Chapter 76: The Reality and Illusion of the Legal Edition

Lu Zongping insisted on setting a new court time, and asked the judge's assistant to inform him.

He doesn't care what kind of well-known barrister Fu Lichen is!

When the court hears a case, it should proceed in accordance with their arrangements and regulations, and no lawyer can be allowed to make the decision.

Ji Shu rubbed his aching forehead, and said helplessly: "Ah Ping, Ah Kang, you should first take a look at the application form handed over by the lawyer and our case file materials!"

This time, the forensic procedure is really problematic!

If we really decide on compulsory treatment against Chen Youle on the basis of this judicial appraisal opinion, when the other party applies for reconsideration, the case will also be revoked by the Intermediate People's Court and remanded for retrial. ”

Lu Zongping and Kang Zenggang both stared in surprise, obviously not expecting it to be so serious.

Ji Shu sighed, and without explaining too much, he saw the application form handed to the two of them.

The application written by Fu Lichen in a few minutes was outrageously concise compared to the applications handed in by other lawyers.

But it is enough to explain the application and the reason for it clearly-

Matters to be requested:

1. Apply for revocation of the judicial appraisal opinion of the Forensic Psychiatric Judicial Appraisal Institute of the Third People's Hospital of Haishi;

2. Re-evaluate Chen Youle's mental state and ability for criminal responsibility at the time of the incident.

Reasons for applying:

In this judicial appraisal opinion, one of the judicial experts was Wei Liangbo, the chief physician of the Third People's Hospital of Haishi, who had served as a witness in this case, which may affect the impartiality of the appraisal.

"How, how can this be?" Lu Zongping couldn't help but scream.

I hurriedly went through the case file materials and opened the last page of the forensic opinion.

Take a closer look: In the signature column of the participating appraisers, the last judicial appraiser to sign is Wei Liangbo, title: chief physician.

Lu Zongping still didn't give up, and quickly turned to the witness testimony part, and there was indeed the testimony of the witness Wei Liangbo in it.

Moreover, Wei Liangbo and Chen Youle live in the same community, and they are also in the same building, so they have known Chen Youle before, and they also know that Chen Youle's mental condition is abnormal.

When Lu Zongping saw this, he finally had to admit that Ji Shu's approach just now was right.

In such a case, if it is really tried in court and a decision is made in court, something big will definitely happen!

Thinking of this, he was glad that Fu Lichen had discovered this key detail, but at the same time, he felt that his face was gloomy, and he snorted angrily: "What did the public security and the procuratorate do?"

I didn't see any obvious procedural problems, so I moved the file to us in one fell swoop. If something really goes wrong, who can afford it?! ”

Ji Shu smiled bitterly, "Seriously, if we don't check this kind of detail carefully, even we may miss it!" ”

Kang Zenggang also agreed: "Yes! Usually, when looking at the appraisal opinion, no one will pay attention to the name of the appraiser, at most to see whether the appraiser's qualification certificate is attached to the back of the appraisal opinion, but even if I have seen it, where will I care if the name has appeared elsewhere in the case! ”

Lu Zongping remembered that when he read the appraisal opinion, he basically only glanced at the final appraisal opinion, and the appraisal process and analysis instructions were generally not carefully read.

Thinking about it this way, Lu Zongping suddenly had no position to talk about the people from the public security and the procuratorate.

Lu Zongping thought about it for a while, and still said: "In this way, it is still necessary to re-evaluate, and it can no longer be entrusted to the Third People's Hospital of Haishi." ”

Thinking of this, Lu Zongping was a little angry, "Forget about others, that forensic expert is the attending physician, and he should always know this rule." Since I have made a record in the public security, I should take the initiative to avoid this kind of thing! ”

Ji Shu couldn't even smile bitterly this time, and sighed helplessly: "Who knows how to make the oolong." Hey, I'll write a letter to the procuratorate later, and send this case back to them for re-investigation! ”

Lu Zongping agreed: "Even such a crucial piece of evidence has major flaws, and there is nothing to say about them." ”

————

Xu Xiaxi returned to the law firm, the excitement gradually subsided, and the distress gradually came up again.

They now have time to investigate, but where is she going to start?

She couldn't even be sure if the 'old ghost' and 'Captain White' really existed?

It's very likely that they have been busy for most of the day, but in fact, everything is just her 'thinking too much'.

Xu Xiaxi let out a feeble lament at the dossier materials.

She read these materials twice from beginning to end, and even read some important parts back and forth three or four times, and they were already ripe.

She remembered every word Chen Youle had ever said.

However, there is still no way to analyze how Chen Youle connects his own world with the real world.

Even though she graduated from graduate school with a master's degree in psychology, her field of study is still somewhat different from this type of schizophrenia.

"What are you thinking?" The bangs in front of Xu Xiaxi's forehead were gently lifted from front to back by a big hand, revealing her smooth and white forehead.

Xia Xi pushed away the big hand that was messing with her head, and glared at Fu Lichen unhappily, "Don't move your hands and feet!" ”

I don't know what's wrong with Fu Lichen, I just like to do these little actions to her.

'Develop' a habit from the very first time they meet.

At that time, Xu Xiaxi was a cowardly in front of Fu Lichen, daring to be angry but not daring to speak, and he was more or less happy in his heart because of this kind of intimate little action.

But now that they are not boyfriend and girlfriend, of course they can't do these misleading actions anymore.

Fu Lichen shrugged, and he didn't know if he had listened to Xu Xiaxi's protest in his ears.

Again, he asked, "What were you just thinking?" ”

Xu Xiaxi told Fu Lichen about her worries and entanglements.

"If in the end we still can't find the meaning of 'old ghost' and 'Captain Bai', or if it is confirmed that Chen Youle is the person who killed Liang Yingdi, will the court ...... That's not good! ”

Xu Xiaxi was really afraid that the judge would really write a judicial recommendation to the lawyers association to sue Fu Lichen, and Fu Lichen would be punished for her ignorance and paranoia, then she would really die of guilt.

Fu Lichen smiled coldly, "They made a witness a forensic appraiser, and the procedure was seriously flawed. I point out now that they still have a chance to make amends.

If I really wait until this case is concluded, and then I apply to the higher court for reconsideration, then it will become a problem with the quality of their case! They don't want anything for this year's performance bonus! ”

"Huh? Oh! "Xu Xiaxi actually doesn't know much about the circles in it, but seeing that Fu Lichen is so confident, it should be no problem, right?

Xu Xiaxi put his mind at ease and returned his attention to the case itself.

"Although Chen Youle needs to be re-evaluated, I have seen the identification process and analysis instructions, and I have been in contact with Chen Youle, so there should be no big problem with the evaluation opinion of schizophrenia.

Therefore, the main role of the re-evaluation for us is to buy us time to investigate the facts of the case. ”

Xia Xi slowly said his thoughts, "I have re-watched some of Chen Youle's ways of speaking and acting, and he does not confuse people and things. Look here! ”

Xu Xiaxi pointed to a line in the transcript of the police's interrogation of Chen Youle and explained: "The police asked him, 'Who are you lying on the floor?' and he replied, 'It's a terrorist, I arrested him here';

Then he asked, 'Where is your mother?' and he replied, 'My mother is above';

Then ask: 'Isn't the person lying on the floor your mother?' and answered, 'He's not my mother, he's a germ man, and if he wants to kill me, I'll drive him away';

Finally, ask, 'Why does she look exactly like your mother?' Answer: 'All his cells have been replaced, he is a germ man, and we are killing germ people every day'......

In addition to showing that Chen Youle fell into serious fantasies, these also show that he was able to understand what we were saying, and was able to not confuse people and things, but only fell into his own fantasies, and did not answer the questions asked by the police.

So the 'old ghost' and 'Captain White' in his mouth both refer to people, but whether these two people are his fantasy or real, I can't be sure for the time being? ”

Fu Lichen asked a question: "Didn't you say that although he is talking nonsense, his way of speaking and thinking is still his own logical system, why can't he be sure whether what he is talking about is a real person or a fantasy?" ”

Xu Xiaxi sighed helplessly: "Because when he was seriously mentally ill, someone once saw him scolding at the air and talking upside down. In his world, in addition to the part that connects and transforms reality, there is also the illusion derived from him. ”

Fu Lichen said that he didn't understand much about what Xu Xiaxi said.

Xu Xiaxi tilted his head and thought about it, and put it another way: "For example, you also know that the immediate family in criminal law only refers to parents, children and spouses. The part of the real world that transforms into his fantasy is the relationship between parents and children;

But children are also independent individuals! After 'growing up', it will still reproduce the next generation on its own, and there will be a new unreal, but at this time, the unreal world and the real world are already the relationship between grandchildren and grandparents, and even 'immediate family' is not counted! ”

Fu Lichen: "......"

This parable...... It's really apt!

Xu Xiaxi blinked innocently, "Do you understand?" ”

"I probably ......understand," Fu Lichen replied casually.

Then before Xu Xiaxi wanted to continue to explain in a different way, he waved his hand to interrupt her, "In the field of psychiatry, I am indeed not professional enough, but have you ever thought about a question?" ”

"What?"

"Maybe Chen Youle's 'Fantasyland' is not as much as you considered, and there are some incomprehensible things, maybe he just heard it wrong." Fu Lichen calmly pointed out a key issue.

Now it was Xu Xiaxi's turn to be frightened.

Big eyes widened.

"What did you say?"