Wu Shuyan, a debater of the old depression reduction team, was a cute girl with glasses, and stood up and discussed:

"Hello everyone!

The philosopher Immanuel Kant advocated that people have rationality regardless of intelligence, wealth and poverty, beauty and ugliness.

Mencius believed that human nature is inherently good, so he further added that everyone has compassion.

And Buddhism says that one-mindedness is the true body, and one-mindedness is the Buddha.

It is precisely because of the inherent goodness of human nature that people can put down the butcher's knife and become a Buddha anytime and anywhere. ”

A series of three famous sentences, from Kant in the West, to Mencius in the East, and then from philosophy to religion, all describe the definition of "human nature is inherently good".

Quoting Kant, Mencius, and Buddhism from a commanding position, she established a basic theory of the goodness of nature and the consequences of evil behaviors, which is extraordinary and concise.

The audience on the barrage was shocked!

What kind of fairy operation is this?

How can you say that?

It seems that the other party is quite well prepared in this hour's preparation time!

"When I learned about this debate, I thought we would have an advantage, after all, the topic of our semi-final debate, "Money Debate", also had something to do with it. ”

"Hey, don't talk nonsense! This is just the beginning, and the main side has not yet said anything, and we have not even started to debate, you will sing down, what does this mean? ”

"That's it! I can also write about the level of the old depression reduction team at the beginning, it's not a big deal, the focus is still to look at the back, don't start at the peak, and then go downhill! ”

"Let's listen quietly to what this square has to say!"

...

The audience on the barrage discussed very enthusiastically.

Because the beginning of the old depression reduction team was shocking enough, I was worried that the Huaguo team would not have a way to counterattack here, so as to lose the opportunity.

Wu Shuyan continued: "Our side advocates that human nature is inherently good, that is, we advocate that the root point of human nature is good, and only when there is a good end can there be good deeds.

We do not deny that there are evil deeds in human society, but the occurrence of evil deeds is caused by the external environment, so evil is the effect and not the cause.

If we insist that evil is cause and not effect, that is, human nature is evil, then there is no real morality in the human world. ”

...

“... If human nature is inherently evil, all human moral norms are used as the greatest means of self-interest for human beings.

Is morality still morality when morality becomes the means?

That is to say, once a person violates morality without being punished, he will not obey the constraints of morality.

At two o'clock in the middle of the night I walked on the road and saw a red light, and if human nature was evil, I would have run through it, because it was just for personal convenience.

But in fact this is not the case, and there are still many people who follow the traffic rules.

Based on the premise that human nature is inherently evil, Hobbes believed that there must be an absolute, omnipresent authority to oversee the fulfillment of moral rules by everyone.

If human nature is evil, no one will willingly abide by the moral code, but the facts have proved that people still have good deeds, people still have morality, and they still have altruistic behaviors. ”

...

Wu Shuyan directly used the example of "traffic rules" as an example, although this reason makes sense, but when I first heard this passage, it made people feel that something was not right.

If you think about it a little bit, you will realize that this is not just wrong!

It simply provides a wonderful example of "human nature is evil"!

If "human nature" is the reason why people obey traffic rules, then where is the law?

This obviously doesn't make sense!

According to the debater, then why bother with laws and regulations on transportation?

By analogy, since the other party said that "human nature is inherently good", does it include that in addition to the laws and regulations on transportation that need to be abolished, other laws and regulations must be eliminated? !

Of course, this one is likely to say, "No! Because there are wicked people in this world! ”

Then we can ask rhetorically, does this mean that the current education is not good?

Because they have taught a good man to be a wicked man!

Does that have to be reformed in education?

Not only Zhu Quan, but also the other three teammates on the stage all heard the mistakes made by the positive side of the debate.

Several people glanced at each other and nodded tacitly.

Wu Shuyan continued to discuss:

"If human nature is evil, then we have only two options:

The first is to live in a world where Big Brother is constantly supervising us;

The second is that our human society will no longer believe in each other.

If that were the case, I would have seen an old lady fall and someone would lift her up, and people would say that she had bad intentions;

And the friendships we forged in the debates were all false and posturing..."

When it came to this, the audience on the barrage was happy, and directly barrage protectors:

"Little sister, you can come to my country to take a look! The rescuer, in the case of conclusive evidence, still has to compensate half of the medical expenses! ”

"It seems that this is really a girl who has not experienced social beatings!"

"According to statistics, there are no three houses with an average price of 3 million in the family, and they are not qualified to support them! So, young lady, do you have tens of millions of assets? ”

Those who really dare to "help" are real warriors, they dare to face the bleak life because of this, and dare to face the blood dripping because of it! What kind of mourner and happy person is this?! ”

"Hey, such good material, but our Huaguo team can't refute it! After all, family ugliness can't be publicized! ”

...

The sentence "An old lady fell and someone helped her up" on the barrage sparked a heated discussion, which made the "can't help the elderly" incident that happened in China over the years once again come out with a "whip/corpse"!

There was still one minute left in the last minute, and Wu Shuyan still discussed: "... But we will find that in the history of human society, there has never been an absolute authority of the monarch, but the self-sacrifice of others is constantly happening.

And in life, there are many unknown people who are good and unknown.

Isn't Mother Telisa's good deeds, the compassionate aspiration of Mahayana Buddhism that "sentient beings will never be able to cross, and they will never become Buddhas", the best example of the inherent goodness of human nature? ”

With the sound of "Di", the time was up, and Wu Shuyan also happened to bow slightly to the camera and said, "Thank you!" ”

The applause rang out at the scene, and Cen Ying said in control: "Thank you, Wu Shuyan, and then I would like to ask Jiang Ge, the first representative of the opposing side, to take a stand and speak, and the time is also three minutes." ”

With the appearance of Goddess Jiang Ge, the barrage was once again filled with the title of "goddess", and the atmosphere suddenly became warm.