Wen Ran heard Sima Qiqi's question, thought for a while and said, "There can be memory sharing between a fused personality and a split personality. ”

"Why?"

Sima Qiqi looked at Wen Ran with a puzzled expression, and Fang Aoqin also looked at Wen Ran at this time, waiting for Wen Ran to give an answer.

Wen Ran asked for paper and pen again, and said slowly: "If it is said that the split personality and the main personality are like rivers corresponding to the sea, and the memories of each split personality slowly converge into the sea, then the split personality and the fusion personality are like this. Split personality is like a river entering the fusion personality, and the fusion personality will form a split personality under the stimulation of the outside world, just like the river water enters the lake, and the lake flows to the river. ”

Wen Ran drew a circular pattern on the paper, several divergences into a circular lake, and then linked to the previous tributaries.

Sima Qiqi smiled slightly and then asked, "Then if my client also has a fusion personality, will she have the same situation as in the last trial?" ”

As soon as Sima Qiqi's words fell, Fang Aoqin hurriedly stood up and said: "Objection, Your Excellency, the defense lawyer deliberately misled the court and the jurors, in the absence of any evidence, the defense lawyer's question just now was to mislead the jurors, and even guide the witnesses to think about whether the defendant has the possibility of merging personalities, in an attempt to make the case difficult to explain in the trial process." ”

Qi Nian heard Fang Aoqin's objection, indeed, Qi Nian didn't see the clue to the question asked by Sima Qiqi before, this Sima Qiqi directly linked the fusion personality with the defendant's behavior, and the information did not show that there was any evidence to prove this matter, which did not add difficulty to the trial of the case. What's more, the jurors are all ordinary people, and after they hear these words, it is impossible for them not to think, and it is very likely that the outcome of the case will be different because of Sima Qiqi's words.

Qi Nian looked at Sima Qiqi with a serious face and asked, "Defense lawyer, is there any evidence to prove the point you just stated?" ”

Sima Qiqi shrugged his shoulders and said slowly: "Unfortunately, Your Excellency, the opinion just now is just my personal speculation, and I don't have any evidence to prove that my client has a fusion personality. ”

"Defense lawyer, you just asked a witness about a point that you have no evidence to prove, you should know that the witness's answer is very likely to affect the court's trial of the case, and you don't have any evidence to prove it, defense lawyer, you don't intend to exonerate your client on the basis of incomplete consideration in the legal provisions."

Qi Nian's expression was not very good-looking, and Sima Qiqi saw that Qi Nian was about to announce the result of Fang Aoqin's objection just now, and hurriedly said: "Your Excellency, please wait, I really don't have any evidence to prove that my client has a fusion of personalities. However, Your Excellency, I would like to present the relevant information of the three murders in the court, and I would like to ask your Excellency to approve it. ”

Qi Nian heard Sima Qiqi say this, and also gave Sima Qiqi a chance to explain.

Sima Qiqi bowed politely at Qi Nian.

Sima Qiqi picked up the case materials and began to state them slowly, and when Sima Qiqi finished stating the content of the three murders, Qi Nian looked at Sima Qiqi with a puzzled face and asked: "Defense lawyer, how the three deceased were killed, we all have information in our hands, and we all know it, so you don't need to state it again in court." ”

Sima Qiqi nodded and continued: "Your Excellency, our attention at that time was all about how the three deceased were brutally killed, the prosecutor thought that my client's methods were cruel, and I was also looking for various reasons to justify my client's behavior, but later I re-examined the relevant information, and I found that our starting point at that time was wrong. Please see that in the first murder case, the forensic autopsy report showed that the deceased Nie Qing had multiple fractures all over his body, and the fracture time span was as long as 30 minutes. ”

Qi Nian looked at Sima Qiqi with a puzzled expression and said, "At that time, the police mentioned in the information that they thought that the defendant was an extremely cruel and perverted prisoner, is there anything wrong with this?" ”

"Yes, Your Excellency. At that time, we all paid attention to what the deceased was killed and what he suffered before death, but we did not think about what these wounds represented, we subjectively thought about the inhumane torture of the deceased by my client, the defendant in this case, but we did not notice where the deceased's earliest wounds were. ”

Qi Nian and Fang Aoqin heard Sima Qiqi say this, they both flipped through the information of the first murder case in front of them, both of them raised their eyebrows slightly, and Sima Qiqi said slowly: "Your Excellency, jurors, the time span of the deceased's fractured scar before his death is as long as thirty minutes, and the reason given by the police is that my client is enjoying the pleasure of torture and killing, but please take a closer look at the scars of the first deceased Nie Qing, according to the autopsy report given by the forensic doctor, the earliest scars appeared on the legs, which can be considered as my client to prevent the deceased from escaping, Most of the earlier injuries were concentrated in the palms and non-fatal areas, and one detail that was not noticed in these locations was that no matter how badly injured these positions were, they would not affect the first deceased's ability to speak. ”

Qi Nian and Fang Aoqin heard Sima Qiqi's words, and the two of them looked up at Sima Qiqi in unison. If it is really according to what Sima Qiqi said, then I am afraid that everything I did before would have gone in the wrong direction. Both of them are senior legal workers, and Sima Qiqi's words naturally had a greater impact on them than others in the court.

The two looked at Sima Qiqi blankly, and Sima Qiqi saw Qi Nian and Fang Aoqin's reactions and knew that in this trial, the balance of victory was in her favor. The others in the court still looked at Sima Qiqi blankly, waiting for Sima Qiqi to explain.

Sima Qiqi said slowly: "Your Excellency, what I said in the previous information was that my client was a criminal who was extremely cruel and did not respect life, but after I re-examined the information, I thought that my client was actually torturing the first deceased and wanted to get some information from the deceased, as for what the information was, we don't know. This is the first deceased, the second deceased everyone knows that he died of internal bleeding due to iron sticks, but we ignore a detail, that is, when the police arrived at the scene, the second deceased was still alive, and the real cause of death was that the medical staff accidentally touched the iron skewer in the middle of treatment, causing the iron skewer to displace, so that the deceased died of internal bleeding. ”

Qi Nian and Fang Aoqin heard Sima Qiqi say this, they both re-read the information, both of them looked solemn, Sima Qiqi looked at Wen Ran at this time and asked slowly: "Witness, then please tell me, do you think any of the three personalities of my client can do the kind of method I just mentioned in the two murders?" ”

Wen Ran thought about Sima Qiqi's question when he heard it, and said slowly: "Among the three personalities of the defendant, there should be no personality that can do the tricks in these two murders. The first murder seems to be brutal, but the perpetrator should be extremely calm, so calm that even if he hears the screams, he will not waver in the slightest. If it is an act of torture, it is impossible to span 30 minutes. Although one of the defendants is very rational, in the course of the investigation, I found that the rational personality of the defendant does not have violent tendencies, and is so rational that even if he quarrels with others, he only finds reasons to reason. ”

Sima Qiqi nodded and then asked, "What about the second murder?" ”

"The second murder is even more unlikely, I have just heard the statement about the second murder, that is, the defendant inserted an iron stick into the human body very precisely, but avoided the main organs and even the aorta, which is not a kind of luck, which should require strong medical knowledge to do. Of the three personalities of the defendants, the rational personality had the highest IQ, but it did not reach the medical level to be able to complete the second murder. ”

"So will there be a fourth personality who can reach the relevant level of medicine?"

Sima Qiqi looked at Wen Ran and asked.

Fang Aoqin originally wanted to object, but now Fang Aoqin also wanted to know, so he held back.

Wen Ran heard Sima Qiqi's question, thought for a while and said, "There is such a situation. In many cases, the patient is not able to swim, but a split personality is good at water and can dive. For example, some patients are disabled because of injuries, but the split personality is a normal person. And sometimes even the gender of the split personality changes. Therefore, if you ask me if I will split into a high-IQ personality, or merge the personality into a new personality with a high IQ, I personally think it is possible. ”

Sima Qiqi smiled slightly and looked at the judge and said, "Your Excellency, according to the witnesses, it is impossible for my client to complete these cases with three personalities now, so there is only one possibility, my client may have a fourth personality, but it has not yet been discovered." Perhaps this fourth personality is my client's fusion personality, because my client has been concerned about someone since the age of ten, maybe those personalities that split and protect the body are useless, and gradually merge into a new personality, but due to stimulation, the fusion personality is split again, when the crime is committed, my client's emotions are stabilized, and in the process of slowly transforming the split personality into a fusion personality, their memories are shared with each other, so there is the content of the evidence provided by the prosecutor during the previous trial. Your Excellency, I have concluded my statement. ”

Fang Aoqin clapped his hands, amazed at Sima Qiqi's performance in the trial this time, and marveled at Sima Qiqi being able to find such a breakthrough.

Fang Aoqin said that there was no question to ask Wen Ran, and Wen Ran left the witness stand.

Qi Nian looked at Fang Aoqin, waiting for Fang Aoqin to answer the call, Fang Aoqin stood up and looked at Qi Nian and said to the eight jurors.

"Ladies and gentlemen, the defense lawyer has just raised the possibility that it is the memory sharing of the fusion personality and the split personality that led to the misleading evidence that appeared on our side in the last trial. I don't know if it's true because the defense lawyer didn't produce direct evidence. However, the defense lawyer mentioned that the three murders were not a kind of cruelty, so here I would like to ask the defense lawyer a question, what is the defendant's motive for doing so? The defense lawyer just mentioned a speculation, torture, so what is the defendant tortured? ”