At the same time as Pang Xuelin issued a response, Xu Xingguo, Li Changqing, Ye Xingmin and several other doctoral students who participated in the experiment also spoke out through various channels.

Xu Xingguo and Li Changqing, who do not have social platform accounts, even opened and authenticated Za Lang Weibo.

Xu Xingguo, academician of the Chinese Academy of Sciences: "Professor Pang is the most talented scholar I have ever met, in October last year, he came to me, hoping to study for another graduate student in materials science, at that time I was a little worried about whether he could take care of his energy, but I did not expect that he had already taught himself all the courses of materials science from undergraduate to graduate level. To this end, we specially organized teachers to evaluate Professor Pang, a total of 20 professional courses, ten full marks, five courses with more than 95 points, and the lowest one with 92 points. So our school made a decision that as long as Professor Pang was able to complete a dissertation above Zone 2, he could award a doctorate. As a result, Professor Pang directly gave a Nature-level experimental plan, which successfully persuaded me and Professor Li Changqing. In the end, our school set up a small team led by Associate Professor Ye Xingmin, and under the leadership of Professor Pang, we worked together to publicize the preparation of high-purity carbon nanotubes......"

Changjiang scholar Li Changqing: "Many people say that Professor Pang has robbed me of my research results, but here I have to clarify that all the experimental ideas and schemes were independently designed by Professor Pang, and I just transferred some people from my laboratory to help Professor Pang form an experimental team." In fact, after the success of the experiment, Professor Pang also invited me to co-sign the paper, and I felt that I had not contributed much to this project, so I did not agree. However, in the follow-up research on carbon nanotubes, I will work with Professor Pang for further research......"

Ye Xingmin, associate professor of the School of Materials Engineering of Jiang University: "Professor Pang is a real genius, there are many difficulties in the research process of this project, and Professor Pang led us to solve them one by one, without Professor Pang, it would not have been possible to produce such an achievement......

An experimental dog: "To be honest, I am not qualified to evaluate Professor Pang's attainments in the field of materials science, in short, if we encounter any problems in research and experiments, as long as we go to Professor Pang, we will definitely get the answer......"

……

As Pang Xuelin, Xu Xingguo, Li Changqing and others spoke out on social platforms one after another, there was a rapid reversal of online public opinion.

Tencent News: "Pang Xuelin slapped his face and elbows strongly, if you can't do it yourself, it doesn't mean that I can't!" ”

Global Network: "Professor Li Changqing, academician of the Chinese Academy of Sciences Xu Xingguo and Changjiang scholar, publicly supports Professor Pang and calls Professor Pang a genius!" ”

Netease News: "Mathematics + materials science, as soon as you make a move in the field of materials science, it is a long article of "Nature", which is the difference between geniuses and mortals. ”

Observer: "The strongest doctoral dissertation in Chinese history has appeared, and there have been many geniuses in history, such as de Broglie, who won the Nobel Prize in Physics with a doctoral dissertation. Professor Pang's paper on the preparation and characterization of high-purity carbon nanotubes, although not to that extent, is enough to rank among the top few of the strongest doctoral dissertations in history. In the history of China's domestic universities, it is absolutely unique. ”

……

Under the Weibo updated by Pang Xuelin, in just a few hours, more than 100,000 retweets and more than 10,000 comments.

"Professor Pang's sentence 'So you can only be your popular science writer ......' is really full of malice, is this a god mocking mortals?"

"Sure enough, the world of gods is not understood by mortals!"

"Worship Pang Shen, sure enough, cattle people will be cattle wherever they go!"

"The final exam is coming soon, give Pang Shen incense and ask Pang Shen to bless you!"

"Believe in Pang Shen, don't miss the course!"

……

And more netizens ran to Fang Elbow's Weibo and slapped him in the face directly.

"Haha, I'm laughing to death, is this a typical example of pretending to be X but not being C?"

"I actually dared to touch the porcelain Pang Shen, but Pang Shen slapped him and slapped his elbow so much that he couldn't find the north!"

"MMP, self-taught materials science, a total of 20 professional courses, ten full marks, five with a score of 95 or more, and the lowest one, with a score of 92...... Is this still human? I seem to have read a fake materialology ......"

"I think Fang's elbow is a little pitiful, his face is swollen by someone, and he still hasn't deleted Weibo."

"Fang Elbow quickly delete Bo and apologize, who are you provoking is not good, but you want to provoke Pang Shen!"

……

However, netizens did not wait for an apology.

Six hours after Pang Xuelin issued a reply statement, Fang Xuezi's Weibo account suddenly disappeared.

Some netizens who had long been unhappy with Fang Elbow applauded loudly one by one.

"Damn, the square elbow has actually been banned."

"You deserve it, this is the price of provoking Pang Shen!"

"Don't look at who Pang Shen is, slander a top scientist in my country at will, he deserves to be banned!"

"I've been unhappy for a long time...... Now I feel comfortable! ”

……

Pang Xuelin didn't know that there was a lot of disturbance on Weibo, and he didn't know that because of his own business, a Weibo big V was directly deleted.

At this time, he was discussing the manuscript of his textbook Ponzi Geometry with Shinichi Mochizuki and Perelman.

"I don't think there is anything wrong with this textbook, which explains the theoretical core of Ponzi geometry and its application in solving partial differential equations in simple terms, and can be directly used as a textbook for undergraduates."

Mochizuki Shimo.

Pang Xuelin turned his gaze to Perelman again.

"Yes!"

Perelman is still a treasure trove of words.

Pang Xuelin said: "Okay, since you all think it's okay, I'll let the school publish it as soon as possible, by the way, how did you sort out the discussion draft of the seminar I asked you to sort out last time?" ”

The Ponzi Geometry Workshop has been held for nearly half a year from the beginning of the year to the present.

Sometimes Pang Xuelin is not at school, so it is co-hosted by Shinichi Mochizuki and Perelman.

Since the members of the Ponzi Geometry Workshop come from all over the world, the main working language in the workshop is English.

Shinichi Mochizuki's English is okay, and there is basically no problem with communication.

Perelman's English is a bit average, but this guy doesn't talk much, and every time in the seminar, when it's his turn to give an article or opinion, he goes straight to the stage and writes his work on the blackboard.

After all, for mathematicians, mathematics is the best language of communication.

As a result, the seminar has been progressing relatively smoothly since its inception at the beginning of the year.

Moreover, these top scholars from all over the world collide with each other, and the seminar has produced a lot of academic results.

In the first half of this year alone, the Ponzi Geometry Seminar of Jiangxi University has published five articles on Ponzi geometry in four major journals, and such a production rate has directly made the Department of Mathematics of Jiangxi University a global Ponzi geometry research center.