"Guys, at what age did you hear the first **? What age did you tell the first **? What age did you first ** have? You can leave me without answering these questions, you just know for yourself. I just wish there wasn't "Forty Old Virgins" here. ”

Ye Wei stood up as he spoke, and the black folding chair scraped the floor with an unpleasant sizzling sound, which resounded through the full house of the appeal court.

As he spoke, a chuckle erupted in the courtroom, and the reporters couldn't help but laugh, while the 11 members of the Rating Committee (CARA) all looked ugly.

Joan Grave had a bad feeling and frowned on her old face, that kid was a prick!

Scared? I really underestimated VIY before! The reporters' pens swiped wildly, and they recorded Ye Wei's sonorous and powerful and infectious words, and public relations could not create VIY. As Harvard-Westlake School once said about Ye Wei's fight without apologizing, the school chose to understand him because he never bullied others, but others couldn't bully him......

"You laugh, I think the answer is no. We all need to face up to the fact that 'kids' over the age of 13. ”

Ye Wei obviously said sarcastically, walked out of his seat, walked to the judge's table, and turned to face everyone.

"They've heard not just **, but all kinds of swear words countless times, ↓ maybe countless times. I'm not saying that this encourages people to swear, but how dangerous can a small non-erotic f word be to them? I don't think it's as big as Cara says, probably close to zero. ”

He made a gesture of zero, looked around, and his voice became louder and louder: "Teenagers, we have long been able to understand, and even skillfully use the meaning of the word f in the context of non-eroticism, when we are angry, when we are free, when we have something that cannot be expressed in ordinary words, we say **." It's a fact. I'm a teenager ......"

"You're not an ordinary teenager!"

Suddenly, a member of the parent committee interrupted excitedly, a thin middle-aged white man, his long face was a little red. Joan Grave didn't stop him from interrupting. He stood up and scolded angrily: "Ye Wei can't represent an ordinary teenager, he's a ...... Prodigy. ”

There was another burst of laughter in the courtroom, and the reporters, Price, and others laughed, and even some of the members of the grievance committee laughed, and although it was funny, this rebuttal argument was not bad.

"Thank you, please don't interrupt me, okay?" Ye Wei didn't smile, his expression became even more cold, he glanced at the cara people, and continued: "Yes, I'm not ordinary! Maybe I'm very smart in some way, but people are definitely not that stupid." That gentleman, didn't you say a ** when you were 13?"

"I don't know what you're talking about. "That skinny parent is sassy.

Joan-Grave raised her hand, and after the judge agreed, she said, "The rating is not based on whether we have said it or not, but on whether it should or should not be, and what impact it will have." It is precisely because there are more and more swear words among young people that we must strictly manage and improve this incorrect atmosphere. ”

"Well said. Ye Wei pointed to Madam Chairman and said without pause: "I want to say some facts, please don't interrupt me, think seriously about what the situation is." ”

Watching him walk back to the table and pick up a document and materials, and ask Secretary Cindy to distribute materials to the committee members, the reporters' eyes lit up, here!

All members of the MPAA felt that dangerous aura......

"How lenient is the MPAA's rating for violence? I'm sure there's been enough talk in recent times that I'm not going to talk about it. ”

Ye Wei raised the document in his hand, and while walking a few steps, he spoke:

"I'm just talking about one case that very few people talk about. Not far from now, the 2003 independent film "Ice and Snow Warriors". There is no ** in the film, not even sex, only a scene of the brutal war, a German soldier rapes a French woman, but the whole scene is only expressed with minimal violence, which has absolutely nothing to do with sex, unless you are a pervert. Just because of this scene, CARA rated R!"

He said as he looked at Cara and spoke louder: "In the end, the studios 'Medal of Honor' and 'Forward Films' had to cut a lot of scenes, including that scene, to get the PG-13 rating. And the violence that is more severe than it and has no artistic significance, when it appears in a big studio movie, you don't think it has any effect on teenagers. ”

During his pause, there was a moment of awkward silence in the courtroom, the members of the MPAA frowned, and Joan-Grave's forehead was slightly sweaty......

In the silent reading of the materials by the members of the appeal committee, and in the excited shorthand recording of the reporters, Ye Wei continued:

"If you say you like violence, you don't like the so-called erotic, the so-called profanity! Then let's look at another case, 2000's 'Screaming,' a Disney syndicate movie, the MPAA review was 'strong rude sexual humor, speech, drug use, and violence,' including ejaculation-ejaculation, penis erection! Is a reasonable rating correct?"

Ye Wei paused, just a angry "no!", walked around and looked around at everyone, and said:

"1997's Father Hala High to Heaven, an independent film, was also a spoof and only got an NC-17 rating because of what you call 'explicit erotic content and dialogue'. But from these materials, you can see that it is not too much than "Scream", in fact, "Scream" is even better!"

He flipped through the text in his hand, "Look at this, there are a lot of f-words, a lot of sexual innuendo, one is a clear erotic-erotic dialogue, the other is strong sexual humor, all have nudity, "Scream" has all kinds of sexuality, while "Father Hala High to the Sky" does not, "Scream" has penis, and "Father Hala High to Heaven" has a-penis...... What the hell is this?"

Ye Wei looked stunned, looked at the members of the appeal committee, looked at the reporters, "Fake penis is erotic, real penis is sexual humor? Why? As a person with a real penis, I don't understand, is it who thinks that their penis is not as easy to associate with eroticism as a fake one?"

Both men and women, the reporters burst into laughter, and the faces of the unidentified parents were really ugly......

"I'm sorry, maybe it's because I'm a little too big to understand the peanuts. ”

For a while, everyone laughed even more happily! Judge De Rohrer, who was a little angry and black-faced, shouted: "Mr. Ye, please respect the court and stop using foul language!"

"Your Excellency, it's just humorous, oh no...... I'm an independent filmmaker, so it's erotic-erotic. Ye Wei shrugged, making the laughter in the courtroom unstoppable.

"You're talking penis and saying f words again and again, isn't it erotic?" another middle-aged woman's parent interrupted angrily, "I will never let my child talk like you, your family, your school will be disgraced because of you!"

"Don't interrupt me, okay? I'm pretty sure your child is disgraced by you. ”

Ye Wei shook his head and laughed, as if mocking something, knocked on one of the texts in his hand, and said loudly: "Because, the producer, screenwriter and director of "Father Hara High to the Sky" Cui Parker and Matt Stone, they are the founders of "South Park", their 1999 film version of "South Park" is much more forbidden than "Father Hara High to Heaven", just because its film company is Paramount, after several modifications, it has been downgraded from NC-17 to R! Father Hala High Heaven" is much stricter. ”

"'Common vulgar language and rude sexual humor, as well as some violent images', look, sexual humor again. By the way, there are-penis sex toys in the film, but they are not erotic. Unbelievable? A record 399 swearing! Unbelievable?

Choi Parker, Matt Stone, these two conscientious filmmakers, they still think it's ridiculous! ”

Ye Wei's finger slid and pointed to the lower position of the text on this page, supported by the signatures of the two people.

"What's the explanation for these things, what does the MPAA explain? Ms. Grave, what does the CARA explain. I sincerely ask why there is such a radical difference in treatment?"

The courtroom had fallen silent, and under the attention of the audience, Ye Wei approached the cara crowd, and his soft voice was like a student asking the teacher: "Didn't you say influence? Everyone knows that big-studio films have a more complete and powerful distribution than independent films, and they will be seen by more people, and their influence will be greater."

Why!? All this massive, massive material says the same answer: because you're not fair!"

In the ugly faces of the cara people, Ye Wei put the document in his hand back on the table and picked up another copy. At this time, the skinny male head suddenly interrupted again: "The boundary between R class and NC-17 class is different from R class and PG-13 class......"

"I said, don't interrupt me!**-you!" Ye Wei Huo Ran scolded. The whole courtroom was ablaze, the parents trembled with anger, and Judge De Rohrer shouted, "Mr. Ye!" Ye Wei spread his hands, "I just used the word f once, which of you is connected to sex? You? Maybe you? How do you have to be?"

The light laughter of the reporters started again, and the skinny male patriarch was about to rush out to fight with Ye Wei, but Joan-Grave reached out and whispered to persuade him......

The appeals court seemed to have become Ye Wei's personal stage, he raised the thick material, and said: "These are called debatable rating discrimination, not only collected by me, but also collected by many people, filmmakers, film critics and ordinary audiences. Everyone hopes that this turmoil is an end and a www.biquge.info of Biqu Pavilion, the last. ”

Syndy, the secretary, handed out new materials to the appeals committee, and Ye Wei walked a few steps back and forth in front of the judge's desk, and continued: "One of the arguments on Cara's lips these days is 'Ye Wei lacks understanding of us, he's talking nonsense, he doesn't know that the total score is just a reference', yes, I lack understanding, but why?"

He looked back at the judge, then at Joan-Grave and the others, "because you have never published a complete grading manual, and it is not even clear how many times you can use the erotic-erotic term in a non-erotic context. In other words, the so-called regulations, standards, and scales can be determined at any time according to your wishes!

We want to see the full grading manual! Where is it? I guess you don't know where it is!"

Cara was speechless, and now Joan Grave couldn't say anything, it was true that the full version had not been released, and the MPAA was still debating whether to release it......

"You always say standards, standards, standards, but these materials show that the MPAA lacks standards consistency. In big-studio films, the scale of this standard is noticeably looser, while in independent films, the scale is surprisingly harsh.

You always say flexible, flexible, flexible, but you're flexible to make the big studios lucky and the independent studios embarrassed! What is Cara after? What is MPAA after?"

Ye Wei put the document back on the table, his face showing disdainful coldness: "I don't know either." But I know, and a lot of people know, it's definitely not the physical and mental health of children, definitely. You always claim to be the patron saint of your children, do you dare to tell your children what you actually do?

When I was very young, one day I was walking down the road and another kid kicked me from behind for no reason, and I beat him up and beat him up badly.

I was the last person to be punished, and he didn't do anything. Since then, I have known that this is not a fair world and that you don't want to be bullied, you have to be tough. Because the guy has been around since when he sees me. ”

Saying this, Ye Wei looked at the media reporters and said in a calm tone: "So what I said just today, and even used the word F, is to refute a hypocritical posture of MPAA, that is, they are completely correct and just." This is not true, just now Ms. Grave's words, to put it mildly, are a bunch of nonsense. Now you can tell. ”

Before he finished speaking, before the judge or anyone could say anything, there was a sudden round of applause in the courtroom, and the reporters were all applauding excitedly, sending Ye Wei the greatest applause of support!

Price, Arndt and others were also laughing and clapping, and Peter Heller, who had been present on the first two appeals, exhaled a long breath, which was really relieved!

Solicitor Salton suddenly felt that if he had to be a lawyer, he would definitely be a barrister......

"Quiet, quiet!" Judge De Rohrer hurriedly shouted, and the 11 members of the rating committee all frowned, while many of the members of the appeal committee fell into deep thought.

It took a while for the applause to finally stop, and Joan Grave's face was almost dead, and the media was not invited to watch and report on how the MPAA was so deplorable by a 17-year-old kid......

Her previous words and MPAA's biggest foothold in this turmoil were all severely shattered by Ye Wei, and any more standards would only appear more corrupt and corrupt. That sex talk!

Thinking of something, Joan Grave raised her hand first, stood up and said, "No matter what Ye Wei says, his materials are very subjective, and he doesn't take into account the actual degree of danger......"

Ye Wei, who was leaning against the judge's table over there, raised his hand, but did not interrupt without saying anything. Grave continued: "Each movie has a different degree of danger for the same expletive sentence because of the different story background, content, atmosphere, etc., and the specific value needs to be evaluated by those of us who are experienced. ”

When she paused, Ye Weicai said: "This is another self-contradiction of CARA, and it means that it all depends on what you think, and you never make mistakes." ”

"We're a group of experienced practitioners!" Joan Grave's words became louder and stricter, "We don't never make mistakes, we were wrong in the rating of 'Exorcism Video' this year, and we quickly corrected it." ”

Ye Wei shook his head and smiled, "That's another unjust case." ”

"We're not wrong with giving "Little Sunshine Beauty" an R rating, just saying that the bad sexual talk in the film has the nature of teaching and indoctrination, and it should never be accepted by teenagers. ”

As soon as Grave finished speaking, the parents around her spoke, some calm and some angry: "Because the film has two A-grade stars starring, we have reason to believe that LMS will have a certain influence, especially for immature teenagers." "It's encouraging people to around, it's bad!", "It's not the right ethos orientation. ”......

After they all finished speaking, Ye Wei said calmly: "Now I invite you to take a look at what that sexual talk is all about." ”

Cindy, the secretary, distributed the documents, and the grievance committee members consulted them, which is a scene from the driving scene of LMS No. 29, which was filmed as a text version of the current version of the video:

[Grandpa (to Di Wynne): Can I give you some construction? (Di Wynn shakes his head) Anyway, I'm going to sue you. I don't want you to make the mistakes I made when I was younger.

Richard: Can't wait to hear from you.

Grandpa: Dee Wynne. That's your name, isn't it? Dewyan? That's what people have told you about it. Did you hear that? (Dewynn nods) Boy, a few more women. Don't just one woman, but many women.

Richard: Hey, that's enough! Dad!

Grandpa (continuing to face Dwyan): Do you understand? Tell me, do you understand? (Dwyanne shakes his head) No, Jesus, how old are you, 15 years old, oh my God, you should enjoy the things that only young people have. That's the most wonderful thing in the world!

Richard: Alright, Dad, that's enough!

Grandpa: Can you not interrupt me?!!(to Dwyan) Listen, now you're a minor, and they're a minor. Once you're 18 years old...... Man, then something will happen. Oh my God, you're still talking about 3 to 5 years old!

Richard: Dad, shut up, shut up now! You're talking nonsense again, I'm going to stop......

Grandpa: Then you just stop! Don't want me to stop talking, **-you! I'm 80 years old, I can say whatever I want. I still have Nazi bullets in my ass. 】

After waiting for a while, Ye Wei read it to all the reporters again, and then said: "Michael is the screenwriter of the film, and he is here today, let's listen to what he has to say." ”

"Hello everyone. Michael Arndt, who was sitting there, stood up and explained to the crowd: "The purpose of this dialogue is all to create the character of Grandpa, who is a very casual old hippie, and what he wants to express is that young people want to enjoy their youth, and nothing else." ”

Ye Wei looked at the members of the appeal committee, took over and said: "This is a clear farce, in fact, no one is listening to grandpa's nonsense." ”

At the same time, under the operation of Secretari Cindy and court staff, a large wall-mounted screen on the wall behind the judge's desk played the full scene number 29 of the film. The reporters only thought it was interesting when they saw it, and the shooting was fantastic, and Alan Akin's performance even suppressed the whole car.

"Can this be called indoctrination? 13-17-year-olds don't have their own ideas? A hippie says, 'Hey, let's it,' and you listen? And we're all aware of the fact that people over 13 already know what sex is. It doesn't matter who teaches, the playboy still fucks around, and the nerd doesn't even have a girl. It's a fact!"

Ye Wei spread his hands and continued to argue: "And we have to pay attention to one thing, Richard is preventing grandpa from speaking throughout the scene, Di Wynn didn't show the slightest interest, and the others are either not listening or laughing. My director's intention was that Grandpa was half right, his attitude was right, and his approach was wrong, so in the later plot he died of a drug overdose. This is a clear and definite punishment! How can this scene and this dialogue have anything to do with eroticism and indoctrination of erroneous ideas?"

The grievance committee members were expressionless, the reporters were busy with stenographing, and the cara crowd was once again a little speechless.

If this continues, public opinion will be over, and Joan Grave tried her best to pull it back: "The character of grandpa is not a villain, it will make teenagers like him, and even regard him as an idol, in this case, grandpa's words will have a teaching indoctrination, which will cause a strict zhòng impact." ”

"Really, it seems that you have changed your mind again, and 'some moderate sexual talk' has become 'some strict zhòng obscene sexual talk', how about it?"

Ye Wei's joke made the laughter rise again, and he looked at the cara crowd, "You are 11 people now, and there are about 10-20 people when the film is reviewed and rated, right?"

He walked back to the table and picked up the laptop on the table, while Syndy, the secretary, handed out materials to the Appeals Commissioners, and he showed a saved web page:

"Recently I started an online petition campaign for the LG-13 rating of LMS, and I put this so-called sexual talk as a one-minute clip. Even if it's not the full version, people can see what kind of character Grandpa is and what kind of drama it is.

In less than half a month, we have received more than 100,000 signatures, and the number is still increasing rapidly! Of these 100,000 people, more than 35% are adult parents, and they don't think this conversation has a problem with MPAA rating, and there are even many comments that it is positive, because Dewyn is not normal at first glance, and he needs this kind of teaching. ”

100,000 people petitioned! The reporters almost cheered and applauded, and the media paid attention to this matter for some days, and Ye Wei finally came up with the one-sided public opinion!

This is simply a fatal blow to Cara!

"This ......" Joan Grave's face seemed to be older, and the green lady's suit was lined like a wasteland.

The parents didn't know what to say for a while, and she had to refute it: "The Internet is full of falsehoods, a child can pretend to be an adult, a person can sign ten names, these petitions have no reference value, they have no experience in ratings." ”

"Seriously, is the so-called rating experience really there?" Ye Wei was not excited, but his face was full of seriousness, and a flame burned in his eyes, "For our 100,000 petitions, you say that they are false without investigation and evidence, and you say that they are subjective for others to treat the facts differently with a large amount of evidence." You're up to you to say everything, right?"

Ye Wei looked at the grievance committee members, reporters, team members, judges and others, "I want to quote a passage from "Twelve Angry Men". ”

He pursed his lips, with a little hope, and said softly: "In the face of this kind of thing, it is really difficult to eliminate personal prejudice. No matter where you go, prejudice always obscures the truth. I don't know what the truth is, and no one should know what the truth is. Maybe we were wrong and no one knew. But we have reasonable suspicion that it is something very precious in our justice system. ”

Hearing these words, the reporters couldn't help but be moved, and several members of the appeal committee were also obviously moved, and the people on the other side were embarrassed and silent.

"More than 100,000 of us think it's wrong to give 'Little Sunshine Beauty' an R rating, why are you 10-20 people so sure it's right?"

Ye Wei withdrew his gaze from the cara crowd, looked at the grievance committee members, and said heartily: "I hope that this court-like place will really have the spirit of pursuing truth and the flash of humanity." Even if it's just a little bit, then it can be a very good thing. Thank you. ”

When he said that, there was silence in the hall, and then suddenly, deafening applause resounded through the courtroom, and there was a can't help but applaud!

"Well said!", "Please, give LMSPG-13 class!", "Viy, you're not alone!"

Praeley, Arndt, Peter Heller, Attorney Salton, and others also gave a standing ovation, and all of them couldn't help but have some expectations of winning the case......

As long as 12 of the 18 grievance committee members vote to overrule the R-rating, "Little Sunshine Beauty" can be released at the PG-13 rating without changing the rules.

And in this rating turmoil, public opinion and public opinion win, MPAA loses, independent filmmakers win, MPAA loses, justice wins, MPAA loses. Let's take a look at what that sexual talk is all about. ”

Cindy, the secretary, distributed the documents, and the grievance committee members consulted them, which is a scene from the driving scene of LMS No. 29, which was filmed as a text version of the current version of the video:

[Grandpa (to Di Wynne): Can I give you some construction? (Di Wynn shakes his head) Anyway, I'm going to sue you. I don't want you to make the mistakes I made when I was younger.

Richard: Can't wait to hear from you.

Grandpa: Dee Wynne. That's your name, isn't it? Dewyan? That's what people have told you about it. Did you hear that? (Dewynn nods) Boy, a few more women. Don't just one woman, but many women.

Richard: Hey, that's enough! Dad!

Grandpa (continuing to face Dwyan): Do you understand? Tell me, do you understand? (Dwyanne shakes his head) No, Jesus, how old are you, 15 years old, oh my God, you should enjoy the things that only young people have. That's the most wonderful thing in the world!

Richard: Alright, Dad, that's enough!

Grandpa: Can you not interrupt me?!!(to Dwyan) Listen, now you're a minor, and they're a minor. Once you're 18 years old...... Man, then something will happen. Oh my God, you're still talking about 3 to 5 years old!

Richard: Dad, shut up, shut up now! You're talking nonsense again, I'm going to stop......

Grandpa: Then you just stop! Don't want me to stop talking, **-you! I'm 80 years old, I can say whatever I want. I still have Nazi bullets in my ass. 】

After waiting for a while, Ye Wei read it to all the reporters again, and then said: "Michael is the screenwriter of the film, and he is here today, let's listen to what he has to say." ”

"Hello everyone. Michael Arndt, who was sitting there, stood up and explained to the crowd: "The purpose of this dialogue is all to create the character of Grandpa, who is a very casual old hippie, and what he wants to express is that young people want to enjoy their youth, and nothing else." ”

Ye Wei looked at the members of the appeal committee, took over and said: "This is a clear farce, in fact, no one is listening to grandpa's nonsense." ”

At the same time, under the operation of Secretari Cindy and court staff, a large wall-mounted screen on the wall behind the judge's desk played the full scene number 29 of the film. The reporters only thought it was interesting when they saw it, and the shooting was fantastic, and Alan Akin's performance even suppressed the whole car.

"Can this be called indoctrination? 13-17-year-olds don't have their own ideas? A hippie says, 'Hey, let's it,' and you listen? And we're all aware of the fact that people over 13 already know what sex is. It doesn't matter who teaches, the playboy still fucks around, and the nerd doesn't even have a girl. It's a fact!"

Ye Wei spread his hands and continued to argue: "And we have to pay attention to one thing, Richard is preventing grandpa from speaking throughout the scene, Di Wynn didn't show the slightest interest, and the others are either not listening or laughing. My director's intention was that Grandpa was half right, his attitude was right, and his approach was wrong, so in the later plot he died of a drug overdose. This is a clear and definite punishment! How can this scene and this dialogue have anything to do with eroticism and indoctrination of erroneous ideas?"

The grievance committee members were expressionless, the reporters were busy with stenographing, and the cara crowd was once again a little speechless.

If this continues, public opinion will be over, and Joan Grave tried her best to pull it back: "The character of grandpa is not a villain, it will make teenagers like him, and even regard him as an idol, in this case, grandpa's words will have a teaching indoctrination, which will cause a strict zhòng impact." ”

"Really, it seems that you have changed your mind again, and 'some moderate sexual talk' has become 'some strict zhòng obscene sexual talk', how about it?"

Ye Wei's joke made the laughter rise again, and he looked at the cara crowd, "You are 11 people now, and there are about 10-20 people when the film is reviewed and rated, right?"

He walked back to the table and picked up the laptop on the table, while Syndy, the secretary, handed out materials to the Appeals Commissioners, and he showed a saved web page:

"Recently I started an online petition campaign for the LG-13 rating of LMS, and I put this so-called sexual talk as a one-minute clip. Even if it's not the full version, people can see what kind of character Grandpa is and what kind of drama it is.

In less than half a month, we have received more than 100,000 signatures, and the number is still increasing rapidly! Of these 100,000 people, more than 35% are adult parents, and they don't think this conversation has a problem with MPAA rating, and there are even many comments that it is positive, because Dewyn is not normal at first glance, and he needs this kind of teaching. ”

100,000 people petitioned! The reporters almost cheered and applauded, and the media paid attention to this matter for some days, and Ye Wei finally came up with the one-sided public opinion!

This is simply a fatal blow to Cara!

"This ......" Joan Grave's face seemed to be older, and the green lady's suit was lined like a wasteland.

The parents didn't know what to say for a while, and she had to refute it: "The Internet is full of falsehoods, a child can pretend to be an adult, a person can sign ten names, these petitions have no reference value, they have no experience in ratings." ”

"Seriously, is the so-called rating experience really there?" Ye Wei was not excited, but his face was full of seriousness, and a flame burned in his eyes, "For our 100,000 petitions, you say that they are false without investigation and evidence, and you say that they are subjective for others to treat the facts differently with a large amount of evidence." You're up to you to say everything, right?"

Ye Wei looked at the grievance committee members, reporters, team members, judges and others, "I want to quote a passage from "Twelve Angry Men". ”

He pursed his lips, with a little hope, and said softly: "In the face of this kind of thing, it is really difficult to eliminate personal prejudice. No matter where you go, prejudice always obscures the truth. I don't know what the truth is, and no one should know what the truth is. Maybe we were wrong and no one knew. But we have reasonable suspicion that it is something very precious in our justice system. ”

Hearing these words, the reporters couldn't help but be moved, and several members of the appeal committee were also obviously moved, and the people on the other side were embarrassed and silent.

"More than 100,000 of us think it's wrong to give 'Little Sunshine Beauty' an R rating, why are you 10-20 people so sure it's right?"

Ye Wei withdrew his gaze from the cara crowd, looked at the grievance committee members, and said heartily: "I hope that this court-like place will really have the spirit of pursuing truth and the flash of humanity." Even if it's just a little bit, then it can be a very good thing. Thank you. ”

When he said that, there was silence in the hall, and then suddenly, deafening applause resounded through the courtroom, and there was a can't help but applaud!

"Well said!", "Please, give LMSPG-13 class!", "Viy, you're not alone!"

Praeley, Arndt, Peter Heller, Attorney Salton, and others also gave a standing ovation, and all of them couldn't help but have some expectations of winning the case......

As long as 12 of the 18 grievance committee members vote to overrule the R-rating, "Little Sunshine Beauty" can be released at the PG-13 rating without changing the rules.

And in this rating turmoil, public opinion and public opinion win, MPAA loses, independent filmmakers win, MPAA loses, justice wins, MPAA loses.