"Without looking at the face, I don't think I can judge the identity of the suspect just by the degree to which the body types of the two people match. Shao Dong put away the smile on his face, squinted his eyes and continued: "It is not as difficult as imagined to imitate a person's body shape, as long as the two people themselves are about the same size and match the same clothes. ”

Jiang Yuan breathed a sigh of relief after Shao Dong finished speaking, no matter what, this head is still good, at least it makes Jiang Yuan hopeful.

Seeing that the evidence he provided was quietly refuted by Shao Dong, a smile appeared on Luo Ying's face. After sorting out his thoughts, he said to the judge: "Your Excellency, next I would like to summon the first witness in this case, Mr. Liu Zheng, who lives downstairs from the victim. ”

After receiving permission from the judge, an old man with gray hair and crutches was led by the bailiff to the witness stand.

After the clerk read out the rights and obligations of the witnesses, Luo Ying got up and said to the old man: "Mr. Wang Zheng, please tell me what you saw before and on the day of the crime. ”

The old man was obviously a little nervous, and the courtroom was not a place that ordinary people could often go and visit, especially since his testimony was likely to kill a young man, which made the old man a little overwhelmed.

"Last Friday afternoon, I heard a particularly noisy movement at Xiao Zhang's house upstairs, and the quarrel was between Xiao Zhang's son Meng'er and the disaster star he brought back before. ”

When the old man said this, he glanced at Jiang Yuan hatefully.

At this time, Luo Ying suddenly spoke, "Mr. Wang Zheng, is the Meng'er you just mentioned the victim of this case, Zhang Meng, the person who quarreled, is he here?"

Hearing Luo Ying's question, the old man showed a look of whether there was something wrong with you, but he still replied: "That's right, Meng'er is Zhang Meng, and the disaster star who quarreled with him is him." ”

The old man stretched out his hand and pointed at Jiang Yuan as he spoke, and he didn't know how Jiang Yuan provoked him.

Hearing the old man's answer, Luo Ying nodded, and then motioned for the old man to continue.

"In the evening, I suddenly heard people walking upstairs back and forth, and it was very noisy. It didn't take long for me to hear a sudden knock on the door of Xiao Zhang's house, so I hurried to the door to take a look, and just happened to see this disaster star, and ran out in a hurry. ”

Hearing the old man mention the calamity again, Jiang Yuan's face obviously showed a dissatisfied look, and he glared at the old man fiercely.

"Did you see it, this disaster star doesn't know how to respect the old man at all, I told Zhen'er when he came, this kid looks like a big prison person, and he doesn't believe it yet. Now, I've got all three of you in. ”

Seeing Jiang Yuan glaring at him, the old man immediately came to his senses, pointed at him and complained. It's nothing more than that Jiang Yuan doesn't look like a good person, he mixes with people all day long, and he comes back drunk every night, disturbing the neighbors.

Finding that the old man's words had nothing to do with the case, the judge stopped him from continuing to complain in time.

Luo Ying walked up to Jiang Yuan at this time, and asked with a cold face, "Do you have anything to say about the witness's confession?"

"I didn't kill anyone, it was this old guy who was looking for trouble with me all day long, I did quarrel with Zhang Meng that day, but I didn't kill him. He just wanted to frame me, and he always looked at me unpleasantly. ”

Jiang Yuan pointed at the old man and roared with anger on his face, it was hard to imagine how a young man like him could have such a deep grudge against an old man.

"Why are you and Zhang Meng arguing?"

In the face of Jiang Yuan's shouting, Luo Ying's attitude was still so indifferent.

As soon as he asked the reason for the quarrel, Jiang Yuan immediately wilted, and he didn't say a reason for a long time.

"No, I object to the prosecution asking our client about things that are not relevant to this case. ”

Seeing Jiang Yuan's dead appearance, Shao Dong immediately got up to exercise his rights.

"Your Excellency, the reason for the quarrel between the defendant Jiang Yuan and the victim Zhang Meng is precisely the motive for his crime of killing Zhang Meng's family, so my question is not irrelevant to this case. ”

As soon as Luo Ying's words fell, the judge spoke: "The objection is invalid, the defendant, please answer the question just now." ”

Shao Dong shrugged his shoulders at Jiang Yuan and said, "The reason why my client is reluctant to say the reason for the quarrel at that time is because he feels sorry for his friend. Since Prosecutor Luo wants to know the reason so much, then I'll tell you. ”

Luo Ying turned his head to look at Shao Dong, waiting for him to continue speaking.

Shao Dong bowed slightly to the judge, and then continued: "My client, Mr. Jiang Yuan, quarreled with Zhang Meng because Zhang Meng likes my client's girlfriend. That's why they quarreled, but I don't know if this reason constitutes the motive for the murder in Prosecutor Law's mouth?"

Speaking of this, Shao Dong glanced at the girl sitting in the auditorium with a worried face, and then said: "Even if it constitutes a motive for killing, I think in that case the person who wants to kill the most should be Zhang Meng." ”

Facing Shao Dong's obviously sarcastic tone, Luo Ying glanced at Jiang Yuan and said in the same tone: "If it is because his girlfriend is coveted, the defendant Jiang Yuan also has a motive to kill. ”

"Oppose!" Shao Dong said loudly again, "Oppose the prosecution's groundless speculation." ”

"The opposition is valid. ”

After Luo Ying heard the judge's words, she saluted slightly, "My question is finished." ”

Seeing Luo Ying return to his seat, Shao Dong got up and came to the witness stand, and asked with a smile, "Is the old man old this year?"

"Eighty-five!" the old man was still very proud of his age, and after finishing speaking, he added, "Deaf and blind!"

Shao Dong smiled and admired: "Yes, your body is really good, it seems that you must pay attention to maintenance on a regular basis, right?"

As soon as he heard Shao Dong say this, the old man smiled implicitly, and being praised for being in good health is definitely the favorite words of the elderly. Shao Dong's simple words immediately made the old man have a good impression of him.

"I can't talk about maintenance, go to bed early and get up early, quit smoking and drinking, eat lightly, and exercise more. The old man smiled and talked about the health scriptures, which was quite endless.

As a lawyer, quickly closing the distance between you and a stranger is also a necessary skill, and Shao Dong has mastered this skill very well.

"See you're on crutches, are your legs uncomfortable?"

Shao Dong looked down at the old man's crutches, and his face showed concern.

Of course, it feels good to be cared for, the old man smiled bitterly and knocked on his leg, "If you don't accept the old age, you can't do without this thing at home now." ”

Shao Dong heard the old man's words, smiled and complimented the old man's body, and then suddenly asked, "Eh, what time do you usually go to bed?"

"I'm going to bed at eight o'clock, and I don't have as many nightlives as you young people when I'm old. The old man was glad to have someone to accompany him in his chat.

"Oppose!" Luo Ying suddenly stopped Shao Dong's questioning and said loudly: "The question asked by the defendant's lawyer has nothing to do with this case. ”

"What I'm asking is the key question that proves my client's innocence. ”

Shao Dong squinted his eyes and said with a smile at Luo Ying.