In the Yazuo Hall of Kaifeng Mansion, Bao Zheng was trying the case of Fan Mingren's lawsuit against Fuguiqiao Guanpudian, and the people watching the trial outside the hall were crowded into three layers inside and three layers outside, and more than 100 people standing on the outermost part could not see the lobby at all, but still refused to leave.

The only person who left was Fugui Qiaodong's advocate Yao Cheng, who felt that it was a loss of identity to respond to the lawsuit here, so he gave carte blanche to the shopkeeper Wu to respond to the lawsuit on behalf of Guan Pudian.

In fact, neither the plaintiff nor the defendant is required to come forward, but rather their respective counsellors.

The two lawyers in the lobby had a fierce battle of words.

Guo Lawyer's voice was relatively high-pitched, and the tone of the accusation against the other party was very harsh, he wanted to overwhelm the other party from the momentum.

"We all know the rules of buying Guan Pu, the list is divided into two, the Guan Po order is given to the customer, the bottom order is left in the Guan Pu shop, and at the same time, the Guan Pu shop has to be recorded, there are such strict procedures, how can Fan Guanren blackmail you?

But not only did you close the old Caomen Guan Pu shop, but the original shopkeeper also didn't know where to go, which clearly didn't want to bear this high Guan Pu compensation, and actually said that Fan Guanren blackmailed you, which is extremely shameless! ”

The lawyer entrusted by Fuguiqiao Guan Pudian is surnamed Wang, and he is also a well-known lawyer in Beijing, with rich experience and good at grasping the essence.

From the point of view of common sense, Guan Pudian is indeed a bit untenable, they should not close the old Caomen Guanpu shop, nor should they replace the shopkeeper, and the discerning person will know what is going on at a glance.

However, he seized on the fact that the other party has no conclusive evidence and no witnesses, after all, common sense is common sense, law is law, and the government cannot rely on common sense to judge the case, there must be evidence and witnesses.

He said with a heartfelt word: "As the saying goes, the forest is big, there are all kinds of birds, a very kind of person knows that some things can not be done, but he prefers to do it, just like we all know, the water surface of the Bianhe River can not leave in winter, it is easy to crack and fall into the water, every Bianjing person knows, this is common sense, but every winter there are still people who will fall into the water and drown, the same reason, we all know that it is useless to fake the ticket, but you can guarantee that no one really makes a fake ticket to receive money?" ”

Wang Lawyer glanced at Bao Zheng and saw that he didn't interrupt him, so he continued: "As for what you said about closing the old Caomen branch and transferring the original shopkeeper, that is an internal matter of the Guanpu store, and it has nothing to do with this matter. What's the point of them closing the old Caomen branch? ”

At this time, Guo Zhengxing saluted Bao Zheng and said: "Qi Bao Daguan, the Guan Po tickets are all printed with serial numbers, and the plaintiff provided a total of five Guan Po tickets, the third of which is five taels of silver to bet on the first child to try the first, and the result is that the bet is successful, winning one hundred and sixty taels of silver, and the Guan Pu shop has been exchanged."

So the first and second copies, the fourth and fifth copies, obviously and the third part are all together, but Guan Pudian doesn't recognize these four copies, isn't it very funny, why don't you recognize the front and back, and only recognize the middle one, just because the amount is small, what is the reason for this? ”

Bao Zheng nodded and said to the officer, "Where is the defendant?" The officer had something to ask him. ”

The official ran out, and after a while, the shopkeeper Wu walked quickly, bowed down and said: "Xiaomin is Wu Qun, the big shopkeeper of the Guanpu shop in Fuguiqiao, entrusted by the proprietor to respond to the case on behalf of the shopkeeper!" ”

Bao Zheng didn't pick a thorn, because Fan Mingren sued Guan Pu Shop, not Zhang Yaocheng, so Zhang Yao Cheng can also let the big shopkeeper come forward, as long as he can represent Guan Pu Shop.

Bao Zheng asked: "How do you think that these four lists are fake?" ”

"Back to the big officials, because there is no record of these four lists in the record book of our store, and there is no corresponding bottom list, so it is easy for us to judge."

"But as far as the official knows, the list of Guan Pu shop is all serial numbers, since you have redeemed the middle one, then there should be a list of four numbers before and after, the official is not wrong!"

Wu Da shopkeeper secretly hated in his heart, he didn't know that the shopkeeper had exchanged the middle list in the chaos, which caused him to be very passive now, although he had made preparations, but after all, it was fake, and he never wanted to take out the fake things unless he had to.

But now that the evidence is here, he has to admit it, he has to nod, "We do have a list!" ”

"Then ask the chief treasurer to take out four copies of the same number, and please bring the record book together to prove your identification."

The shopkeeper of Wu was helpless, so he had to order a man to go back to get the list and records, and Bao Zheng asked a scribe to go with a few officials.

Panlou Street is not far from Kaifeng Mansion, and when Bao Zheng finished drinking a cup of tea, the envoy and the other party's buddies had already returned.

The scribe was holding a large box in his hand, which contained a thick register book, and there were four copies of the Guan Bao Bottom List next to it, and this book envoy was very shrewd, and by the way, he also took the bottom slip of five taels of silver that had been cashed.

The envoy whispered to Bao Zheng: "Their proprietor asked me to tell Shao Yin, he said that this case involves the face of the concubine, please pay attention to this." ”

Bao Zheng sneered, and moved the concubine out at every turn, the Zhang family is this virtue, Zhang Yaozuo is this kind of person, and his brother is the same, but they forgot, who is Bao Zheng?

Bao Zheng spread out the four lists, and compared them with the four lists of the plaintiff in his hand, the four bottom sheets are all bets on consistent money, and Zhang Qiu of Bianliang County won the first place in the children's test, obviously did not bet, and the gamblers naturally did not come, and the four bottom sheets were stamped with the seal of the unsuccessful.

Since the other party's four lists are the base lists, while the plaintiff's four lists are the main orders, the format is different, the paper is different, and the handwriting is different.

Of course, this just proves that the original and the main list are not the same list, and it is not the plaintiff who has made it or the defendant who has made it false.

Bao Zheng took out the bottom slip of five taels of silver that had been redeemed and compared it.

A comparison can see some clues, the paper is different, although it is all jute paper, but the paper that has been exchanged for the bottom sheet is slightly yellow, a little old, and these four bottom sheet paper is relatively new, the printing is the same, all are the same board, the number is written by hand, although the handwriting is very similar, but it can still be seen that it is not written by a person.

Bao Zheng also compared the four plaintiff's main slips with the five taels of silver, and they were exactly the same, with the same paper and the same handwriting.

Bao Zheng sneered, flipped through the record book again, and found that the binding fine hemp rope of this thick record book was actually new, and the record book was a long time old, indicating that this record book had been opened, and then found the two pages of the registration, which were also relatively new, and not the same as before and after.

Bao Zheng was shocked, and said sharply to the shopkeeper Wu: "Your four copies of the base sheet and the record book are clearly forged, not originals, can't you see it as an official?" ”

The shopkeeper of Wu was speechless for a while, but the lawyer next to him said unhurriedly: "The big official thinks that the bottom list does not match, because the original list has been destroyed, but the government needs it, so he temporarily made four sheets." ”

The shopkeeper Wu nodded hurriedly, "That's true, we will destroy these useless lists in time, because there are too many lists, and it is very troublesome to keep them, so we won't keep them." ”

"Then why don't you destroy this one?" Bao Zheng raised the bottom slip of five taels of silver.

Wang Yishi said with a smile: "This is the winning list, of course you have to keep it, this is the general practice of closing the shop, shopkeeper Wu, I'm right!" ”

Wu Da shopkeeper hurriedly said: "It is for this reason that the original list has indeed been destroyed by us, and this winning lottery will be destroyed after three months, and this is the case with Guan Pu Shop." ”

Guo Songshi said on the side: "Since you can't produce evidence, why are you insisting that our four lists are fake?" ”

Wang Advocate smiled proudly, "Of course Guan Pudian thinks that your list is fake, and you also think that we are fake, since both sides insist on their own words, do you have witnesses?" Bring out the witnesses, and maybe you can turn the tables around. ”

At this time, a hearty laugh came from outside the hall, "Unfortunately, I can testify for the plaintiff!" ”

A young man in a white brocade robe walked into the lobby unhurriedly with a folding fan, followed by Fan Ning, Akihito was overjoyed, and Fan Ning really found this Tai student surnamed Cao.

Bao Zheng was stunned when he saw this student, and the young man winked at Bao Zheng and signaled Bao Zheng not to reveal his identity.

Bao Zheng glanced at Fan Ning behind him, he was really funny in his heart, it seemed that Fan Ning didn't know who this young man was, and only after a while did he ask with a smile: "Why is Yanei here?" ”

https:

Genius one second to remember the address of this site:. Mobile version reading URL: m.