"May I ask Operator Liu, what brand of mobile phone are you using?"

This question really makes people fall into thought.

What brand of mobile phone would a veteran operator use?

"This ......"

Operator Liu was also shocked by this question.

He never dreamed that the defense lawyer would not even ask about the case, but would care about his mobile phone?

Is this a Shenma situation?

Does my phone have anything to do with this case?

Similarly, it is not only the officer Liu in the witness stand who is in confusion, but also Judge Chen in the trial seat, and ......

on the hearing bench.

"Mr. Luo, may I ask this question......

"Don't ask me, I don't know."

Luo Xiaoxiang subconsciously shook his head and shook his head into a rattle.

He tries to keep up with Alice's brain circuitry by shaking his head to get different ideas.

Unfortunately, this is obviously unrealistic, and he, as a lecturer in criminal law and a senior professor at the University of Tokyo Law School, is also in a state of confusion at the moment.

Qi Zhengtian next door was the same, looking at the little girl on the field, he muttered in his heart.

Is this a question that law students can ask?

Are law school students so sassy now?

Enduring the physical discomfort, Qi Zhengtian turned his head mechanically and looked at Luo Xiaoxiang's side face beside him.

"Lao Luo, are these tricks you taught?"

"Qi Zhengtian, don't you wronged me, I'm the kind of person who will ask for other people's mobile phone brands?"

"Aren't you?"

"Am I?"

"So, it's not you?"

"When did you get the illusion that it would be me?"

This conversation made Zhang Yi, who was sitting next to these two people, muttered in his heart.

What about the two of you intriguing here, and you don't like to answer questions head-on, so you have to use rhetorical questions?

And their dialogue can also tell the story.

They don't seem to understand this operation!

"Against!"

In the field, Ren Qianning finally reacted.

I don't know what Alice is up to, but as the prosecution, I just have to oppose it.

"Reason!" On the trial seat, Chen Rushan asked coldly.

"Why?" Ren Qianning was straightened up by Judge Chen's rhetorical question, and her expression was a little speechless.

Does this need a reason?

Asking someone about their mobile phone brand, is this a question that ordinary people can ask?

Did you, Judge Chen, just watch as the witnesses and senior officers of the Investigation Division were put in order by the defense's tricks?

However, since the judge asked, Ren Qianning thought about it and replied: "The defense's questions are not related to the facts of the case, and they are invalid questions." ”

"Hmm......" Chen Rushan fell into thought, as if deciding whether this objection was valid or not.

This still needs to think about the ghost!

Ren Qianning almost blurted out a sentence of MMP on the side of his mouth.

"Your Excellency, I'm just curious, after all, this question doesn't hurt......

On the other side, Alice also spoke, and in a pitiful tone, as if she had asked such a question out of curiosity.

"The opposition is valid!"

Chen Rushan thought for a long time and finally made a decision.

Ren Qianning breathed a sigh of relief......

"But ......"

But before she could smile, Judge Chen immediately answered two words.

But what?

Ren Qianning looked at the one on the judgment seat, and saw the latter calmly speaking, keeping his face unchanged: "Actually, ......"

"This court is also a little curious!"

it!

Ren Qianning really scolded in her heart, the kind that almost scolded on the spot.

Judge Chen Rushan, you are the one who sits on the judgment seat and strikes the hammer, how can you do this?

Do you know that you are conniving at the defense, you are ......

Ren Qianning may have 10,000 sentences of "grass and mud horse" in her heart at this moment, but unfortunately no one can hear it.

And because of Chen Rushan's acquiescence, or explicit, everyone looked at Lao Liu on the witness stand.

Now, it's impossible to answer without answering.

"Is my phone ......?"

Lao Liu reached into his pocket and took out an old mobile phone.

This mobile phone is not a popular fruit brand, nor is it a smart phone, but an old feature phone.

The most famous point of his mobile phone brand, the quality of the mobile phone is excellent, how hard is it?

The kind of hardness that can smash walnuts!

Seeing this old mobile phone, everyone actually showed an unsurprising expression.

After all, the quality of mobile phones needs to be excellent, and even many people will buy feature phones.

Because they go out to act, but they all have to experience a rain of bullets, even if they catch a thief, they have to fly the eaves and walk the wall, all-terrain parkour.

If you buy an expensive mobile phone, it may be broken or worn, and replacing the phone is also a big expense.

Therefore, they need people who go out to work, and they like this kind of hard handpiece that can smash walnuts, and it can't be broken no matter how they fall.

Seeing this phone, Alice understood.

Because this is exactly the same as what Zhang Yi said.

Seeing that Lao Liu took out her mobile phone, Alice knew that it was time for her to work again.

She plucked up her courage, cheered herself up in her heart, and pretended to be an innocent little girl.

"Wow, what an old mobile phone, it reminds me of the changes of the times, the replacement of the old and the new, ......"

"By the way, by the way, Cadre Liu, why do you like to use such an old mobile phone, just like your people, aren't you old?"

As soon as these words came out, a touch of resentment appeared on Cadre Liu's face.

Little girl, what are you talking about!

You're scolding me all the time, aren't you?

You also asked me about my mobile phone, isn't this just a mockery of things?

It's a shame that I thought that you had prepared some routines, so that's the case!

"Speaking of Cadre Liu, you have been doing criminal investigation for more than 30 years, right?"

"Yes!"

Operator Liu replied angrily, not even wanting to look at Alice.

"I heard that when criminal investigators used to handle cases, there were routines, such as phone books, foot pads, ice and fire, out-of-print tiger chairs, and the famous "judicial milk tea", which is scary to think about."

"What are you talking about, are you implying that I tortured the suspect to extract a confession?!!!"

Lao Liu suddenly glared, and his tone was a little anxious.

He can be regarded as hearing it, this time the girl in front of him is planning to slander herself.

"Against!"

didn't need Lao Liu to remind her, Ren Qianning immediately stood up.

"This is anecdotal evidence!"

Chen Rushan nodded, this is indeed hearsay evidence.

Although a long time ago, when the judicial system was not perfect, it is true that some unconventional means will be used when handling cases in some places.

But the times are advancing, technology is developing, and this kind of behavior no longer exists.

"I'm sorry, my fault, I know that law enforcement is now transparent, and the investigation department will not have the same problem as I said in the process of interrogation and case handling."

Alice hurriedly apologized, and her attitude was sincere.

But soon, after she apologized, she continued: "But Cadre Liu is an experienced veteran cadre after all, so is there really no problem with his case-handling process?" ”

"No, it's not a formal question!" Ren Qianning didn't even sit down.

"But I have evidence to prove that there were some problems in the investigation bureau's interrogation of my client!"

Alice said, and finally turned around to greet Sun Dasheng and Zhu Tianpeng.

The two took out a few photos and handed them to Alice.

"This is a photo we got from the logistics department of the Dongmen District Public Security Bureau, please take a look."

Alice handed the photo to Judge Chen, as well as Ren Qianning, and returned a copy to Lao Liu by the way.

And Sun Dasheng and Zhu Tianpeng were tinkering with the projector, and soon the projection screen was also connected.

The photo is very simple, a scrapped chair, which looks like a chair leg has been broken, and it has been placed on the ground like this.

"Is there anything wrong with this chair?" Ren Qianning looked at the chair with a puzzled expression.

Although Judge Chen didn't speak, and his old face was still tight, he almost meant this in his eyes.

The jury and the hearing bench also looked at the chairs on the projection screen, curious.

"I said, would you be surprised if this chair was the one that sat under my client's butt when Willow interrogated my client?"

Hearing this explanation, the crowd looked at each other.

What is this?

"Oh, you said this, the chair was indeed broken during the interrogation, but we immediately replaced it, what's wrong with that?"

Lao Liu also spoke, thinking that it was a big deal, and it would be okay to replace the chair if it was broken.

"Yes, it's okay to replace the chair if it's broken, but at that time my client was sitting on the chair, right?"

Alice continued to explain, "In the dark interrogation room, my client was stared at by Operator Liu and his colleagues, and suddenly there was no support under his buttocks, and the whole person lost his balance and fell to the ground. ”

"Please put yourself in, in the dark room, you suddenly lost your body balance, and the person suddenly fell to the ground with a bang, and before he had time to come back to his senses, he was grabbed by Operator Liu, looking at his fierce face, how much psychological pressure do you say?"

Many people immediately imagined it, and then secretly glanced at Lao Liu's face, and immediately understood.

Indeed, being caught on the regret chair, and then being stared at by Cadre Liu, suddenly fell down with a bang, and it was indeed very stressful.

"You fart!"

But suddenly, Lao Liu couldn't sit still, and immediately slapped the wooden railing in front of him and stood up.

"Operator Liu, is he in a hurry?"

"Oh my God, oh my God, he's really in a hurry!"

These words were not said by Alice, but by Sun Dasheng and Zhu Tianpeng, who were sitting on the defense bench.

Although Alice has mustered up the courage, it is naturally difficult for her to mock the witness in person.

So before the trial, Zhang Yi gave Sun Dasheng and Zhu Tianpeng a task, that is, to act as mockers.

"What are you talking about, that is, the chair just broke, what does it have to do with me!" Lao Liu opened his throat and scolded the two of them angrily!

Being treated like this, let alone Sun Dasheng and Zhu Tianpeng, the two rookies, even ordinary people can't stand it.

The two of them sat down immediately, and their legs began to shake, apparently cowardly.

"Nonsense, it has something to do with you!"

But Alice was not frightened at all, and even walked back to her place again and took a list from the two of them.

"This is the material declaration list of the Dongmen District Public Security Bureau every quarter, Cadre Liu, your name is in this list, and the frequency is very high, can you explain to us, why the number of chairs damaged in your group every quarter is more than ten times that of other groups, and on average, you have to replace a chair in 2-3 days?"

"The chair is not durable, what can we do?"

Lao Liu said this, but this time his momentum was obviously weakened.

Whether the chair is really not durable, whether it is really not of good quality, who can not know, no one knows.

But this list and this data, that's real.

At least in the eyes of the jury, this case seems to be really watery, is it really torture to extract a confession?

Probably not, what age is it now, they all pay attention to transparent law enforcement, and this situation is impossible.

But when you were suddenly caught and sat on the regret chair, the chair suddenly broke because of the poor quality, and you fell, which really seems to have nothing to do with torture?

When you think about it, isn't it right?

Indeed, Lao Liu and their department did not force the suspect, and the chair was broken just because the quality was not good, and it had nothing to do with them!

Just, does it really matter?

You have to change a chair every 2-3 days, does it really have nothing to do with the quality of the chair, so why don't you use iron chairs, you have to use wood?

At this moment, the jury's attitude towards Lao Liu also changed significantly.

on the hearing bench.

"Damn, it's actually this trick!"

Even Luo Xiaoxiang, after seeing this change in the courtroom, he couldn't control it.

"Teacher Luo, what makes you so excited?"

"Xiao Du, she ......"

Luo Xiaoxiang wants to say that this routine is definitely not something that Alice came up with by herself, absolutely not!

Because it is absolutely impossible for a rookie to think of this trick.

As for what this trick is?

It's very simple, if I can't solve the problem, then take care of the person who created the problem!

Isn't your old willow awesome, isn't it amazing, isn't it experienced?

I can't do anything about your testimony, so I'll do it directly to you!

Your testimony is unassailable, but is it true of you yourself?

I don't need to refute your testimony, I just need to make the jury disgusted with you as a person, and that's enough!

Your old Liu has become a bad person here on the jury, so no matter what kind of testimony you come up with, the jury will not look at it or listen to it!

This is the most effective way to deal with tricky witnesses!

This trick can't be used by rookies, and veterans generally don't teach rookies.

Because of this trick, it's too dark.

At least Mr. Luo himself would not teach this trick to his students, and even he himself would not dare to use it.

Only those lawyers who have a flexible moral bottom line will generally use such a trick.

They don't have a face on their own, and of course it doesn't matter.

"Ahem, what's that, classmates, keep watching, look good!"

Luo Xiaoxiang said, hurriedly said a perfunctory sentence, let the students stop asking questions, show me more and think more, and turn around and realize for yourself!

Anyway, I didn't teach you this trick, and when you appear in court in the future, if anyone uses this trick to deal with the prosecution, it is also your own problem, and it has nothing to do with me.

Luo Xiaoxiang was shaking the pot here, and Qi Zhengtian next door to him was frowning.

Wrong!

Something is very wrong!

The girl on the defense bench, or maybe she definitely has a superior behind her!

This routine is not used by ordinary lawyers, but a rookie can use it.

There must be something greasy here, who is helping that little girl?

Qi Zhengtian thought about it for a long time, but he couldn't figure it out.

Is such a case or a public interest case worthy of a barrister's action?

I don't know if it's worth it, but Lao Liu at this moment is really in a hurry.

After Alice presented the "evidence", he was stimulated by the jury's eyes.

"You, what are you looking at, I, I......"

"Old Willow Operator, I understand you, after all, you are old, you can't keep up with the times, and you don't trust high-tech and so on, so you are under pressure and choose to treat the suspect in this way, I can understand it!"

Alice pretended to be compassionate at the moment, and spoke softly to Operator Liu in a soft tone.

"Really, don't you have pressure, I didn't have a case to take at the beginning, and I quickly adjusted my mentality, I believe that you also have pressure to solve the case, so you choose to treat the suspect like this......"

"You know what!"

Lao Liu was enraged by Alice's words, stood up angrily, pointed at Zhou Ping'an and scolded: "I can see at a glance that that kid is a murderer, why should I get used to him!" ”

It was such a sentence that detonated the audience.

Everyone was not calm at all, and even Judge Chen Rushan, who was sitting on the trial seat, widened his eyes at this moment.

How did your old willow become a powder keg, just one point, and one point burst?

I wanted to remind you, but I didn't expect you to be in such a hurry, and there is no way to remedy it now.

Chen Rushan sighed and turned his head to look at the prosecution.

Ren Qianning also maintained a stunned look, looked at Alice with some incredulity, and then looked at Lao Liu on the witness stand.

She didn't expect that just as she was about to get up and oppose it, this old willow suddenly exploded.

The explosion caught people off guard, and the explosion made people have no time to react.

Now, what should I do?

Ren Qianning is a rookie prosecutor after all, although she thinks she can already be on her own.

But she really hadn't seen this situation, so she could only look helplessly in the direction of Qi Zhengtian.

Cutie Lisi didn't intend to give them a chance to communicate, but chased after the victory.

"Cadre Liu, you mean, you rely on your so-called intuition to determine that my client is the murderer, right?"

"Our investigation department used to rely on intuition to handle cases, and we didn't solve a lot of cases?"

"But the investigation bureau handles the case, isn't it relying on evidence, only evidence is the basis for law enforcement, but you, as a senior officer, choose to ignore the evidence, and believe that your sixth sense is also an intuitive method?"

Alice looked at Lao Liu, her eyebrows full of puzzlement.

"I ......"

"I know, because of pressure, as a senior officer, you are eager to solve the case, it must be this why you chose to ignore the evidence and believe that my client is the murderer, isn't that so?"

"I ......"

"Cadre Liu, thank you for your answer, I understand."

Alice smiled, and then, like a winner, jumped up and waved her arms at Zhang Yi and Tracy in the hearing seat.

Because even at this point, it did not exceed Zhang Yi's expectations.

It was Zhang Yi's plan to anger Operator Liu, and Alice completed the task perfectly.

Zhang Yi smiled.

A grim smile appeared on the corner of his mouth.

The plan is .jpg