Chapter 168: White Horses Are Not Horses
Zhao Feng was still very angry in his heart when he saw Lu Ming ignoring him like this, but considering that An Yan was here, it was not good to say anything. Pen | fun | pavilion www. biquge。 info
The miscellaneous scholars were still sarcastic beside him, and his words were not good, but Lu Ming still didn't care.
An Yan walked to the table, raised his glass and said with a smile: "Brother Lu Xian is my Liang Guomaocai, it is an honor to be able to come to participate in the debate meeting today, and I will have a cup of respect for Brother Xian." ”
"Brother An Yan is polite, please!"
Lu Ming had no choice but to get up and pick up the wine glass, and drank it all with An Yan, which could be regarded as a hello.
An Yan looked around, and then asked Xiang Zhisheng: "Brother Xiang Xian, have all the children of the family you invited here?"
Xiang paid attention to it, judging from the current number of people, it should be basically all there, after all, there are so many famous scholars in Suzhou. ”
"Okay, now that the number of people has arrived, let's start the meeting. ”
An Yan showed a little smug on his face, and said to everyone: "Today's dialectical essay will not talk about poetry, regardless of words, only based on dialectic, I don't know which scholar will discuss with Zai Xia first?"
After the words were spoken, a long-prepared reader couldn't wait to speak: "Under Qi Wenbin, please give Brother An Yan advice." ”
"Good. ”
An Yan made a gesture and said, "Please come to the room with me to debate." ”
The two immediately came to the field, and many readers surrounded them, which was very lively.
Lu Ming is Maocai, only he stands at the front, and everyone else leans back.
"I know Qi Wenbin's literary name, he is a more talented reader of the State Academy of Literature, and he usually dabbles in dialectic, I believe this is a very wonderful literary debate. ”
"Hehe, no matter how talented Qi Wenbin is, how can he compare with An Yan of our miscellaneous family? Brother An Yan has dabbled in various genres, and it is his forte to say that this dialectic technique is his specialty. ”
"The miscellaneous family is not refining dialectics, so it may not be able to defeat Qi Wenbin. ”
"Then we'll see. ”
The surrounding chatter quickly returned to calm.
Lu Ming watched intently, faintly excited in his heart, because the famous debate of "white horses and non-horses" will be displayed in front of his eyes, on the earth, "white horses and non-horses" is a debate that has been passed down for thousands of years, and it is very famous.
An Yan pointed to the white horse in the field, and then said, "This 'white horse' is actually not a 'horse'. ”
Qi Wenbin immediately retorted: "Brother An Yan's words are wrong, if this 'horse' is not a 'horse', then why should it be called a 'white horse'?"
The reason is very simple, if we are talking about "horses", then both yellow horses and black horses can meet the requirements, and if we are talking about "white horses", then yellow horses and black horses cannot meet the requirements. ”
"If the white horse is the horse, then the 'horse' and the 'white horse' we are talking about are exactly the same, that is, if there is no difference between the 'horse' and the 'white horse', then there is no difference between the same horse and the black horse and the yellow horse, then the so-called white horse is not the yellow horse?"
"If there is no difference between a white horse and a yellow horse, then there is no difference between a yellow horse and a black horse, since there is no difference between each other, then the white horse is a yellow horse, and at the same time a black horse, then the horses in the world are all in chaos?"
"This ...... This ......"
Qi Wenbin's face changed in shock, and at the same time, sweat broke out on his forehead, and he began to think about the logic of this sentence.
"What a powerful 'white horse is not a horse', it really deserves its reputation when I see it today!"
Lu Ming was secretly frightened, even if he was mentally prepared, he was surprised by the dialectic of "white horses are not horses" at this moment.
The readers present all looked surprised, and then they turned from surprise to admiration, leaving them speechless.
"That's why I said, white horses are not horses. An Yan said with a smug smile.
"You ......"
Qi Wenbin was extremely ashamed, he didn't expect that he would fall behind from the beginning, and it was difficult to refute in the face of the "white horse not horse" debate.
Whether it is from logic or between words, it is as airtight as a hard wall, and it is difficult to refute with normal theories, which is really too clever.
"Qi Wenbin fell directly behind, the victory or defeat is very clear, An Yan's argumentation skills are really powerful, even I think that the white horse is not a horse. One said admiringly.
After a long time, Qi Wenbin said unwillingly: "If the white horse is not a horse, then what is it?"
"White horse. ”
"You...... Nonsense!"
"I heard that there are many strange people in Suzhou, but I didn't expect that there is not even a good debater, which is really disappointing. A miscellaneous scholar scoffed.
"You guys are so rampant!", many of the readers looked dissatisfied.
An Yan raised his head slightly, and sneered: "Don't waste your efforts, with your ability, you can't argue with me, so it's better to give up as soon as possible." ”
"Not necessarily, I have something to refute. ”
Qi Wenbin said with some confidence: "If it is according to your meaning, the horse is different from the horse when it has a color." But there are no colorless horses in the world, so can we say that all colored horses in the world are not horses?"
The smugness and sarcasm on An Yan's face became even stronger, and he said: "Horses are originally colored, so there are white horses, yellow horses, and black horses." If a horse has no color, it is only a "horse", how can it be called a white horse? Therefore, a white horse is different from a "horse". The so-called white horse is that the horse is limited to white, and the horse limited to white is naturally different from the horse, so I say that the white horse is not a horse. ”
The voice fell, and the scene was silent.
"Such a powerful argument, completely impeccable!"
Qi Wenbin broke out in a cold sweat, and his Wenfu began to waver, this is the great magic power of "dialectic", once it is suppressed by dialectic, the name of the text will be attacked, and even the Wenfu will be affected.
"Qi Wenbin, I heard that you are the most skilled scholar in Suzhou City, but now that you look at it, it is really just a vain, and today I will teach you how to be a person by the way. ”
"You...... You ......"
Qi Wenbin's face was flushed with anger, and the four golden words "white horse is not a horse" appeared in his mind, which made the Wenfu shake even more violently.
"Ahh
Qi Wenbin stepped back and hugged his head suddenly, looking very painful.
Seeing this, An Yan was even more proud, and said with a smile: "You have already lost, and you are not qualified to argue with me again, Suzhou scholars are just like that." ”
"You...... You...... How can you use your arguments to hit my Wenfu, how can you do this!", Qi Wenbin roared angrily.
"Because you lose, you have to bear the danger of being attacked by the name, and the more undetermined your courage is, the greater the damage. ”
"Poof!"
Qi Wenbin suddenly opened his mouth and spurted out a stream of blood, and his entire body immediately fell backwards.
"Brother Qi!"
Lu Ming was closest to him, and rushed up to support him with an arrow step, "Brother Qi, are you okay!" (To be continued.) )