"Even if Liu Jing was desperate for a while and called Liu Zhaodi for help, it is unlikely that Liu Zhaodi would agree to help without saying a word."

"But the fact is that Liu Zhaodi helped dispose of the body, so the person who called Liu Zhaodi and asked her to help is more likely to be Liu Yuanyuan. Liu Zhaodi may ignore Liu Jing, but Liu Yuanyuan should not be able to see death without help."

As Yang Feng's analysis deepened, Wang Xing's spirit became more and more excited: "Look, analysis comes and goes, the murderer is not Liu Yuanyuan."

"I only said that the person who called to ask Liu Zhaodi to help dispose of the body was more likely to be Liu Yuanyuan, but I didn't say that Liu Yuanyuan must be the murderer."

"If Liu Jing kills someone, thinking that with her own face, Liu Zhaodi may not be able to help dispose of the body, so she turns to Liu Yuanyuan for help, and finally Liu Yuanyuan opens her mouth to Liu Zhaodi, such a possibility also exists."

"In addition, Liu Yuanyuan and Liu Jing committed the crime together, killed He Shuangxi and Du Juan, and finally Liu Yuanyuan asked Liu Zhaodi for help, which is also a possibility."

Then, Yang Feng changed his words again:

"As I said earlier, these three siblings are all masters of storytelling."

"In a criminal case, in order for one's story to appear to be in line with the facts of the crime, the most basic requirement is to combine the facts of the crime and exert personal associations within the general framework composed of various objective elements."

"These objective elements include the place and time of the crime, the details of the crime, the tools used to commit the crime, etc."

"This kind of half-truth, half-false confession, which combines various objective elements, may achieve the effect of confusing the public, distorting the facts, and even using the false to confuse the truth, so as to achieve the goal of replacing the real murderer."

"Obviously, the purpose of these three siblings is to each rush to make themselves the real murderer."

"Therefore, from their confessions, it is not difficult for us to see the existence of some objective elements or objective facts. For example, the order of Du Juan's and Ho Shuangxi's deaths is the same, and the use of Du Juan's mobile phone to send text messages to Du Wen are all in line with objective facts."

"The place of He Shuangxi's death was in the living room of Liu Jing's house, and as long as Liu Jing's home has not changed the sofa or re-laid the floor, our police can extract relevant physical evidence from here. Although the comrades in the technical team have not yet given feedback, I believe that this point should be in line with the objective facts."

"In addition, the three siblings also said that the cuckoo was strangled to death, although this cannot be verified by physical evidence for the time being, but it is very likely that they subconsciously abide by the principle of 'only stealing for the real murderer, so this statement is also very likely to be true."

"These three siblings have their own associations and integrate themselves into the case to 'steal the real murderer, so as to make themselves' the murderers, and there is no doubt that they need to grasp the whole picture and all the details of the crime."

"If it is not a joint crime, to do this, the three siblings must have shared and exchanged information about the incident, or it is also called 'information sharing.'"

"The problem is in this 'information sharing.'"

"This goes back to my original question, Liu Yuanyuan and Liu Jing knew the details of He Shuangxi's letting Tao Qiangsheng and Tao Lixin get out of here before he was killed, but Liu Zhaodi didn't know about it."

After a pause, Yang Feng's words turned again:

"Let's take a look at the confessions of the three siblings about the murder of He Shuangxi and Du Juan for the time being."

"Liu Zhaodi's confession shows that in addition to not knowing that He Shuangxi has asked Tao Qiangsheng and Tao Lixin to get out, it also shows that she is very likely not to know the specific time when Liu Jing was robbed, otherwise she would not have made a low-level logical error at this point, exposing her false confession."

"Based on this, I think Liu Zhaodi's understanding of the death process of He Shuangxi and Du Juan and related information is the most incomplete and detailed. This is also in line with our previous inference, that is, Liu Zhaodi is not suspected of killing these two people."

"Looking at Liu Yuanyuan's confession again, she only knows that He Shuangxi hired two people to kill Liu Jing, but what are the names of these two people

The name and what it was for, but she couldn't say it at all. Liu Zhaodi didn't mention this at all, and she probably didn't know about it."

"But what about Liu Jing? Liu Jing not only knew that the two people He Shuangxi found were Tao Qiangsheng and Tao Lixin, but also knew that the two of them were construction workers."

"Therefore, judging from the overall confessions made by these three siblings, Liu Jing has the most comprehensive grasp of information, followed by Liu Yuanyuan, and Liu Zhaodi is the roughest."

"It's not difficult to see that in the process of 'information sharing, Liu Jing should be the source of information, Liu Yuanyuan should be the transit station, and Liu Zhaodi is the last one to get the information."

"In the process of communication, they can't copy and paste data and information, and then forward and receive it like a computer, so as to achieve 'zero omission sharing' of information resources, so it is inevitable that some details will be missed."

"Since Liu Jing is the source of information, he should be the real murderer of He Shuangxi and Du Juan. Moreover, he is the only one who knows the names and occupations of the two 'killers' hired by He Shuangxi, and this alone can largely determine that his confession is true."

"According to what I said before, when these three siblings made up the story, it is very likely that they subconsciously adhered to the principle of 'only stealing the real culprit, and will not deliberately distort or conceal the known objective facts. Liu Yuanyuan integrated herself according to the objective facts she knew, and wanted to cover for Liu Jing, but he obviously didn't know the relevant situation of the two killers.

"With this, we can rule out the possibility that Liu Yuanyuan and Liu Jing jointly committed the crime to kill He Shuangxi and Du Juan."

"Therefore, there is only one real murderer who killed these two people, and that is Liu Jing. After he killed someone, he called Liu Yuanyuan, and Liu Yuanyuan asked Liu Zhaodi for help and asked her to help dispose of the body."

"In this process, there were omissions in Liu Jing's crime process and the transmission of relevant information, and the situation we see now has emerged, the crime process narrated by the three sisters and brothers is roughly the same, but there are slight differences in some details."

"Of course, it is these inconspicuous nuances that reveal who the real culprit is."

Then, Yang Feng looked at Wang Xing again: "As for the day you said that you killed He Shuangxi, Liu Zhaodi claimed that she took 4 tickets to Liu Jing and asked him to go out with the old lady and two children, and Liu Yuanyuan's confession also confirmed this."

"Why are Liu Zhaodi and Liu Yuanyuan's confessions consistent? It's very simple, they both told lies, and they should have colluded about this beforehand, but the purpose of the collusion was not consistent, as I said before."

"It's not impossible for Liu Jing to say that he doesn't remember where the family went on this day."

"For him, he just needs to make sure that he is the only one in the house that day, as for what excuse he found to send the old lady out with the child that day, or whether the old and young people really happened to have something to go out, such as going to the hospital with a cold and fever, who had a happy event in the family of the seven aunts and eight aunts, or what activities the children's school held, maybe I really don't remember."

Wang Xing did not refute.

Wu Xiaojun looked at the three confessions in front of him:

"I agree with Team Yang's opinion that the suspect who killed Du Juan and He Shuangxi is basically locked up as Liu Jing...... But what about the two brothers of the Yuan family? The confessions of these three siblings about the murder of the two Yuan brothers are basically the same, and I am afraid it will be difficult to find a logical loophole in their confessions, so as to determine who the real culprit is."

This time, Wang Xing thought about it seriously, and then said: "Such a highly similar confession can only show one thing, they are accomplices, and they both participated in the killing of the two brothers of the Yuan family."

"Besides, Team Yang also said before that the three sisters and brothers of the Liu family should each have their lives on their backs, so they rushed to admit that they killed these 4 people alone, so that one can protect two."

"From the current point of view, Liu Yuanyuan has Zhou Xiaolu's life on her back, Liu Jing has the lives of Du Juan and He Shuangxi, and Liu Zhaodi, as an accomplice, has also carried the lives of the two brothers of the Yuan family, so it can be inferred."

Yang Feng didn't though

expressed different opinions on this, but did not arbitrarily conclude on this: "The death of the two brothers of the Yuan family can only start from their corpses, as well as the pigsty that the three sisters and brothers of the Liu family said that they were imprisoned, and the autopsy report and the investigation report of the crime scene will not be released for a while, so we can only wait and talk."

Then, Yang Feng remembered one more thing:

"Liu Yuanyuan's confession about the killing of Zhou Xiaolu should also be verified, and people should ask Shang Biao whether he left suddenly for a day or two in the days before and after Zhou Xiaolu's death, that is, from July 1 to July 5, 2004, when he went to other places to stay with Liu Yuanyuan, who was studying in graduate school. I also want to write to the local police to go to the door to find Liu Yuanyuan's mentor back then to verify."

After a pause, Yang Feng muttered to himself: "I called Liu Yuanyuan back then, and only asked if Shang Biao was on her side during that time, and she said yes, and said that if she lied, she would not die...... Hmph, of course she didn't lie, it was Lao Tzu who asked the wrong question, and Lao Tzu should have asked her specific itinerary...... Numb."

In the end, Yang Feng finally couldn't help but yawn: "Let's call it a day today, and let the three sisters and brothers go back to the private room...... I'll see tomorrow's physical evidence report."

Wu Xiaojun also stretched his waist while packing up his materials and preparing to leave.

Wang Xing still sat motionless on the stool, looking extremely distracted.

In the extremely puzzled eyes of Yang Feng and Wu Xiaojun, Wang Xing suddenly said, "Team Yang...... If Liu Jing kills the cuckoo, just a few days later, in the face of my door-to-door investigation, he will be able to deal with it without changing his face and heartbeat, which is wrong."