"This is a surveillance video taken from the subway, which can fully restore the scene at that time, which is enough to prove that my client did not take the initiative to provoke at that time."

The judge again played the surveillance footage in court.

Everyone clearly saw that Qu Ning was just sleeping in his seat at the beginning, and he didn't take the initiative to say or do anything to Yang Lihua at all.

Instead, Yang Lihua leaned over to talk.

It's just that there is no sound from the surveillance, and no one can tell what is going on just from the surveillance.

Liu Jiu also began to defend this point: "The monitoring did not record the sound, which can only prove that my client couldn't help but take the lead in desperation, and it does not mean that the plaintiff's injury was caused by my client, let alone the responsibility of the plaintiff in the incident." ”

"Then evidence No. 3, the hospital's injury appraisal report, it can be clearly written on it, my client was injured on the same day, not an old injury."

Chao Yang unhurriedly took out the certificate issued by the hospital:

"And this, this is proof of the operation."

Liu Jiu once again questioned the authenticity of the evidence: "I doubt the authenticity of this evidence, according to the injury appraisal, the plaintiff has a fracture and dislocation, but you can take a look, now the plaintiff's arm is the same as a normal person, there is no trace of injury, and the fracture cannot be healed so quickly, so I suspect that the plaintiff has forged the appraisal." ”

Qu Ning immediately exploded when he heard this: "It doesn't make sense for you to say that, I have to be injured for the rest of my life?" Can't I have a special constitution and heal early? ”

The clerk cleared his throat: "Please pay attention to the plaintiff's emotions and do not break the discipline of the court." ”

Qu Ning reluctantly shut his mouth.

It is quite abstract to say that his injuries healed so quickly, and on the third day after the incident, Qu Ning woke up, not only did the plaster collapse, but even the steel nails in his arm fell out.

He hurriedly spent ten scum points asking Joker what was going on.

The answer is that after using Joker's primary disguise, no matter how the disguised part has been changed during this period, it will return to its pre-use state when the three-day period expires.

In other words, the effects of surgery will be completely negated.

This made Qu Ning stare at the steel nails on the bed and fall into deep thought for a long time.

He also thought about putting on a plaster cast and hiding it again, but he was worried that the hospital would arrest him for autopsy and study after discovering this situation, so he had to give up.

"Next is the witness, explain in advance that before the incident, my client and the witness had no connection in the slightest, the two parties did not know each other, and there was no possibility of acquaintances testifying."

Chao Yang still looked indifferent and continued to come up with evidence.

As his words fell, the bailiff brought in a young girl.

It was the person who was with Shirakura at the time.

They went to work together at the time, and encountered this incident on the way, Bai Sakura couldn't see it and called the police, called the emergency number, and she was a witness to the whole process.

Qu Ning also learned through Bai Ying that she also worked in the TV station, but she belonged to a different department from Bai Ying, and through Bai Ying, Qu Ning finally persuaded the girl to testify in court.

"At that time, it was the aunt who insulted the plaintiff first, and the plaintiff only returned a few words, and did not fight back after being beaten, and there was no excesses in the whole process."

"Can you take responsibility for what you say?" The judge asked.

"Yes, what I said is all true, the doctor who came to deal with the incident that day saw me, and my companion and I were the ones who called the police at that time." The girl nodded.

Liu Jiu shook his head: "Similarly, I still have doubts about the authenticity of the witness, according to my investigation, the witness and the plaintiff belong to the same city TV station, and the plaintiff is the boss of the witness, and the two parties have interests, and it does not rule out the possibility that the witness received the plaintiff's benefits and gave false testimony." ”

As soon as this remark came out, it immediately caused an uproar.

What do you mean? What kind of earth-shattering melon is this?

Qu Ning is actually a person inside the TV station, so justice comes to this show, is Qu Ning also involved?

So why did Qu Ning blacken himself on the show, instead of using the home advantage to whitewash himself?

The people who eat melons don't understand.

But although they can't see the situation clearly, it doesn't prevent them from eating melons even more.

Such a twist and turn in the trial process is really too exciting.

Qu Ning was stunned for a moment, as if he didn't expect the other party to find out his details.

"It's a general, there's something."

"Well, something." Chao Yang also nodded: "It's a pity, there aren't many things." ”

At this time, Yang Kai gradually put his mind at ease, although the other party had many tricks, but every move was taken by Liu Jiu, which made Yang Kai extremely relieved.

It is worthy of being the trump card hired by the trust relationship at a price higher than that of the vast majority of lawyers on the market, and it is trustworthy.

Liu Jiu was also proud in his heart, this was the trick he gave back to Chao Yang just now.

This time, not only disgusted the other party, but also parried the opponent's attack, in comparison, his own hand is naturally superior.

Generally speaking, all the witnesses are pulled, which naturally means that the donkey skills are exhausted.

Liu Jiu's demeanor gradually relaxed, and he couldn't help but feel a little contemptuous, just Chaoyang, it was still too tender.

Just when he thought that Chao Yang would not be able to produce more evidence and was about to enter the stage of questioning by the judge, there was another change.

In fact, just as Liu Jiu expected, even the judge thought that this was the end of the matter, and began to ask if there was any evidence to add.

But Chao Yang just shook his head and sacrificed the last big killing weapon.

"Evidence number four and the last piece of evidence."

Chao Yang paused:

"The most real, but also the most intuitive - the whole process taken by passers-by accidentally! The judge is asked to watch it in conjunction with the surveillance footage. ”

"What?!"

Yang Kai was shocked, he was extremely sure that there had never been a video of the whole process circulating on the Internet, otherwise he would not have been so tough from beginning to end, according to common sense, it is impossible for a good person to start recording when there is no strong conflict and contradiction.

Where did the so-called whole process come from?

"Don't worry, if you want to combine the surveillance video, most of it is just an unknown audio, this thing can be faked, and it can also be dismissed."

Liu Jiu comforted Yang Kai, who was a little flustered, in a low voice, and Yang Kai calmed down.

Yang Lihua was even more panicked, as the person concerned, she knew the situation best, but she looked at Yang Kai, but found that the other party had no leisure to comfort her again, so she had to lower her head and her hands trembled nervously.

To everyone's surprise, this is really a full video.

The moment the video screen appeared, someone immediately discovered that the person in the picture was not Bai Sakura?

"Today's first day of work, I'm so nervous, I'm on the subway now, and I'm still forty minutes away, whew, I'm so excited."

In the video, Bai Sakura concave a few shapes towards the camera, and from time to time pointed the camera at her best friend, which made the two people at the scene feel embarrassed, and their toes were about to scratch the soles of their shoes.

Fortunately, there was a noise in the video very quickly, and Shirakura in front of the camera seemed to be attracted by something and switched the camera to the rear camera.

In the next second, Qu Ning and Yang Lihua appeared in the picture.

"Today's young people, why don't they know how to respect the old and love the young, just forget if they don't give up their seats, and don't even let people finish their words, do you see that I am an old man who is easy to bully?"

Yang Lihua scolded Qu Ning arrogantly.

Bai Sakura's voiceover whispered: "It seems that I want someone to give up my seat, and when someone else refuses, my aunt is in a hurry." ”

Immediately afterwards, it was Qu Ning's euphemistic explanation, but what was exchanged for it was not understanding, but Yang Lihua's intensified and more ferocious questioning.

"Line 4 is already crowded, so you dare to say that every time you are tired, there is a place for you to sit? Didn't you stand over too? You have good arms and legs, you can't overcome it today? ”

"It's really the same as the toad in the toilet, it won't move if you don't poke it, and you have to pick out the words to understand it."

"I don't even know the most basic politeness, and my education is definitely not high, so I say it nicely, go to work! I don't know which factory I am working in as a screw, hmph, I have no contribution to society at all, and I deserve to work hard for a lifetime! ”

"You! You... You little deflated three, I have lived for so many years, and this age is about to catch up with being your grandmother, you usually talk to your grandma like this?! ”

As the words became more and more vicious, Qu Ning in the video was never humble or arrogant, but replied without dirty words.

It wasn't until the end that he couldn't bear it anymore and said the sentence: "Can you die too." ”

Next, there is the scene that appeared in the online video.

At the end of the video, not only Yang Kai and Yang Lihua, but also Liu Jiu and everyone present, as well as all the viewers in front of the TV and in the online live broadcast room, were all silent.

And the silence lasted only a moment, and it erupted like a tidal wave.