Chapter 191: The Great Discussion
The reason why the "limited self-defense" and "ultimate control" functions on the Bangbang robot were castrated is mainly to avoid two arguments.
1. Can robots harm humans?
Second, is the tool guilty, or is the person who uses the tool guilty?
On these two points, public opinion is very fiercely arguing.
"I think the Bangbang Robot should have a 'limited self-defense' ability, which is set up to protect humans, to prevent good people from being harmed by bad people! With this ability, we have an extra line of defense to protect ourselves, and this function should not be castrated. ”
Someone immediately retorted: "Hehe, how can you tell the difference between a good guy and a bad guy?" How can a machine tell who is good and who is bad? If the user who buys Bangbang is an old man, he doesn't pay off his debts, and he doesn't pay back his money! Someone else came to his house to collect debts, using a little drastic means, can this old man order the Bangbang robot to activate the 'limited self-defense' to drive away those debt collectors? Do you think Bangbang is helping the good guys or the bad guys? ”
"Your assumption is not true, in recent years, the state has cracked down on the untrustworthy very severely, and the old man who is restricted from high consumption is not qualified to buy a bangbang robot!"
"Okay, then exclude Lao Lai, what if it's a family conflict between husband and wife? Which side should the Bangbang Robot be on? There are also disputes between brothers, conflicts between mother-in-law and daughter-in-law, and there are many big fights in the end, how to deal with these contradictions? Do you want to engage in 'limited self-defense'? ”
"This ...... No one can handle household chores well, but I think the weak should be protected, and the bangbang should protect the weak! ”
"The weak? Hehe, think about those old people, when they got on the bus, they were all as delicate as Lin Daiyu, and when they got off the bus, they were all Bruce Lee...... Do you think they're weak? Think about those square dance aunts with explosive combat effectiveness, do they need the protection of robots? I think they are all strong, and we are the weak! ”
"You...... You can't generalize too much, if you encounter a real gangster, this function can save your life! ”
"Oh not necessarily, if you really encounter a gangster, with the fighting ability of a bangbang robot, it is possible to be solved by the gangster in two or three clicks, and then be severely retaliated by the gangster, and the gangster who would not have caused a fatal case, the gangster who was angry and embarrassed killed someone; What was supposed to be a small loss and damage turned into a bigger loss and damage...... In the face of the real bad guys, the little self-defense ability of the Bangbang robot is simply not enough, unless it is stronger than the bad guys. ”
"I ...... I ......"
The opposing view has the absolute upper hand.
The debate about the "ultimate control mode" of the Bangbang robot is even more intense.
It's not that this feature is bad and impractical, but it's very likely that bad guys will take advantage of it and use it to do bad things.
"In the future, thieves don't have to steal things by themselves, they just control a stick robot to steal, and they don't have to expose themselves at all; The robbers who robbed the bank only need to control a few stick robots to rush into the bank, and after a breakdown, hundreds of millions of dollars will be in their hands, and they are not afraid of being caught by the police, so they throw the remote control in their hands and continue to get away with it...... Awesome Robot is simply the perfect tool for committing crimes. ”
"Yes, with Bangbang Robot, it's so convenient to commit crimes, such as killing a person, controlling Bangbang Robot to kill, regardless of whether the assassination operation is successful or not, the real killer will get away with it, and then continue to look for the next target...... The number of murders in this society will skyrocket. ”
But the following is countered:
"The two upstairs have watched too much, their brains are quite big, I guess you didn't go into the theater to watch the movie "Wow Wow 2", right? In the movie, the process of activating the 'ultimate control mode' is clearly introduced, when you encounter tricky trouble, you have to apply first, get the remote approval of Xinghai Technology, and you have to call the police to report! Under the supervision of the three parties, the 'ultimate control' can be opened, and the whole process will be recorded.
In the movie, Xiaolan's father in order to apply for this function, Xinghai Technology Company did not hesitate to blacken himself, and actually grinded and chirped for five minutes, when the audience wanted to scold, Xinghai Technology gave approval, and Xinghai Technology's own purpose is also very simple, one is to show that the 'ultimate control' will be launched under the supervision of multiple parties;
Even so, Xinghai Technology in reality still announced that it had emasculated this function, saying that Xinghai Technology had many concerns and would rather castrate than cause controversy.
I don't think so! There is no good or bad tool, the key depends on the person who controls the tool, is a good person and a bad person, and if a bad person wants to do evil, the stone will become his tool for committing crimes, is it because the kitchen knife kills people and all knives are disabled? It's impossible.
The 'ultimate control' function of the awesome robot is indeed likely to be used by criminals, but under the perfect supervision mechanism, this probability has become very low, Xinghai Company's remote monitoring + police supervision + full video, if this can still be drilled by criminals to loopholes, it can only reflect the incompetence of all parties, as well as the amazing talent of criminals...... This is rare.
Therefore, there is really no need to castrate the 'ultimate control' function, which is definitely much safer than the drugs rampant in Canada and the guns rampant in country M, and at critical moments, this function will definitely play an unimaginable role, and even become a hand that the user extends out to firmly grasp our happiness. ”
This man's view was widely echoed.
"Yes, with the tools of perfect supervision, you can use them with confidence."
"This kind of supervision is much more perfect than the 'Didi taxi' supervision, and it is very safe and effective!"
"Dude, you talked about the guns of country M, I can only say that you gave a beautiful example, if the guns of country M are supervised by 'bangbang robot', the death toll can definitely be reduced by 99%! The problem is that the gun safety is too easy to open, and the finger is pressed on the trigger again...... It's better to be a great robot. ”
"Tools are not guilty! As long as regulation is in place, I want to retain the 'ultimate control' feature of the Bangbang Robot. ”
In terms of public opinion, more than 90% of people say that this function can be retained.
At the discussion meeting of the relevant state departments, more than 70% of the officials believed that it was not impossible to retain the "ultimate control" function of the Bangbang robot under the perfect regulatory mechanism.
So the person in charge of the relevant department said hello to Xinghai Technology: "The 'limited self-defense' function is best castrated, but the 'ultimate control' function can be tried to be piloted in one or two places, and if it proves that the 'advantages far outweigh the disadvantages', then it can be fully applied." ”
This positive signal released by relevant departments is extremely exciting for Xinghai Technology!
Zhou Kun, who is in charge of the Bangbang Robot project, rubbed his hands and said excitedly: "The relevant departments are still very reasonable, not one-size-fits-all, but let us pilot, giving us a chance to prove that 'the tool is not bad', we must seize this opportunity!" Not only is the proof tool not bad, but it can be extremely helpful! ”
"yes!"
Zhang Zhiwei, who was promoted to deputy project manager, sighed: "Fortunately, this is in country Z, if it is in the West, products like bangbang robots cannot be launched at all, and the 'robot extinction theory' and 'robot harmfulness theory' are deeply popular, conspiracy theories are prevalent, and there are too many anti-intellectual remarks...... We, the Chinese nation, are still relatively pragmatic. ”
Chen Jin shook his head: "Fear stems from ignorance, there are too many ignorant people, and scientific progress will be hindered...... In the final analysis, they still have poor basic education, insufficient scientific literacy, and even they do not have the ability to judge good and bad. Bangbang robots can save people, but they are likely to resist...... The ignorant sometimes really die of ignorance. ”
Everyone nodded.
……
With the hot release of the movie "Wow Wow 2", the discussion on the functions of the Bangbang robot in public opinion is getting hotter and hotter.
February 10th.
Hundreds of millions of people are eagerly awaiting.
Xinghai Technology's new product, Bangbang Robot, will be released tonight.