Chapter 21: Who's Lying
"Then let's just type out the score of the question, you must be objective, and don't take into account my feelings."
Qiu Yanzi said his requirements very frankly, the game, if you don't take it seriously, it's not fun, and everyone knows this very well, so they buried their heads in thinking about the score.
After a few minutes passed, everyone showed their scores, Jiang Wentai "4 points", Chen Yingjie "4 points", Yang Huhu "4 points", Mo Ming "5 points".
"According to the rules, my score is 4 points, Mo Ming and Jiang Wentai scored 5 points, who will come next?"
"I'll do it."
Jiang Wentai smiled and raised his hand, looking very positive, he picked up a stack of A4 white paper, and the first one had some black pen words written on it, which was obviously the title. Jiang Wentai is relatively well prepared among these people, which also stems from his meticulous attitude. Of course, for him, when it comes to games, you have to win to be interesting.
"Ahem, then I'll get started."
Brew a little.
"Student K was beaten with a burlap bag over his head after school, and he heard the voices of two people at that time, but he was covered with his head and his voice was disturbed, so he could not recognize people by sound. On the way to the beating, he accidentally saw the prisoner's school uniform, which was from the same school as him, and after reporting the crime, he found that there were only four students passing by that place during this time, three of whom were his classmates, namely student ABC, and one was senior D."
Jiang Wentai stopped suddenly in the middle of speaking, he glanced at the four people, made sure that everyone understood, and then, he sent four pieces of paper to the four people, on which were handwritten conditions, holding the paper, everyone was a little puzzled.
"That's the background of the question, and then the paper I sent you is the self-report of the four ABCD people at the police station."
After listening to Jiang Wentai's words, everyone understood the meaning of the paper, and the top was the backbone.
The above content is:
Round 1: A says that B had an argument with K after school and threatened to beat K.
B says that A and D know each other.
C said that B was going home with me after school and didn't discuss going to beat K
D said, I just happened to be passing by, and I didn't know A.
At the end of this round of self-statements, there were two people who lied.
Second round: A said, B lied in the previous round.
B said that I did argue with K, but I did not threaten K and said that I would beat him.
C said that D was not passing by, and D and A did know each other.
D said, I have no grudge against K.
At the end of the second round, one person lied.
Round 3: A says that B and C did not walk together after school, and K can testify.
B said, D said he was going to beat K for me.
C states that D and A had made some kind of money transaction.
D said that A just borrowed money from me normally, and later repaid it.
This round, no one lied.
Round 4: A says K can prove my innocence.
B says that D and K have had a conflict
C said that it was me and D who hit people
D says, C is lying.
In the fourth round, the two lied.
After reading a long question, some people are obviously a little confused, ABCD or something, it's too complicated, and it's still the motivation and conditions are not sufficient, how to answer this?
"Wentai is too shady, he actually has such a question."
Chen Yingjie was a little complaining, but Jiang Wentai just laughed.
"Let's try to answer it, the question of this question is: who is the prisoner, but it is not enough to say who is the prisoner, you also have to reason, according to the result of the reasoning, I will judge the score, which is 1 to 5 points, that is, this is an open-ended question, and if it is reasonable, you can score."
"Jiang Wentai's topic is very interesting."
"Yes, let's start thinking, ten minutes."
While everyone was working hard, Mo Ming gave Jiang Wentai a blank look, this guy was too disgusting.
On the surface, this question is for everyone to reason, but in essence, it is a bit of a psychological test, and according to a person's answers, you can know how dark the person's heart is. Moreover, the more you think about this, the easier it is to make people feel that they are "really dark", it seems that Wentai wants to analyze human nature, and Mo Ming is secretly unhappy.
Time is passing, and the members are meditating, and it seems that this is a problem.
Finally, after ten minutes, everyone showed their answers slowly, just like a very difficult math exam, and the candidates were pressing the test papers to submit.
Qiu Yanzi and Chen Yingjie chose AD, Yang Huhu is BC, and Mo Ming is B.
"Everyone's choice is very interesting, let's talk about their opinions, the minister will come first."
Jiang Wentai looked very interested.
Qiu Yanzi was a little hesitant, and the expression on his face was not very relaxed.
"Then I'm throwing bricks, alas, my reasons are not very good."
She doesn't look modest, but really struggling.
"Just make sense, there is no standard answer, take it easy."
The comforted Qiu Hina smiled politely.
"According to the following self-statement, we can know that A and D should know each other, then BD is contradictory, B is the truth, and D is false. In the second round, A says that B is lying, but in fact B is not lying, so the liar is A. Then it can be deduced that A and D are cognizant. In the second round, only one person lied, and the liar was A, then D should have no grudge against K, and in the third round, they all told the truth, proving that AD had a normal loan and repayment between them, so AD's relationship was not bad. Although D and K have no grudges, it makes sense for A to let D bully K as a senior, right? So, the prisoners are A and D."
After Qiu Yanzi finished speaking, he breathed a sigh of relief, and then looked at Jiang Wentai expectantly. Jiang Wentai was very satisfied, clapped his hands, "Very good, it's very well considered, I think it can be 3 points."
"Huh? That's only 3 points, huh? Wentai, you're too stingy, aren't you? It should be higher anyway."
Chen Yingjie was indignant for Qiu Yanzi.
"Well...... Yingjie, there must be other better explanations, and besides, I can't figure out some places......
Mo Ming knew very well what Qiu was referring to, why did A insist on letting K prove it for himself in the third and fourth rounds? If she had said the reason for this, she would have scored even higher.
After Qiu Yanzi finished speaking, Chen Yingjie, who had the same answer as her, began, she had some concerns, should she steal Qiu Yanzi's statement? After some hesitation, forget it and play the game seriously.
"That, in the third and fourth rounds, A has been emphasizing that K can prove himself, isn't it a bit of an intimidation of K, and then in the third round, A and D have a normal borrowing relationship, and I have the same idea as Hinako here, AD has a good relationship, so it should be A and D who went together to beat K. That's my guess."
Mo Ming was a little surprised, Chen Yingjie was able to think of so much, and it was reasonable. But, she was wrong.
"Yikes! Ying Ying is really good."
Jiang Wentai's rare praise of Chen Yingjie made her blush, maybe she was still quite smart.
"Hmph, you're underestimating me too much."
"Yingjie did a beautiful job, and said what I hesitated about."
Qiu Yanzi also began to praise Chen Yingjie, which made Chen Yingjie, who is usually criticized for not liking to use her brains, a little fluttery.
"But, I can only give two points."
Jiang Wentai made a gesture of two, which made Chen Yingjie very hurt, and began to question Jiang Wentai angrily.
"Huh? Why, what's wrong?"
The senior sister, who rarely spoke, spoke.
"Yes...... There are problems, and the fourth round is two...... The two lied, and AD was the word of the prisoner...... AB's statement is wrong, then the words of the CD are all truths, but ...... But these two are contradictory."
When the senior sister suddenly said this, Chen Yingjie reacted, first of all, A said that K could prove himself and was intimidating K, so A was lying, B said that D and K had a contradiction, and C said that the prisoner was himself and D was also lying, so it was four people who lied, which was obviously wrong.
"Ugh." Chen Yingjie hung her head and became depressed, why didn't she think of this.
"Yingjie is already great, there is still room to get it back."
"Thank you, Hinata."
Feebly.
When it came to Yang Huhu, her answer was BC, she was not good at speaking in front of people, but it seems that she said a lot today, which is also a huge progress.
「AD…… They obviously know each other, and they can come out later, so in the first round, B is the truth, A is a lie, AD looks like they are together, and BC ...... BC is also in the same group, C is defending them, and in the second round, ACD is telling the truth and B is false...... Then it means that B threatens K and will hit K. Then B should be the prisoner, and C should be the accomplice, and that's it......
After Senior Sister Yang Huhu finished speaking, her face turned red, and then
Lowering her head, she didn't dare to look into everyone's eyes, in fact, she didn't have to do this, because her statement was very logical.
"Senior Sister Tiger is really good, this idea is good!"
Qiu Yanzi applauded first, and indeed only judging the first two rounds can be explained, which is a very smart approach. In the third round, no one lied, and there was no problem with the words of the key BC, and in the fourth round, it was DC who lied, so there was no problem, and it also met the conditions for the two to lie.
Chen Yingjie also felt that this kind of thinking was very smart, but she didn't expect this senior sister to be so powerful, and she couldn't help but admire it.
Jiang Wentai was also satisfied with this answer, and nodded, "4 points."
It's a good score, although it doesn't show it obviously, but the corners of the senior sister's mouth are still slightly raised, and she looks a little happy.
But this kind of meticulous answer turned out to be only 4 points, and I have to say that Jiang Wentai is very demanding.
After the three of them finished speaking, they set their eyes on Mo Ming together, Mo Ming was surrounded by these hot eyes, and obviously felt a burst of heat, wiping the sweat on his temples.
"How about turning on an air conditioner......
"Classmate Mo Ming, you can only make a request if you win."
Oh, sure enough, there is still this trick.