After generously picking up the teacup and taking a sip of Bingxin Yujie, his eyes swept over the faces of the three of them and said: "This question is actually difficult to conclude, it is likely that everyone has their own answer in their hearts, but few people can analyze this question from a truly objective perspective." ”

"Since you have asked, then I can tell you what I think."

"Judging from the lawyer's account, your contradiction is whether or not organs should be bought and sold legally."

"Do you think that if you develop a legal business, it will instead encourage the evil forces?" Generously said to the white.

"Yes, this is the inevitable result, and it is still impossible to be fair, queuing is the fairest, once it can be bought and sold, why donor official beneficiaries don't choose the highest price? And this should also involve the bottom line of human ethics. But the most important thing is that it is the most stupid thing to use an impossible and fair method to break and overthrow the relatively fair order. White-eyed expounded his point out loud.

There is one thing that is very clear in Bai Cai's heart, when Dafang expounds the truth in his own righteousness, he will not beat and scold himself for no reason, after all, in the public, the old demon who is a hypocrite will take more care of his wings. But the old demon will definitely hold a grudge, its treacherous and despicable heart, must be thinking all the time, how to bully and retaliate against himself, the standard villain psychology, but you can only blame yourself for your bad life, no way, villains are like this, so you can only use a small notebook to write it down first, and then let the old demon look good!

But this lawyer on the side makes him equally annoying, looking like an honest child, but he definitely hides a bad stomach, which he has already determined when he saw the other party for the first time! But the most annoying thing is that this guy is younger than himself, and he actually wants to refute himself from the debate. Hum! It's a fool's dream, and I can't measure it to the extreme!

"And your argument is that after the opening of legal trading, the number of people who have been treated will increase significantly, right?" Be generous and humane.

"Yes sir, hundreds of thousands of people die every year because of this, it is an objective fact, if it can be opened to trade, then the number of people who live because of it will be far more than now." Ritsuto nodded.

Bai Aoyao immediately retorted: "But you ignore that those who die because of this, some organs are indispensable, and the life of one person must represent the death of another." ”

"But brain death is itself doomed to physical death." The lawyer asked rhetorically.

"The three people who died in the past two days were not brain dead, they were murdered for the sake of their organs." Bai Bai said coldly.

"But this can be stopped by law."

"Really? This is not the Human Realm or the Four Cities, and the law only works on the transcendent when Qin Haoran is there. Bai Hao sneered.

"So as long as the law stops criminals, do you agree with the view that my organs should be bought and sold legally?" The lawyer asked rhetorically.

"Of course not, because it's not fair, and the law should never and can't allow it." White-eyed sneered at each other.

Dafang quietly waited for the argument between the two, picked up the teacup and took a sip, and Yang Cong quietly pulled the white coat.

"One feels that this breaks fairness and violates the moral bottom line, and the other feels that it is acceptable to procure organs from brain-dead people and use them for trade to prolong the lives of others, and as for how to ensure relative fairness again, other legal means can be used. Really? Dafang asked after summarizing the opinions of the two again.

This time both nodded at the same time.

"Then in this way, the problem seems to have become easier, which of you will squeeze Qin Haoran out of his seat and replace him with himself, and then you can directly turn your views into the constitution? And why quarrel here, are you right? Dafang looked at the two of them.

When the lawyer heard this, he was a little dumbfounded, but he refused to give up, and shouted loudly: "You just said that you want to tell us your own opinion, and the debate is a collision of ideas, which is beneficial to both sides, of course, there will be disputes. ”

Dafang smiled slightly after hearing this, nodded and said: "This is a good point, an objective debate is indeed beneficial to both sides." But attacking the other party obviously does not have objectivity, what do you think? ”

"Humph!" Bai Bai tilted his head and didn't look at the dead man's face, but his ears were there, obviously he still wanted to hear it.

Dafang said slowly: "In the era of the human home planet, there was a period called the Three Kingdoms, when the warlords were fighting, and the warlords who occupied the imperial capital at that time had a strategist under him, and he admonished: The tombs of the emperors and ministers of the past dynasties have countless treasures, and they are useless to the dead, so why not go out and use them for the living?" After hearing this, the warlord was deeply convinced, and let people dig up the mausoleum of the imperial capital and get countless treasures. ”

"In fact, grave digging is also common in most civilizations, but the same thing is that this practice is only exchanged for spitting all over the world."

"Obviously, this means that no one likes this practice, and this point seems to be not much different from your practice of using the organs of brain-dead people to help the sick, it is all useless for the dead, why not use it for the living."

This was said to the lawyer, and Bai was very proud after hearing it, and the lawyer shook his head and said: "Tomb robbing and saving people are different in concept, and I don't think they can be confused." ”

"But it's the same, isn't it?" Dafang asked.

"One steals, one buys, how can it be the same?" The lawyer asked rhetorically.

"On the surface, this is so, but if you take into account the starting point, the behavior of the two is the same." Smile generously.

"But the starting point is different, huh?" Ritsuto's eyes widened and he didn't understand.

"No, the starting point is the same." Dafang shook his head.

After thinking for a moment, Ritsuto still shook his head and said he didn't understand.

"The starting point is, for the living." Dafang explained.

When the lawyer heard this, he finally nodded and agreed with Dafang's statement, and the starting point was the same.

"But there's a difference between stealing and buying." The lawyer said.

"Yes, there is a difference" Dafang also nodded, and then he said: "However, there is a very secret thing here that ordinary people don't associate with very much. ”

"That is, did the deceased have a right?"

"The answer is yes, in the laws of human civilization, the deceased generally have the right to name, honor, reputation, likeness, privacy, and inviolability of the body and bones."

"However, when it comes to organ transplantation, these laws do not address the fundamentals and are not objective enough."

"From a truly objective point of view, it should be, who does the corpse belong to?"

"I think that the corpse still belongs to the dead, and this right is the inevitable extension of the basic rights of every living person, we can't say that the body belongs to you when you are alive, but it is not after death, but it has become a property that others can dispose of at will."

"That's what I said before, a really objective perspective."

"But almost no one will pay attention to this kind of objectivity, because it is the living who can communicate ideas, and all the living are fundamentally different from the dead, which is actually a more acute contradiction than racial antagonism and slavery, except that the dead cannot resist."

"It is obviously the weak who cannot resist, so all the living people who have not considered it from this perspective and support the sale of organs are bullying the weak and bullying others, and this is precisely the thinking of the weak, because only the weak will bully others." Generous way.

"But isn't it normal to be afraid of death? Do the strong like to die? Or do you gladly accept death? And even if the strong are really like this, what right does the strong have to ask others to think the same way as him? The lawyer retorted.

"You are right, the strong have no right to demand the same from others, but don't forget, the weak also have no right to dominate the dead, because the dead also have rights." Smile generously.

But ......" the lawyer did not know what to say.

Dafang said: "The angle you stand on is on the side of the living, but the most objective angle to look at this issue should be the same, the two different camps of the living and the dead, after all, every life will face death after all." ”

That is too objective, and from this point of view, isn't that tantamount to putting oneself in a position where one is neither born nor dead? Where there is such a state, it is either a living person or a dead person, and where there are people who are both alive and dead. The lawyer shook his head.

Bai Hao also rolled his eyes, and said in his heart: I don't believe that you, an old monster, can be so objective when he is dying.

Of course, Bai Hao was only mocking in his heart, and he didn't dare to say that.

"If you want to truly analyze a thing to the root, you must stand on the most objective perspective as much as possible, and the root has always been everything, the infinitesimal point at the beginning of the universe. The binary opposition of black and white thinking itself means that one must be placed on one side of black and white, that is, he has a position, and if he has a position, he abandons absolute objectivity, which is a very simple truth. And in this world, is there really only two states: life and death? Not necessarily. Dafang said lightly.

The lawyer shook his head and said, "It may not be so. Moreover, as long as there is one premise for the rights and interests of the deceased, which you mentioned earlier, it can be established, that is, if the living are voluntary, and the feelings of the living or the sick should also be taken into account. ”

Dafang didn't continue to talk about the state other than life and death, but nodded and said, "Yes, voluntarily." There are also two types of voluntariness. ”

"As for the two kinds of voluntariness and the feelings of the living, then this brings us to another issue, which is what you are contented with, the question of the law."

()

Set a small goal first, such as remembering in 1 second: book guest residence