For Zhuang Yan, the details of this case don't matter, He Chunsheng confessed to his murder, he killed the person, there is no doubt about this, the only thing he has to figure out is two questions, that is, whether it is really as He Chunsheng said, he was designed by Xie Lowercase to do such a radical thing, and whether He Chunsheng is really mentally ill.

As He Chunsheng's defense lawyer, no matter which of the above two possibilities is true, then the goal of reducing He Chunsheng's criminal responsibility can be achieved.

In fact, at first, Zheng Zheng still rejected this case very much from the heart.

He Chunsheng killed someone This is a fact, he himself admits it, killing people to pay off debts and paying back money is a matter of course, the law has its own ruling, how to sentence it, but this He Chunsheng said that he was framed and designed by Xie Xiaobao, which is a little puzzling, and he can't say why Xie Xiaobao framed him.

But with Yan Yan's contact with He Chunsheng and Xie Xiaobao, Yan Yan began to feel that this case was a little interesting.

Assuming that what He Chunsheng said is true, then why did Xie Xiaobao do it? Zhuang Zhuang thought that there was only one possibility, that is, he wanted to kill that woman with He Chunsheng's hand, that is, the girlfriend he snatched from He Chunsheng. But why did he want that woman's life? The question popped up in Solemn's mind at once.

Did he have a new love, but the woman was haunting him?

Probably not, if he wanted to kill that woman, then with his playboy energy, I don't know how many women deserve to die. But if not, then for what?

A series of questions went unanswered.

In everyone's opinion, He Chunsheng was angry at the crown, he couldn't stand the betrayal of a woman, he hated Xie Xiaobao who snatched his girlfriend, so he would kill people.

solemnly re-read the case file, the case file said that Xie Xiaobao and He Chunsheng had a verbal conflict on the day of the crime, Xie Xiaobao did ridicule He Chunsheng, and threatened that he was a cuckold life, that is, if he begged his wife in the future, his wife would go out of the wall, and even elope with other men, because He Chunsheng did not look like a man at all.

Xie Xiaobao's words were very annoying, He Chunsheng moved the knife when he was angry, but what about before that? There is no mention in the file that the two had any quarrels before, and it should be said that there is a deep grudge against He Chunsheng to the point of using a knife, but there is not much in the file.

That's right, Xie Xiaobao robbed He Chunsheng's girlfriend, but that was more than half a year before the crime, He Chunsheng was dating another woman at the time of the crime, and it has been more than half a year since the incident, why did it suddenly erupt, this is a little unreasonable.

Seeing that Zhuang Zhuang had not spoken, Zhang Da asked, "What are you thinking?" ”

solemnly squinted his eyes, and did not look at Zhang Da, his eyes fell on the windowsill: "It took more than half a year for Xie Xiaobao to snatch He Chunsheng's girlfriend before He Chunsheng's murder happened, and He Chunsheng was already preparing to have a relationship with his new girlfriend at that time, which shows that He Chunsheng is ready to start a new life, why is he still so impulsive?" ”

Zhang Da smiled: "Why don't you ask He Chunsheng these questions?" ”

solemnly turned his head to look at Zhang Da: "He Chunsheng may really be like you said, he has a problem with his brain, and when he talks to him, he always feels that his thinking is confused, and his logic is not so clear, and it is very difficult to communicate with him." And he didn't seem to trust me much, and he always wondered if I could really help him. ”

Zhang Da listened and nodded: "I feel that there should be something hidden in this that we don't know." ”

solemnly sighed: "Yes, if He Chunsheng was really designed by Xie Xiaobao, then Xie Xiaobao's motive for designing him is very crucial, in addition, Xie Xiaobao concluded that He Chunsheng would use a knife?" ”

Zhang Da was stunned for a moment, from the bottom of his heart, he also believed what He Chunsheng said, but he didn't think about what Xie Xiaobao's motive was, and even if he could find Xie Xiaobao's motive, how could Xie Xiaobao be so sure that he could provoke He Chunsheng and let He Chunsheng kill the woman in a fit of rage?

At this time, the doorbell rang, Zhang Da went over to open the door, and Ye Mei walked in: "Where are they all?" ”

She sat down in a chair, picked up an unopened bottle of mineral water on the table, opened it and took a big sip.

solemnly said: "If it is hot, drinking cold water in this weather is not good for the stomach." ”

Ye Mei's heart warmed when she heard this, but her face did not show it: "The spiritual appraisal experts in the province will be there tomorrow." ”

solemnly told Ye Mei about her questions, Ye Mei didn't speak for a long time after listening to them, obviously she was also thinking about something.

Zhang Dadao: "Xiaozhuang, why did Xie Xiaobao say that? ”

Zhuang Yan and Ye Mei looked at Zhang Da together, and they didn't react to Zhang Da's words for a while.

Zhang Da said again: "Why did he say that He Chunsheng was a cuckold, why did he say that even if He Chunsheng begged his wife, his wife would steal people and elope with others, and besides, he didn't look like a man, would there be any subtext in this?" ”

Solemnly said: "What do you think? ”

Zhang Dadao: "What really angered He Chunsheng should be something that he thought was humiliating, such as not being like a man or not being a man, the difference here is very big." ”

As soon as he understood this explanation, he said, "Are you saying that He Chunsheng may have a problem in that regard?" And the reason why Xie Xiaobao knew this should have been told to him by that woman, and He Chunsheng really had murderous intentions because his secret was told by a woman, and he also told it to someone like Xie Xiaobao. ”

Zhang Da nodded frequently.

Ye Mei looked at the solemn face: "If this is what He Chunsheng said about the design, the court will not approve it, this is at best only a cause of this murder case, at most it is to win a little sympathy for He Chunsheng." ”

"Well, you're right, but if you can find Xie Xiaobao's motive for doing this, then let's talk about it, I believe that Xie Xiaobao definitely doesn't just want to humiliate He Chunsheng for no reason, there must be some secret in this that we don't know, maybe this secret even He Chunsheng himself doesn't know."

Ye Mei and Zhang Da glanced at each other, and they both looked at the solemn again.

solemnly said: "If Xie Xiaobao is borrowing a knife to kill people, and his purpose is to kill him, then has the nature of the whole case changed fundamentally?" ”

"By your instincts again?" Ye Mei said with some disdain.

solemn and wry smile: "It's not intuition, it's common sense, if Xie Xiaobao just wanted to humiliate He Chunsheng, the timing was not right, he should have come to show off after snatching He Chunsheng's girlfriend, instead of running to He Chunsheng more than half a year later to provoke him." ”