Chapter 31: Give a Reason First
Sun Xiucai's heart-wrenching words can be described as extremely vicious.
But in Chun Tuyi's eyes, he only felt ridiculous, and couldn't help but smile and sarcastically said, "Sun Xiucai, although the people are ignorant, they understand that only the adults who are in charge of the court can make a final decision on the case. Now that you've complained, I haven't responded yet, but I'm sorry for you to make a decision for the three adults in the hall, aren't you tired? ”
"Hmph, little girl, if you know a few words, do you think you can turn things upside down?" Sun Xiucai sneered contemptuously, "The advantage of the tongue will not help!" ”
Chun Tu also ignored him, and bowed to the hall and said, "Three adults, the folk girl has doubts in her heart and wants to ask the witnesses, I don't know if it's okay?" ”
"Exactly." Zhang Hongtu responded.
Chun Tu Yu did not pose as aggressive as Sun Xiucai, but had a gentle and serious attitude, and even a little begging for advice, which made the witness relax his tense nerves, and then asked Dr. Wen first, "The doctor's parents, Dr. Wen is very angry when he sees so many people who have been poisoned by drinking fish soup, right?" ”
"Yes." Dr. Wen is a decent person, and he does not hide it at the moment, and he said, "The things that are imported are related to people's lives, whether it is food or medicine, they must be cautious, otherwise it will harm people and violate morality and conscience." ”
"You're right." Chun Tu Yu thought so, nodded and said, "The folk girl is also from this county, and she knows that Dr. Wen's medical ethics and medical skills are extremely high, so she will never doubt your diagnosis, and I am sure that those people were poisoned by eating mackerel." However, what the folk girl wants to figure out is ......"
At this point, she paused, aggravating the sense of suspense and attracting the attention of the hearing officials and the people watching the trial. At the same time, she also took time out of her busy schedule to observe the faces of Kang Zhengyuan and Han Wuxing, and saw that their appetites were all lifted, revealing a look of special concern, and she was satisfied, so she continued the questioning, "You must be poisoned because of fish soup, but can you be sure that Zhao Laoqi's death was caused by fish soup?" ”
From ancient times to the present, doctors have always been accustomed to not talking to death, because medicine, like science, has too many possibilities. Moreover, there are many doubts about Zhao Laoqi's death, and as a person with medical ethics, Dr. Wen will not give a conclusive conclusion.
In Fang Niangzi's case, it is a fact that someone has food poisoning, and under the eyes of everyone, they can't shirk their responsibility. Therefore, she is not entangled in this issue, and the focus of her defense is: this incident was an unfortunate accident, or Fang Niangzi was secretly framed. If this is confirmed, Fang Niangzi is also a victim. In modern terms, she paid some silver in the spirit of humanitarianism, and the matter was settled. The worst result is to bear the crime of negligent wounding, and the fine of silver and ransom will end. But manslaughter is absolutely unacceptable.
The law, in many cases, is the weighing and trade-off of interests and losses, and it is not just black and white, dead and alive, but bears one's own mistakes and evil thoughts. Or, helplessly.
Sure enough, Dr. Wen was stunned. After a pause, he shook his head and said, "Not sure." ”
The people watching the trial couldn't help but let out another shock. And Sun Xiucai's face changed suddenly.
But Chun Tu didn't wait for him to open his mouth to refute, and then turned to ask him, "Then may I ask you, Zhao Laoqi has no other wounds and scars on his body, and there are no other poisons in his vomit, but can you see if there is any hidden disease on his body?" For example, the heartache can also kill people. Also, if the poison in him is a powder dissolved in alcohol, can it be detected in the vomit? ”
"I can't." He also answered honestly.
Of course, Chun Tu Yu knew that he couldn't, because the ancient forensic science was very backward, and he couldn't perform autopsies from time to time, even if it was the great Song Ci Song Ti, he was far from being born at this time, and because of the limitations of the times, it was far from reaching the modern level.
"Huang Langjun, may I ask what symptoms you have after being poisoned?" She turned to the victims' representatives.
"It's just that I vomited and turned over the river and smashed the sea, no wonder I can't take out my stomach and wash it." When Huang Langjun said this, he couldn't help but stroke his abdomen, obviously having palpitations.
"Uncomfortable?" Chun Tu showed a sympathetic look.
"It's uncomfortable!"
"Not dead?"
"Huh?!" Huang Langjun didn't understand for a while, but quickly patted his chest, "Of course you live well, if you die, it will be impossible to testify." After vomiting, I was nauseous for a long time, and after eating the detoxification soup prescribed by Dr. Wen, it was no big deal, and I also ate a big bowl of mutton soup cakes at noon today. "Soup cakes are noodles.
He said it so funny that everyone in the hall couldn't help laughing, and the atmosphere became less serious.
Before Zhang Hongtu slapped the shocking wood, Chun Tu Yu quickly ended the topic and asked the last witness, "Hong Bantou, you said before that from the fish soup is ready to the dish is served, it is impossible for anyone to do anything about it. But what about mackerel before it's cooked? ”
"The fish has become a fish soup, and it is not formed in the soup, and the fish meat is made into fish paste balls, so when the fish is purchased, it is naturally impossible to know." Hong Bantou replied with a straight look, for fear of saying something wrong.
However, Chun Tu Yu didn't ask any more questions, but turned back to face the public seat in the hall and said, "My lord, the folk girl has already asked clearly." Sun Xiucai kept saying that there were all the human and material evidence, but there was no definite statement, how could he be trusted by the people? How can we rely on these indirect circumstantial evidence and corroboration to convict Fang Niangzi? ”
"This ......" Zhang Hongtu was completely confused. In Datang, the most important evidence is the confession of the prisoner, but Fang Niangzi made it clear that she would not summon her, and she was not allowed to move the punishment without authorization when the previous evidence was vague and the official was present, so what should I do?
But Chun Tu didn't give him time to think, and then said, "Also, Linshui Building has been open in this county for six or seven years, and the hibiscus fish soup is famous far and wide, has there been a mistake before?" Folk eat this fish, and occasionally there will be poisoning, but the waterfront building has never been, which shows Fang Niangzi's cooking intentions. And on the day of the accident, that is, there was no emergency affecting Fang Niangzi's emotions, how could she make poisonous fish soup by mistake? And if she knew that there was something wrong with the fish soup, for the sake of the restaurant's reputation, she would destroy it immediately, at most not selling the soup that day. She still has to continue to do business in the waterfront building, and she can't destroy her reputation. So, isn't this something weird? The so-called abnormality is a demon, who dares to say that there is no fraud in it? ”
"She was careful before, and she can't prove that she didn't make a mistake this time." Sun Xiucai finally seized the opportunity to refute.
"Then how do you prove that the fish soup is poisonous and it is indeed Fang Niangzi's fault?"
Whoever asserts, who adduces. This is the principle of modern civil law, and it cannot be eaten in Datang. However, she first set a text trap and mentioned the word "negligence", at least this lawsuit can be guaranteed.
"Poisoned people, human lives are at stake!" Sun Xiucai was in a hurry, and he really didn't pay attention to the details.
"So many people drank the soup, why did Shan Zhao Laoqi die? And in that situation, when Han and Kang saw it in person, it should have been a violent death. I didn't know that a bowl of fish soup was like arsenic. Chun Tu said sarcastically, "If mackerel had such an effect, the imperial court would have banned fishing and eating a long time ago, right?" Otherwise, wouldn't it be very cheap for someone to take poison from this fish! ”
After that, without waiting for Sun Xiu to answer, she suddenly walked in front of the Zhao family, half-bent down and asked, "May I ask the sister-in-law of the Zhao family, is your husband weak?" ”
The Zhao family didn't expect to suddenly ask her, and they couldn't help but panic. Instinctively, she understood that Chun Tu Yu was using her husband's physical weakness as an excuse to prove that being poisoned was the reason for herself, so she hurriedly argued, "Miss Hui, although my husband is thin, his body has always been strong, and even minor illnesses are rare, and his neighbors know it." ”
"Oh, it's so good." Chun Tu Yu dragged out his tone, "I also think that he is not even thirty this year, he is in the prime of life, and he has a strong reputation in the countryside on weekdays, so he is naturally not a weak person." But I wondered why all the people who ate the fish soup, including a septuagenarian and a six-year-old, were all right, given that he was in such good health. After speaking, she looked at Sun Xiucai, and saw that the latter's face was green, and her heart was dark.
She had long expected that Sun Xiu would use Zhao Laoqi's poor health to defend that the degree of poisoning was deep and led to death. After all, it is also an injury, and it is common sense that the weak die first. Therefore, she used the spear of the son and the shield of the attack on the son, and questioned the Zhao family before Sun Xiucai, and used his witnesses to nullify his mind.
Moreover, she mentioned Zhao Laoqi's reputation, which has a strong suggestive effect. That is a person who is idle, bullying the weak and afraid of the hard, and making a living by opportunism and extortion. It is possible that he took inappropriate drugs in order to blackmail, which led to sudden death, and there is no direct connection with the fish soup. At most, he didn't expect that there was a problem with the fish soup, and as a result, the two evils combined and killed himself.
"My lord, even though Miss Spring is clever and eloquent, she can't match the facts." Sun Xiucai reacted very quickly, and immediately did not dwell on this issue, so as not to fall deeper and deeper, "According to the students' investigation, Zhao Laoqi's death was actually deliberately done by Fang Niangzi!" ”
Ho, this is a bombshell, the most serious accusation. Actually, the other party didn't want to convict Fang Niangzi of manslaughter, but wanted to fight for intentional homicide? The appetite and guts are not small. What kind of hatred does this have to be, to put Fang Niangzi to death?
"I'm surprised, so I killed, but in front of everyone, I am still in my own restaurant? Fang Niangzi is not crazy and stupid, why do you want to do such a self-inflicted crime? Chun Tu sneered, "Will she still be in business in the future?" ”
"Maybe, this is the cleverness of Fang Niangzi." Sun Xiucai also sneered, "The most dangerous place is the safest place, everyone understands this truth." She is trying to confuse the world with this, so that the world will think that she will not do evil things under the noses of the villagers and in her own restaurant, but can clear herself. Don't you know that the legal net is restored, how long can you hide it with such careful thinking and small calculations? ”
"Can you say such strong words?" Chun Tu smiled instead of being angry, "Why? Why did Fang Niangzi do this? With the future of the restaurant and the life of the second half of his life, he is worth an unrelated life? Give a reason first! ”
……………………………………
……………………………………
…………… 66 Have something to say............
Merry Christmas to all!
Thanks to the people in the brocade night walk masked sunglasses for the priceless and wall, plus a Christmas hat
Thanks to UU's mother for the peach blossom fan, another 5 PK tickets
Thanks to Jiu Suihe for the two Santa hats, I will change them, borrowing a little joy from pregnant women, hehe
Thank you for the peach blossom fan that passed by 9868
Thanks to Sun Guozhu for the 10 PK votes
Thanks to the cinnabar and green daisy and the Santa hat rewarded by the small yard
Thanks to Chieh-Ching for the peace charm and the PK vote cast
Thanks to the fox spirit's dead friend, gsdgsgsgsgsg, green snake dance, and the peace charm rewarded by gold, purple, silver, and green Jy
Thanks to bones2 for the PK vote
Thanks to bobo9676, Yoo Ge Xing, danmozj, Late Autumn Dream Chasing, Sonia220, White Port, tashidelek, Sugar Candy ╅ Sugar Candy Reward Christmas Socks
Another: Today I will introduce two old books, one is a very popular alternative fairy work, and the other is an authentic ancient saying, describing the bad boyhood of national heroes, please click on the small blue print below
[bookid=142127,bookname="Immortals also have rivers and lakes"] [bookid=1353236,bookname="36 Tricks"]