After watching all the photos and videos, the experts returned to their respective positions, and Chen Dingxing said: "I don't know how everyone watched, do you need to play it back?"

Everyone shook their heads.

Those who do identification can often make judgments from one or two details, and many things are even more familiar with them, and they can distinguish seven seven or eight at a glance.

The broadcast just now,Almost all the details have been presented.,If you don't make a judgment on this.,It's the same result to play it again.。

Chen Dingxing said: "Then let's start with Professor Chen and ask for opinions." ”

Chen Huanzhi, a senior professor of art appraisal and auction at the Department of Fine Arts of Fandu University, and an advisory member of the Sin Chew Art Industry Association, enjoys great prestige in the art appraisal industry of Fandu.

Chen Huanzhi took a sip of tea first, and then said slowly: "Although I can't see the real body, I can still make a preliminary judgment from the photos and videos just now." In my opinion, this calligraphy work has been inherited in an orderly manner, is well preserved, has been clearly recorded in history, and has been evaluated by many critics, so there is no doubt that it is the authentic work of Wang Zhi. ”

Chen Dingxing smiled from ear to ear, and said continuously: "Thank you, Professor Chen!"

Then there is Gong Zhongxia, deputy director of the Fandu Museum, an expert in calligraphy and painting appraisal, and currently serves as a guest on the Fandu TV [Heirloom] program, known as "Gong Yiyan", which means that any fake can be judged at a glance.

Gong Zhongxia said: "This work is first of all inherited in an orderly manner, and every time the owner is changed, there is a detailed historical record. Please take a look at these Tibetan seals and inscriptions, including Mi Yuanzhang, Tang Wenming, Wang Jinxiang, He Yannian, Zhao Guishou and even Emperor Xuan of the previous dynasty. After Emperor Xuan, this work was left behind, and there is still a detailed inheritance, and it is certain that this is a genuine work with a very clear origin!"

Chen Dingxing's face blossomed happily, of course he hoped that this was a genuine product.

Once the record is set, it will not only mean a large amount of commission income, but also the fame of the Star Family, and even if it can't catch up with Harvest, at least it can break with Gao Nabao.

The next experts expressed their opinions one by one, and everyone generally agreed that this was a genuine product.

Twelve years ago, before this calligraphy work was auctioned by Harvest, 20 experts were also invited to appraise it, and the results were exactly the same.

Now, there should be no problem, Chen Dingxing is very satisfied.

At this moment, someone said: "Ladies and gentlemen, I have an objection, I think this [Peace Pavilion Post] may be a fake!"

There was an instant silence in the room, and everyone looked at the dissenting person in disbelief.

Fan Qianqiu.

Of the twenty invited experts, only two remained unspoken.

One is Fan Qianqiu, and the other is Gao Fei.

Goofy's opinion didn't matter to anyone, because everyone thought he was here to make up the numbers.

But Fan Qianqiu is different, although he is very young, the youngest one here, no one dares to ignore Fan Qianqiu's ability.

This person has already proven himself with net worth and experience, and is qualified to be on an equal footing with the experts here.

Chen Dingxing opened his mouth wide, he couldn't imagine that there would be such a show, and couldn't help asking: "Mr. Fan, how did you come to the conclusion that it is a fake?"

"Feeling. Fan Qianqiu gave a word that should never appear in the appraisal of works of art.

There was an uproar all around.

Several experts had mocking expressions on their faces, and in their opinion, Fan Qianqiu was simply fooling around.

Identification is a rigorous technique.

You say it's genuine, and you need to show proof. For example, personal style, painting skills, pen and ink age, paper quality, mounting techniques, and inheritance records are all indispensable.

If you say it's a fake, you have to show evidence, where is it fake, how it was done, and what era is it imitated.

The word "feeling" alone cannot be used as evidence.

Chen Huanzhi smiled: "Xiao Fan, are you joking again?" ”

Fan Qianqiu shook his head and said, "I'm not joking, I just feel that this painting is not genuine." ”

"You have to give reasons, you can't prevaricate with feelings. Chen Huanzhi said displeasedly.

Chen Huanzhi is not only the first of the twenty experts invited this time, but also has just signed a cooperation agreement with Xingshijia, and the interests of both parties are tied together for the next three years.

This [Ping An Pavilion Post] is the pioneer of the Xingshi family to seize the art trading market in Fandu, and it must be an instant hit. It was also a pivotal turning point in Chen's career, and it was only natural that he would have to put in 100 percent effort to make the auction a success.

What's more, Chen Huan firmly believes in his heart that [Ping An Pavilion Post] is genuine!

Other experts also said: "Xiao Fan, you have to give a reason, right?"

Fan Qianqiu thought for a while and said, "Everyone is talking about the inheritance of this calligraphy, so I will raise a question from the inheritance." According to historical records, it was completed in the Southern Dynasty era 1600 years ago, but the earliest Tibetan seal on the post was left by the Beiliang Mi Yuanzhang 1050 years ago. Excuse me, in the middle of 550 years, in whose hands is the [Peace Pavilion Post]?"

"Huh?" everyone was stunned.

The people here are all experts, and the inheritance of [Ping'an Pavilion Post] is like a treasure, and they have not thought about the question raised by Fan Qianqiu, but the historical records are unknown.

Some ancients believed that after the [Peace Pavilion Post] was written, it was collected in the hands of the royal family, and later after several wars, it went to the people. It was not until the Beiliang era that the famous calligrapher Mi Yuanzhang was excavated and rediscovered.

The inheritance of [Ping'an Pavilion Post] also started from Mi Yuanzhang, and it was never broken in the middle.

But there are also other literati notes that give different answers.

In short, before the Mi Yuanzhang, the inheritance of the [Ping An Pavilion Post] did have some doubts.

Chen Huanzhi said: "Xiao Fan, the problem you mentioned is difficult to trace. Our current research can only conclude that the lineage from the Mi Yuan chapter onwards is intact, do you admit that?"

Fan Qianqiu said: "I admit this. ”

Chen Huanzhi nodded and said: "According to historical records, Mi Yuanzhang was overjoyed when he got this post, feasted guests for three days, and called it the first book in the world, do you have any questions?"

Fan Qianqiu said: "These are all recorded in the [Biography of Mi Yuanzhang] in the [Beiliang Book], I have no opinion. ”

Chen Huanzhi said: "In this case, do you suspect that what Mi Yuanzhang got at that time was not the real [Peace Pavilion Post]?"

As soon as this question was asked, Fan Qianqiu showed a look of embarrassment.

According to Chen Huanzhi's logic, if Fan Qianqiu denied the [Ping'an Pavilion Post], it would mean that Mi Yuanzhang was wrong.

Who is Mi Yuanzhang? He was one of the greatest calligraphers in the history of Jiuzhou, and his works were not inferior to Wang Zhi at all, and he could be called the treasure of the calligraphy world.

In terms of appreciation and collection, Mi Yuanzhang is also a master of ancient gold diggers, if it weren't for him, many rare treasures would not have been preserved.

Give Fan Qianqiu another hundred guts, and he doesn't dare to deny Mi Yuanzhang, not to mention that he has no evidence.

After hesitating for a moment, Fan Qianqiu said, "I still reserve my opinion." ”

Everyone smiled, and a reserved opinion means that there is no opinion, that is, Fan Qianqiu's opinion can not be counted.

Chen Dingxing breathed a sigh of relief, as long as Fan Qianqiu didn't insist, it would be fine.

"And ...... One more did not comment. Mr. Gao, what do you think?" Chen Dingxing was very happy in his heart, the first round of appraisal was completed, and then he invited a few members of the Xingshi family's appraisal committee to go through the motions, and then he could carry out the pre-auction publicity.

Gao Fei sat in the last position, listening to the discussion between Fan Qianqiu and the expert group with great interest, and when he heard Chen Dingxing ask himself, he said: "I support Fan Qianqiu's opinion, this is a fake." ”