Chapter 174: Dispute (Revision)

"What do you think?" The other five were discussing fiercely, and Zhang Yichi wanted to ask the unpredictable opinion in private first.

"I think the views of these two people are too extreme, wait for a while to read the specific materials and then I will say what their opinions are." Mo Ji leaned back in his chair and smiled at the dispute, "What about you?" ”

Zhang Yichi said: "I don't have an idea yet." This is also a hot topic in the real world, and the reason why it has become a hot topic is because it is always full of disputes, each with its own rhetoric and opinions, and none of them can completely convince the public. In the current environment, the concept of judging whether a person has committed a crime by age is outdated. ”

"Indeed." Mo Ji nodded.

"But there's no better way to do it. When a problem arises, the person who proposes the solution is more important and scarce than the person who asks the problem. Zhang Yichi said.

"Let's pause for a moment, it always feels like playing the harp to a cow." Number One always has a sense of superiority when he speaks, which makes him feel disgusted, and naturally his opinion will not receive a lot of support, "We'll talk about it when you're done thinking about it." ”

No. 4 came up and said, "Who are you putting on a stinky face with?" looks like you're the smartest and everyone else is stupid, I think you're the worst in the world! ”

"Whatever." Number One shrugged his shoulders and ignored Number Four.

"This matter is certainly not so simple, and it cannot be solved by an innocent person and a death penalty." Number Two broke the silence, "God will not be satisfied with the outcome of such a judgment, so we have to negotiate a more convincing outcome that everyone can accept." ”

"It's easy to say." Number Five pouted, "No one knows what God's standard is, so why do you think innocence and the death penalty are wrong?" I think the death penalty is okay, otherwise I want to give this kid a chance to continue to do evil? Everyone hurry up and agree, and when it's time to vote, all vote for the death penalty, and get out early! ”

"I agree!" I don't know if No. 4 really agrees with No. Five's idea or if it's because No. 5 has just helped him speak and has a good feeling.

No. 2 frowned: "This matter is a matter of life and death for us, and you have to make a final decision after less than ten minutes of discussion now?" I don't know how you got to where you are now. ”

"It's a miracle that these two people have survived until now." Number One made a mocking remark.

Trumpets four and five will be angry.

No. 3 came out again to ease the atmosphere: "Don't be angry, everyone! What is there to be angry with your own people, we are on the same front, the relationship between living together or dying together, discuss it well! ”

Four snorted and tossed the materials on the table.

Zhang Yichi leaned over and took it.

The rest were in the hands of several others, and the one he got was a plan of the crime scene, which marked the purpose of each room, as well as the location of the murder and the place where the body was hidden.

Mo Tu also came over to check.

"There is only one window on one side of the living room, so the eyewitness child should have seen the whole murder process from this direction." Mo said thoughtfully.

"Do you think it's possible that this girl wasn't killed by a boy?" Zhang Yichi put forward an idea, "If that's the case, then innocence is definitely the standard answer." ”

"Probably not, there is no need for this child to lie in the diary, and the on-site investigation proved that there were only two children in the family at that time, and the fruit knife also had the boy's fingerprints." Mo Tu didn't think about it that way, "It shouldn't be reversed into a boy who didn't kill anyone." ”

Zhang Yichi let out a "hmm" and began to continue to think from other aspects.

No. 2 was silent for a while, looking at Zhang Yichi and unpredictable, "No. 6, No. 7, you two have been talking just now, I don't know if you have any ideas?" ”

"I think it's too subjective to judge this matter now, and we have to try to objectify it so that we can give the most pertinent opinion." Zhang Yichi said.

"Wasn't I objective enough just now?" Number One asked.

"You're an objective fart." Number Four crossed his legs, his arms around his chest and disdainfully.

Zhang Yichi continued: "That's someone else's objectivity, your subjectivity. I can't say that it is wrong to apply real-world laws and regulations here, but in fact, there are also deficiencies in real-world laws and regulations, some of which are outdated, and they are only for reference and cannot be used as a standard answer. ”

"You mean you're smarter than the people who make the laws?"

"What is the reason why laws and regulations are constantly being changed? Isn't it precisely because it still has shortcomings that it also needs to make progress with the times? Zhang Yichi said, "What is formulated by people, people are certainly qualified to question and update it." ”

"Okay, you don't think it's right, then tell me what you think, how do you think this boy should be punished?" Number One has been repeatedly refuted, and now his face is not very good-looking.

"I'm thinking." Zhang Yichi doesn't like No. 1's attitude, "Since we want to look at this matter from an objective perspective, then we still need to have a deeper understanding." It's not just a simple sentence of 'the boy got it and stabbed the girl to death', and then there is a verdict. ”

Seeing this, No. 3 asked: "The boy has always denied that he killed the girl, and we don't know his motives." ”

"Give me the piece of paper you have." Mo Tu asked for a piece of material, which had the contents of an eyewitness's diary, and he read it, "The eyewitness wrote in his diary that 'I saw someone fighting today, my brother hit my sister, and then my sister was motionless on the ground. The teacher taught us that it was not right to fight, and that I could not learn from my brother. ’”

"Is there anything you can say?" Number Three asked.

"It's hard to say." Mo Ji put the paper back on the table, "What we know about the incident was written by a child, and if there is any inappropriate word in his words, it will lead to our misunderstanding of the case to increase." ”

Zhang Yichi, of course, supported the unpredictable, so he also followed: "This diary only tells us that the boy killed the girl, and we don't know how it happened." What if I now make a premise that my sister has been provoking my brother, and finally my brother wants to scare my sister in anger, and then kills my sister by mistake? Later, because he was afraid, he hid his sister and lied to the adults that his sister had gone out. If the background is like this, do you still think that this brother should be sentenced to death so severely? ”

"The problem is that we can only set the background, and no one knows what the real background is." Trumpet 2, "Does this mean that God wants us to discard those factors and simply judge a juvenile homicide?" ”

"Makes sense, too." Zhang Yichi does not deny this possibility, and it doesn't matter whether his views are recognized or not.

After Zhang Yichi's non-aggressive comments, the discussion of the trial was back on track.