Chapter 12: The Flames of War in the Courtroom (I)

/newmessage.php?tosys=1&title="Rebirth: Officialdom Romance."

Chapter Errors/Click here to report

Half a month later, the Hucheng Hubei District People's Court accepted the criminal case of Wang Zhonghe being beaten and disabled.

The plaintiff Wang Zhonghe sued the defendant Liao Qiang for illegally injuring the body of others, and in addition, the medical expenses, mental damages, lost work expenses, etc., and miscellaneous expenses, together with the sum of the plaintiff's claim for compensation from the other party, totaled 1.2 million yuan.

I have to say that as far as this case is concerned, the plaintiff is definitely a lion's mouth, making it clear that he wants to send the other party to prison and make some more money by the way.

When he walked into the trial hall, Chen Yang quickly scanned the trial bench and saw that there were more than 300 people in the black press, all of whom were teachers and students from the law schools of several well-known universities in the city. Then, he went to look at both sides of the courtroom, where the defendant Liao Qiang was standing energetically in the defendant's seat, and the bailiff was already there.

However, what surprised him even more was that the person sitting in the defense lawyer's seat for the defense was his neighbor -- lawyer Li Qiuhe.

Of course, he was just surprised, because he had made full preparations before, all the official certificates had been completed one by one, and through the relationship between Wu Gang, he also invited Bian Heping, a gold medal barrister from the largest justice law firm in the provincial capital, to help fight this lawsuit, so he was not worried about the result of today's trial at all.

The first step of the trial was to go through the motions, the public security organs submitted the case file, and then the plaintiff's lawyer questioned the defendant and the witnesses at the time of the crime, including Chen Yang and Liu Fatzi.

The fact that the defendant Liao Qiang illegally injured others with a remy Martin wine bottle is irrefutable, and the only focus of the dispute between the two sides now is whether the victim is really as miserable as he said he was, and he was disabled after being knocked on the head.

For this reason, the plaintiff's lawyer also issued a minor concussion certificate listed by the hospital to the court, and after verification by a professional organization, the victim's physical impairment met the sixth-degree disability standard. In fact, according to national regulations, this standard is neither high nor low, and it is in a very awkward position. Of course, the concussion thing is not clear, it mainly depends on how the doctor decides, but if the patient keeps saying that he has a headache, the doctor will not hesitate.

In the end, the results of the evidence were quite good, and the evidence was conclusive and beyond doubt. Lawyer Bian's appearance is also remarkable, sonorously accusing the defendant Liao Qiang's despicable behavior, and the hearing staff are passionate, if there is no accident, the presiding judge can almost announce the verdict on the spot.

Of course, according to the usual practice, the presiding judge still has to leave time for the defense to appeal, he looked at the defense lawyer Li Qiuhe and asked, "Defense lawyer, do you have anything you need to ask?" ”

Li Qiuhe is dressed very formally today, wearing a black suit and skirt. Of course, she usually dresses like this. Hearing the presiding judge's question, she stood up from her position, bowed slightly to the judge and several clerks of the jury, and said calmly: "Honorable presiding judge and jurors, first of all, I doubt the authenticity of the disability certificate issued by the prosecution. ”

It is normal for the defense to express doubts about the evidence, and it has become an international practice, so there was no commotion at the scene.

Li Qiuhe continued: "As far as I know, if the hospital wants to issue a disability certificate to a patient, it needs to go through at least a 60-day observation period before it can finally reach a conclusion, and the plaintiff's admission report shows that the plaintiff was discharged from the hospital only three days after admission, so it can be seen that his condition is not as strict as the prosecution said. Take 10,000 steps back, even if he is seriously injured, and he has to go to the hospital regularly for check-ups every day afterwards, it has only been fifteen days so far. I wonder if there is any artificial factor in this that wants to disrupt the normal order of the trial?

Therefore, I hope that the presiding judge and the jurors will ignore this meaningless evidence for the sake of prudence in the following trial process. That's all I have to say, thank you. With that, she bowed slightly and sat down again.

The presiding judge looked at the defense lawyer Bian and asked, "Prosecution lawyer, do you have anything to say about this?" ”

"Yes." Lawyer Bian nodded slightly, stood up, and said confidently, "Based on the question just raised by the defense lawyer, I can explain it here. As far as I know, there have been several cases before, and the hospital has made a determination in advance about the victim's physical condition in order to cooperate with the court, which is normal, and my client is not a special case, so the authenticity of this material is beyond doubt. ”

As far as the current national situation is concerned, no one can say anything about this kind of thing, but most of them agree with Lawyer Bian's opinion, after all, everyone has the psychology of sympathizing with the weak.

"Defense lawyer." The presiding judge waved his hand and gestured to Li Qiuhe.

Li Qiuhe nodded and stood up, "Presiding Judge, can I ask the plaintiff a few questions?" ”

"Yes, you ask." The presiding judge nodded in agreement.

Soon, Wang Zhonghe, under the protection of the bailiff, sat on the plaintiff's seat.

Li Qiuhe habitually picked up a pen and glanced at Wang Zhonghe with a cold and stern gaze. This aura alone made Lao Wang in the plaintiff's seat shudder.

"Mr. Wang, can you give us a brief account of the incident?"

Li Qiuhe's trick is very international, and it is nothing more than wanting the plaintiff to tell the flaws himself.

The prosecution's lawyer immediately objected, arguing that the police transcript had been recorded in detail and there was no need to waste everyone's time.

But unfortunately, the opposition was invalid, and Wang Zhonghe had to answer.

Fortunately, lawyer Bian had already explained before appearing in court, and although Wang Zhonghe was a little flustered, he still honestly followed the lawyer's instructions to repeat the case.

After listening to this, Li Qiuhe smiled slightly, nodded with satisfaction and said, "Mr. Wang, there are three questions in your statement just now, which puzzle me very much. ”

As soon as this remark came out, Barrister Bian was slightly surprised, he was obviously fully prepared for this statement, why did Wang Zhonghe just finish speaking, and the other party dug up three questions?

"First of all, according to what you just said, you and my client had an unpleasant argument first, right?"

"Yes." Lao Wang nodded in response.

"Immediately afterwards, you said that my client insulted your wife with swear words, oh, that is, Ms. Liu, another witness in this case, can you accurately tell us how my client scolded people at that time?"

When Lao Wang heard this, he stood up angrily, pointed at Li Qiuhe and said angrily: "What kind of lawyer are you, can you bring that kind of disgusting words to the court?" You're a woman yourself, and if someone scolds you like that, I don't think you can stand it! ”

Two bailiffs who maintained order hurriedly came over and invited Lao Wang back to his seat.

Lawyer Bian saw that it was broken, and quickly stood up and said, "I object!" ”

Chen Yang also secretly scolded despicable in his stomach, this Li Qiuhe asked this kind of boring question, obviously wanting to provoke Lao Wang, so as to pave the way for the next step, and then couldn't help but secretly scolded Lao Wang for his temper Why is he so angry, what an elm pimple, this little trick can't be seen, and he fell for the evil of others in vain.

The presiding judge nodded to Lawyer Bian, and then said to Lao Wang, who was out of control: "Plaintiff, please stay calm." He looked at Li Qiuhe again, "Defense lawyer, please pay attention to your questions and don't ask questions that are not related to this case." ”

"I'm sorry, Presiding Judge." Li Qiuhe smiled and apologized, and then looked at Lao Wang, "Mr. Wang, if the question just now caused you trouble, I'm sorry, you don't have to answer." ”

Lao Wang snorted and turned his head away angrily.

Li Qiuhe seemed to be very satisfied with Lao Wang's current state, raised the pen in his hand slightly, and continued to ask: "Mr. Wang, according to the records made by the police after the incident, you and my client first had an unpleasant quarrel, which then led to an argument, and then began to push each other. However, in your statement just now, I did not hear you say how the pushing began, or who started it, and you did not give a detailed statement about this, but only directly said that my client smashed your head with a Rémy Martin bottle. So, now can you tell me exactly whether it was you, or my client, who made the first move? ”

"I'm against it!" Lawyer Bian stood up again and said, "Presiding Judge, I object to the defense lawyer asking my client this kind of question, which has long been an established fact!" ”

"I'm sorry, presiding judge, this question is critical to this case, and I hope the plaintiff will answer truthfully." Li Qiuhe didn't give an inch.

"The objection is invalid, and the plaintiff must answer the question." The presiding judge agreed with Li Qiuhe's opinion, and Lawyer Bian sat back with a grim face, and talked to the assistant next to him in a low voice.

"Mr. Wang, please answer my question immediately." Li Qiuhe accentuated his tone and volume.

"It was chaotic, I, I don't remember exactly."

"Oh, really?" Li Qiuhe had an expression that he knew you would say this, and said sarcastically, "Mr. Wang, have you really forgotten it, or have you chosen to forget?" ”

Lao Wang's eyes erupted with fire, glared at Li Qiuhe angrily, and said loudly: "It was a mess at the time, who remembers how it started!" ”

"You're lying!" Li Qiuhe drank coldly, the sound was not loud, but it was shocking.

"I didn't lie, Presiding Judge, believe me, I really didn't lie" Lao Wang was anxious and spoke incoherently. Also, he has lived for more than 30 years, and what he is most proud of is his unbending character, and now he is being accused of lying in public, as a principal and a cultural person, how can he stand it.

"I'm against it!" Lawyer Bian had to stand up again, "Presiding Judge, given that my client's current situation is extremely unstable, he is no longer fit to answer any questions from the defense lawyer. ”

The presiding judge agreed, but still glanced at Li Qiuhe more.

Li Qiuhe smiled coldly, nodded confidently, and said, "Presiding Judge, if the plaintiff really can't answer this question, I won't force it." ”

In this way, Lao Wang could finally go down to rest, and when he walked out of the plaintiff's seat, he still glared at Li Qiuhe angrily.

Li Qiuhe seemed to be accustomed to this, and directly ignored Lao Wang's murderous gaze, and continued to talk eloquently: "Presiding judge, as I said earlier, there are three points in the statement made by the plaintiff Mr. Wang just now, which are very puzzling to me, and I have already asked two points before, and now there is one last question left. At this, she consciously paused and looked at the presiding judge and the clerks and jurors.

"Defense lawyer, please go on." The presiding judge waved his hand.

"Thank you, Presiding Judge." Li Qiuhe was still very polite and continued, "I don't know if you have noticed that according to the confession provided by the police, the cause of this case stemmed from a very normal interpersonal communication between my client and the plaintiff, Mr. Wang's wife. ”

"I'm against it!" Lawyer Bian was furious and raised his objections loudly.

"Attorney for the prosecution, please state your reasons." The presiding judge looked at Lawyer Bian.

"Your Excellency, according to the police transcript and confession on the night of the crime, as well as the interrogation at the trial just now, my client, Mr. Wang's wife, Ms. Liu, who is a witness in this case, has repeatedly explained the situation at that time, that is, the defendant Liao Qiang harassed her, and after she raised objections many times, the defendant still kept pestering her, which led to a series of unpleasant incidents that followed. Therefore, I believe that the defence counsel has a deliberate motive to mislead and disrupt the public view, and I implore the presiding judge and the jurors to ignore the statements that the defence counsel have just said that are not in line with the facts. Thank you. ”

"Defense lawyer, please be careful with your words next." The presiding judge appears to have adopted Lawyer Bian's opinion.

"I'm sorry, Presiding Judge." Li Qiuhe nodded in agreement, and then said, "Then now can I ask Ms. Liu, a witness, to ask her a few questions?" ”

"Yes." The presiding judge nodded.

Lawyer Bian wanted to object, but this was the right of the defense, so he had to give up first.

Aishang Novel Network would like to thank all book friends for their support biquge.info