At the judge's suggestion, someone came to take the voice recorder and USB flash drive that I put in the plastic bag, and the judge opened the voice recorder first, and there were three dialogues in it, the first one was from Chen Huan.

When Chen Huan's voice came out, I noticed that Xiao Dong's face changed, and when he began a meaningless conversation, he stood up and objected: "Oppose the defense lawyer's presentation in court of things that are not related to the case, so as to delay time." ”

I immediately said, "Listen, it's only five minutes long, and no one in the room would think that listening to another five minute recording would mean we're stalling for time." ”

The judge glanced at Xiao Dong: "Lawyer Xiao, please sit down and listen to the evidence provided by the defense lawyer." ”

After Xiao Dong sat down, his face was expressionless, and his mood was not as fluctuating as just now. I know that he did not raise his objection for the purpose of really opposing it, and since I have presented new arguments and evidence in the current situation, both the judge and the bench will insist on listening to it, and he is only putting on a tough posture to deter the other party.

Indeed, as I said, Chen Huan's conversation was very short, and after listening to it, the judge asked me: "Lawyer Jia, what is the significance of this recording you provided?" I walked out of my seat and said slowly to the judge and the side judge: "The man in the recording is called Chen Huan, the owner of a strolling chain bookstore on the pedestrian street in the commercial district, and there are three chain bookstores in the commercial district. In this recording, I mentioned that he deliberately instigated He Xiangjie and Qian Huijuan and others to deliberately touch the Cibashan Book City, and he did not object to this remark, but pointed out that the two jumping clowns were his random chess pieces! ”

My words immediately caused an uproar in the audience, and the spearhead was originally on the side of Bashan Book City, but at this moment, it was pushed to this is a conspiracy. It stands to reason that Xiao Dong will immediately stand up and refute me at this time, so as not to let public opinion spread, but he has always sat there with his eyes down, making people unable to touch his mind.

On the contrary, Qian Huijuan, the plaintiff beside him, was a little restless, and she went to see Xiao Dong several times, but she did not get a response from Xiao Dong.

I saw the worry on Qian Huijuan's face, so I directly challenged: "Dare to ask Ms. Qian, is the fear and worry you are showing now because the conspiracy you led has been exposed?" ”

"Not really!" Qian Huijuan shouted loudly, "You are talking nonsense, where am I afraid?" ”

I smiled and said, "Being loud doesn't mean being justified, it usually just means bluffing." Now let's listen to the second recording, Judge, and you can move on to my second piece of evidence. ”

The judge pressed the recorder again, and what came out was a child's voice: "I like to take pottery classes very much, and my father signed me up." The teacher said that there can only be five children in a class, but one child had to come in and said that I had taken his place, but my father gave me the name first. Later, the teacher also let the child go to class, but he insisted on snatching my machine and broke all the cups I made. ”

At the end of the recording, I looked at Qian Huijuan, "Ms. Qian, do you know what this child is referring to?" ”

Qian Huijuan's eyes flashed and said: "What do you understand, I don't know what you're talking about, our little handsome didn't rob the kid's machine, it was obvious that he cut the queue himself." ”

I shook my head: "Did I say that it was your son Chen Jun who grabbed the machine with the boy?" ”

Qian Huijuan was stunned and speechless.

Turning his eyes to look around at everyone, he said loudly: "I implore the judge and the side trial to consider the testimony of this boy, he is He Mingxi, the son of He Xiangjie, another party to our incident." Unfortunately, because the child is too young to come to the court to testify, only a recording of him can be provided. I believe that everyone should not doubt the truth of what a child said, and the cause and effect of the matter are basically very clear, and this He Mingxi child unfortunately has a rare blood disease. ”

I paused before continuing: "You may wonder what the child's illness has to do with this case. It was precisely this child's illness that led to this incident. The child's father, He Xiangjie, the other party involved in the accident, had been in contact with the person in charge of the Wandering Bookstore before the incident, and the other party asked He Xiangjie to create an 'accident' in the Bashan Book City on the premise of helping the child treat his blood disease. In the judge's voice recorder in your hand has his testimony. ”

He Xiangjie's confession was undoubtedly a hammer when it appeared in the scene, which reversed the direction of the whole incident.

I only paid attention to Xiao Dong's dynamics, and at this time he had no intention of getting up and arguing. Not only did it not make me breathe a sigh of relief, but my heart was sinking, with Xiao Dong's character, it would definitely not be such a sluggish state in court, and he would not be able to make a "let" behavior, even if my former friendship with him is still there, not to mention that we have already turned against each other.

Now it is equivalent to the fact that the witnesses who were originally his have become counter-evidence, and the original civil dispute has evolved into a commercial espionage war. On the other hand, Qian Huijuan's expression was clearer, although she was panicked, she looked dazed, and she didn't know what was going on.

Apparently, she was not involved in the framing scheme. That is to say, the actions she did were of her own volition, but she may have filed a lawsuit at the behest of someone, which is not included in the discussion in court for the time being.

After the judge had listened to the recording of the third testimony, I spoke again: "Therefore, I beg you to reopen this case, which is not so much a civil dispute as a pre-designed economic crime case of peer-to-peer competition." ”

The judge pondered for a moment and then asked Xiao Dong: "Lawyer Xiao, do you have any relevant counter-evidence to raise?" ”

Xiao Dong slowly got up after being named, and his eyes were shining, "The evidence listed in Lawyer Jia's defense just now is all through the voice in a voice recorder, in today's high-tech era, sound synthesis has been extremely extensive, I take the liberty of asking: Can there be any evidence to prove the ownership of these three sounds?" ”

I nodded: "Naturally, there are witnesses, and I implore the judge to announce my witnesses." ”

The judge agreed.

But after a while, the staff of the witness suddenly walked in from outside and whispered a few words to the judge, and the judge looked at me: "Lawyer Jia, your witness has just left suddenly. ”

A shock in my heart, how is it possible?

I tried my best to calm myself and asked the judge to adjourn the trial for 10 minutes so that I could communicate with the witnesses.

After the judge agreed, I got up and walked out, but I felt a tightness in my hand, and I turned my eyes into Zhou Yu's deep sight, and he said, "Don't worry. With a wide heart, I nodded at him, and the two of them walked out of the door together to a secluded place, and I called He Xiangjie.

At the hospital that day, He Xiangjie finally stopped me and asked, "If I am willing to testify in court, can you guarantee that I will not go to jail?" Because I still have parents and sons to raise. ”

I frowned and walked back over to him, asking him, "Why did you change your mind?" ”

He bowed his head, "Because I still have a conscience." ”

I shook my head and said, "No, because Skynet is so vast that you are afraid that one day what you have done will be exposed, and then not only will your son learn that there is a father who has made mistakes, but you will also face prison." ”

He Xiangjie raised his eyes and looked at the panic in his eyes, undoubtedly because I said that he was in his heart.

For whatever purpose, the two sides agreed that he would testify on my behalf today. I had contacted him before I came to the courthouse, and he said he was already on his way. He Xiangjie is in the service industry, and the most important thing in this industry is integrity, I believe in his character, and I also learned from the staff of the witness hall that he did go to the court.

But at this moment, when I called him, it was a voice prompt that was not in the service area over and over again.

Zhou Yu patted me on the shoulder and persuaded, "Don't fight." I put down the phone and looked at him, "How so?" ”

He said: "If it wasn't premeditated by the other party, it was a sudden emergency. For He Xiangjie, his son is his biggest weakness. ”

I was shocked, "You mean ......"

Zhou Yu shook his head at me, gestured behind me with his eyes, turned around and saw Xiao Dong standing at the entrance of the corridor, his eyes looking at us with a faint and deep light. Suddenly I understood why he was so calm from beginning to end, because he already knew what was going to happen! Originally, I thought that He Xiangjie might really have something urgent to leave, but now I suddenly realized that this is another game laid by the other party! The idea came from Chen Huan, or someone who was more than ten meters away from me, I didn't think about it.

In the past, I must have walked over to question Xiao Dong at this time; But with the precipitation of time, the impulsive factor has gradually worn off, and I only looked at him for a moment before turning my eyes away and saying to Zhou Yu: "Let's go back to the courtroom." ”

Zhou Yu looked at me carefully, and the corners of his mouth curled into a smile: "Okay." ”

He reached over and grabbed me, pulled me straight away, and when he reached Xiao Dong, he raised his eyebrows and said in a light tone: "Lawyer Xiao, let me go." "Actually, the aisle is wide enough for two people to pass side by side.

In the face of Zhou Yu's deliberate provocation, Xiao Dong was not annoyed, and turned sideways to the side, passing by us.

But when we took two steps, we heard Xiao Dong's low voice rise quietly: "Jia Ru, the next half time will be very fast." ”

My heart skipped a beat, and a strong sense of foreboding followed. I wanted to look back, but I felt that I was holding my palm tightly, Zhou Yu glanced at me, and the warning in my eyes made me restrain my thoughts.