Chapter 35: The First Encounter
Although the decline of the positive side was temporarily stabilized by Guan Xiaoyang, this kind of stability is like love without material, which cannot withstand the slightest temptation; It's like a plate of loose sand, and the wind blows and disperses.
Before Yu Lei came on the court, the other three people on the field jointly gave him an idea, asking him to continue Zhu Quan's strategy just now, grasp the point of "avoiding the difference between desirability and undesirability" to attack, cover up the truth of his own argument, and focus their attention on defense.
Professional debates are not only about who has the loudest voice and who is imposing, but also about who is basically protecting them.
This is completely different from the amateur debate that relies on hype and the courtroom where the rhetoric focuses on evidence.
In other words, at the end of the debate, professional debates are about who makes the opponent's arguments even worse.
You must know that there is no 100% correct word in the world, as different classes, with different positions, and different education, they will naturally have different views on an issue.
Therefore, it is only natural that there will be countless holes waiting to be explored by both sides of the debate.
And the process of debating is the process of digging holes, and whoever digs more wins the competition.
And now, what Yu Lei has to do is to continue to dig deep and expand this loophole that the square cannot make up, until the square is finally dug up.
Yu Lei wore a gold-rimmed glasses, looking gentle and polite, but as soon as he opened his mouth, he showed an aggressive momentum completely different from his appearance, and said: "First of all, look at the logic of the other party's classmates, the other party's classmates said that today they only need to cite a little bit of desirability, they are equal to desirability, and no matter how many undesirable points we cite, it is not called undesirable, is this called "only the governor is allowed to set fires, and the people are not allowed to light lamps"? ”
Yu Lei himself is not conspicuous, but as long as he is out, he has never failed.
Moreover, from the beginning of the audition, he has played from the first debate to the fourth debate, and he has done every position, and he has done an excellent job, so he can be said to be an all-round player.
Therefore, Jiang Feng is very confident in Yu Lei, she thinks that after Jiang Ge achieved an initial advantage, Zhu Quan almost turned this advantage into a victory, but because the debate had just begun, it could not be done.
Therefore, if Yu Lei plays well, he will definitely be able to determine the victory.
Judging from the situation on the spot, Yu Lei seems to be able to successfully complete the goal.
Yu Lei continued to say generously: "If the other party's classmates must say to us today, is there a little bit of merit, I say yes!" Where is it? This can make everyone realize how harmful it is to judge heroes from the point of view of success or failure. ”
As soon as these words came out, the hall burst into laughter.
"It's three harvests, and there's no grass!"
"That's funny, isn't it? Hit the opponent directly on the head, without giving a little respite. ”
"Anyone has noticed that the four people on the square are all science students! And the four people on the opposite side are all liberal arts students! Playing tricks with liberal arts students, science students are born to suffer! ”
"The positive side is not a loss, it depends on the next free debate and closing argument, but does this have to wait for Sun Qiang to turn the tide?"
"Sun Qiang: Three pig teammates, I can't take it!"
"The three of us: it's not that we're too weak, it's that the other party is too strong!"
"Yu Lei is too ruthless, he directly wants the positive side to refute all the arguments of his opponent!"
"This method is called homeopathic reversal in the field of debate, that is, a wolf in sheep's clothing, if you really think that I am a sheep, then I will only be eaten."
"Zhu Quan's is called AOE damage, Yu Lei's is directly the crazy output of ADC, the kind that is terrible."
Netizens on the Internet discussed Yu Lei's debate and speech very enthusiastically, and the audience also applauded Yu Lei warmly.
“... If there is no success, there is no success, so heroes should be judged by success or failure. Let's think about it, if the hero doesn't eat, the hero will turn into a ghost. So can we judge heroes by the amount of food, and see who eats more, who is the hero? ...”
“... There is nothing wrong with pursuing success and encouraging success, but does encouraging success and pursuing success mean judging heroes by success or failure? Our society still encourages everyone to get rich and get rich, but can we use rich and poor to judge heroes? If he could, why did Wang Bo still say "be poor and strong, and not fall into the ambition of the clouds"? ...”
The judges nodded one after another, agreeing with what Yu Lei just said, and Dr. Zhong Bangzhi on the side couldn't help but sigh that he "has poetry and books in his belly"!
"Dr. Chung is right! However, I don't know how the organizing committee arranged it, the four people on the positive side are all science students, and the four people on the opposite side are all liberal arts students, resulting in a confrontation between arts and sciences? It's kind of interesting. ”
Deputy Director Li Bingxuan looked at the treatment of the players in front of him and said.
"It was decided by lottery, Director Li, this can only be said to be too coincidental. But it's really exciting now, isn't that enough? ”
Xu Fangting is the jury** and the top decision-maker in the overall competition, and he doesn't want to hear insider comments.
All the judges laughed kindly, but Zhao Jinmao was a little cold, and said: "That's not necessarily, you don't have it, it doesn't mean that the people below are convenient!" ”
Well, it's a bit unpleasant.
"Actually, all the problems of the other students today are because they are not clear about the examination questions. What is called a hero by success or failure, that is, a person is a hero if he succeeds, and he is not a hero if he fails.
So let's think about it, there is a shadow of success in many heroes, and we are not against it, but what ordinary, ordinary person does not have a little bit of success? If both heroes and ordinary people are successful, how can heroes be judged by success alone?
On the other hand, if there is no failure in the slightest, if he fails, he is not a hero, then in addition to the all-knowing and all-powerful God, can the other student find even one hero in the world? ”
After saying this, Zhao Jinmao, who has been supporting the positive team, couldn't help but chuckle in his heart, this loophole that the opposing side has not been repaired just now, and finally made up for it under Yu Lei's words.
Because most of the examples just said by the opposing side are that a hero fails in the end, but he is not a hero, so you can seize this point to attack and tell the opponent that they are still heroes after they failed in the end, because he was successful before!
Isn't this still a "hero based on success or failure"?
But now, the three arguments of the opposing side have directly plugged this loophole!
Looking at Yu Lei, who was talking eloquently on the stage, and the rest of the three self-confident opponents sitting next to him, Zhao Jinmao couldn't help but recall the previous speech of the opponent just now, as if this loophole was deliberately thrown out, but he didn't expect that the positive side did not "take the bait", to be precise, it was not found at all.
Now, it's difficult!
As Yu Lei finished his last sentence, he sat down: "... The success or failure of a hero is often like a meteor across the sky, and what makes us cry can only be their noble spirit and heroism that transcend success or failure. Thank you. Zhao Jinmao had a grim expression on his face.
There is no way to retreat, and the next free debate and conclusion depends on Sun Qiang!
Zhao Jinmao's eyes were like Sun Qiang, the fourth debater in the square seat, and Sun Qiang, who had been thinking about how to find a glimmer of life, seemed to feel the encouraging gaze from the judges' seats.
The two looked at each other, and Sun Qiang nodded firmly towards Zhao Jinmao, as if to say, "Teacher, don't worry, I will control it next!" ”
After the hostess sitting in the middle announced that the time for a pause had come and was ready to start a free debate, Sun Qiang, who had been in the position of the fourth debate, got up and asked directly: "May I ask the opponent's debater, does the 'success or failure' of heroes encourage success?" ”
Jiang Feng, as the captain, is also the fourth debater, and the "first shot" of this tribute should be fired by her:
"Friends on the other side, we want to encourage success today, but we can't encourage unscrupulous success. So we can't encourage 'success or failure' as a hero. I would like to ask you a logical question. Is success a sufficient condition or a necessary condition for a hero? ”
Sun Qiang got up again, directly ignored Jiang Feng's speech, and continued to chase after his own point at the beginning, asking: "Why does the opponent's defense friend just see the success of unscrupulous means?" When we advocate it, can't we take the best of it and discard the dross?
There is a good saying: the place where you stand is your China; What you do, what happens to China; China is what you are; If you have light, China will not be dark.
Just ask, you have such a dark idea, and even promote such a dark thought, what is your intention! ”
As soon as these words came out, they directly pulled the positive side to the highest point of justice and morality, and knocked the negative side off the altar.
The audience at the scene applauded his remarks without hesitation, and there were a few whistles, which cleaned up the decline just now.
Zhao Jinmao nodded with satisfaction, his student would pat himself on the back, and he actually used the sentence he posted on Weibo as an introduction.
Very good, very good!
After Zhu Quan heard this, he also chuckled in his heart, this Sun Qiang is really a clever man who can speak well, and he directly reversed the form with just one sentence.
Looking at the other three people who were speechless for a while, Zhu Quan got up and said: "It's not that we want to see unscrupulous success, and it's not that we have dark thoughts, it's caused by human nature."
We can't say that we are dark because we have peeled away the stench under this beautiful flat bag, this is a partial generalization, this is revenge, and this is the "crime" that you are afraid that we will puncture your so-called "sweet dream".
The fundamental question is, under the guise of 'success or failure', how many people will do whatever it takes to achieve success? Ask the opposing students to answer the questions of our four debates. ”
Zhu Quan's speech also temporarily stopped the impact of Sun Qiang's speech just now, and the first confrontation between the two ended in a flat sentence.