Shen Qingming completed the temptation of Gongsun Chang between the words and swords just now. Gongsun Chang's thinking logic was slightly biased just now, confusing the abolition of the death penalty with the price of justice, which was what he wanted to see the most.

At this moment, his forehead began to feel a pain, and beads of sweat the size of beans dripped on the platform.

Surrounding.... It's just too noisy. Even Gongsun Chang's breathing was harsh. The train of thought that had just been coherent was interrupted at once, and the inspiration disappeared in an instant.

Shen Qingming was stunned for a moment: "I..... I do not rely on the death penalty to show the dignity of justice. The death penalty is only an effective means, not a necessity. ”

Gongsun Chang raised his head slightly, looked at Shen Qingming with a dumb attitude, and looked at the hairs in Shen Qingming's heart.

Shen Qingming glanced at Gongsun Chang with a weak heart, and found that there was a touch of determination on the corner of Gongsun Chang's mouth, which was a kind of determination to kill first and then quickly. He said, "What are you laughing at? If you have something to say, you will abstain if you have nothing to say." ”

"The death penalty has an irreplaceable deterrent effect, like a nuclear bomb. If there was no death penalty as a final deterrent, can you imagine how far the crime rate would have increased?" Gongsun said, "It is the existence of the death penalty that makes the murderers feel a distant deterrent when they do evil." This deterrent reminds thieves not to hurt their owners with knives, reminds drug dealers how dangerous the world they live in, and reminds those who want to commit crimes that there is a final bottom line in this world. ”

A brilliant counterattack, this kind of sentence can greatly strengthen the weight of the argument in the referee's heart in practical application. At the same time, it deepens the impression score of the topic held by Gongsun Chang on the referee's side.

Shen Qingming smiled, and said in his heart that he had successfully lured the topic into his trap. He immediately pointed out: "It is a big mistake! It is not that the death penalty has a deterrent effect, but that death has a deterrent effect. ”

"Huh?" Gongsun Chang didn't understand what he was trying to say, "Is there any difference between the two?"

"The key to the death penalty is punishment. The deterrent power of the death penalty stems from the endorsement of the country's laws, not death. The deterrence of the law is far more important than the deterrence of death. Shen Qingming said, "Especially now, civilized society. ”

"There are prison sentences for theft and robbery, and detention for petty fights, which are all deterrents of the law. Why is there no greater deterrent effect than the death penalty? Aren't they all backed by the law?" Gongsun Chang did not give in, and immediately retorted, "In the final analysis, isn't it because death is more deterrent than other forms of punishment?"

The headache struck again, and Shen Qingming's mind went blank. In a trance, it is like a lack of oxygen, and when you think intensely, it is indeed easy to produce such a situation.

After this distraction, Shen Qingming began to think of some other things. I'm in here now, I don't know how long it's been, and I don't know what happened to the three of them in Xiling? Did they successfully pass the Jedi of the Heart? If they didn't pass, what would be the situation now?

"Hey, hey, why are you distracted again? If not, just admit defeat honestly. Gongsun Chang urged impatiently.

Shen Qingming pumped his mouth, trying to make himself more sober. "There is no direct connection between the two, and the death penalty does not affect the crime rate," he gritted his teeth and said. The key to influencing the crime rate is the environment of society, not the horror of death. Isn't it a practical example of the fact that the death penalty cannot affect the crime rate in the Nordic countries, which have abolished the death penalty, but their crime rates are much lower than in other countries where the death penalty is available?"

"The example you gave lacks sufficient data? There are only a few people in the Nordic countries? The land is vast and sparsely populated and the resources are abundant, so naturally they lack the motivation to take risks, but how many countries have their situation?" Gongsun Changwei said with a clear thought, "And what the Nordic countries can do, can other regions do it?

Shen Qingming's attack was smoothly blocked by Gongsun, and he also threw himself a big problem.

He adjusted his breathing and decided that Gongsun would decide to win or lose in the debate.

Gongsun said: "The core of this problem is whether the essence of criminal law is education or punishment. I argue that the essence of criminal law is punishment, and education is an additional attribute. ”

Shen Qingming objected, saying: "On the contrary, the essence of criminal law is to educate people again. Otherwise, why would there be a reprieve?"

Gongsun sneered: "It is undeniable that the law also has the role of educating people, but education is also after the punishment is completed." ”

"Both happen at the same time. Shen Qingming was unwavering, "You yourself said that late justice is not justice, and the punishment or education that is also late has no original meaning!"

"As you can see, the death penalty is the punishment of death row inmates, so that death row inmates understand that the way of heaven is clear, retribution is unpleasant, and everyone has to pay the price for what they have done, which is to educate them. Who said that education must give people the opportunity to regret?" Gongsun Chang stared into Shen Qingming's eyes and said, "You just said that the two should happen at the same time, right? Punishment and education were indeed carried out at the same time during the death penalty, but those death row inmates were not given the opportunity to cry bitterly and repent to outsiders. ”

Shen Qingming was speechless.

Gongsun Chang immediately took advantage of the victory to pursue: "Stop your hypocritical sympathy, have you ever thought about why death row prisoners were sentenced to death? You just want to see the scene of the death row prisoners when they repent, and you don't think about the tragic situation of those who died, right?"

Shen Qingming was just about to say something, but suddenly his mind went blank, and his feet were soft, just like stepping on cotton. He opened his mouth, but he couldn't say anything.

"I'm against ......," Shen Qingming's words just came out of his mouth when he fainted on the platform.

By the time he woke up, he couldn't tell how long he had been lying. I only knew that I was already on the same level as Gongsun Chang, and when I looked down, I could already feel the scorching heat of the fire in the fog.

"Angry?" Gongsun Chang said leisurely on the side, "It seems that your psychological quality needs to be improved, if you faint next time, you should do BBQ in the fire." ”

Shen Qingming forced himself to get up and said, "My meat is definitely not delicious when grilled, if I can get out alive, I will consider burning some skewers for you." ”

"I'm not a dead man, what's the use of you going to my grave?" Gongsun Chang relaxed and smiled on his face, "I'm just a projection of you, if you think of me, be kind to yourself." ”

Shen Qingming nodded.

"Like getting yourself a girlfriend or something. Gongsun Chang smiled and said, "It's not a very excessive request, is it?"

"It's excessive!"