After Sima Qiqi finished his statement, the magistrate nodded, thinking that what Sima Qiqi said was reasonable, Sima Qiqi saw that the magistrate's attitude was tilted towards him, Sima Qiqi continued: "In the case of not being sure whether it was Qian Keyu who jumped into the lake or not, I think my statement should be more pointed, rather than misleading the court into thinking that it was Qian Keyu who jumped into the lake." ”

The magistrate nodded slightly, and then Xiao Yan took Sima Qiqi's words and looked at the magistrate and said: "Your Excellency, it is necessary to find out the cause of Qian Keyu's death, if Qian Keyu did not commit suicide but was killed, then what is the reason for the killing, why was Qian Keyu killed not long after Liu Ming died, we believe that there is a connection between the deaths of these two people, then the plaintiff's lawyer's reason for compensation is not valid." ”

Before Xiao Yan's words fell, Luo Ying stood up and retorted: "Your Excellency, what the defense lawyer and witnesses said has no substantive evidence, maybe Qian Keyu saw the rising sun, thought of his major economic problems, and thought that the Cuihu Club was surrounded by various failure situations because of Mr. Liu Ming's death, and he couldn't think of jumping into the lake to commit suicide for a while, but Qian Keyu's face was not visible at the location of the witness at that time, as for the cause of death, The defense lawyer should not have any substantive evidence to prove that Qian Keyu's death was related to Mr. Liu Ming's death, Your Excellency the Magistrate, the defense lawyer's attempt to create the false impression that Qian Keyu and Mr. Liu Ming were killed, so as to avoid huge compensation for their clients, this seems to me to be a shameful act of playing with the law, and I hope to immediately terminate this meaningless trial. ”

After listening to Luo Ying's words, the magistrate looked at Xiao Yan and asked, "Defense lawyer, is everything you just said your conjecture or is there tangible evidence to prove?" ”

Xiao Yan smiled slightly at this time and said, "Your Excellency, we have tangible evidence to prove what we just stated. ”

Luo Ying also frowned when she heard Xiao Yan say this, but Luo Ying didn't believe that Xiao Yan could come up with any evidence from the bottom of her heart, even if there really was, Luo Ying was confident that the credibility of all the evidence would be broken. Luo Ying seemed to have seen the goddess of victory beckoning to her.

Xiao Yan said slowly: "Your Excellency, I request that Evidence No. 10 be presented in court, that is, Mr. Qian Keyu's autopsy report. ”

The magistrate nodded, Xiao Yan flipped through the autopsy report and looked at Sima Qiqi and asked, "Witness, may I ask you, what happened to the person suspected of Qian Keyu after jumping into the lake?" ”

Sima Qiqi said slowly: "I saw that the person suspected of Qian Keyu jumped into the lake, but it did not surface, so I asked my colleague to call someone to help, and I called the ambulance and the police. As a result, the man was not breathing when he was rescued. ”

Xiao Yan nodded and then asked, "The man who fell into the water, did he call for help or struggle?" ”

Sima Qiqi thought for a while and said: "I didn't hear the person who fell into the water shouting for help, but I heard the sound of splashing on the surface of the water, because the sun was too dazzling at that time, so I didn't see the situation on the lake clearly." ”

Xiao Yan nodded and continued, "Your Excellency, Magistrate."

The autopsy report on Qian Keyu in my hand pointed out that the deceased drowned in the artificial lake of the Cuihu Club, but the autopsy report mentioned that the deceased Qian Keyu showed no signs of struggle before his death, and the deceased's ten fingers were unusually clean. ”

The magistrate was taking notes, and when he heard Xiao Yan's statement, he looked up at Xiao Yan in confusion and asked, "Defense lawyer, what is the reason for this, please explain, is there anything wrong with the deceased's ten fingers being clean?" ”

Xiao Yan nodded, closed the autopsy report, looked at the magistrate and said slowly: "Your Excellency, according to the confession of a senior forensic doctor, when a person wants to commit suicide, the person who hangs himself will be oppressed because of the trachea, etc., and the body will resist involuntarily, and in the same way, people who commit suicide by jumping into the water are also, although they are bent on ending their lives, but the body will react naturally, such as waving their hands in the water, so a person who really commits suicide by diving will have more or less a little dirt on his nails, However, there is not a trace of lake dirt in the fingernails of the deceased Qian Keyu, which is also where our side has doubts. ”

The magistrate hurriedly recorded the key points that Xiao Yan said, Xiao Yan looked at the magistrate at this time, and then looked at Luo Ying confidently and said: "Your Excellency, the witness just mentioned that the person suspected of Qian Keyu jumped into the lake, and there was a splashing sound on the lake, indicating that the diver still struggled, but Qian Keyu's ten fingers were unusually clean, which is not in line with common sense, so we think that there is a problem with the cause of Qian Keyu's death." ”

As soon as Xiao Yan finished speaking, Luo Ying stood up and said, "Witness, I want to ask you, when did you first go to the Green Lake Club?" ”

Xiao Yan hurriedly stood up and objected: "Your Excellency, the plaintiff's lawyer's question has nothing to do with this case!" ”

Luo Ying looked at the magistrate and said with a smile: "Your Excellency, the question I asked is inevitably related to the splashing of water on the lake, please allow me to continue to ask." ”

The magistrate nodded and said, "The objection is invalid, and the witness asks you to answer." ”

"Around the 8th of last month."

Sima Qiqi replied.

"What are you going to do?"

Luo Ying asked, and Sima Qiqi replied slowly: "Because Mr. Qian Keyu, the owner of the Green Lake Club, is going to hold a fishing competition and hired me as a legal consultant. ”

The corners of Luo Ying's mouth rose slightly, and then asked, "Witness, what did you see on the day of the fishing competition?" ”

Xiao Yan stood up again at this time to object, Luo Ying explained the reason, and the magistrate urged Luo Ying to complete the interrogation as soon as possible and not to waste the court's time.

Sima Qiqi stated that when he saw the scene of the carp jumping out of the water, Luo Ying seemed to have achieved his goal, Luo Ying suddenly said seriously: "So witness, your confession is not credible, you said that you saw a person jumping into the lake at that time but did not hear the sound of help, only the sound of splashing water, so why do you say that Qian Keyu was struggling at that time, Your Excellency the magistrate, what the defense lawyer said just now was not bent on death, there are many people who have the urge to commit suicide, but at that moment someone retreated, Some people only retreat and struggle when they are dying, but those who really want to die are burned even by fire

It may be motionless, so the doubts raised by the witness's defense lawyer are not valid, and the sound of the water splashing is likely to be a precautionary action for the carp to see the sunlight and prepare to jump. ”

The magistrate recorded what Luo Ying said, looked at Xiao Yan and asked, "Defense lawyer, do you still have questions for witnesses?" ”

Xiao Yan stood up and nodded, Xiao Yan looked at Sima Qiqi and took a deep breath and asked slowly: "Witness, you said that you saw someone jumping into the lake, and you not only called the emergency number but also called the police, why?" ”

Sima Qiqi said slowly: "Because I took into account the complicated situation of the lake, I called the police in advance, hoping that the police would make a record, after all, I and another colleague are witnesses, in order to avoid unnecessary trouble, so I called the police and hoped that the police would come to the scene to assist." ”

Xiao Yan nodded and then asked, "When did you see the person suspected of Qian Keyu, and when did you call the police, and when did the police come?" ”

Sima Qiqi answered Xiao Yan's questions one by one, Xiao Yan took out a document at this time, looked at the magistrate and said slowly: "Your Excellency, this is a copy of the police dispatch record and the interrogation record of everyone in the Cuihu Club on that day, which clearly records the time, which is consistent with what the witness said, please take a look at the magistrate." ”

The magistrate took the records from the staff, flipped through them carefully, and after a while, the magistrate read all the records, nodded slightly, Xiao Yan saw that the magistrate had finished reading it, and then said: "And this is an inquiry we made about the bus to and from the Cuihu Club on the day of Qian Keyu's death. ”

The magistrate was puzzled when he heard what Xiao Yan said, and asked, "Why is it an investigation of the shuttle bus, and what is the purpose of your investigation?" ”

Xiao Yan said slowly: "Find someone!" ”

Everyone in this court except Xiao Yan and Sima Qiqi was puzzled, and even Luo Ying didn't know what kind of medicine was sold in the gourd of these two people, Luo Ying's expression became serious.

The magistrate asked Xiao Yan to explain clearly, Xiao Yan nodded and said slowly: "I think that the death of the two deceased Liu Ming and Qian Keyu is suspicious, because of the witness's report, the police investigated the Cuihu Club, so the road was temporarily closed, and other vehicles except buses could not pass, after a detailed investigation, the staff of the Cuihu Club who was questioned by the police on the same day was investigated, and in the process of investigation, we found an employee who did not appear on the police interrogation record, But it appeared on one of the buses returning from the Cuihu Club to Shuzhong City, which is an investigation report. ”

The magistrate looked at it and motioned for the staff to show it to Luo Ying, Luo Ying saw that it was the record of the real murderer who used his mobile phone wallet to pay the bus fare, and Luo Ying scolded secretly: "This idiot." ”

Xiao Yan and Sima Qiqi exchanged glances, Xiao Yan was about to continue, Luo Ying stood up and said: "Your Excellency, the appearance of this person may also have multiple possibilities, which does not prove that there is a problem with the cause of Qian Keyu's death, even if there is a problem with the cause of Qian Keyu's death, there is no actual evidence related to Mr. Liu Ming's death

In the absence of evidence, the defense lawyer deliberately delayed the trial and wasted public money. ”

Xiao Yan said very confidently at this time: "What the plaintiff's lawyer said is right, but you are also speculating without evidence, what is the truth, it is better to let the extra person on the list testify in court, and let him explain." ”

When Luo Ying heard Xiao Yan say this, her face changed greatly, a drop of sweat slowly oozed out of her forehead, and the magistrate felt a trace of doubt, looked at Xiao Yan and asked, "Didn't the defense lawyer find more than one person on the list to question?" ”

Xiao Yan looked at the magistrate and said very seriously: "Your Excellency, because the plaintiff's lawyer applied for this person to be the plaintiff's witness in advance, we are not qualified to question, but at present, the doubts in the case are related to the plaintiff's witnesses, and we implore the court to compel the plaintiff to summon witnesses." ”

(End of chapter)