In the end, it was Gongsun Chang who was the first to speak, saying, "Fish can swim and birds can fly, and this is because they have such a nature in their nature. So why should people be taught to do good deeds and be good people? is because we believe that there is goodness in human nature. If there is no goodness in human nature, then how can we be enlightened to understand what is good and what is evil? Even if our nature is evil, then who will teach us to be good people, and will it be the inherently evil people who will teach us how to be good people? Why should they teach us? What motives do they have? Can we trust him? Would you doubt that your parents and teachers were planning to teach you to be kind to others? In the same way, why is the social attribute of human beings acquired, not nature? The social nature of human beings means that people can be taught, people have good roots, and people have good ends, so isn't this the nature of people?"

Shen Qingming smiled happily and said, "It seems that the first attack is not suitable at any time?"

"Who made me the first to attack?" Gongsun sighed helplessly, "I can only see the move." ”

There are still many differences between polemics and brawls, in the process of fighting, the first attacking side can always maintain the first-hand advantage, and the polemic is not so simple, everyone has to speak according to the round, in other words, if the attacker is sharp, he can suppress the opponent to fight back breathlessly, if the attack is weak, it will allow the opponent to find an opportunity to fight back while defending, resulting in the two sides attacking and defending in a different position. This time, Gongsun's speech was not strong enough, and it was a good opportunity to turn the situation around.

"It's a big mistake, Gongsun, even if people are taught to do good deeds and be good people, they will still do bad things. In the past few decades, Gongsun, have you not done a single bad thing? Growing up in a good environment and living under a good education, everyone has more or less evil behavior, isn't this an important argument for the inherent evil of human nature?" Shen Qingming shook his finger exaggeratedly, and said in a condescending tone, "You said that evil comes from the outside world, but if the egg is not sewn, will the flies bite it? So there is still an internal reason for evil." The origin of human civilization is not counted from the birth of morality, but from the time of the emergence of law. Only the law of violence can restrain man's own evil. A society without law and only morality, a society without restraining man's inherent evil, is doomed to ruin. ”

The counterattack just now was very powerful. Not only did he complete the logical counterattack, but he also used Gongsun Chang's personal attack question just now to get stuck in Gongsun Chang's vital point. No matter how he answered, he was asking for trouble.

Gongsun fell silent, and Shen Qingming secretly counted for almost a minute. He then spoke: "The origin of your human civilization is nothing more than your hypothesis, and there is no basis at all, and I will not answer this indefinite answer." I also want to ask you, if you insist that human nature is evil, then why do good deeds still happen in this world?"

Shen Qingming shrugged his shoulders, snickering uncontrollably on his face. The essence of the polemic is not to persuade the opponent to surrender obediently, but to win the approval of the referee.

Speaking of this referee..... Shen Qingming thought worriedly, does the Jedi of the Heart really have the same emotions as humans?

Putting this aside for the time being, as long as this problem is not solved logically, it will be buried in the heart of the referee and become a plus point, and become an important means to defeat the inherent goodness of human nature.

Shen Qingming said righteously: "The education of the day after tomorrow makes people good. It is not a shame to recognize that human nature is inherently evil, just as it is to recognize that our ancestors were monkeys from East Africa. What should really be reflected on is to face the truth without daring to face it. The journey of progress in our society is the path of continuous improvement in the face of our own shortcomings. ”

Gongsun asked: "If human nature is evil, then why do people have a good heart, and why are they .....?"

Shen Qingming directly interrupted him and said, "I won't keep repeating the superfluous words! ”

"The acquired environment?" Gongsun smiled, "If the evil nature of human nature is established, then doing evil is just taking advantage of the trend, why should the acquired environment be corrected and the law intervenes?"

Shen Qingming really didn't think about this problem, and was stunned for a moment. The mind is racing, and the day after tomorrow is ..... Environment..... Good and evil?

Gongsun is a very critical thinker and never steps into the trap he has set. Can you take advantage of that, trap him with a trap he has set himself?

If you think so, there is indeed a slight chance of defeating him!

"Why, is there nothing to say?" Gongsun glanced at him appreciatively, "but you have worked hard beyond my imagination, and you are an opponent worthy of being taken seriously." ”

A smile appeared on the corner of Shen Qingming's mouth. Gongsun observed his smile suspiciously.

"It's not over yet. Shen Qingming said.

Gongsun said coldly: "Then let the horse come." ”

"You seem to think that the harsh environment in the outside world will affect people to become bad, right?" Shen Qingming confirmed. 、

Gongsun nodded. "May I ask if in the Jedi, in the environment of nine deaths and one life, will people become bad?"

Gongsun keenly sensed Shen Qingming's trap and said, "Don't induce questions to make wrong assumptions. My proposition is that human nature is inherently good, and that in good circumstances it will develop into good, and in bad circumstances it will degenerate into evil. ”

Shen Qingming said: "According to what you said, human nature is inherently good. Wouldn't it be nice to find a sunny place with plenty of rain and let them grow freely? Why do you need to educate them the day after tomorrow? That's what you said, in a good place, people will automatically become good, right?"

This blow hit Gongsun Chang's logical core. To fight back on this will only push to the arguments he has worked so hard to erect. There is no difference between not rebutting and admitting defeat on the spot.

"I think .....," Gongsun Changqiang said in high spirits, "I think there is a ...... in your point of view."

"Enough!" Shen Qingming snapped, "The winner has been decided!"

The high platform under Gongsun Chang's feet sank in response, falling straight to a height of one-half, only a person's height away from the burning flames, and there was a feeling of falling into the flames at any time.

Shen Qingming stood on it, looked at Gongsun Chang condescendingly, and said, "How is it? How does it feel to lose a game? ”

Gongsun Chang was not angry, and said lightly: "The radical method is useless to me. ”

Shen Qingming sighed for a moment, and said with a smile: "How about it? Are you ready to play the second game now?" I can't wait. ”

Gongsun Chang took a deep breath and said, "Let the horse come." ”