiqi nodded and then asked, "What was the situation at that time?" ”

C.K replied: "At that time, the defendant saw that I politely asked me what I was uncomfortable with, and when I replied that I was here to find Xue Moxuan, the defendant suddenly changed his expression and answered me in a cold tone. ”

Sima Qiqi then asked, "What do you think of the relationship between the defendant and Dr. Xue Moxuan?" ”

C.K thought for a moment and replied: "I felt that the defendant had a very bad relationship with Xue Moxuan, and it felt like Xue Moxuan owed money. ”

Sima Qiqi continued to ask expressionlessly, "Then what about the two of you saw the next day?" ”

C.K thought for a while and replied: "The two of them are like men and women in love, so I think it should be the defendant who quarreled with Xue Moxuan at that time." That's why I ......" Before he finished speaking, Sima Qiqi interrupted: "Your Excellency, it can be seen from the performance of the two of them in their ordinary work that my client tries to keep a certain distance from the injured in the hospital, so that the injured person's work will not be interfered with by unnecessary things, and I have no problem." ”

After saying that, he also sat down.

C.K cursed in his heart: "I'll go, one will do the same, and the two will do the same, treat me like a monkey, and I'll settle accounts with you when the case is over." ”

After C.K left the witness stand, Sima Qiqi stood up and said, "Your Excellency, the defense requests to continue questioning the defendant Ms. Xia He. ”

Xia He's mood had calmed down at this time and sat down on the witness stand, Sima Qiqi asked, "Miss Xia, I want to ask how is your relationship with Xue Moxuan?" ”

Xia He thought for a while and replied: "The relationship between the two of us is very good, although Xue Moxuan is older than me, but he is very tolerant of me and tolerates my little temper, he is like a warm-hearted uncle, but occasionally he quarrels because of his small temper, but every time he apologizes and admits his mistakes." ”

Saying that, Xia He's face was overflowing with a happy smile.

Sima Qiqi asked, "Then why didn't you tell everyone that you and Xue Moxuan are a couple?" ”

Xia He lowered his head and replied in a low voice: "Because his reputation is too great, I am afraid that my relationship with him will attract some unnecessary harassment." So I offered not to make our relationship public, because the two of us are not in the same department in the hospital, so we don't have to care, but we don't post photos when we go out to play. So everyone didn't know that when I heard Xue Moxuan fall downstairs and enter the ICU, I was completely confused, so when the police asked me, I forgot to tell them. ”

Sima Qiqi nodded and continued to ask, "Did the police explicitly ask you about Xue Moxuan's girlfriend when they questioned you?" ”

Xia He thought for a while and shook his head, Sima Qiqi asked, "Defendant, please answer clearly." ”

Xia He replied, "The police didn't ask me, because I and Xue Moxuan are not in the same department. ”

Sima Qiqi smiled and looked at the judge and said, "Your Excellency, it can be seen from what the defendant said that it was not that the defendant deliberately concealed it, but because of the negligence of the police, so the prosecution's assertion that my client concealed the relationship between their boyfriend and girlfriend by pushing Xue Moxuan downstairs is untenable." ”

After speaking, he looked at Qi Nian, and Qi Nian smiled fiercely. All of this was seen by C.K., who always felt that a storm was coming.

Qi Nian knocked on the table and smiled, but his eyes stared at Sima Qiqi coldly. Sima Qiqi sat down, and the judge asked, "Do you still have any questions about the prosecution?" ”

Qi Nian stood up with a smile and said slowly: "It is true that the defense thought that the defendant loved the injured deeply, so they did not disclose their relationship to others, but as the saying goes, the deeper the love, the deeper the hatred." Defendant, I'm curious, the injured person is in a different department than you, and he is a well-known doctor, how did you two get together? ”

As soon as he finished speaking, Sima Qiqi stood up and said, "Objection, Your Excellency, how my client and the injured know each other has nothing to do with this case. ”

Qi Nian replied slowly: "Your Excellency, if the two are together with the same philosophy, then when one of them violates the concept, the other party is likely to hate out of love. We want to prove that this is possible. ”

The judge thought for a while, nodded and said slowly: "The objection is invalid, and the witness asks you to answer the prosecution's questions." ”

Sima Qiqi sat down helplessly, staring at Qi Nian angrily with his hands.

Qi Nian said with a smile: "Defendant, please answer my question just now." ”

Xia He said slowly: "We met at the annual meeting of the hospital, and we found out that everyone had the same opinion on not applying for a patent, and then I took the initiative to show goodwill, but I didn't expect him to like me, and we were together." ”

Qi Nian smiled and said: "Thank you, Your Excellency Judge, that's what the defendant just said, she and the injured person have the same opinion on whether to apply for a patent, but this is the previous opinion, when the defendant knew that the injured person contacted the patent office to apply for a patent for his medical technology, the two were far from each other in this concept, and the defendant felt that the injured person was like violating their oath of love, so he quarreled with the injured person, and even moved excitedly, who knew that Xue Moxuan was pushed downstairs, so the defendant did not show his relationship with the injured person's boyfriend and girlfriend." ”

Sima Qiqi stood up and retorted loudly: "Your Excellency, I oppose the prosecution's presumption of guilt on my client, and there is currently no evidence to prove that my client quarreled with the injured person over the patent application. ”

The judge thought for a while, looked at Qi Nian with a serious expression, and said slowly: "Prosecutor, please pay attention to your wording, in the absence of substantive evidence, the suspect is still a suspect, not a criminal, and there can be no presumption of guilt on this." ”

Qi Nian smiled and nodded, and replied politely: "Yes, Your Excellency, I admit that the words I just used are inappropriate, and I am here to express my apologies to the defendant." I'm sorry. ”

After speaking, he bowed deeply to Xia He and stood up, Qi Nian's expression became extremely cold, and he said coldly: "Your Excellency, the prosecution requires evidence No. 4 and 5 to be presented in court. ”

The judge nodded in approval, and Qi Nian played the video on the big screen of the courtroom, and everyone's attention was on the big screen, which was actually two prosecutions together. It can be seen that it is the monitoring of the hospital where Xue Moxuan is located.

Just when everyone was puzzled, Qi Nian said: "Your Excellency, the video is the surveillance of the entrance and exit of the back stairs on the fifth and third floors of the hospital where the accident occurred, and it can be seen from the video that the injured and the defendant entered the back stairs on the fifth and third floors almost at the same time, so the prosecution has reason to believe that the two met on the back stairs, but there was a quarrel during the conversation, so they started to move, and the defendant pushed the injured person downstairs." ”

At this time, Sima Qiqi stood up and retorted: "Your Excellency, in the video, I can only see that my client and the injured person entered the back staircase almost at the same time, but no one saw whether the two met and quarreled. There is no evidence to prove that the two have met, the injured person was pushed downstairs by my client, the evidence cited by the prosecution is only indirect evidence, there is no direct evidence that my client is the murderer, and the interests are attributed to the defendant based on doubtful points, and I request that this trial be terminated immediately and my client will be acquitted. ”

Qi Nian interrupted: "Lawyer Sima, I still have one piece of evidence that hasn't been played yet. After reading it first, although there is no direct evidence, the testimony of the injured person should be able to convict him! ”

After speaking, his smile was put away, and he looked at Sima Qiqi with cold eyes.

Sima Qiqi glanced at the judge slowly, and the judge said in a calm tone: "Defense lawyer, let's read another piece of evidence from the prosecution first!" ”

Sima Qiqi took a deep breath and had no choice but to sit back in his place. The second video was played on the big screen, and when C.K saw that the video was Dr. Kang and Xue Moxuan, as well as a few police officers, C.K immediately thought of what kind of video this was, and frowned.