Sima Qiqi looked at the judge and said slowly: "Your Excellency, from the unreasonable behavior of the plaintiff, we think that there are doubts in this case, and even the plaintiff did not tell the truth. We believe that the plaintiff has deliberately framed our client, so based on the principle that the interests of the doubtful points of the case belong to the defendant, we request that our client be acquitted. ”

The voices of the spectators in the courtroom began to be noisy again, and the judge stopped repeatedly, and the judge looked at the documents, looked at Ding Shan and asked, "Does the prosecution still need to make a statement?" ”

Ding Shan stood up and nodded and said, "Your Excellency, the prosecution has something to add." The plaintiff and the defendant did not know each other, and the types of work of the two were very different. The plaintiff is an accountant and the defendant is a new energy researcher, so there will be no competing interests to frame the defendant. ”

At this time, I saw Ding Shan pick up a document and put a picture on the big screen of the court, and everyone looked up at the big screen and found that it was a simplified image of the interior of a bus.

Before he could figure out the purpose of Ding Shan's actions, he only heard Ding Shan say: "Your Excellency, according to a sociologist's research, on the bus, the space where wheelchairs can be placed is the most comfortable standing position. 98.4% of the respondents said they would like to stand in this position if they do not have a seat on the bus. ”

The judge nodded and continued to record, and Ding Shan continued: "So, Your Excellency, the defense lawyer believes that the plaintiff's unreasonable behavior is actually very reasonable. Because there were no seats on the bus at the time, it was natural for the plaintiff to go to that position. As for the defense's argument, it is understandable that the plaintiff did not resist when he was violated by the defendant. According to the survey report of foreign psychologists, when people encounter very frightening events, their bodies will freeze involuntarily and cannot make various reactions, just like when a person is facing the danger of life, he will stand motionless and will not flee immediately. In this case, the plaintiff was a weak lady who was molested on the bus, which was not only an insult to the plaintiff, but also a physical and mental injury. So the plaintiff did not react in a timely manner at that time. ”

Ding Shan looked at Sima Qiqi and suddenly said, "Defense lawyer, not everyone dares to resist like you. Especially for weak ladies, many ladies choose to forbear and inaction in the face of this kind of thing. ”

The judge nodded, and Ding Shan saw that he had achieved his goal, and continued: "Your Excellency, although there are doubts in this case, it is not enough to acquit the defendant on the basis of the statement that the benefits of the doubts are attributed to the defendant. ”

The judge nodded slowly, looked up and said, "Indeed, although the defense pointed out that there are doubts in this case, it is not enough for the defendant to be acquitted. Since the plaintiff and the defendant have no interest relationship, the plaintiff will not use his reputation to frame the defendant for indecency. Accordingly, the defence's claim was dismissed. ”

Sima Qiqi stood up and said, "Your Excellency, the reason given by the prosecutor is not completely credible, if it is the rapid return of blood to protect the heart, but no

It may last for a few minutes. We require the plaintiff to undergo a psychological inquiry to determine the plaintiff's psychological state, which is a fair reflection of our client. ”

The judge did not speak immediately, was silent for a while, and said slowly: "Indeed, in this case, without substantive evidence, a judgment cannot be made immediately, and if the interests of doubt are attributed to the defendant, it is blasphemy against the law and irresponsibility to the plaintiff." If the defendant is convicted on this charge, it will also be an injustice to the defendant. This case requires careful investigation, and in order to prevent any unreasonableness in this case, the plaintiff is requested to cooperate with the prosecution and conduct a mental health assessment. Everything is waiting for the plaintiff's mental health assessment report to come out and try again. The case was adjourned to be heard here the afternoon after tomorrow. The defendant was allowed to file bail and release on bail pending trial. Withdraw from court. ”

left his place and came to the door of the court to wait for Sima Qiqi and Xiao Yan.

After a while, the two of them walked out, and when they saw them, they immediately greeted them, and asked with a smile, "Lawyer Sima, you have really worked hard." Ah, this case has been postponed for retrial, how many more sessions do you think the case will be tried? ”

The three of them came to the car, got into the car and left the court, Sima Qiqi said slowly in the car: "There are too many doubts in this case, but I didn't expect this judge to do this, if there is no new evidence on the prosecution's side, I estimate that this case should be tried in three more sessions at most." ”

On the afternoon of the third day, the court held a retrial of the Zuo Jing bus molestation case.

The judge lowered his head and asked slowly, "Prosecutor, has the plaintiff's psychological assessment yielded results?" ”

I saw Ding Shan stand up and nodded, and replied: "Your Excellency, the results of the plaintiff's psychological assessment have come out, and the results have been handed over to the defense lawyer." ”

The judge looked up at Sima Qiqi, and then asked, "Has the defense lawyer already reviewed the results, and there is no problem with the timing of this trial?" ”

Sima Qiqi also stood up and nodded, and said, "Your Excellency, the prosecutor gave the result to the defense as soon as possible, and the defense has enough time to review the evidence and has no objections." ”

The judge nodded and looked at Ding Shan and said, "Prosecutor, you can start your statement." ”

Ding Shan stood up and nodded to the judge, and said, "Your Excellency, the prosecution would like to invite Dr. Ye Qian, the doctor of this psychological evaluation, to testify in court. ”

The judge flipped through the file and nodded.

At this time, a woman came to the auditorium and sat down, believing that this was Dr. Ye Qian, and then I only heard Ding Shan say: "Dr. Ye, may I ask your plaintiff Ms. Yang Ziyi whether she is mentally healthy, and whether there is an unhealthy psychological state of being abused." ”

Dr. Ye nodded and said slowly, "According to the psychological evaluation of Ms. Yang Ziyi, the plaintiff, Ms. Yang Ziyi, is psychologically healthy. There is no such thing as an unhealthy state of mind that you think it is. ”

Ding Shan nodded, and it was obvious that the corners of Ding Shan's mouth were slightly raised in the auditorium, and then Ding Shan asked: "Then Dr. Ye, I still have a question I want to ask you, why at the time of the crime, the plaintiff was violated but did not resist, and did not even move his position."

？ ”

Dr. Ye thought for a while and replied: "If the defendant is a more introverted girl, generally speaking, introverts tend to lack assertiveness and cannot make a decisive decision immediately in the face of many things, as in this case, when the plaintiff was violated, because this kind of thing is difficult to talk about, introverts often choose to forbear, so the plaintiff did not shout for help from his lover at that time, this kind of person is psychologically fragile, especially there are many strangers on the bus, and some unreasonable actions of the plaintiff will attract the attention of others." This is a very shy thing for an introvert, so the plaintiff did not make any moves. ”

Ding Shan seemed to get a satisfactory answer, and looked at Sima Qiqi before sitting down.

Sima Qiqi didn't even look at Ding Shan, and then the judge took note and said slowly: "Defense lawyer, you can start." ”

Sima Qiqi stood up and asked, "Dr. Ye Qian, you are a psychiatrist, so I would like to ask you on what basis you determined that the plaintiff is mentally healthy?" ”

Dr. Ye said slowly: "Ah, it is an internationally accepted set of psychological assessment questionnaires, and the assessee needs to answer without thinking, and there are some conversations between me and the assessee after completing the questionnaire to comprehensively assess the psychology of the assessee. ”

Sima Qiqi nodded and said contemptuously: "Oh, internationally recognized, so is this set of questionnaires highly accurate?" ”

Ding Shan was already impatient at this time, and hurriedly stood up and objected: "Your Excellency, the defense lawyer questions the professionalism of the witnesses. ”

The judge looked at Sima Qiqi, and Sima Qiqi said slowly: "Your Excellency, I don't question the level of the witnesses, but only the questionnaire used for evaluation. ”

The judge frowned, looked down at the document, raised his head and asked puzzledly: "This set of questionnaires is internationally recognized as a highly accurate questionnaire, what is there to question?" ”

Sima Qiqi smiled and said: "Your Excellency, this set of questionnaires has all the questions and the corresponding psychological states of each answer on the Internet, if someone deliberately memorizes the self-interested answers, it is not impossible. ”

Before Sima Qiqi finished speaking, the court auditorium began to discuss again, at this time the judge and Ding Shan did not speak for a while, and suddenly Dr. Ye said: "I will answer this question!" ”

Sima Qiqi looked at Ye Qian and made a gesture of please, only to see Dr. Ye answer slowly: "This set of questionnaires will delete the questions every year and add new questions, even if someone memorizes them, but I ask for a question to be answered for no more than five seconds, so even if I memorize it, it is impossible to answer so quickly, and the questionnaire is just an auxiliary tool, this is just to help me determine the direction in the follow-up conversation, if the follow-up conversation is different from the questionnaire, then I also know that the assessee did not answer honestly, So I can assure you that this assessment report is accurate. ”

Sima Qiqi smiled and said, "Yes, I'm really sorry, Dr. Ye." Then I would like to ask you how you determine that the plaintiff is an introvert. ”

Ye Qian was speechless for a while, thought for a while and said, "She, she acted like an introvert at that time

。 ”

Sima Qiqi tilted his head to look at Ye Qian and asked with a smile, "Ah, what is it like?" ”

Ye Qian said embarrassedly: "At that time, it was just to investigate whether the plaintiff was mentally healthy, well, I didn't pay attention to the plaintiff's personality, but since she chatted with me less at that time, she was not very talkative, so I think she is an introvert." ”

Sima Qiqi nodded, looked at the judge and said, "Your Excellency, I have no problem. ”

The judge looked at Ding Shan, who quickly stood up and said, "Your Excellency, the prosecution has no question about the witnesses. ”

(End of chapter)